Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you Netgalley for the e-book!

First things first- if I've learned anything from Sarah Beth Durst's writing is that she is able to spin these cozy magical worlds that literally feel like a hug. The descriptions and the world building are so well done- I can honestly close my eyes and I feel like I'm there with Terlu and Yarrow on Belde.

The story follows the woman -Terlu who enchanted Caz the spider plant. After being turned to stone for breaking the Imperial law (enchanting the plant) she ends up on Belde- home to a sole gardener and a billion enchanted greenhouses. A natural social butterfly Terlu puts in the work to win over the curmudgeon gardener.

One of my favourite tropes in books is the grumpy sunshine- but further more, sunshine and curmudgeon misunderstood character. It has me kicking my feet at every wall torn down.

If you like winged cats, enchanted plants, heart- warming stories and books that just feel like a mug of warm tea next to the fireplace- I would highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Terlu, a librarian who had been turned into a wooden statue wakes up in a snowstorm on an isolated island. Its only resident is Yarrow, a gardener who cares for the plants in a giant greenhouse made up of many greenhouses some with diverse environments. When Terlu accidentally brings a rose back from seeming death she discovers it is sentient and mobile, like Caz, the spider plant from The Spellshop and may help in saving the greenhouses that seem to be failing, one by one. Cozy fantasy at its best with endearing and resourceful characters and compelling conflicts.

With its exquisite storytelling and world building this is definitely one of the best books of 2025 and not to be missed.

Was this review helpful?

What an absolute DELIGHT. This was the perfect addition/companion to the world created in The Spellshop.

I adored the story, the characters, the lush descriptions, and the entirely cozy vibes of it all.

Was this review helpful?

"If you're hurt, you're hurt. It doesn't matter if anyone else thinks you don't have a good enough reason. Pain doesn't require approval."

Thank you to NetGalley, Sarah Beth Durst, and Tor/Forge for the E-ARC!

The Spellshop was one of my top reads of 2024, so I can't express how excited I was when I got the email saying I got accepted for The Enchanted Greenhouse's E-ARC. Sarah Beth Durst knows the formula for the perfect cozy fantasy, hitting the nail on the head once again with this book.

Terlu was once a librarian, until she was found to have brought a plant to life. After a judge ruling, her punishment was to become a wood statue, and she was forced to stand still as life passed her by in the library she once called home. That is until one day she wakes up in a cold forest by herself. Apparently, she was awakened by a gardener looking for the help of a sorcerer to heal his failing enchanted greenhouse. Although Terlu isn't a sorcerer, she's set on helping him in anyway she can.

As I previously mentioned, this is the perfect cozy fantasy. Written with vibrant imagery and descriptions of different types of greenhouses, the plants that reside in them, and of various delicious bakery goods, this book is filled with wonder. That's not even to mention the creatures residing inside the greenhouses, not limited to but including a variety of sentient plants, a flying cat and even miniature dragons.

I absolutely loved the romance in this book. Terlu is chatty and bubbly, while Yarrow, the gardener, is silent but passionate about the things he loves. The contrast between the characters was wonderful, making the journey of them growing closer, becoming friends and then more a true delight to read. They were so cute that I couldn't keep myself from smiling while flipping through the pages.

I feel so lucky to have been able to read this early, and can't wait for when it releases so everyone can enjoy it as I did. I don't know how I'll manage the wait until the newly announced addition to this series, but I'll do my best to be patient!

Was this review helpful?

Can lightning strike twice? Actually, that might be too violent an idiom for Sarah Beth Durst’s cozy fantasy writing. Let’s start over. Can a magician create two perfect fluffy magical creatures in a row? In both cases, the answer is an emphatic yes when it comes to The Enchanted Greenhouse, the sequel/companion novel to Durst’s runaway bestselling 2024 cozy fantasy book The Spellshop.

I am loath to compare apples to oranges, or perhaps once you’ve read the books you’ll prefer to say raspberries to oranges, (inside joke nudge to the handful of people who have read both) so I won’t say if one of these books is better than the other. But I can confidently say that they are both magnificent reads, full of comfort and happiness. They are books that make you feel better about everything once you’ve read them. They are a sanctuary away from hard times, but interestingly, this second book actually also addresses some of the trials of these current times, albeit in a non-jarring, non-traumatizing way.

One thing I truly adore about Durst’s writing is that you can tell she’s also writing for her own serotonin. She has said in multiple interviews that she shamelessly wrote The Spellshop by starting with a list of things she loved, and then finding a way to incorporate as many of those things as possible into the novel. In the hands of a less skilled author, this might result in a hodgepodge of saccharin twee-ness. But in The Spellshop you find yourself saying “hell yeah, bring on the unicorns and cloud bears. Let’s go rescue some flying cats from a flood and then go have some raspberry jam.”

For that reason, I am happy to report that Durst allowed her imagination to take flight just as much, if not more so, in The Enchanted Greenhouse. After all, when a skilled magician makes an island full of themed greenhouses, it’s a blank canvas rife for the imagination, and the results don’t disappoint.

I truly loved every character in this story, and didn’t want it to end. The grumpy/sunshine trope is done to perfection, and the chemistry between the main characters was delightful. And our protagonist!!! Oh, I just adored Terlu and her body positivity. Her extroversion masking a deep-rooted history of rejection and trauma gave her character depth as well as relatability. She was an absolute delight.

Five out of five stars, can’t wait to listen to the audiobook to find out what sorts of voices the narrator gives to these characters I already love. This will, like The Spellshop, also be a repeat comfort read I know for sure.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley & Tor Publishing Group for the early copy in exchange for an honest review. Sadly, I DNF'ed at 40% of the way through.

I really liked Durst's other books but this one wasn't doing it for me.

The protagonist is an insecure and self-centered airhead and the eventual love interest is a self-centered loner obsessed with plants and nothing else. I really hated how he treated the protagonist from the beginning and he moderately got better but not really. It felt like he treated her as an afterthought and could barely speak 5 words to make her feel any better about her awful situation. She's not a very fun protagonist either with how insecure and doubtful she is. Dottie was also a really annoying character, not as nice as Caz was.

Was this review helpful?

Another great cozy fantasy that takes place in the same universe as The Spellshop. I loved the characters and the setting! I slightly prefer The Spellshop over this because that one had more baking elements, whereas this one has more gardening imagery.

Was this review helpful?

A fun, cozy fantasy with sweet romance. I enjoyed this just as much as "The Spellshop!" I was so happy to find out what happened to the librarian who created Caz and was then unjustly turned into a statue. I found some the dialogue a bit quirky, but on the whole this was well written and fun to read. Beautiful cover art as well!

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderful follow-up to the Spell Shop. It closes the loop on some unfinished business and is an interesting and creative story.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved The Enchanted Greenhouse! Sarah Beth Durst’s writing is so beautiful and comforting—it’s like stepping into a warm, magical hug. Her worlds and characters are always so vivid and captivating, and this book is no exception.

The only small thing that didn’t click for me was the political undertones throughout the story. I read fantasy to escape into a world of magic, and those moments felt a little out of place for me personally.

Still, I’m such a fan of Sarah Beth Durst’s work. Her writing is pure magic, and I’ll keep coming back for more! Thank you so much NetGalley for the early reader copy. I was so excited to get this one!

Was this review helpful?

I’m so glad I got this. This is one of my favorite authors. This is the second book series so if you haven’t read this read the first one and then read this one you will not disappoint. I absolutely fell in love with every bit of these books.

Was this review helpful?

This book healed a little part of me that I didn’t know needed fixing. Talking plants, a reclusive gardener, a second chance—oh, this one is worth the read.

Was this review helpful?

The Enchanted Greenhouse is just as good as The Spellshop. I couldn't put it down, it captured my heart from the very first sentence. I've already been recommending it to coworkers and patrons at the library. Who doesn't want a cosy time restoring magical greenhouses with a grumpy gardener?!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored The Spellshop so I was really looking forward to reading this book. Thank you NetGalley and Tor Publishing group for the ARC.

Sarah Beth Durst's The Enchanted Greenhouse is a delightful, whimsical tale that exudes the charm and coziness readers have come to expect from her work. The story follows Terlu Perna, punished for creating a magical, sentient spider plant out of loneliness. Turned into a wooden statue and forgotten in a library, Terlu’s journey truly begins when she awakens one winter day on a mysterious, nearly deserted island filled with magical but dying greenhouses.

Cold, hungry, and uncertain, Terlu finds an unlikely ally in a grouchy gardener and a witty, sentient rose as she uncovers the secrets of the island. Determined to restore the greenhouses’ fading magic, the trio embarks on a quest filled with challenges that test their courage and resilience.

The world Durst crafts is richly imaginative, with enchanting details that bring the magical greenhouses and their inhabitants to life. The writing feels magical, pulling readers into the story effortlessly, and the themes of friendship and redemption are heartfelt and engaging. However, the narrative lacks the tension and sense of adventure that made The Spellshop such a standout. The pacing is slow, and though the romance adds warmth, it feels rushed, developing a little too much, too soon. Still, the cozy, feel-good vibes and imaginative setting make this a perfect read for fans of gentle, low-stakes fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

“The Enchanted Greenhouse” by Sarah Beth Hurst, a delightful new title that I believe will resonate strongly with readers.

As a bookseller, I’m always on the lookout for engaging stories that spark interest and inspire readers. “The Enchanted Greenhouse” beautifully fits this criterion. The journey of Terlu Perna, who begins her adventure as a lonely soul turned into a wooden statue, offers a unique premise that captures the imagination.

Waking up on a magical island filled with enchanting greenhouses, Terlu's discovery of both friendship and purpose is spellbinding. The dynamic between her and the grumpy gardener, along with the sentient rose, creates a heartwarming narrative filled with humor and warmth. Their quest to save the island, threatened by the dwindling magic, keeps readers engaged and invested in Terlu’s fate.

This book deftly explores themes of second chances and the power of connection, making it a timely read for many who seek both escapism and meaningful introspection. The vibrant world-building and relatable characters ensure that it will appeal to a broad audience, from fans of fantasy to those simply looking for a touching story.

In my shop, A Novel Idea Bookshop, I can already envision the displays and promotions that would surround “The Enchanted Greenhouse.” I believe it will not only fly off the shelves but also find a permanent place in the hearts of readers.

Was this review helpful?

This was absolutely everything I love in a cozy fantasy! It’s set in such an atmospheric island with the most lovable and quirky characters. It’s full of wonderful imagery that makes you feel so warm inside {just like a greenhouse}. It’s a magical slice-of-life following Terlu and Yarrow as they discover and recover the magic of the greenhouse on their remote island. It’s a story of healing and loving yourself. It’s a story full of hope, found family, and a tender quiet romance. It’s a book that is meant to be taken slow with a cup of tea and honey cake. Definitely for fans of House in Cerulean Sea and Emily Wilde. I absolutely loved it and was just what I needed! Thank you so much NetGalley for the early copy— can’t wait for you guys to read this one!!

Was this review helpful?

Cozy, whimsical, charming and comforting! Everything I was expecting and hoping for, adored this story so much!

Was this review helpful?

I was enchanted by SarahBeth Durst's world and writing from The Spellshop. The Enchanted Greenhouse is a standalone book that takes place in the same world as The Spellshop. It tells the story of a librarian, named Terlu Perna. Terlu uses a spell to create a friend. All magic is forbidden unless you're a sorcerer. The punishment was both swift and harsh. The story picks up after a brief history of that incident to when Terlu awakens from her punishment in a strange place she's never been. There she meets the caretaker of enchanted greenhouses. He's the only person on the island and he doesn't really have any answers. Just questions of his own to a pretty big problem. The Enchanted Greenhouses are failing. One by one. He needs a sorcerer, but Terlu isn't one. Is there a way she can still help though? She is willing to take the risks as she and her new friends tackle the problem.
I fell in love with The Enchanted Greenhouse and all its amazing rooms. I want to go back to this world. I hope we all get the chance to.

Was this review helpful?

A perfect feel good story! I really love the librarians that live in this world and find their own home and talents. Honestly I think this one was better then the first which is really rare for me with sequels. It was the exact cozy read I needed.

Was this review helpful?

Another cozy tale full of whimsy and heart! This is a stand alone book, but there are some references to characters and locations from The Spellshop (which is a fun little bonus). If you loved The Spellshop, you will love The Enchanted Greenhouse— they are like two different branches off the same magically sentient plant!

Was this review helpful?