Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Set in the Arabia Gulf, this is the story of 5 very different women who have their agency stripped from them and how they all survive this horrific circumstance. Dounia, Flora, Zeinah, Justine, & Eskedare and 5 different women from all over the world. They have each ended up in the same place. How will this place, these circumstances, and their own circumstances shape them and the world around them?

Was this review helpful?

I keep going back and forth between 3 and 4 stars - will settle on 3.5…

These are the stories of five women of various backgrounds, who make their way to the Arabian Gulf for various reasons. Told from the perspectives of each woman, the writing is lyrical, vivid and often harrowing.

It was not the most uplifting read, each story heartbreaking but eye-opening, exploring the circumstances that lead to profound decisions made, as well as the aftermath. Each of the five characters imprinted deeply in my mind, causing me to question what my own actions would be if faced with similar situations.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Very emotional and well-written! Definitely recommend if you like deep, impactful, thought-provoking stories. Very timely and important perspectives in today's world.

Was this review helpful?

“𝘖𝘯𝘦 𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘴𝘰𝘯 𝘤𝘢𝘯 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘦 𝘢𝘭𝘭 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘪𝘧𝘧𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘯𝘤𝘦.”

Thank you Summit Books for the advanced readers copy! I find this cover simply stunning. The story? Heavy, but powerful. Note that there is some difficult subject matter, however it is handled in a way that is both gentle yet very honest.

For all my fellow literary lovers, especially when it includes multicultural aspects, this is one to pick up and savor. I went through this significantly slower than my norm but it’s not because I wasn’t interested. It is quite bold and raw in the ways it addresses womanhood, motherhood, religion, class, culture, boundaries, marriage and family, loyalty, purpose, hope, and survival in a dangerous land, literally as well as psychologically, emotionally, socially.

I am blown away that this is a debut but truly by this story. It slowly weaves these five women together yet I never felt the pace itself to be slow, likely because the “chapters” are short, alternating between all five. We witness their fragility as well as their strength; the ways they are forced to compromise in order to survive, and how their circumstances change them, sometimes not for the better. What I also found stunning was the way that Ogrodnik both subtly and blatantly exposes the ways women can either build one another up or be their greatest destroyer. The suspense and tension in this novel, for each of the five women, grew and grew, and Dounia and Flora specifically - oh my heart!

This is one of the most tense and best books I’ve read all year (Summit is 2 for 2 for me this year with their new releases, Maggie is the other!). I was moved, captivated, frustrated, angered, educated, heartbroken, and I know it’ll be one I will revisit again and again. I highly recommend! Content includes loss of children, forced marriage, violence (flogging, public torture, various punishment methods), attempted rape (vague), and suicide.

Was this review helpful?

Gulf follows the intersecting lives of five women whose different backgrounds and personal histories bring them to the Arabian Gulf. Though each woman’s story is distinct, together they form a powerful reflection on displacement, gender, labor, and survival in a region shaped by wealth, migration, and systemic inequality.

At the center of the novel is the Gulf itself. Across the Gulf, we meet Justine, a curator from New York City recruited by the Emirati government to develop a falconry exhibit at the Zayed National Museum in Abu Dhabi. Her outsider perspective frames much of the novel’s early exploration of cultural heritage and national identity. We also meet Dounia, a wealthy Saudi woman living in Ras al-Khair, who battles postpartum depression in deeply isolating circumstances. Dounia’s narrative becomes entangled with that of Flora, a Filipina domestic worker she hires—and ultimately exploits—under the region’s notorious Kafala System. Last, but not least we meet Eskedare, a young Ethiopian woman who has always felt a bit out of place and is desperate to reconnect with her long lost friend.

The novel also weaves in global events, touching on the Yemeni and Syrian civil wars, the rise of ISIS, and the enduring legacy of colonialism and labor migration in the Gulf. These wider geopolitical forces are not simply backdrops but deeply embedded in the characters’ lived experiences, shaping the constraints and limited choices available to each woman.

What Ogrodnik does exceptionally well is capture the often invisible negotiations women make daily to endure and adapt in spaces dominated by power imbalances whether they be economic, political, or familial. Her writing is both visually evocative and emotionally precise, likely informed by her background as a filmmaker. The pacing is brisk but never rushed; each chapter propels the story forward while maintaining a steady emotional pull.

If there’s a shortcoming, it’s that the novel occasionally feels like it’s reaching for breadth over depth. At times I longed for more critical reflection or psychological depth in some of the characters’ arcs, especially that of Eskedare who felt the least fully-formed of the main characters. Still, even with these moments of brevity, the stories remain compelling. I found it hard to put the book down - not just because of the plot, but because of the atmosphere, tension, and emotional weight each chapter carried.

Overall, this was an unsettling read that was unflinching in its interrogation of privilege and complicity in systemic exploitation. It’s not without flaws, but it is full of emotional resonance.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

Gulf by Mo Ogrodnik is a powerful novel about the lives of five women from very different backgrounds and their experiences living in the Arabian Gulf. It is not an easy read, as it depicts acts and ideologies of gender inequality with no reserve. It shows the incredibly difficult, and sometimes morally gray decisions that these women make, often because they are forced to, not because they want to, as a result of the unfortunate circumstances they are dealt.

The writing in this novel is poetic, which is an incredible feat considering the difficult topics that are covered. And despite the work being fiction, I learned a lot about the lives of those who live in a region of the world that don't get depicted often.

With that being said, I had a hard time connecting with, and being invested in, a couple of the characters. One of the stories is especially confusing and hard to follow because the woman's background is only explored marginally, and it doesn't make sense as to why she goes to the Gulf in the first place (whereas the reason is more clearly laid out for the other women). I also had a hard time understanding the ending of the novel and comprehending what happened to the women (well all but one). And lastly, a random thing I don't really care for is the multiple mentions of urination sprinkled throughout the book... is there a deeper meaning behind it or is it solely for the shock factor?

But all in all, this book is beautifully written and does a remarkable job shedding some light on multiple marginalized groups.

Special thanks to NetGalley and S&S/Summit Books for this e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Gulf is available now wherever books are sold.

Was this review helpful?

This one could have been two books. There are a lot of characters to keep track of. However, each character is her own and they are remarkable women their own stories. This is not a light read, but a good read that shows the lives of five women living in five different areas, all trying to make their way through life. Through the obstacles and hurdles thrown at them by society and family simply because they're women. I would perhaps have had an easier time reading them as individual short stories rather than bouncing back and forth between characters.

Was this review helpful?

"Five women with vastly different origins—from the Philippines to Ethiopia to New York City—must navigate the difficult but true realities as women, wives, and mothers in the unrelenting landscape of the Arabian Gulf."

Thank you #NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for the ARC. The jacket does say that "Gulf is a book about cruelty, rebellion, resilience—and hope. It asks the how far would you go in order to survive?"

Debut novel, filled with resilience and the will to survive as women have done for ages. It was a hard read and I walked away with the learning that you do what you have to do to survive. There are no options and choices for some women. Made me appreciate all the creature comforts I have.

3.5 stars rounded to a 4 because of the debut writer.

Was this review helpful?

Gulf is a heartbreaking story tracing the lives of women living in Muslim countries. All of their lives are impacted by regimes who care little about them, from ISIS-controlled areas to richer countries like the UAE.

The stories told in Gulf, although fictional, reflect what women’s lives in these areas are in today’s world. Some of the women are complicit in the oppression, lashing out from their own pain, while others suffer and keep trying to move forward in a system not designed for them. It struck me how much these women endure, and while depressing, it also points to a strength of spirit that exists in women across humanity.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book took me a bit to get into, but once I did it was a runaway train. Told from the point of view of five very diverse women, it's a story of privilege, disillusionment, complicity, terror, and, finally, consequences. In Ogrodnik's telling, these disparate things are experienced in varying amounts by pretty much all of the characters. As you may know, I love to read a story about a place I've never been and know very little about (I do read the news, but still), so this one fit the bill perfectly.

Was this review helpful?

(Actual: 4.5⭐, rounded up) A quick, propulsive read following several different women - of varying nationalities and socioeconomic backgrounds - as they make their way through and in the Gulf/Middle East, with one of the overarching themes being how [at least, to me anyway] resilient women are and that, regardless of any circumstances life or society may throw our way, we will do whatever we must in order to survive and thrive in this world. I really enjoyed and found the narrative structure of this book to be quite interesting, as well as its use of multiple/alternating POVs (and, technically, timelines). I think Ogrodnik did a stellar job at weaving all of the different plotlines together in really unique, at times subtle, but overall just generally fascinating ways, both big and small. And while I did latch on/relate to some of the women moreso than others, I still left feeling like I got a very well-written & well-developed sense/understanding of who they ALL were as individuals, the struggles they faced, and the journeys they each went on. While there is no shortage of heartbreaking moments in GULF, it also isn't necessarily one that's primarily defined by tragedy or suffering either. This book is great for those who love deep character studies, richly vivid prose, and stories that are ultimately realistic in their portrayal of everyday lives we might otherwise overlook.

Was this review helpful?

This was an intimate, haunting, and engrossing depiction of five women of various nationalities in the Gulf.

Dounia, a young Saudi woman, rejects her family, is disappointed with her life, and takes it out on Flora.

Flora leaves the Philippines to support her daughter, haunted by sadness. Her work overseas is not unheard of among other Filipina workers.

Justine leaves New York for fancy expat life but not only can she not outrun her problems but only complicates them further.

Zeinah, a young Syrian woman, is trying to find herself among a war - and is disappointed by what she finds.

Eskedare, an Ethiopian free spirit, escapes to Abu Dhabi to avoid marriage.

Not every story ends in tragedy and they coalesce in surprising ways. I found myself deeply empathetic to each of the women at various points so it’s a real heart-wringer as the story moves forward. While I’ve only spent a bit of time in the Gulf, my general sense is that the author did an extraordinary job of capturing differences between each location and culture - painting a picture even for those who’ve never traveled there.

Was this review helpful?

A unique perspective of the lives of women not often told. A little tough to get through in some places.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this novel from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Very aptly named, this novel is set in the Gulf and it depicts the gulf of differences between the characters and their opportunities. Heartrending.

Was this review helpful?

Fairly propulsive read, with the exception of Justine, whose pov I couldn’t get in to. Would have liked to read a more cohesive connection between the women. The endings were abrupt. It was memorable but not a book I think I’ll recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Disturbing in all the right ways. In all places and all situations, a woman must do whatever she can to survive.

Thanks to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster for the ARC to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

*****3.5*****
I learned a lot from this book, and it's beautifully written. I like the structure of 5 different points of view and one of them being in the present and moving forward while the rest are in the past. It was interesting to follow along.
I learned about the Yemeni Civil War and that Filipina women work as maids in the Persian Gulf region to send money back to their families. I also learned more about the Syrian conflict and ISIS than I ever knew before, and I learned about the all-women brigades that helped enforce Sharia law. I also learned something more about falconry and a decent amount about Abu Dhabi that I didn't know before. I like the 5 stories about women and their various experiences, backstories, struggles, and traumas. I also really like the endings of each section except one. The ending of the book is, for me, perfect and very strong, evoking a lot of emotion and tying back to themes throughout the whole novel.
For me, the book contains two points of view that lessen the impact on me and therefore my rating. Otherwise, in style, structure, writing, and depth, it is a five-star book.
Overall, I recommend this book if you like stories with multiple points of view that take place in a part of the world that Americans don't always know a lot about and if you like stories about women and their resilience or lack thereof to the culture around them and its demands.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an e-book for this review.

Was this review helpful?

It was a good book but the ending was very abrupt. Left no resolution in the stories and made me wonder what came next. It just didn’t feel satisfying after all of the buildup in the story. I loved how different characters in intertwined, and how their paths frequently crossed, but I didn’t understand Zeinah’s purpose, as she didn’t meet or appear in any other woman’s story. I enjoyed each character’s arc, I’m just left wondering at the what the point of it all was?

Was this review helpful?

An interesting portrait of several women whose stories come together through geography and circumstance. There were some temporal pieces I struggled to follow in terms of plot but a rich character study.

Was this review helpful?

GULF by Mo Ogrodnik is a stunning, unforgettable read featuring diverse, deeply developed characters whose lives entangle and influence one another in unpredictable and fascinating ways. I deeply enjoyed the settings and the way the author wove them together, somehow keeping the voices so very distinct. I couldn't say that I had a favorite character as usually happens with multi-dimensional stories, but this one was so compelling, so keep-me-up-too-late reading that I never wanted to leave the world Ogrodnik created. A fantastic read for book clubs seeking deep, thought-provoking discussion. I received a copy of this book and these thoughts are my own, unbiased opinions.

Was this review helpful?