Skip to main content

Member Reviews

What was that ending!!!! What do you mean?!?

This was so good! I enjoyed the sequel so much but that ending!?! I need to know what happened! I’ll definitely be checking out this authors next book!

Was this review helpful?

How gorgeous is this cover?!

The Blood Phoenix concludes Ying and Ye-yang’s story in an unexpected way. With expanded world building and an increased focus on two very interesting characters, this book delivers an adventure full of drama, politics, romance and even pirates. I’m really interested in seeing where the author takes us next and I can hope we get a glimpse into the lives of some of these favorite characters.

Was this review helpful?

Perfect sequel to the first book, was able to relate more to some characters & THAT ENDING was amazing.

Was this review helpful?

And we're back! As we dive into TBP, there are some notable differences from its predecessor. This story takes place two years after the last events in OJAD. We're in the middle of a war, and there's a POV switch between Ying and her little sister, Nian. I'm all for growth and broader storytelling, but I didn't particularly care for the sequel. It didn't grasp me as the first book did. And even though OJAD ended on an open cliffhanger, I could have done without finding out what happens to Ying after. It has more to do with the creative direction of where the book was heading, rather than the writing. I'd say one of the good things that came from this story was that bratty, now grown-up sidekick, Ye-Kan. He had an amazing coming-of-age arc and came out to be the true hero in this sequel.

Was this review helpful?

The plot was all over the place and felt super disjointed. It needed more setup and a clearer direction to make me actually care. Also, the side characters were never really developed, so when things got dramatic, I just didn't feel anything.

Ying and Ye-Yang's relationship is so confusing. Are we supposed to be rooting for them? He doesn't respect her at all and manipulates her constantly. She keeps saying she's done, then they're back to kissing. It's not healthy at all and just plain unsatisfying.

This was super disappointing, especially because I liked the first one. There was way too much going on, and it barely connected to the first book. p.

Thank you Netgalley, author, and publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Five stars for me!! 🥰
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🏴‍☠️🤖💣🐙🐉

The Blood Phoenix is the continuation of Of Jade and Dragons, set two years after the events of the first book.

I was beyond excited to get my hands on this ARC, I needed to know if Ying would find her way back to Ye-Yang! Let’s just say I was giggling every time they had a scene together. 😜 We also get chapters from Nian’s point of view, and I loved her dynamic with Ye-Kan, especially the way she stood her ground and took charge.

No spoilers… but ohhh the twists and turns—the PIRATES, the BETRAYAL! OMG! 😮 I was on the edge of my seat.

And that ending… BROKE. MY. HEART. My Sheyla!!! 😭

I absolutely cannot wait to get my hands on the Illumicrate special edition to match my Of Jade and Dragons copy!

Was this review helpful?

I greatly enjoyed Of Jade and Dragons, the first book in this duology, and was looking forward to this one, but I'm sorry to say it fell short of my expectations. There was significant focus on the relationships - particularly the relationships between Ying and Nian and their respective love interests - but the ending, which included the resolution to one of those relationships, felt both rushed and forced, as well as unfinished, as if this duology is now intended to be a trilogy, or more.

It's too bad that the ending fell short, because the rest of the novel was enjoyable, if a little slow in places. The characters continue to grow and develop, motivations are revealed, wars are fought, in ways that are interesting and engaging. There are a great many strong female characters, which I appreciate, and a strong Asian vibe, which was well done. Overall, if you read Of Jade and Dragons, then The Blood Phoenix is worth your time.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book provided by Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this sequel! It had romantic subplots, political intrigue, hidden identities, betrayals, and characters finding their strength when the world expects them to be docile. I do think the two-year time jump between books one and two was a bit too much. I would’ve loved a novella about Ying’s time after leaving the guild and the events that took place upon returning home.

This book beautifully explores the complexities of family, the tug-of-war between love and duty, and challenges a woman’s place in society. I especially loved the introduction of pirates (always a win for me!). While I know some readers aren’t fans of Ye-Yang and Ying’s relationship, I think it’s important to remember they’re young. At that age, always choosing duty over feelings isn’t easy. Yes, Ye-Yang can be manipulative in his duty-bound way, but those moments where both of them act on emotion instead of logic felt age-appropriate and true to the story.

The cunning plotting, the scheming, the surprising character growth, especially from those thought to be weak, kept me engaged with the story. I also loved the underlying theme that invention is only as good as the intention and application behind it. If the first book was Ying’s rise to prove herself among the boys like the first half of Mulan, this one feels like the second half. Here she owns her choices, faces the consequences, and truly understands sacrifice, fighting not just for those she loves but for her entire people.

The ending took me by surprise. It was not the “happily ever after” I expected, but was fitting for the journey. Definitely YA: some kissing, some battle-scene gore, but nothing beyond that.

Was this review helpful?

The Blood Phoenix by Amber Chen was a good sequel to her first book Of Jade and Dragons.
Ying is a great character to follow in part because of her flaws but I feel like this book took away some of what she learned in the first book.
I enjoyed the pirate story line and the open ending for her and Ye Yong.
If there is a third book I will definitely be reading.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

Thank you Penguin Young Readers/Viking Books, Amber Chen and Netgaley for providing me an eARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Having adored the first installment of this YA Fantasy duology, I just knew I needed to quickly get to the second one to figure out how the very messy, unresolved things left at the end of book 1 ended up tying themselves back together.

I was surprised with the time jump at the beginning and confess it took some time until my memory was fully jumbled as a result. There were certain things I had most definitely forgot from book 1, which led to a slow start on my end. In hindsight, whilst I understand the decision to set things in the future, I also believe that had the narrative continued directly from the end of book 1, it would have been easier to get back into the story.

We are introduced to a new POV, Nian's, which was the strongest for me in this book. I loved how she formed a strong relationship with Ye-kang despite being engaged to Ye-lang. Their dynamic certainly kept things interesting since Ying was not in the same picture for quite some time.

Ying's reconnection with the characters from book 1 was very action-packed, and it kind of set the pace for her pov since there is so much going on in her side of the story. I feel like the romance between Ying and Ye-lang took the backseat as a result, but I'm not mad about it. I think in this book, Ying's relationship with her passion for engineering changed as she grappled with the consequences of technological advances. I feel like this is certainly a theme that was well explored and for a young adult audience, it will not be hard to grasp that progress can be used as means for good or evil, depending on people's intentions. I think this is an important message especially as we enter the age of AI.

The world building got expanded in this installment too, and I so appreciated the new characters we were introduced to. The pirates and their internal organization reminded me of The Pirates of the Caribbean, so those chapters were really fun and somewhat nostalgic. However, I feel like there were a lot more opportunities to introduce new parts of this world that were sort of neglected in my opinion.

Just like in the first installment, there were multiple plot twists, mystery and betrayals along the way. I was definitely shocked by some of the reveals but I feel like they were a lot more impactful in book 1 due to Ying's lack of knowledge around court politics, which contributed to the reader's unawareness of a lot of dynamics. In book 2, readers are equipped well enough to be able to guess a few things here and there when it comes to conspiracies, which I didn't mind.

The romance between Ying and Ye-lang was the let-down for me. Ugh, as much as I tried to get back to rooting for them, I just couldn't. Ye-lang gets better but his actions in book 1 made it too hard for me to trust him as a character (and Ying felt the same way which doesn't help), but I liked his redemption. The ending definitely left things open to opportunity, making me wonder whether Amber Chen has intentions of creating another series/duology/standalone set in this world but following a different set of characters.

Was this review helpful?

The time jump from the first book felt a bit long and out of sorts, but I understand why it was done. The world concept was really cool and it was fun to meet new characters, although I found it hard to keep track sometimes (could be a me problem). It didn’t really feel like it flowed on well from the first book and the resolution didn’t feel final even though I believe it’s meant to be a duology. I think this book will be a hit with younger teens who enjoy fast-paced low fantasy adventures.

Was this review helpful?

Book review: 3.5/5 ⭐️
Genre: fantasy duology
Themes: engineering, disguise, infiltration, murder
📖 Read if you like: Powerless, Mulan, The Dragon’s Promise

While book 1 was a story of vengeance and identity, book 2 deals with the aftermath of deadly decisions and the shadow it creates. It takes place two years later with Ying having left the capital, while her sister remains dutifully behind as the betrothed to High Commander Ye-Yang. When a deadly pirate attack on a small coastal village by the fearsome Blood Pheonix kills a dear friend, Ying will be pulled back into the world of political drama, deadly creations and a looming war of destruction.

With new engineering challenges that pull Ying and her friends into a new underwater landscape, the creativity on this front remains high. The pirates were a fun addition with another feminist storyline to root for, though they were certainly a deadly group of enemies. The plot was once again complex with a power struggle between brothers continuing amidst threats from external sources. The hidden agents and grand battles really made for an exciting and entertaining read.

Then there is the heart of the story. With lies and betrayal leaving their scars, Ying and Ye-Yang’s relationship remains a tumultuous one. Thrown back together, their love for each other is undeniable, but so is the undermining decision making and withheld trust, along with the Nian of it all. With her sister’s happiness at stake, Ying wants to take herself out of the picture. Yet with the fate of all Antarans at risk, Ying will do what she must to protect the people, as is her duty as an engineer.

In many ways this sequel was didactic, a morality lesson if you will. What is a life worth, what is the cost of vengeance, what to do with power. There were many complex issues raised within the deadly political and sea-based battlefields. I liked the conclusion to the story with a bitter sweet inevitability.

What let me down a bit was Nian and Ye-kan. It may have been two years, but they both appeared to be very different characters. I cannot pretend that the girl who spent her life dancing and caretaking could suddenly become a brilliant strategist who would be privy to the High Commander’s office before they were married. Nor, that she would have any real power. It didn’t help that her character was rather bland compared to Ying. I understand the contrast and her steadfast nature was the point, but I didn’t buy into the metamorphosis. She lacked the barriers that Ying faced and the fact that everyone was so welcoming and helpful lead to a very obvious outcome. Then there is the young and hot-headed prince who seems to have lost all his candour and bossiness, which made him a loveable character during the competition. His personality seemed to have been snuffed out as he served as a supporting backbone to Nian. Ye-kan needed to be more to step out of his brother’s shadow and deserve the right to rule. Frankly I am not sure either one really understood the sacrifices needed to lead, yielding a very naive pair in a dark landscape. It took a rather complex storyline and characters into a more black and white territory, which I thought was boring. So I really enjoyed some elements, but others were not to my particular taste. Still it made an excellent finale with possibility for another story within the same world.

Thank you to @coloredpagesbt @penguinteen and @amberwrites88 for a copy of this book for review. As a debut duology, it was really well done!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I loved this continuation of this series! I really enjoyed all of the action and adventure in this installment. The introduction of a second point of view was very well done and I could not get enough of this character and her story. I really enjoyed the steampunk aspects in this book and all of the inventions that were developed throughout the book. This was such a great story with so many plot twists.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the first book a lot, even with its flaws the storyline kept me intrigued. But I felt this book was rushed a little too much and I'm left with unanswered questions

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I enjoyed the prose and the world built into this story, and I enjoyed the budding romance between Ye-kan and Nian. I also enjoyed that two years passed between the first book and this one, and there was a betrayal that I didn't see coming until just before it occurred.

Aside from that, I have a lot of issues with this story. 1. There’s a ton of movement in this story that felt like whiplash. Ying constantly moves between Fei, then leaves, returns, leaves, returns, all before the climax, then leaves again. 2. Saving Nian was so easy, there was essentially no time from Ying’s pov to worry the worst had happened. 3. Ye-Yang has the super-human ability of ki that is glossed over when it's first brought up in this book, and its potential is wasted/hardly mentioned or used, especially in times of danger.. 4. Ying’s motivation to stay away from Ye-Yang is shaky. Most of the time, it seems for the logical reason that she doesn’t trust him bc of what happened 2 years prior, but other times, it seems more like it’s only because he is engaged to her sister. 5. The main "villain" set up from the first book is posed as the empire across the sea, and yet they are not the enemy in either book, and are waylaid in this book in place of pirates plus treason/inner political intrigue. It seems odd to me that so much emphasis in both books was put on the war with the country across the sea, and yet there was no real focus on in-story and no resolution.
The final straw for me was the ending. Without giving too much away, the ending felt so incomplete and lazy.

Was this review helpful?

In the sequel to "Of Jade and Dragons", "Blood Phoenix" begins two years after the last book and we're given Ying's POV as well as her sister's!
The characters are really well developed, the plot is action packed and twisty, and the Mulan steampunk vibes are there.

I just wish there was an additional epilogue of the after events for more closure.

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I've really enjoyed reading this duology, even though it didn't feel like the story was complete with this book. Maybe Amber is going to surprise us with another book, because I have some questions amiga!

I continue to love the engineering and STEM plot that we were introduced to in Of Jade and Dragons; I think it's what I enjoyed the most about this world. There are so many challenges for the characters, so many obstacles to overcome, and the journey of it all was beautiful. Ying has a wonderful growth throughout these books, and she became my favorite character.

The pace of this book was a little harder for me towards the middle of the story, but I think it was necessary as part of the author's intended direction. There are a lot of struggles and new hardships, and also new POV's that made the plot even richer than before.

Thank you so much to Colored Pages Book Tour, Penguin Teen, and Amber Chen for the gifted copy of this amazing story.

Was this review helpful?

Ying takes to the high seas in the conclusion of the "Fall of the Dragon" duology.

It's been two years since Ying said goodbye to Ye-yang and left the Engineer's Guild in Fei. Trying to put all her past mistakes behind her, Ying is attempting to move on. When her fiancée is murdered in a brutal pirate attack, Ying has no choice but to return to the capital and meet her destiny. Her little sister, Nian is betrothed to marry Ye-yang, the High Commander of the Nine Isles. Unfortunately, he's distracted and has little time for her with all the war preparations. At least Nian is kept company by his younger brother, Ye-kan. As tensions rise, Ying, Ye-Yang, Nian, and Ye-kan must band together to save their people from utter destruction.

I must say, I definitely enjoyed reading this second installment more than the first book. If it wouldn't have been so long, I may have even liked this one. However, I found myself growing bored at the repetitive nature of this book and all the political turmoil that literally advanced the story nowhere.

It takes quite a while for the action in this one to even begin to pick up. Reuniting the main cast of characters took way too many pages, which definitely added to the length of this one. There is also a long section in the middle in which Ying's gang gets kidnapped by pirates (which was honestly one of the more interesting portions of the book), that caused the plot to get elongated immensely. Nian and Ye-kan meanwhile are stuck ruling the kingdom and trying to uncover the traitors in their midst (which was a super boring part of this story). The plot in this one had a bit of a hard time plotting, in my opinion.

This book didn't make me like Ying or Ye-yang any more than I already did, which was unfortunate. Going into a book that is over 400 pages long and not liking the main characters is a major oof. I still find their romance to be creepy, and I cannot get behind how controlling this man is. Luckily, Ye-yang has some growth before the end of this series, but still, yeesh.

My favorite part of this book was definitely getting to know Nian and Ye-kan more. Ye-kan was my favorite character in the first book and seeing him evolve from this nerdy dweeb into the temporary leader of a kingdom is pretty neat. The little romantic snippets between these two was honestly the only thing that kept me going at times, and it's still pretty mid for a romance all things considered.

I do like the messages about family, letting go of the past, and such that this book leaves the reader with. Unfortunately, these themes are nowhere near strong enough to make reading almost a thousand pages worth it.

The ending was also one of the most underwhelming things I have ever read. The way that half of the characters either end up betraying each other or dead just felt rather weak in my opinion. The lack of any actual conclusion was super annoying to me. I've spent so much time with these characters, and I feel that the author gave us literally nothing worthwhile in the end.

Overall, "The Blood Phoenix" was a disappointing conclusion to a disappointing series. I was so excited to dive into the "Fall of the Dragon" series, but this was actually one of the most underwhelming duologies I have ever read. I am definitely not a fan of this one, so I will not be reading any spin-off series set in this same world, that's for sure. It makes me so sad to rip into this one so extremely negatively, but I just couldn't bring myself to feel as though these books are worth the time commitment.

Was this review helpful?

This one was a bit of a slow burn for me. The beginning didn’t hook me right away, but once the story found its rhythm, I started to get pulled in. There’s a heavier, more emotional tone in The Blood Phoenix.

Some pacing issues and character decisions made it hard to fully connect at times, but there were scenes that really stood out and made me pause. The world is getting darker, the stakes feel more personal, and by the end, I was definitely more invested than I expected to be.

Not a favorite, but it had some strong moments and is definitely worth a read. A solid 3.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Book 2 of the Fall of the Dragon series, it picks up 2 years after the end of Book 1 so you need to read Of Jade and Dragons for background on things mentioned, as well as the main characters. This was much more emotional and dark since the attack on the fishing village from The Blood Phoenix. Between lives at stake and emotions running high, Ying has to face her past with Ye-Yang, who’s now the High Commander.

Ying’s sister, Nian, and the 14th Prince, Ye-kan also appear in this chapter of their lives as Ying has to return to —- to use the equipment at the Engineers guild. Things are so tense given how things ended in Book 1 and now there are pirates! I had to get the audiobooks to hear this read to me and it wasn’t a disappointment. I did feel like the ending could have led to more and I’m hoping that maybe another chapter in the series could come. A spin-off maybe? Overall, very enjoyable reads and more so as listens.

Was this review helpful?