Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I will admit that this took me an embarrassing amount of time to realize this was CHARLIE-Charlie…like from “Every Summer After” Charlie.

BUT, once I realized that I was sooo excited! I am so glad she finally shared his story and it didn’t disappoint.

I loved this book cover to cover. The banter between Charlie and Alice was TOP TIER! She was a little too shy at some parts, in my opinion, but it was so fun to see Charlie bring her out of her shell.

Charlie was very cocky, sometimes overly so, but it was perfect for his character and I was kicking my feet and giggling the majority of the book.

THE TENSION in this book!! It was more of a slow burn/friends to lovers, and it was so much fun!!!

This book is a perfect summer read and I loved revisiting Barry’s Bay. Carley Fortune has such a brilliant and beautiful way of writing about summer, that it paints the most beautiful picture in my mind!!


Thank you to NetGalley and publishers for the ARC in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

ok i guess i'm going to be thinking about charlie florek forever??

5 beautiful stars for ms carley fortune!! again!!

every summer after is one of my fav romances ever so i literally itching to get back to barry's bay and read charlie's story. it absolutely met and exceeded my expectations!!

i really loved charlie in every summer after and was glad to see a whole book centered around him! carley did an amazing job of developing his character in this book in a way that felt consistent with his portrayal in the first one. i enjoyed how they tackled the Big Spoiler from ESA too, because it was such an important convo to have. some of my favorite scenes were between charlie alice and nan, i was just so charmed by that dynamic. and of course it was so sweet whenever percy and sam showed back up!! i do feel like charlie pushed alice away for JUST A BIT TOO LONG and i wish they resolved their drama during the summer. that's my one and only qualm though i love you charlie i love you alice i love you nan and i love you carley fortune!!!

thank you thank you berkley for the ARC!! <3 <3

Was this review helpful?

This one is the perfect summer time/beach read! From the very first page, I was swept away by the warmth, nostalgia, and undeniable chemistry between the characters. I could not put this book down.

This one iis like a soft breeze off the lake, gentle, evocative, and layered with emotion. The way it captures those bittersweet in-between moments, where past and present collide, tugged at my heart in the most unexpected ways. Alice is such a beautifully written character, thoughtful, vulnerable, and so deeply real. And Charlie? Whew. The slow-burn tension, the flirtation, the longing... it all builds with the kind of ache that stays with you long after the last page.

The setting itself feels like a character, a sun-dappled haven that holds memories, secrets, and the promise of healing. The lake, the cottage, the yellow boat... every detail is painted with such love and wistfulness.

If you're looking for a book that will make you feel seen, make you swoon, and leave you a little breathless, this one is it. It’s romantic, emotional, and infused with just the right amount of angst to pull on your heartstrings in the best way.

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic summer reading! Carley's writing is compelling and beautifully done. This is going to be THE book of the summer.

Was this review helpful?

This book was utter perfection. I have loved every one of Carley Fortune’s book but this one might be my favourite. Returning to Barry’s Bay felt familiar and new at the same time. Alice was a fantastic protagonist and I loved how she flourished throughout the book. The depth given to Charlie was unmatched and swiftly led to him being crowned my favourite Florek brother. It was also so great to see Percy and Sam again and get a glimpse into what their life post Every Summer After is like. This book was so romantic and well written, I will definitely be picking up a copy when it comes out!

Was this review helpful?

First off, thank you so much to the publishers and NetGalley for my ARC! I screamed when I was approved for it. Thank you, thank you, thank you!

To start, I ate this up because it was so summery and cute. I have loved every book by this author and this one was no exception. However, it wasn't my favorite title from Carley Fortune. I would rate it 3.5 stars, rounded up to 4.

It was fun & easy and cute, but nothing special. It felt oddly long for not much happening, while simultaneously being a very quick and easy read. I didn't love the aspect of insta-love that it felt like Charlie and Alice had, as well as the unexplained idea of friends with benefits. It felt like a key conversation was missing.

I loved the summer bucket list, and would love to see it in either the front or the back of the book in print form. While reading an e-copy, I couldn't remember everything that Alice had written and would have loved to refer back to it throughout the course of the summer.

Finally, I felt that the entire book wrapped up way too quickly. Suddenly Charlie was in the hospital but then magically better and having sex within 3 pages? It felt very rushed and while it was teased throughout the course of the book, it felt that it came very second-best to the sex scenes.

Again, not my favorite Carley Fortune book, but still worth picking up even through it fell slightly flat for me. I would love to see it as a movie though!💛

Was this review helpful?

Is this the best Carley Fortune book yet?! It very well could be! I am obsessed with everything about Charlie Florek and his and Alice's relationship during their golden summer. At first he came off as a bit arrogant and annoying, but with time you can see just how loveable Charlie really is. He bakes for Alice, takes Nan to choir practice, and spends the lazy summer days just being with them. And if you loved the setting of Every Summer After, you're in luck because this takes places back at Barry's Bay (Charlie is actually Sam's brother!). Great execution, great romance, great summer setting, all-around just great great great! Definitley do not miss this one!

Was this review helpful?

Easiest 5 stars ever. “Good things happen at the lake.”

There is SO much to love in this one. It took the top spot for my favorite Carley Fortune book!

This story follows 32 year old Alice Everly. Her grandmother, Nan, is feeling really down after hip surgery. Alice is going through a lot dealing with a bad breakup and being in a work slump. As a way to try to lift Nan’s spirits and also get a little escape herself, they decide to head to Barrys Bay for the summer (Alice’s first time back in 16 years).

Charlie Florek (yes, that Charlie Florek, from Every Summer After) is helping to fix up the cabin that they are staying in. He is just as flirty and fun as he was as a teenager.

Alice creates a summer bucket list with all the things she wished she would have done when she was 17. Charlie, being the kind and helpful man he is, decides to help her with it!

The banter right out of the gates is SO GOOD. What I love so much about this one is the foundation of friendship that they form first, building with the slow-burn. They are able to be open and be completely themselves with each other, which they have both struggled with.

The friendship between Charlie and Nan was a major highlight for me throughout. I also loved watching the dynamics unfold between Alice, her 3 siblings, and her parents as the story goes on. The banter between Alice and Heather is so accurate to a sister relationship.

And of course, getting some updates on Percy and Sam was just the icing on the cake!!

This book just felt so nostalgic to me. Reading about the bridge and rock jumping threw me back into all the memories I had of doing that when I was younger as well. I love when stories can evoke personal memories.

I sure do love those Florek boys!!

Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book is definitely a favorite of the year for me. If you loved Every Summer After, then you have got to read this one. Between the lake setting, a romance that gave me butterflies and characters that I felt attached to, this book was a total win.

From start to finish I felt the chemistry between Charlie and Alice. Even from simple moments like the way he said her name or looked at her. It was so easy to feel the pull and desire between them. Between Charlie's constant teasing and Alice speaking her mind, it created the most entertaining sparring. I loved how flirty Charlie was but also just a genuinely sweet and thoughtful guy.

Charlie and Alice were opposites but complemented each other so well. Alice could truly be herself and felt free around Charlie. They had fun together. Alice wasn't used to having these experiences. I loved how her photography connected to different pieces of the storyline. Especially going back to when her and Charlie were teenagers.

With a perfect blend of light, fun moments with deeper parts to the story, this is a book I will remember for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

I have been wanting to DNF this book since being 20% in it but I kept going and I decided I'm just gonna DNF while I'm 60% in. I really think the author messed up with not giving Charlie a POV at all. We are reading this book because we know of Charlie's story and because we've read him in a passbook so it makes no sense for you not to have him have a voice at all in a book that should really be about him.

I do not care about Alice after everything happened in the last book with Charlie. Also Alice is very annoying and honestly is harassing Charlie throughout the whole book. I read lines were says Alice goes to kiss Charlie and he's hesitant or honestly uncomfortable yes he's like she just doesn't care and keeps trying to make a move on him.

Alice and her Nan I'm such a weird relationship because I feel like NAN barely likes Alice and would rather be around Charlie all day which is so weird. Also I think Alice storyline and purpose in the whole book is dumb. I understand that she wanted to be more authentically you in your career but it's not that deep that your picture is being shown in a gallery. For someone to have no money you're so price to have your work off of the Internet.

I just don't think this is what Charlie deserved after reading about him in every summer after. The book should have been in his POV or had at least a couple chapters of his POV because we're not really here for Alice.

Was this review helpful?

I will never forget how entranced I was by Carley Fortune's first novel, Every Summer After. That entire reading experience was special and rare and I just loved the immersive summer setting at the lake and the characters within. I was also one of many readers a bit intrigued by Charlie, the older brother, and I was SO DELIGHTED when Carley announced that she was writing this book about Charlie's life in his 30s. I went into this book with high expectations for a great read set in Barry's Bay and my expectations were exceeded. This book gave me the same tingly feelings I had when I read Every Summer After, but I also found it significantly more relatable since it featured two main characters in their mid-30s. Alice in particular had a similar personality type to my own and I really related to her feelings of always wanting to help others and finding it difficult sometimes to stand up for her own needs and wants. I also revelled in a side character named Heather (yay!), related immensely to the ups and downs of interacting with Alice's 13-year old niece, and absolutely adored Alice's beautiful relationship with her grandmother (which made me miss mine SO much).

In short, this entire book had me vascillating between tears and a goofy grin and I swooned and instantly picked it back up after finishing and reread all my favourite bits. The banter and chatter between Charlie and Alice was SO FUN, the setting (as we already know) was 100% ideal, their character developments and career choices were realistic and fascinating, and the glimpses of Percy and Sam made me so happy.

Carley has said that you don't need to read Every Summer After before diving into this one, and that's true, but if you do ever plan to read Every Summer After I'd read that one first because many of the events will be spoiled and it will set you up to really savour and appreciate Charlie's story here. This will be one I return to, highlight, listen to on audiobook when it's out, and recommend widely.

Was this review helpful?

good things happen at the lake!!! 📖🌞💘📸⛵️ and one golden summer proves it again and again.

from the very first page, carley fortune drops us back into barry’s bay with all her signature warmth & magic. you can literally feel the golden light warming your skin, hear the hum of the dock under your feet, and smell the sunscreen and old paperbacks on the porch. it’s a love letter to summer, coming home to yourself, and invisible strings 🌅

enter: charlie florek. my new favorite book boyfriend. this man is a green-eyed flirty menace with emotional depth and I ate up every single word that came out of his mouth. the banter? the tension?? I was SQUEALING. he brings fun back into alice’s life – makes her laugh again, feel seen again. and he shows up for her, quietly and consistently, even when she doesn’t know how to ask for help.

and then there’s alice everly, who sees the world so clearly through her camera lens, but has to learn to see herself with that same compassion. I loved her emotional arc. how after years of loving others so deeply, she finally lets herself be loved back. and not just passively, she chooses charlie too, even with all his baggage and his fears, she meets him there. this book is for the girls who are still figuring it out, but know a good thing when it shows up.

forehead kisses to Berkley for the eARC! i will be referencing this book in every ‘what should i read next?’ conversation until further notice.

Was this review helpful?

DNF @ 22%

Unfortunately, this Carley Fortune was not for me. Part of this is my fault - I did not realize that Charlie, our MMC, is a character from Every Summer After, another Fortune novel that I did not like (particularly because of the third act conflict). The main reason though is the writing. While Fortune excels in setting, the characterization of Alice and Charlie feels much younger than their ages, and the dialogue feels forced and awkward to me. Alice is 32 years old, but her inner thoughts feel much more like someone in their early twenties or even younger. I know a lot of readers will really like this book, so I hope it finds its audience!

Was this review helpful?

This book was exactly what I needed, it gave me life and made me so excited for summer. Carley Fortune just gets how to write atmosphere. I could feel the sun, smell the lake, hear the waves, it was like stepping right into Barry’s Bay. The setting was so vivid and nostalgic, and the whole story felt warm, honest, and just really human in the best way.

Alice was such a relatable character. She tries so hard not to be a burden and to show up in a way that’s easier for everyone else, so watching her slowly drop those walls and just be herself with Charlie was really special. I loved being in her head and seeing that transformation.

Now let’s talk about Charlie Florek. MY. HEART. This man is confident and charming with total golden retriever energy, but also has this soft, broken side that made me melt. The way he looked at Alice like she was the most precious thing in the world? Swooning. The way he cared for her and her Nan? Absolutely done for and had me melting in a puddle.

The romance was a slow burn, but so worth it. The tension, the flirting, the yearning, I was fully invested. Their connection felt real and layered, and they actually communicated (!!), which made everything hit even harder. And while it’s not some breezy, no-conflict summer love story (they definitely go through it), the payoff is so satisfying.

I loved this book so much and already want to re-read it. Take me back to Barry’s Bay, please.

Thank you to Berkley Publishing for the eARC via NetGalley!

Was this review helpful?

𝙶𝚘𝚘𝚍 𝚃𝚑𝚒𝚗𝚐𝚜 𝙷𝚊𝚙𝚙𝚎𝚗 𝚊𝚝 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝙻𝚊𝚔𝚎 ☼

One Golden Summer by Carley Fortune
Release May 6, 2025

Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️

ummmmm excuse me, carley we need to talk…. because you had no business writing the perfect summer romance.
this is hands down my favorite work by carley fortune. i completely ate this up with absolutely zero notes.

if you have read every summer after you will recognize our MMC. charlie was the brother of sam in ESA, and we finally get a story focused on him! charlie literally had me giggling and kicking my feet the whole time. he is THE summer book boyfriend of 2025.

out FMC, alice, is a photographer who is feeling a little lost after her relationship falls apart and she takes her grandma to stay at the lake for the summer to help her recover from a hip replacement.

i loved the focus on family relationships in this. between alice and her nan, charlie and his brother. also charlie dealing with the loss of his parents and coping with changes in his life.

i cannot recommend this enough! it was absolutely perfect and i cannot wait to run to bookstores to pick up my physical copy on the release day!

thank you @carleyfortune, @berkleypub and @netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this amazing arc!

Was this review helpful?

I have read all of Carley’s books and I have to say that this one might be my favorite or at least tied for favorite with Every Summer After. Sooo happy to be back in Barry’s Bay! I loved getting Charlie’s story and I also really appreciated the little sneak peaks of Sam and Percy. It was well worth the wait. I felt like I was right back where I was three summers ago and it gave me such a nice nostalgic feel. I also FLEW through it.

I absolutely LOVED the friendship between Charlie and Alice. It felt authentic and the flirty banter was top notch. Also — pour one out for Nan, everyone needs a Nan! Overall, Carley gave me everything I was left yearning for when I finished Every Summer After.

Read if you like: banter, forced proximity, summery lake vibes, friends to lovers

Also — You can always count on Carley to give us beautiful cover!!

Huge thank you to NetGalley + Berkeley Pub for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

5 Stars!

When I finished Every Summer After, I was weary of reading One Golden Summer hoping that it would live up to the standards ESA set. However, it truly exceeded them. This book was amazing. I legit could not put it down. I loved being back in Barry's Bay and I absolutely loved Charlie's character this time around. Every time I started reading, I was instantly transported back to the lake, on the dock, with the sun shining and the banana boat heading our way. If you loved Every Summer After, you NEED to read this book - it's a non negotiable! And if you haven't read Every Summer After, then I'm super jealous of you and you have TWO amazing books to look forward to!!
​--

One Golden Summer introduces a new character, Alice Everly, who is at a crossroads in her career and her love life. She decides to take her Nan to Barry's Bay to Nan's old friend's cabin for the summer to help her recover from hip surgery. Little did she know that the summer would not only heal Nan, but it would change Alice forever. Charlie lives across the lake and has been helping out with Nan's friend's cabin. Soon, Alice recognizes him from a photo she took when she visited Barry's Bay at 17. The story from that photo comes back to life and Alice has the summer of her 17 year old dreams.

YES Sam and Percy make an appearance and my heart explodes throughout the entire book.
--

Long story short - just go ahead and pre order your copy now! Thank you SO much @netgalley @berkleypub and @carleyfortune for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review. I have already pre ordered my paperback copy to add to my collection!

Was this review helpful?

One Golden Summer is hands-down my favorite Carley Fortune novel yet. It’s the perfect mix of love, lake life, and the bittersweet beauty of growing up. The setting was vivid and nostalgic, instantly transporting me to slow, golden summer days by the water. The main characters were relatable, captivating, and entertaining—and the supporting cast, especially the grandmother (my favorite!), made the whole storyline so easy to fall in love with.

This is the definition of a perfect summer read: heartfelt, emotional, and full of charm. It’s the kind of book you’ll want to pack for your summer vacation—whether you’re lakeside, beachside, or just dreaming of it.

As a high school librarian, I’ll absolutely be adding One Golden Summer to our collection—it’s the kind of story that will resonate with readers of all ages that are looking for emotional depth, nostalgia, and a truly unforgettable summer. Carley Fortune’s writing truly hits its stride here, and I’m already hoping for a sequel. Until then, I’ll be recommending this one to everyone I know.

Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for the free advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

I loved Every Summer After by Carley when it first debuted years ago. I followed along every year a new release came out, but they just didn't have the same magic that book exuded. So when I heard her 2025 story would bring the return of Berry's Bay and Charlie I knew I was going to be seated. But to the point that I would be giving its sequel a 5 star review?! Well, that was a great surprise for me!

Granted, this story started off slow and I was sort of worried I was not going to enjoy Alice as a main character. But she really began to shine once she was introduced to Charlie. It's funny, I looked back at my review for Every Summer After and I saw I made a comment to protect Sam Florek at all costs... but I'm changing my tune and saying we must protect CHARLIE FLOREK AT ALL COSTS! He had amazing banter and my heart ripped out of my chest during those final 40ish pages of the story. It was a plot twist I did not see coming!!! I just felt like the chemistry between Alice and Charlie was so genuine and I think it will take a lot this year to top these two as my favorite rom-com couple. I enjoyed the peeks back into Percy and Sam's world from Book One while not feeling forced.

I am back on the Carley Fortune train until further notice!

Was this review helpful?

Alice Everly spent one magical summer at the lake when she was seventeen, shy, and awkward. Now, years later, Alice is a photographer and recently single; she's back in Barry’s Bay to help her Nan recover from a hip surgery, and maybe reconnect with the girl she wanted to be. What she doesn't expect is Charlie—older, bolder, and still able to make her heart race. She didn't even know him then, had only taken one memorable photo, but it was everything she wished for herself that summer. As Alice and Charlie fall into an easy rhythm of sunny days and starlit nights, their connection deepens into something real—something that makes Alice question where she belongs, and who she wants to be. Because while Alice sees the world through a lens, Charlie is the one who truly sees her. And as Nan always says, good things happen at the lake.

This book is summer. Long days, starry nights, bikinis and boats, bucket lists, summer flings. Charlie had a play boy reputation, but that didn't really scare Alice away and I liked that she could look past his past. Alice was very relatable - an easy child growing up, often overlooked and reliable, everything is always "fine." Charlie was the first to look at her like she mattered, and to prioritize her. As always with friends to lovers, I found myself saying - just go for it!! Your reasons for not dating aren't good enough!! But, there's a bit of a twist holding Charlie back. Alice found her worth and I loved to see her grow and glow. Families and relationships can be messy, but they can also be worth it. Charlie and Alice were opposites and so good for each other. Add this romance to your summer reading list!

Was this review helpful?