A spicy take instead of a spicy book today:

I spent the first thirty years of my life judging romance readers LOUDLY. I am in no way proud of it, on the contrary I’m ashamed to have shared the same sort of energy as that clown on BookTok with her “Your book is about dragons, what did you learrrrn” reel. I was genuinely perplexed as to why anyone would choose, of their own volition, to spend their time reading low brow, predictable rot about getting railed. I felt that reading lit-fic made me superior and more discerning and intellectually capable.

How far this asshole dickhead has fallen from her perch because this MAGNIFICENT work of literature by Laurent Binet was absolutely wasted on me. Not - and let me make this plain - that I didn’t recognise the beauty and brilliance of Binet’s writing and tale, but merely that I didn’t have the mental bandwidth as a perpetually sleep deprived mother to fully appreciate it.

I salivated over the language, the rhythm of it all. Mooned over the concept of the plot being woven exclusively through letters. Admired the skill necessary to write and manage a double digit cast - couldn’t keep track of them for toffee (would be easier to keep flashing back to the list of correspondents in a paperback than it was an eARC). Couldn’t stop thinking about the intricate labyrinth of the mystery. Savoured the view of Renaissance Florence.

Truly, I adored this book. But three quarters through, and with all the talk of sodomy and the perverted Venus painting, F me, I was ready for someone to get railed and railed HARD.

An absolute masterpiece, make no mistake, and I would recommend it without hesitation for any lit-fic fans.

Thanks kindly to NetGalley for the much appreciated ARC.

[Review as published on GoodReads and Instagram]

Perspective(s) is a novel that really has to be your specific historic cup of tea - but in my case, it was! A murder has taken place in 16th century Florence, and it is up to Giorgio Vasari, painter and architect, and friend to the Grand Duke of Florence, to find the culprit. The whole book is written through letters - not just from Vasari, but from many political interesting figures from that time, including Michelangelo and Catherine de Medici. I think a decent interest and a bit of knowledge about these times is needed to fully enjoy the letters, as the political intrigues of the 16th century Florence are the main focus. There are many letters between many people of interest happening, which sometimes made it a bit hard to follow and remember who was who - so if the topic does not interest you, don't pick it up thinking it'll just be an exciting murder mystery. For a history fan like myself, though, I thought the main value of the book was in all the historical aspects and details, and the unfolding of the plot with murder, betrayal, and some serious Machiavellian plotting was a lovely extra. Finished in four days and cannot wait to get back to Florence someday.

Perspective(s) won’t be for everyone, but wow, was it for me. It’s a mystery told through letters, set in Renaissance Italy, surrounded by the scheming and machinations of the elite. The body of a renowned painter is discovered beside his fresco, with part of the painting clearly altered. Who had the talent to change it, and why? Amidst the investigations, there’s a scandalous elopement, an imprisoned nun, and a workers’ rebellion.

I could have tried to keep track of the various characters and how they connected, but I didn’t even bother, instead reading solely on a vibes basis. Everything was still clear to me, but a heads up that there’s lots of complicated politics and names, and I was happy to let some of it go over my head, but you might not be. I really liked this one: carefully crafted, multivocal, and completely immersive. Thank you NetGalley for the early review copy!

Very unusual book, but entertaining and enjoyable. The whole story is told in letters back and forth to the principle characters. You have a murder mystery, a love story, humorous side stories, and political intrigue. It was quite surprising.

Know that you might (well, I did) find this murder mystery told through letters just a little hard to follow. It's complicated, it's clever and it's twisty. It's also nicely atmospheric and virtually all the characters are based on real people who lived in Renaissance Florence (and elsewhere in Europe). I spent time looking the characters up as I was reading (so I learned something !). Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. For those who enjoy a more cerebral mystery.

Thank you to the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I really enjoyed this book! The epistolary format was refreshing and kept me hooked through the whole book, and it was surprisingly fast-paced even if there were some slow moments here and there. The mystery, intrigue, and dynamics between these characters (who are very much real people) was so interesting and as someone who knows vaguely about the history in this time period I had a good time. The writing style/prose was rich and made the person behind the letter real, as if they were reading it out to me. Tying the different plot threads must have been difficult, but Binet does a wonderful job keeping the reader hooked throughout the novel. I definitely was.

Rating: 4 stars

PERSPECTIVE(S) by Laurent Binet is a captivating and intricately woven tale, blending historical fiction with a touch of mystery, political intrigue, and rich character dynamics. The story unfolds through a series of letters that reveal both the grandeur and the darker, more twisted aspects of Renaissance Italy, making for an immersive and entertaining reading experience.

The novel begins with our storyteller, who, while on vacation in Tuscany, stumbles upon a bundle of dusty old letters in a quaint antique shop. These letters, once belonging to various figures from 1557 Florence, form the backbone of the narrative and tell a remarkable and multifaceted story. At the heart of this story lies the death of the renowned artist Jacopo da Pontormo, whose nearly completed frescoes in the Chapel of San Lorenzo were said to rival those of Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel. The murder of Pontormo sets the stage for a gripping investigation, spearheaded by none other than the legendary artist and author Giorgio Vasari.

The plot thickens when a portrait of Cosimo de’ Medici’s young daughter, Maria, is discovered—her image altered in a compromising manner and used as a tool for political blackmail. This revelation propels the investigation deeper into the political machinations of the Medici court and the world of Renaissance Florence, a city rife with power struggles, scandal, and betrayal.

Binet’s storytelling is notably unique as it unfolds entirely through a series of 176 letters, written by an eclectic cast of characters, from royals and artists to assistants, rebels, and even Pope Paul IV. This epistolary style offers a personal and immediate view into the lives and minds of those involved, making each letter a piece of the larger puzzle. The correspondence provides rich insights into the political, cultural, and social fabric of the time, yet it remains accessible thanks to Binet’s skillful use of modern, engaging language.

What makes PERSPECTIVE(S) truly compelling is the way it balances historical detail with a lighthearted tone. The letters are filled with drama, humor, and the occasional salacious tidbit, adding layers of entertainment to the rich historical backdrop. It’s both a fun read and a thought-provoking exploration of Renaissance Italy’s art, politics, and power dynamics.

In conclusion, PERSPECTIVE(S) is a delightful and intellectually satisfying journey through history, with well-developed characters and a plot that keeps you guessing until the final page. It’s a book that is as much about the art of storytelling as it is about the historical figures it brings to life.

3.5 stars
This is an epistolary book which was quite captivating.
I enjoyed the book - the time period and setting really appealed to me. Florence Italy in the time of the Medici and Michaelangelo!
The characters really came alive with what felt like their own voices. Very impressed how the author made the writing style seem to fit the time period being written about. Thankful for the character list at the beginning of the book. It was essential to get to know the characters and their connections.
However the style did seem to slow down the action of the story. Many of the twists seemed diminished to me by the style as well. The ending did wrap up all the loose ends but it seemed slightly awkward in the telling.
I found it very interesting that the story seemed modern in terms of the issues faced by the characters. History repeats over and over and we can learn something about dealing with our current times by reading historical fiction - that is its beauty.

Thank you to Farrar, Straus and Giroux and NetGalley for the e-book.

In Perspective(s), Binet blends a wide cast of characters bursting with personality and a propulsive, epistolary format into a fresh and humorous take on the murder mystery. Readers who are into history, Italy, and/or art will most likely enjoy this read!

Sixteenth century Florence was the home of master artists and noted historical figures. Laurent Binet’s work revolves around the murder of one such artist commissioned to paint church frescoes. This epistolary novel is concerned with finding his murderer. Simultaneously there is a campaign to find and destroy one of his portraits, an offensive painting depicting a young noblewoman which could destroy her reputation. There are letters from artists and their associates, royalty and religious figures. From Michelangelo to Medici, artistic theory and European history are revealed as the tense and twisting searches continue.. There is much to learn in this work about the era; unfortunately, so many opinions and theories I found confusing at times.

A 1500's Florence murder mystery in an epistolary format, cycling between what we are to believe are a stack of letters that have all found themselves together in a perfectly-constructed narrative.

Don't get me wrong, as an art and art history person, this book should have been right up my alley. I wrote a 25-page paper on Michelangelo in college. And it was, in a lot of parts. But for me, and maybe this is because if the epistolary format, I just didn't get enough voice from some to differentiate from others. One of the pros of the format, I will say, is that it was very easy to dip in and out of, which helped me get through it more quickly. That said, by the 50% mark, I could see where it was going and was just sort of riding it out.

The book shone in the moments where Binet was able to lean into recounting action like a chase through the pieces of 1500's architecture. I was, obviously, drawn to the letters where the characters were given the space to flesh out their recounting of events. But so often the letters are short, with the writer addressing that the brevity of the letter was the result of a need to convey the message quickly, for whatever reason. Which is fair, but I became a bit tired after letter 100+.

All this said, I really appreciated, once I got into the meat of the story, the musings on perspective, and the fact that this book gave me an excuse to revisit the mannerists of Florence and enjoy their use of color and liberal use of perspective. It was fun to sit with these characters, and I guess my main complaint is that I didn't get to for longer. But I think it's purely a limitation of format, for me.

I'm a sucker for historical fiction during Italy's Renaissance. I'm even more of a sucker for a murder-mystery of a famous artist during the time period.

This is written in the form of letters to and from famous people and artists of the time period, including the Medici and Michelangelo, Because of this style, the pacing doesn't suffer from historical background. This lends a quick pace full of action. The perspectives of each persons creates that nuanced version of the murdered artist and what could have happened. It's such an interesting take on Florence, art and power.

Who is allowed to have all the power? Who is allowed to deem what is art and what is allowed? Again, the perspectives explored in this book far out reach the murder of Jacobo. It questions the world and if there is a right perspective at the heart of art.

I truly engaged with this story and will definitely read more from this author.

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC!

When I read [book:The Seventh Function of Language|36031246] I reflected on Laurent Binet's clear affection for the work of Umberto Eco, and this feels a little like another run at Eco (in the <i>Name of the Rose</i> mold rather than the <i>Foucault's Pendulum</i> mode). Binet is still no Eco, and isn't making as big of a swing as Eco did (with accordingly fewer intellectual, philosophical, and theological digressions); this book is a bit more focused on the mystery at hand (who killed the artist Jacopo Pontormo?) and the associated political subplots ramifying off of that murder (the theft of a scandalous portrait, French meddling in Italian politics, the eloping of the Duke of Florence's daughter, etc.). What philosophical content there is, is pretty directly related to the high-art-world milieu of the main murder (e.g. the debate over nudity in art).

And, it's all told in a quite-well-done epistolary style, presented as a classic found-media setup where some separate narrator in the 1800s found a bundle of all of the letters comprising the book (which starts to strain credulity if you think about it too much, but that's probably true of all found-letters epistolary novels of the era). I liked the epistolary style a lot, although I feel like there was still meat on the bone there where Binet could have played a little bit more with the unreliable-narrator (or correspondent?) idea - I noticed one very obvious place where one writer was obviously fabulating and was gratified to have correctly predicted a subsequent letter was going to puncture that (although, that did mean it was a pretty predictable note). I wonder if a closer reader than I would notice further use of unreliability, or not; perhaps Binet didn't want to lean too heavily on the idea given that the underlying "point" of the book is to solve a mystery, and he wanted a mostly-objective record of the mystery-solving.

One major disappointment, though: no author's note or afterword or historical note, aside from the in-fiction preamble describing finding the fictional letters. Given that this is by the author of [book:HHhH|7992363], which I think of as if an author's historical afterword metastasized and overtook the entire preceding novel, this felt like a substantial absence. It may be that Binet thought it would have undermined the fictional conceit of the frame narrative (such as it is) to have Binet himself intrude as the "real" author at the end, but I always love to know what's real and what's imagined (or fictionalized from real inspiration). I found no indication through a cursory Google search that Jacopo Pontormo was actually murdered (much less in the manner described), so there's one obvious fictionalization, but some other things (such as a proto-Marxist trade union agitator that keeps popping up) I'd love to know how much is historically accurate.

I received a digital advance copy of Perspective(s), and it was not at all what I expected - in a good way. The story is entirely told through short letters (a total of 180) written by the characters/correspondents to each other, among them the great Michelangelo and members of the Medici family. Thus the story develops from different perspectives, as the title suggests, but we also learn about different perspectives in art given that the murder victim and many of the characters are famous painters and sculptors. In a fascinating mixture of history and fiction, the author transports us to Renaissance Florence and ‘paints’ a great picture of life, religion and politics in the 16th century with bold characters and a good portion of humor. First and foremost though, this is a murder mystery. In the book, Jacopo Pontormo, one of the city’s greatest artists is found dead on New Years Day 1557 under mysterious circumstances. His last painting goes missing, and unfortunately it is discrediting the Duke of Florence’s family. He commissions his nobleman Giorgio Vasari, none other than the author of ‘Lives of the Artists’, to solve the murder and find the painting.
Delightful intrigues, plenty action and the mystery itself make this novel a fun and quick read. The unique epistolary writing style proves perfect for the story and rendered a more personal impression of the correspondents. Some of the stories are hilarious and show the author’s exceptional wit and humor. I truly enjoyed this novel and loved that most of the characters were actual historical figures. Thus this novel is not only highly entertaining but also educational. I admit I did have to look up many names and references but the book held my interest from start to end and the big twist toward the end blew me away. I can’t wait to read more from this author and hope that it will be just as unique as Perspective(s). A 5⭐️read for me. Initially published in 2023 in French, the publication date for the English edition is April 8, 2025.
I’d like to thank Netgalley, Farrar, Straus and Giroux as well as Mr Laurent Binet for gifting me the digital ARC. It was a pleasure and honor to read it. The above is my honest review and my own opinion.

For me, this novel rated somewhere between a 3.5 and a 4. This is a fictional murder mystery set in Florence in 1557. The characters are a mixture of real and fictional people of that era, ranging from Michelangelo and Cellini to Medici family members. An artist has been found murdered in the church where he was painting frescos and Duke Medici launches an investigation into his murder. I liked the setup, which involved the contemporary author finding a bundle of antique letters and discovering that they revealed this mystery. After the initial preface, the remainder of the plot is relayed through the letters themselves. For me, this structure was what reduced the appeal of the book. The letters jumped between characters and keep straight who was who was not always easy. The author includes a character chart at the start of the book, but it is not always easy to flip back to and study if you are reading on kindle, as I was. The letters also meant that the author's ability to describe settings, smells, and lives of everyday people is more limited. You get the voices of particular characters, their thoughts about things, and their descriptions of art works. You don't get as much of a three-dimensional sense of the feel of life back then. I would have prefered that the book move between letters and the characters themselves (that is, more traditional author narrative). The letters somehow kept most of the characters feeling two dimensional. I found my interest in completing the book ebbing and flowing and may have put it aside before finishing it if I had not been obliged to read the full book and write a review for Net Galley. One of the reasons I am drawn to historical fiction is that I like to feel I am learning something while being entertained. Did I learn something here to warrant sticking with the slower parts of the book? Perhaps...but not as much as I'd have hoped. I was also frustrated that the author did a quick and dirty tying up of plot lines. We learn that a particular important character subsequently died, but not how or why. You learn that someone else managed to survive, but not how that happened either. So, after sticking with the book to see how things turn out, one is a bit disappointed. Again, this was not a terrible book--it had its merits. It was just not strong enough to have me looking forward to reading it each night.

I was excited to read the new Binet, but “Perspectives” was kind of a disappointment. It is an epistolary detective story is set in 1550s Medici Florence and revolves around the murder of Jacopo Pontormo. (“His work,” Wikipedia tells me, “represents a profound stylistic shift from the calm perspectival regularity that characterized the art of the Florentine Renaissance.”) The plot and sub-plots that sprout from it are fun, and the epistolary conceit works well at first, with the correspondents including the ever-so-dysfunctional Medicis, Giorgio Vasari, the “divine” Michelangelo, as well as some weird nuns. Narrated with a very post-modern wink and a nudge, the story moves along nicely— it is something that professional reviewers will almost certainly call a “romp” and may even use the phrase “literary hijinx.” Problem is, it all feels kind of lightweight—the potential to explore “perspective” as a central allegory is left badly underexplored; instead, it ends up being fodder for a Tarantino-esque joke in one of the late scenes. My hope for a nervy, self-examining voice that made “HHhH” so distinctive was disappointed.

— with thanks and apologies to Farrar, Straus & Giroux for an ARC via NetGalley

A really interesting and unique plot that turns a mystery into a history lesson. I really loved the format of the book, reading letters from different narrators can be very difficult to pull of but it kept the pages turning! I think the period of the novel was also very interesting, especially for those who are interested in history and art. Overall, this book was a great read!

Nope not for me, will appeal to many. History and in a letter writing format didn’t quite grab my attention. Thank you to the author. Thank you to #netgalley and the publisher for an ARC.

Unfortunately this book did not live up to the excitement and intrigue promised in the blurb! Although it was fast-paced and clearly, incredibly well-researched I would not recommend it to fellow readers or customers unless they were already interested in art, art history, or the Italian Renaissance period. But for people looking for a captivating historical thriller - I could not find it here. I struggled to form any attachment to the characters or curiosity about where the plot was going, and instead felt that it just delivered a very factual play-by-play of real time events leading to a somewhat anticlimactic twist/whodunnit reveal. I really had high hopes for this based on quotes and reviews I'd seen but felt that maybe it just wasn't meant for me!

I recently finished Perspective(s) by Laurent Binet, and I have to say, it was unlike any book I’ve read before. The novel weaves together history, fiction, and philosophy in a way that feels both intellectual and engaging. It follows a writer’s journey as he embarks on an exploration of various historical events, constantly shifting perspectives on the people and moments that shaped them.

What really stood out to me about this book was the narrative style. Binet doesn’t just tell a story—he invites the reader to question the very nature of storytelling itself. The blending of real events with imagined scenarios, and the constant interplay of different viewpoints, creates a thought-provoking and sometimes dizzying experience. I found myself reflecting on the subjective nature of history and the ways we perceive truth.

The pacing was interesting, as it’s not a fast-paced thriller but more of an intellectual journey. It took a little time to settle into the rhythm of the narrative, but once I did, I was fully immersed. The characters, or rather the historical figures presented, are complex and multi-dimensional, and I appreciated the way Binet brought them to life in unexpected ways.

Overall, Perspectives is a novel that will make you think long after you finish it. It’s not for everyone, especially if you prefer more straightforward plots, but for those who enjoy books that challenge the way we view history, storytelling, and perspective, it’s a fascinating read. Binet’s writing is sharp and clever, and I’m excited to see what he comes up with next.