Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Amity Gaige has written a thrilling story about three tenacious women. It is beautifully constructed in such a way as to seamlessly pull these very different women together. One of the women Valerie, more commonly known by her trail name Sparrow, is missing on the northern most portion of the Appalachian trail. Bev is all in as the lead of the search and rescue unit deployed to find her. Lena is a wheelchair bound retiree who is dogged in finding out what happened to Sparrow through an online link she thinks may help. The story is told through multiple POVs that link seamlessly. It is a mystery because it is unknown how she got lost and if Sparrow will ever be found alive.
Sparrow refuses to give up. She must overcome multiple obstacles in order to survive. We are able to get her POV as she imagines letters to her mother as she wanders alone and afraid, but determined, through the woods. Bev is a woman ranger in a man’s world who constantly has had to prove herself again and again. In each missing person case she emotionally invested and in the case of Sparrow you can feel the strength of her desire to save the young girl. It seems almost strong enough to push the hounds forward as they follow the scent. Lena seems like the outlier, the piece that doesn’t quite fit until she beautifully falls into place.
If you liked “God of the Woods” you will love this book. It has the right balance of mystery, tension and character building. I cannot recommend it highly enough. 5 stars from me, I couldn’t put it down. Thank you Simon and Schuster and NetGalley for an advance copy of this extraordinary book. This opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fantastic book. I really enjoyed every second I spent reading it. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Definitely a genre blend book which is always welcomed and refreshing. The women in this book were just so bad ass. I can always get behind strong women. It had enough suspense and mystery to keep my interest while still being invested so deeply in the characters.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed Gage’s Heartwood, a suspenseful story of a woman who gets lost in the wilderness. This book combines the perspectives of Valerie/Sparrow’s letters, Lt Bev (Search & Rescue), and Lena (online sleuth). I really enjoy how the story was narrated, plus the story pulls you in - at no point did the story feel boring.

Was this review helpful?

.Told from many points of view that not only maintain their individual integrity, but also advance the plot without letting it get ahead of itself. Valerie has gone missing off the Appalachian Train in Maine, necessitating a search that runs into more days than feasible led by Bev, a Maine game warden on the verge of retirement. Concurrently, there is Lena, a 76-year-old resident in a Connecticut retirement home. How these stories overlap and intertwine with startling insights into their interior lives is masterful. I plan on looking up Amity Gaige's earlier works.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved Sea Wife, so I was excited to pick up another novel by the author, this one centering on a woman who goes missing from the Appalachian Trail. There is a mystery element here, but it's not a fast paced twists and turns book full of red herrings. Instead it's reflective of the conflicts between mothers and daughters, connection and independence, and choosing paths where women are the minority. I read this in a weekend and liked it a lot! It feels similar in pacing and vibe to a book like Tim Johnston's The Current.

Was this review helpful?

A woman is missing while hiking, and it's up to the main character to investigate and find her. But we also get a lot of insight into the main character's life and family, and we learn how she became who she is and what motivates her choices. It's interesting and grows on us.

Was this review helpful?

"Like the Amish raise their barns, Mainers search for each other in the woods. It's what we do."

Oh my. I really am at a loss as to how I want to approach this review. Well, first off, I didn't just read this book: I inhaled it. This struck a chord so deeply and so purely that I was racked with chills at the end. I felt this was a beautifully-told, masterfully-constructed tale, that, on the surface, is the story of a woman lost in the Maine woods. But it's more than that. To me, this was the story of three very different, very strong women. I don't want to ruin anything; just read the book.

I'm sad that I'm finished with the story, and I will absolutely read anything the author decides to put to paper...

I received a complimentary copy of the novel from the publisher and NetGalley, and my review is being left freely.

Was this review helpful?

Heartwood is a wilderness suspense novel that will make you think about life, love, and relationships. Valerie Gillis, a forty-two-year-old nurse, is hiking the Appalachian Trail and vanishes almost 200 miles from her final goal. She has her journal with her and writes letters to her mother while she waits for help. Beverly is the Maine State Game Warden in charge of finding Valerie. She is tough as nails and will not give up the search until Valerie is found. Another character central to the story is Lena, a seventy-six-year-old bird watcher who lives in a retirement community in Connecticut. Lena becomes an unlikely internet sleuth for Valerie. Will they find Valerie in time?

The heart of this story is the mother-daughter relationship. The author weaves the stories in and out beautifully. I love the letters Valerie wrote to her mother. I can’t say more without giving anything away. Sometimes the pace lagged a little for me and I wished it had been a little faster. I appreciated the detail on trails, hiking, and search and rescue procedures. I loved the idea behind the name Heartwood. This is a special book and I look forward to reading more from this author. Thank you to Simon & Schuster for providing this book for review consideration via Net Galley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

"Heartwood" presents a distinctive approach to the suspense genre. The story centers around Valerie Gillis, a 42-year-old hiker who mysteriously vanishes while trekking the Appalachian Trail in Maine. As she navigates her way back, Valerie shares her innermost thoughts through poignant letters addressed to her mother. Meanwhile, Beverly, a dedicated game warden, spearheads the search efforts for Valerie. Additionally, Lena, an elderly birdwatcher residing in a Connecticut retirement community, takes on the role of an amateur detective. The narrative unfolds through the varied perspectives of these three women, creating a compelling and engaging experience. The suspense builds as readers are left questioning whether Valerie will be located in time, making it a thrilling addition to any reading list.

Was this review helpful?

I was afraid this would be a rip of Cheryl Strayed — wow was I wrong! This tale of the deep wild woods of Maine had me captivated and enthralled. The language magic Amity Gaige used created characters and descriptions of such depth and truth. I have hiked in some beautiful places but nowhere as challenging as the AT. I am familiar with all the areas evoked so beautifully and that enriched my experience immensely. But the most wonderful thing about this book is how character driven it is. Very very highly recommended you will not want to eat or sleep till you’re done!

Was this review helpful?

Warning - make sure you have time to read this book - you will want to keep reading. This is a story about a woman Valerie who is lost while hiking the Appalachian trail. All of the characters are interesting. I found the descriptions of the hiking process very interesting. The story unfolds as the author includes Valerie's hiking friend, her husband, the Maine warden who is in charge of the search and rescue team. This book was hard to put down. This was a 5 star book for me. Something different.
Thank you NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story of an experienced hiker who has taken to the Appalachian Trail for a long hike. Somehow she has become lost - she is 200 miles from her final destination. What she does to survive. She also writes letters to her mother while looking for the right trail.
It is also about the woman who is in charge of finding her on the Trail and the hundreds of people searching for her. It is what each does - one to save herself and one to save another.

This was quite an interesting story of hiking and searching - their personal stories as well - and the battles that you may find along the way. I found it very interesting and educational as well. Even tho I am not a hiker this was interesting as to the trails and what to do and not to do. I believe you will find it interesetinfg as well. I highly recommend it. Thank lyou to @Simon & Schuster for allowing me the opportuhity to read this pre publishsed novel.

Was this review helpful?

A creative central plot (Valerie, a nurse/hiker goes missing in the Maine wilderness), well-honed, interesting and sympathetic characters (including “Lt. Bev,” the game warden leading the search, and Lena, an armchair sleuth working from her retirement community), and enchanting prose that illuminates and transports the reader, all combine for a very satisfying and memorable read. Mother/daughter relationships add an additional element of familial humanity to this story. Don’t miss this one!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this story and found it very engrossing. I particularly liked that it was so female-driven with three strong women as the main characters:

Was this review helpful?

Heartwood is about a woman who goes missing on the Appalachian trail. I absolutely loved this book and I could not put it down. The amount of detail and research that went into this novel is stunning. I loved the characters and their stories. Everything tied together so well in the end. This was one of my favorite books of 2024. Thank you to Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for my advanced reading copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 solid stars for this story of three strong women.

Valerie Gillis is 42 years old and she’s hiking the Appalachian Trail. She goes missing in Maine, only two hundred miles from her final destination. While she tries to survive the unthinkable she writes letters to her mother.

Beverly Miller, a Maine game warden leads the search for Valerie while Lena Kulcharski, a 76 year old biker swat her living in a Connecticut retirement community acts an an armchair detective. Can the women find Valerie in the vast wilderness and what is behind her disappearance?

Interesting story, especially the parts about the AT and survival on it….I would have liked more of that.

Was this review helpful?

Valerie Gillis’s voice is raw and poetic as she pens letters to her mother while battling the elements. Her fragmented reflections pull the reader into her psyche, revealing her determination, fear, and vulnerability as she navigates the isolation of the Appalachian Trail. These passages are beautifully written, capturing both nature's grandeur and the human spirit's fragility.

In stark contrast, Beverly, the tenacious Maine State Game Warden, offers a grounded and methodical perspective. Her relentless pursuit of the truth adds urgency and tension to the narrative, while her empathy and dedication make her a deeply relatable character.

The unexpected addition of Lena, a seventy-six-year-old birdwatcher turned amateur detective, is a delightful surprise. Her sharp observations and unorthodox sleuthing bring a fresh and contemplative angle to the mystery, illustrating the interconnectedness of seemingly disparate lives.

With its intricate plot, vivid prose, and compelling characters, this is a must-read for fans of literary thrillers and survival stories. It lingers long after the final page, a testament to the power of hope and the enduring mystery of the human experience.

The publisher provided ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was not what I expected and honestly it was all the better for it. It’s described as a thriller but it felt more literary fiction to me. The focus was on interpersonal relationships and reflecting on past trauma more than the suspenseful plot. I actually found this much more engaging and paired with the really lovely prose it made for a wonderful study of character and story.

ARC provided by NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

3.75⭐️

I’ll be honest, I wanted to like this book so much more than I did. Overall, it was an interesting read that I am glad I read. I think my issue is that it’s listed as suspense but that’s not the experience I had at all.

However, I did like the characters and how they were interwoven together. I love the Appalachian Trail and the connections to it and Maine so I enjoyed the look into that world. I would put this in the Literary Fiction category as mostly what stood out was the mother daughter relationship and how it unfolded in the “victims” journal.

I do know many of my personal friends will enjoy this read. It is unique as it’s told through phone calls, journal entries, reports and more. So it was a nice change from the typical prose.

It comes out April 1,2025

I want to thank Simon & Schuster for reaching out and asking if I wanted to read this ARC for free as overall I enjoyed the experience.

Was this review helpful?