Member Reviews

Just finished Rumoured by the Mancaruso Sisters, and WOW—what a ride! A celebrity reporter digging into the shocking arrest of a superstar? Yes, please. But the best part? They included her actual articles, complete with likes, comments, and internet chaos. It felt like scrolling through a real scandal in real time! Plus, the deep dive into conspiracy theories? Absolute perfection. I was hooked from start to finish!

Was this review helpful?

Harlow Hayes is a pop star, a global sensation and then, she is arrested on suspicion of murder. The world thinks they know her but really, they have no idea.

Naomi is a reporter and sent to write a piece on the arrest but what she finds is so much more! I loved the mixed media in this one and the way the authors weaved the various threads through the story, it was so cleverly written. It was dark in places and the secrets that were uncovered piece by piece really drew me in.
This was such a fabulous debut and I look forward to more by these authors.

Was this review helpful?

Loved that as a reader you were also finding information out as Naomi did. Worked out the ending a few pages before the reveal, which is exactly how I like thriller books to be.

I saw a couple of resembelences to Taylor Swift, mainly at the beginning of the book, but not so much that it felt like fan fiction.

I hope once the book is released, the list of Easter eggs and anagrams is posted somewhere, either in the book or on the authors website - because I can never find them myself!

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for an arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book had a great plot with intriguing characters. I’ll definitely be looking out for more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

This book had a great plot with intriguing characters. I’ll definitely be looking out for more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

This gripping thriller plunged me into a whirlwind of suspense, keeping me on the edge of my seat as I frantically searched for clues alongside the characters. Though I confess my detective skills could use some sharpening, the intricate plot kept me guessing until the very end.

The author masterfully weaves social media into the narrative, providing a captivating glimpse into the court of public opinion and the power of online sleuths. The inclusion of humorous and outrageous comments added a touch of realism, mirroring the often-absurd nature of online discussions.

While the story expertly explores the aftermath of the crime, I found myself craving a deeper dive into the initial investigation. Unraveling the chain of events that led to Harlow's arrest and delving into the evidence that painted her as the prime suspect would have added another layer of intrigue to this already captivating tale.

With its clever plot twists and exploration of social media's influence, this book is poised to become a sensation upon its release. The line "When we said SLAY QUEEN, we didn't mean literally" perfectly encapsulates the story's dark humor and chilling implications.

Gratitude to the publishers and NetGalley for providing me with an early copy of this thrilling read.

Was this review helpful?

3 / 5

Thanks to NetGalley and publishers Aria & Aries for this ARC in return for an honest review.

I enjoyed the book but I expected more. Harlow Hayes is an A-list pop star who gets arrested for the murder of a Hollywood actor. Naomi is the journalist looking into the case for a celebrity gossip magazine.

I love the premise but there were just too many unrealistic things that were niggling away at me - lots of things Naomi wouldn't have gotten away with in real life and she would've been fired for immediately. Everyone she interviewed and asked tips from were so easy to open up and tell her everything - it all felt too easy at times. Her journalism was always based on nothing - a random rumour or quote. I didn't warm to Naomi as a character either and I felt she lacked emotional depth. I struggled to really care about any of the characters as they all seemed very surface-level.

I would've liked more perspective from Harlow as I thought she was more interesting than Naomi. But Harlow reminded me way too much of Taylor Swift and it was distracting. I also felt it dragged in the middle and there was a lot of repetition in Naomi's mind - constantly asking the same questions and mulling over the same theories over and over, so the story didn't move forward.

I enjoyed the ending however, it was satisfying and I liked how everything tied together with the plot really picking up pace during the last 15%.

Was this review helpful?

A servicable thriller, and the authors clearly understand the celebrity world they write about. However I found the writing somewhat pedestrian and the author's enthusiasm for their topic didn't compensate for a lack of style.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the authors for providing me with an ARC of this book.

Rating:
3.9/5

Summary:
Good beach read of a thriller if a little slow to get going. Read it if you enjoy popular culture, easter eggs etc and playing spot the Taylor Swift inspiration points.

Review:
Harlow is a global sensation adored by millions, and my star only seems to keep rising. Then at the height of her fame she is arrested for murder.

So far so good right? And honestly it's a decent book that is an enjoyable read but the first half took a while to get going and all I could do was spot the Taylor Swift inspiration. I called the ending within the first 29% of the book (yes I noted it down). Knowing this didn't ruin the book for me but once I knew it I wanted the book to get there faster. I almost wished there were more Harlow chapters instead of it being so Naomi focussed as the book is supposed to be about Harlow.

It's a fun read if you are into swiftie easter eggs but I wasn't inclined to try and solve the easter eggs or anagrams etc as I went. I still have no clue about them as they didn't seem to push the story forward nor were they revealed in the book (not even at the end of it which would have been fun).

The inclusion of social media, fan theories etc were good but I felt could have been explained more to try and pull the reader in.

If however, you are after a light beach read of a thriller set in the pop world with a bit of a look behind the curtain then this book is a fun read.

Was this review helpful?

Colton Scott, a famous and popular actor, is found dead and Harlow Hayes, a mega selling and popular singer/songwriter is arrested for his murder and that of an unknown woman.

Naomi Barnes, a journalist working for a celebrity gossip website, is given the job of reporting this breaking story.

Rumoured is a crime thriller set in America and the plot is brilliant. I thoroughly enjoyed reading Rumoured and think it would make a very good film. The story is mainly told from Naomi’s point of view but also features short parts from other media sources, fans of Harlow Hayes and users of many social media platforms. Harlow Hayes later on adds her point of view which is a good twist, as it can be difficult to develop empathy for a diva who had been arrested for murder. I liked how this story was told, with the authors starting off by telling the reader how many musicians over the years have added “Easter Eggs” to their output that give clues to fans looking for hidden gems within their music. The reader is encouraged to look out for the many Easter Eggs hidden within this story to find out who-dunnit before Naomi solves the mystery.

I liked how celebrity culture was explored and what it must be like living the role of a popular, successful musician. I liked how Rumoured dealt with how social media engages with celebrity gossip and how rumours gained momentum. There were elements of conspiracy thrown into the story, which when you have finished reading this book make you wonder if these actions happen in real life but never become public knowledge.

The writing quality from the authors is very good making this a focused and entertaining read. I found it very hard to believe that Rumoured is a debut novel and I can’t find anything wrong with this OUTSTANDING 5 star read.

The authors are sisters born in New York and Kelly now lives in Nottingham, England. This fact shows the effect her move has made on her when I read this little snippet and being English myself, made me smile…

Amelia pulls Naomi in for a hug and kiss. She smells of expensive perfume mixed with fake tan. “You alright?” Naomi’s smile drops, worried she must look a hell of a lot worse than she thought. She really should have gone heavier on her makeup. “I’m okay. Just exhausted. Why, do I look tired? I took the red-eye-”

“Babe…” Amelia says. “Remember, when a Brit asks if you’re alright, it just means ‘Hi.’ Or ‘What’s up.’ Don’t need your life story, do I?”

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable read. Loved the layout and the modern day social themes and use of social media input.

Refreshing to read something unique, interesting and current

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading this book! I find that having read a lot of crime thrillers, they can get quite repetitive and predictable, and while I did expect some plot points, I was also completely engrossed and entertained by the story. I loved the use of Easter eggs and connections to artists like Taylor Swift and The Beatles.

I found the writing engaging and easy to read and loved the exploration of celebrity journalism, celebrity culture, and sisterly love.

Was this review helpful?

Harlow is a pop star who writes lyrics about aspects of her life that captivate her audience, fans from all over the world that absolutely love her. But Harlow is then accused and arrested for murder. Naomi Barnes is a journalist who investigates this crime and has a personal interest in Harlow’s life and it is through her the majority of the story is told.

I can’t say that I was overly impressed with the book and feel that the role that Naomi’s character played in this may have added to its downfall as it was all a bit long winded regarding her own sisters death although I do understand why the author presented the story as such, connecting the two storyline’s but did feel it and could have been greatly condensed. The reason I say this is it makes up the majority of the book but does not lead to the answers the reader is looking for, which is why and how she did it. I do agree it was a novel way to present a story which I think would have appealed to a younger reader than a more mature person like myself, a reader whom is more interested in social media and pop culture.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of the book, all opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this and I just didn't!! The start dragged far too much, at 30% it felt like the only thing we'd learned is that Harlow Hayes writes her own songs and that our MC's sister died. When I read a thriller or mystery, I want the world to be built up quickly so the action can start unfolding and this was not the book for me because of that. As a swiftie, there were too many Swift references for me and it felt a little cringe and try-hard.

Glad to see so many people have enjoyed it, maybe I'm just not the target audience!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this and read it in a day. It’s got a great pace and characters I was invested in. As a swiftie I enjoyed the Easter egg elements and the social media conspiracy theories. It’s an original story and I think it would make a great adaptation to screen. Only reason it isn’t 5 stars is because I’d consider the ending a bit rushed but that’s all and just my preference.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! I didn't realize this was a debut until I searched the authors to shelve their work! Amazing concept and well written. I liked the themes of music industry, artist and the thriller placed within it. The book does an amazing job of lightly bringing forth the celeb culture, role of social media in conspiracy theories and condemnation and the fans. I liked the writing style and new format. The choice of using the journalist was another interesting aspect for me.

This is overall and interesting read that kept me guessing. I liked the use of the latest trends and new media to make it more upbeat. Would love to read more by the authors!

Thank you Aria & Aries and NetGalley for this e-arc in exchange of my unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This novel felt bloated and overly long. There’s plenty of Swift references for those who partake, but this book tried to do too much while giving too little.

I am clearly not the target audience so I would suggest it for younger people.

Was this review helpful?

RUMOURED BY KELLY AND KRISTINA MANCARUSO.
Release date set for the 2nd of June 2025.
5 HUGE stars from me.
This is the debut novel for these two sisters and what a debut it is.
I feel like i was made to read this book.
I found it thrilling, suspenseful, entertaining and i loved the layout of the full book.
I think this book could be really big as its released over the summer.

Was this review helpful?

<b>Real rating: 3.5 stars</b>

I am conflicted about this book because it was kind of awesome but also it kind of dragged.

Most of the first half could've been more compact, and it drew too many similarities to Taylor Swift. And I'm saying this as a Swiftie.

The fact that the book followed Naomi Barnes from the beginning instead of Harlow made me believe they were somehow connected and that Naomi's dead sister might have a connection.

I would've preferred for the book to kick off right after Harlow left prison, without Naomi's endless attempts to discover her motives and how she did it. Don't get me wrong, all that part was interesting but it basically led nowhere and it could've been edited into a smaller part, without feeling like dragging until getting to the point.

Once she discovered THAT secret and The Beatles connections could've made the entire book. Maybe use some of the early information here and there but, other than that, it was too long.

The premise was good and the character was mainly likable, especially with all her flaws and difficult past.

Thank you to the authors, publishers and NetGalley for access to this arc in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Harlow Hayes has it all—or so the world believes. As a global pop sensation adored by millions, her music seems to touch the souls of her fans with lyrics that feel deeply personal. She’s the icon, the voice of a generation, and seemingly unstoppable. But on September 24th, everything changes when she is arrested for murder, leaving the world in shock and disbelief.

Rumoured is told through the eyes of Naomi Barnes, an investigative journalist assigned to cover the case. What begins as a high-profile assignment quickly turns personal when Naomi discovers unsettling links between Harlow’s story and her own sister’s mysterious death. Driven by grief and a need for answers, Naomi digs deep into Harlow’s life, uncovering secrets about the star’s meteoric rise to fame, her enigmatic lyrics, and the people surrounding her.

As Naomi pieces together the threads of Harlow’s complicated past, she realizes the truth is far darker than anyone could have imagined. But the closer she gets to exposing the story, the more dangerous her pursuit becomes, threatening not only her career but her life.

Kelly and Kristina Mancaruso masterfully weave a tale of fame, betrayal, and hidden truths in this riveting thriller. The dual focus on Naomi’s stakes and the complexities of Harlow’s celebrity world creates a rich, layered narrative. Themes of media manipulation, the pressures of stardom, and the cost of keeping secrets are explored with nuance and depth, keeping readers gripped until the final shocking revelation.

With its unpredictable twists, morally ambiguous characters, and unrelenting tension, Rumoured is a must-read for fans of psychological thrillers and stories that delve into the dark side of fame. It’s a haunting reminder that even the brightest stars can cast the darkest shadows.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.

Was this review helpful?