I’m a sucker for mythology so I HAD to request this ARC of The Gods Time forgot

This story is a historical romance with hints of mythology and magic. It’s so vividly descriptive of the era it’s set in you feel like you’re in the period of the book, and evokes such strong emotions towards the characters and their actions.

Gonzalez was cooking when writing the banter between Finn and Rua because it had me kicking my feet.

This isn’t one you wanna miss! The Gods Time forgot is out on April 8th 2025.

I am rating this 5 stars simply because this book was PHENOMANAL. If you throw mythology into any story, I will probably love it immediately, but Irish mythology in Gilded Age Manhattan surrounded in mystery and forbidden love? Oh my god as soon as I was in, I was hooked. My one critique is the ending felt a bit rushed and cut off rather suddenly, but I think that just means I have to read it again! A stunning debut and I cannot wait for others to read it, to obsess over it just like me! Kelsie has become a must-read author for me in one fell swoop. PICK THIS UP IN APRIL, you absolutely will not regret it.

A book with Bridgeton vibes set in 1870s New York with a smudge of magic.

I actually liked the longing, the buildup of the romance quite a lot! The yearning for each other while trying to abide by the rules of high society really brought the banter. I also liked the originality of the Irish mythology and the mystery at the start of the book.

However, it felt like two complete different books tied together. For a big part, the middle, the magic / mythology aspect fades to the background in which it is just a historical romance. Nothing wrong with that, but going in I had a different expectation.

I received this eARC courtesy of NetGalley. Thank you for the review opportunity!

An amazing historical romantic fantasy with the some of the best banter I’ve ever read:) The book catches your attention from the very first word in chapter 1. I do wish there was a more fantasy element to the book but nonetheless it was great

I wasn't convinced of this as enemies to lovers. Finn is sympathetic to Rua from the start. Rua insists she dislikes him because... well it was never actually clear to me why she disliked him. She seemed to get worked up over how rude and dismissive he was when he'd said fairly normal things by my reading, and despite the fact that he was also—by her own admission—the only person who was nice to her at these events.

This book is set in 19th century New York, back when women in general didn't have rights, the poor are poor and the rich are wicked and could care less about everyone and everything else. Rua's family is about to become one of the Manhattan elite, but the problem is, she doesn't remember who she is and that whoever she was before, "Emma", she was pretty... problematic to say the least. Rua's fiery nature proves an obstacle to the Harringtons' plans to be accepted to the fold. And then there's the enigmatic Lord of Donore who she probably knows from *somewhere*...

First off, that cover? Gorgeous! It's got all of what the typical romance reader might want: enemies-to-lovers, yeaning, banter between the love interests. The worldbuilding of the setting was immaculate; the author did a great job reflecting on the social issues of that era and weaving it into the story.

Here's the not-so-great parts: I feel like the beginning dragged on for a bit too long before we got to anything exciting, and the ending felt too rushed and didn't solve everything. I only got morsels of the Irish mythology the book marketed, and that's only when I reached about 50% of the book. I didn't like Rua very much as she represented the stereotypical "I'm not like the other girls" trope, with her acting stubborn and difficult half of the time. It could've helped her if she kept her temper in check so that she could have time to figure out her past. That alone almost made me DNF. Then again I'm probably not the right audience for this book. Finn was a whole lot better though; I loved the complexity of his character and how he was the opposite of the New York elite he was trying to join so much.

The only other good thing in the story was the little twist at the near end that got me thinking "Say what now?". It got me good when I started questioning the signs of how everything came down to that moment. Saying more will warrant a spoiler.

I wanted so much to love this book, but alas it fell short from my expectations.

Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for providing me with this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

I will never be over the banter in this book. Kelsie has a way of writing tension and yearning that is just truly an art. I am a huge fan of period romances and mythology and I think this book married the two in a really interesting and fresh way. Annette is one of the better villains I’ve read all year and I loved the juxtaposition of the human world often being as cruel as the world of Gods. The characters all sing in their own ways and I truly enjoyed my time with this story. Thank you for never giving up on Rua and making sure this story was told.

The Gods Time Forgot by Kelsie Sheridan Gonzalez is unlike any book I've ever encountered. The story masterfully blends mythology, fantasy, and a deep exploration of time and fate in a way that feels fresh and innovative. The world-building is exceptional, pulling you into a realm where gods, mortals, and the very fabric of time intertwine in unexpected ways.

What really sets this book apart is its originality. I’ve never read anything quite like it, and that’s what made it so captivating. The characters are richly developed, and the plot twists keep you on the edge of your seat. The pacing is mostly well-done, keeping the story moving without feeling rushed.

However, the ending felt a bit too quick for my liking. It seemed rushed, and I couldn’t help but feel that certain elements of the story could have been fleshed out more. Some of the conclusions and character arcs felt a little too abrupt, leaving me wanting more depth in those final moments.

That said, the book is still a fantastic read, its uniqueness and the creativity behind it more than make up for the slightly hurried conclusion. If you’re looking for something different that challenges your expectations, The Gods Time Forgot is a must-read. It’s an unforgettable journey that will stay with you long after finishing it.

The Gods Time Forgot by Kelsie Sheridan Gonzalez is a perfect book for a switch identity romance.

Rua only knows two things: her name and she has no memories. She tries to blend into the society when the Harrington family mistake Rua for their missing daughter, Emma.

As she tries to blend into the society, she drawn to a newcomer in Manhattan society, Lord Donore which somehow familiar to Rua. Finn knows he shouldn’t become involved with a mysterious, recently missing debutante but he is intrigued by Emma and he has uncanny feeling that this isn’t the first time they met.

✅ Irish mythology
✅ past lovers from another time
✅ past life
✅ ritual
✅ sacrifice
✅ dreams
✅ threat
✅ suspense
✅ action
✅ angst
✅ trap
✅ plot twist
✅ betrayal
✅ clean book

There a lot of characters in this book and each character gives impact to the main characters such as the Harrington family which gives Rua pressure to blend into the society or else she will face the consequences.

This was a fun, light fantasy romance, but it didn't really work for me. From the title and cover, I was expecting a sweeping epic, so maybe this is down to my expectations, The characters felt very underdeveloped, and while the mythology component was intriguing, the world just fell flat.

This story weaves mythology, mystery, and a touch of the divine into a narrative that feels both epic and intimate. With lush world-building and compelling characters, this novel immerses you in a story where ancient deities and modern struggles collide.

.Gonzalez’s writing is rich and atmospheric, capturing the grandeur of mythical elements while grounding the story in human emotions and stakes.

Rating: 4.5/5
Recommendation: Ideal for readers who enjoy mythological retellings, intricate world-building, and stories that explore the bond between humanity and the divine.

1.5

Rua wakes up under ground and doesn’t remember anything but her name, but when found, people call her Emma. Pretending to be Emma she stumbles upon a gentleman that sparks up a feeling like they know each other.

This book was one word: boring. The story failed at every aspect: characters - boring, background - boring, writing - boring. One and only positive thing is that I’m now interested in Irish mythology.

Thanks to NetGalley and Alcove Press for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Thank you NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
I was so excited for this book because the premise was SO good! But unfortunately this fell very flat for me. The world building was lackluster and the pacing was just completely off. Not my favorite

Irish Mythology mixed with Outlander & Bridgerton vibes!! I really enjoyed the book, The Gods Time Forgot. It was a quick, adventurous, fun story to read. The teasing & banter between Finn and Rua was amusing and delightful.

The last chapter felt extremely rushed for the ending of the story, especially the last few pages. I thought it could have stretched a little more, but I still loved the book.

For starters, I really enjoyed these characters. It was a great mix of POV’s. The only thing I wasn’t a fan of is how long it took for the story to get started. It felt like I was reading the same scenario over and over until about 50% of the way through. I am not one for excessive ‘set up’ in a story, it’s usually the reason I put a book down. I wasn’t reaching for this as often as I’d like to. I felt a lot of time was spent on rich parties rather than diving deeper into the characters. HOWEVER—once it picked up I was definitely invested in the story. Rua & Finn were exceptional and I’m itching to learn more. For full transparency—I have this a 3.75 on StoryGraph but I could not in good faith give it a 3 here because it was an intriguing story & will be reading any follow-up from this story/author!

A whimsical and captivating read! I have never read anything involving Irish mythology before, but this story was so mysterious and engaging. At first, I wasn’t really sure what was going on with Rua and her amnesia/family dynamics. However, I stayed for the ride, because as much as I was confused, I found Rua’s “always in trouble” personality to be endearing. 

And then FINN! Ohmagosh, what a connection! That boy was so down bad for Rua that even I ignored the mysteriousness of his background. He was a lord somehow but also pretty “new money” and self-made. Rua and Finn’s chemistry was insaneee—they tried fighting it, but whether it was arguing or intensely staring at each other from across the room, you could basically feel it off the pages. And then against the glittery atmosphere of old New York high society, their banter and connection just felt *oh-so* romantic. 

I also enjoyed the pacing of the plot just because of how the story/“truth” was revealed, but I can see someone wishing it was a bit sped up if they weren’t necessarily invested in the Finn-Rua connection. I did, however, struggle with some aspects of the storyline—namely, the fact that Rua got away with SO much scandalous behaviour that it left more questions than answers. Why would she keep being invited to events if basically everyone hates her and she’s causing the scandals of the season? I also would’ve liked the ending to be drawn out; it felt very cut-and-dry for what was a pretty complex plotline. I think that an epilogue or a few more pages could've really elevated the conclusion as a whole. I just wanted to keep reading more of it!

Overall, I think this is a great release from the author! Kelsie Sheridan Gonzalez intricately combines Irish mythology with the glam of a golden-era New York, and I would be interested to see what other works they come out with. I recommend this story for readers who enjoy a unique blend of fantasy, historical romance, and mystery.

Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an eARC in exchange for an honest review!

This book was really confusing at the start and I know that Rua is confused but it was a bit jarring for me as the reader. I had to take a break and try again which always bums me out a little bit. I did enjoy it once I got into it but I wanted to just get lost in it from the beginning!

I enjoyed this debut novel which I read as an ARC thanks to netgalley and publishers.
The character of Rua is well developed and I enjoyed the hints of backstory as Emma/Rua tries to regain her memories. The relationship building with Finn was good and I enjoyed their back and forth. NY high society was well done and though I HATED flossie she was a great character (not sure about her ending!)
Pacing a little off and the very end was rushed IMHO.
Solid 3 stars

The story shines in its vivid depiction of 19th-century New York, capturing both its glittering wealth and its darker undercurrents. The opulence of the Gilded Age is beautifully juxtaposed with Rua’s haunting, otherworldly memories, which hint at a deeper connection to Irish mythology. These flashes of Rua’s past add an ethereal quality to the story, creating a rich tapestry of lore and suspense that keeps readers guessing.

Recommendation: for lovers of romantasy and anyone who enjoys stories brimming with magic, mystery, and heart.

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the chance to read and review an ARC of "The Gods Time Forgot" by Kelsie Sheridan Gonzalez.

It is really difficult to critique an author's debut. It is such a momentous accomplishment to finish a book, nevermind to get as far as the process of publication. I want to acknowledge that before I start, because I think that this book had so much potential and Kelsie Sheridan Gonzalez is definitely an author that I will be watching.

I also want it noted that this is my very first time reading an advanced reader's copy and I'm so thankful for the chance. I don't know how different the finished product will be, but this is my review of the book in its current state.

This is one of those books that has a brilliant premise but poor execution. The author clearly lost steam halfway through and then rushed headlong to a fairly unsatisfying conclusion in the last few chapters. There was so much build up that ultimately lead to nothing. The lovers averted danger because Finn Hulked out and... closed a hole with dirt? A GODDESS that has been controlling their lives from the start of the novel is defeated by... dirt?

The mystery presented in the first chapter hooked me in. After that, it was the love story. And then the mystery dragged on and on for hundreds of pages with empty clues and it felt like there was no reward. A whole lot of nothing happens.

I have to address the characters. For a character-driven rather than a plot-driven book, the characters are inconsistent and one-dimensional, especially where Rua is concerned. She is the main female protagonist and there's just not much to her beyond her rage. I get it, she is a war goddess at war with her instincts and her newfound humanity, but... that's it. She is just rage. She seems to have a soft spot for children, and deep down, she seems to crave the acceptance of the society that she is masquerading in, but it's not enough. It must be incredibly difficult to flesh out a character who doesn't know who she is, but regardless, Rua needs some work. She doesn't need to become good or even be likable, but she is an extremely flat character with no development whatsoever. It is impossible to understand why the kind-hearted Finn could love her beyond phantom memories from the past. There is no reason for him to love her now beyond the physical stuff. Finn is a much more fleshed out character. He had goals, ambitions. He had loves and hates and connections to other characters. This is why the romance falls flat, though. It's easy to see why Finn is lovable, but why does RUA love Finn? What drew her to him in their past life? What was it about him that made her want to give up immortality and power? We never find out. There has to be more there for it to be compelling and believable.

As for the side characters... they are written even more poorly than Rua. Mrs. Harrington is like a deranged Mrs. Bennett. The society women are insipid and extremely one-dimensional. I think that the author needs to do a bit more research about what the rules of etiquette were like for women in that era. They would never behave as her characters do in public or in formal settings; and especially not in front of men. I understand that this is fiction, but if you're going to represent a real historical period and an entire class of people, you have to try to do it right. I get what she was going for and I have a feeling that the finished product will be a lot better. This just really bothered me as I was reading this copy.

Lastly... I think when you are including mythology and religions in a story, you should do so with accuracy. They were, at one point, real religions that were practiced by real people and it's important to be respectful. Combining The Morrigan with Hekate by making them the Mother, the Maiden, and the Crone kind of wasn't cool. I'm not sure if it's meant to be a simplification or something, but that stuck out to me and bothered me as well. Again, I understand that it is mythology and many might consider it to be fair game for adaptation, but... what can I say? I majored in history.

To close this off, I want to reiterate that this book had enormous potential and I think it was pretty fantastic. I just think it really needs some work and some fleshing out. I'll be willing to give the published edition another go when it comes out.