Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to Atria Books for my advanced copy of Murder At Gulls Nest by Jess Kidd.

This is a cozy mystery set in 1954 at a seaside in Kent. This is the first book in the series about a former nun who left the order to find out more about the disappearance of a former novice.

I enjoyed this book. I don't read too many cozy mysteries but I was intrigued by the former nun turned detective aspect, plus 1950s England. The characters were fun and I liked trying to solve the mystery along with Nora
I'm looking forward to more books in this series!

This book comes out on Tuesday - April 8th.

Was this review helpful?

Nora asks to be released from her vows as a nun so she can try to figure out what happened to her former novice, when Frieda’s letters suddenly stop arriving. Because it’s the last place Frieda mentioned, Nora goes to Gulls Nest, a hotel in Kent, looking for answers. But what she finds there only raises more questions… and puts her own life in danger.

This is the first book I’ve read by this author, and it sounded right up my alley. Unfortunately, it didn’t take long to realize that the book wasn’t going to live up to those expectations. I really didn’t like any of the characters, except for teenaged Rose and maybe the detective inspector. The rest were too busy hiding their own secrets to really care about anyone else, making it hard to care what happened to or around them.

While we were still trying to find proof of what happened to Frieda, there were several murders that may have been related to her disappearance, but maybe not? Everything was so wrapped up in secrets and only tidbits of information that I didn’t even bother to try to figure out what was going on. I didn’t have any one person at the top of my (almost non-existent) list, but I wasn’t surprised when the culprit was revealed, but the motive seemed a bit odd.

Goodreads shows this to be the first book in a series, but I doubt that I will continue with it. This book was apparently well-received by many other GR users, it just wasn’t my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

This book was very nearly a 5-star read for me (more like 4.5 stars). I absolutely loved the cozy mystery feel, the setting, and the main character (a nun who leaves the order to investigate the disappearance of her friend). There were plenty of red herrings and a few twists that I didn't see coming. The only downside for me is that the reveal at the very end isn't all that surprising. It also felt a bit rushed, and I would have liked the whole ending to have been a bit more developed. I would gladly read more books in this series though, and I'm excited to see what else Kidd has in store.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Atria Books for gifting me a physical and digital ARC of the latest book by Jess Kidd. All opinions expressed in this review are my own - 4.5 stars rounded up!

Set in the 1950s, Nora Breen is a nun who has left her monastery behind. She's trying to find her friend, Frieda, a former novice, whose letters to Nora suddenly stopped. Nora heads to Gull's Nest, a hotel in Kent, where Frieda was staying, and tries to quietly investigate what happened to her friend. But then there is a series of murders at the inn, and her investigations take a deeper turn.

This is the first in a coming series entitled Nora Breen Investigates, and sign me up for the rest! In Jess Kidd's very capable hands, a cozy mystery delves into a very multi-layered story. Nora's backstory slowly plays out, as we learn what led her to the monastery, as well as what prompted her to leave. We see her explore a new world and become a different person away from her past life. Everyone in the small inn has a secret, and the characters are a story onto themselves. Nora slowly gathers respect from the local police chief, Rideout, as they try and solve the mysterious deaths. Wonderful!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun and cozy mystery. Loved the adorable characters and the beautiful scenery.
I had never read anything by Jess Kidd before, but when I’m the mood for something a little more lighthearted, I would totally pick her up again.
Nora Breen, a nun, is compelled to investigate her friend’s death when she she stops receiving letters from her. She heads to Gulls Nest, a quaint seaside town, where she questions her way through delightful characters. I feel like the ending wrapped quickly and the beginning started a bit slow, but other than that - loved it.
Thank you Atria books for sending me an ARC! So fun!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adore a cozy mystery and Jess Kidd did not disappoint! Nora as our main character was absolutely fantastic. The way Kidd explores and weaves the characters together was absolutely masterful. The tension in this!!! Also being able to discover with Nora who she is after 30 years of erasing herself was such a treasure. This book was well-written and perfectly paced. I cannot wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to Atria books and NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I have really enjoyed Jess Kidd in the past. I very much liked Himself, and very much loved Things in Jars, so I was excited to see a new one coming out by her. Surprisingly, this read nothing like the previous books by her I've read, and yet I loved this one too! Murder at Gull's Nest follows Nora Breen, formerly of a Carmelite monastary, as she leaves her order to go look for former novice and friend, Frieda, who has gone missing from a boarding house called Gull's Nest.

To me, this read more like a Golden Age mystery, and with richly drawn and interesting characters and a setting I could so clearly imagine- both the geography of the coast and the deteriorating, formerly stately home. Nora is a fantastic character: smart, witty, self-aware, compassionate and stubborn, and as she works to solve the mystery of Frieda's disappearance on top of other very suspicious deaths and the reckoning with her own past, I was really, really pulling for her. This is set up to be series, and I will enthusiastically pick up the next one when it comes to see where Nora's new life takes her, along with her new partner in crime (solving), Inspector Rideout.

Was this review helpful?

Murder at Gulls Nest is a solid beginning to a new series featuring former nun, Nora Breen. It is 1954 and Nora, who used to be Sister Agnes of Christ, is worried about her friend, Frieda Brogan, a former novice. Nora and Frieda corresponded on a regular basis since her friend went to Gore-on-Sea and stayed at Gulls Nest boarding house. Butcher suddenly the letters from Frieda stop. Nora is released from her vows and moves into Gulls Nest, even staying in Frieda's old room hoping to find clues as to what has happened to her friend.

There are some interesting characters staying at the boarding house and it seems that they have secrets in their past and these secrets are catching up to them. One of the guests dies and Nora, much to the frustration of DI Rideout, Nora begins to ask questions and investigate. Further mystery follows when more deaths occur.

Nora is a great character. She has been a nun for 30 years and is now out among the public learning how to get around. She even starts smoking and drinking. The author did an excellent job of creating the atmosphere of a seaside town in England in the 1950s. I loved Nora bonding with a seagull she named Father Conway. There are some twists and red herrings thrown our way. This is a fun read and I am looking forward to more of Nora.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher, Atria Books, for an ARC. The review is my own.

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn't love a cozy seaside British mystery following an Irish former nun??

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for this copy in exchange for an honest review.

⚠️Please see TW/CWs before consuming: Death and sexual assault.

Set in 1954, after Nora stops receiving letters from her best friend living in a boarding house called Gulls Nest in Kent, England. Scared for her friend, Nora decides to leave the convent to find out what happened. Nora disguises her background and moves into the boarding house to learn the truth about what happened to her friend.

What really drew me to this book was a former nun as the main character/amateur detective. I just knew some religious trauma was going to be unpacked in this story! And it wasn't explored too much, but I did love our MC, she was very confident in all she did, and SO determined! She had such gusto, and I loved that she is at an older age, which you do not often see in MCs nowadays.

I thought the plot moved very quickly, as there are a lot of eventful things going on while you read. And Nora can easily get answers from just about everybody in the story, I do wish the romantic subplot had just a little more tension between them, but I still appreciated it.

Go read this new release, or add a hold with your local library to read in April!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️(4 stars)

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this at first. But the suprise rape scene really threw me for a loop. I think that there should be a trigger warning for it. If I had expected it, maybe it wouldn't have thrown the cozy mystery vibe off. It's first mentioned in chapter 9. It's not detailed and very brief, but if that's something you'd like to know about before reading this, than I think you should.

Was this review helpful?

This one started strong but unfortunately about a third of the way through the story just lost speed and slowed way down. I enjoyed the character of Nora Breen and am curious to see where the series goes from here. Thank you to NetGalley for the chance to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley & Atria Books for an eARC ♥️

Oh, what an absolute treasure of a book! If you love mysteries that feel like a warm cup of tea with just a dash of poison, then “Murder at Gulls Nest “is your perfect match. Imagine Agatha Christie and Father Brown had a literary love child—only this one’s a quick-witted ex-nun with a habit of stumbling over corpses.
Nora Breen is the kind of heroine you’d want as your best friend—or at least your partner in crime-solving. She’s sharp, compassionate, and refreshingly human, wrestling with her faith, her past, and the very earthly problem of *multiple murders* in her cozy seaside hotel. The setting—**Gore-on-Sea, *—is so vividly drawn you can almost smell the salt air and hear the seagulls squawking over the guests’ scandalous whispers.
And what a cast of characters! From the delightfully nosy Mrs. Peabody (who definitely knows more than she lets on) to the brooding Dr. Marsh (does he have secrets, or is he just *that* serious about his tea?), every guest at the “Gulls Nest Hotel” feels like they’ve stepped out of a classic golden-age mystery—with a few modern twists.
If you adore cozy mysteries with depth a dash of mid-century atmosphere and a sleuth who’s equal parts nun and Nancy Drew, this is your next obsession. **Five stars—and a whispered prayer that the next book comes soon! ♥️

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for an advance readers copy of this book.

Murder at Gulls Nest is an absorbing mystery filled with odd and engaging characters.

It is the early 1950’s, and Nora Breen, newly released from her vows as a Carmelite nun for 30 years, comes to the boardinghouse called Gulls Nest in Kent, England. She is there to find out the fate of her younger friend and former postulate, Frieda. Nora is a nurse, and during a serious illness of Frieda’s, they became close. Frieda, too, has left the monastery, and wrote regularly to Nora. Then the letters abruptly stopped, Frieda disappeared, and no one can say what happened to her.

Joining the small but motley crew of boarders at Gulls Nest, Nora seeks answers. Though WWII is several years behind them, many still suffer from its physical and emotional scars, and the consequences of events that occurred around it. Further deaths at Gulls Nest bring some to a breaking point.

Nora, herself, is a lovely character: interested in others, strong and sympathetic, as well as self-aware, noting her own transformation from cloistered nun to part of the larger world. She is inquisitive, clever, and finds people endlessly fascinating.

Gulls Nest does not have the depth, breadth, drama and fantasy elements of some of Jess Kidd’s earlier works, but this is like comparing a busy landscape painting to a small one: Gulls Nest is a more focused canvas, but with a vivid setting and quirky characters.

I hope that the advance materials, calling this the first in a series, are accurate. I would greatly like to spend more time with Nora Breen.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!

I unfortunately DNF'ed this at about 25%. This was just not for me at this moment. I thought Jess Kidd's writing was great, and it was incredibly descriptive, but the pacing and the tense of the novel made it feel like the story was dragging. The best thing I could compare this to is a noir detective film with the internal narration and realization Nora has. While this could be exactly what someone is looking for, I think I prefer a mystery novel that is slightly faster paced.

Was this review helpful?

Super cute murder mystery- SUPER COZY and love the seaside setting. Beautifully descriptive
Thank you so much netgalley!

Was this review helpful?

"The ultimate mystery is one's own self." (Sammy Davis Jr.)

Ain't that the truth? Complex, secretive, and constantly hiding our dirty laundry.

Jess Kidd has taken on a new genre here. I'm not usually a big fan of cosy novels, but then cosy novels never were inked by an author who ratchets up a storyline like Jess Kidd. Kidd puts a set of wheels on Murder at Gulls Nest and then the rubber hits the road at a fast pace.

Kidd introduces us to a bevy of strange characters who wear reflective vests flashing mystery upon themselves. It's 1954 with the prim and proper at Gore-on- Sea in Kent. But the prim and proper don't necessarily reside at the Gulls Nest boardinghouse. Just wait and see.

Nora Breen arrives with very few personal items. She's a middle aged woman who has recently left the convent after thirty years. Now most would think that Nora would be of a very complacent nature. Oh, not Nora. She's secretly trying to find out what happened to the young Freida who also resided at that convent but left for Gore-on-Sea. She and Nora corresponded continuously. Not a letter in quite a while. Nora will take it upon herself to find out why.

The inhabitants of the Gulls Nest are as feathered in secrecy as those birds. And then there is a death that visits upon them. The police think that it was a suicide. Nora thinks differently. Each resident could be a book unto themselves. But Jess Kidd places all the marbles upon Nora. Kidd keeps to the atmosphere of the 1950's with mindsets, deep conversations, and period dialogue. She also carves out Nora's witty nature and sense of humor. There's a section involving Nora with bare feet, a set of shoes, and the police station. It's a hoot.

Murder at Gulls Nest is the first in this new series. Like I always say, get in on the ground floor. This book has all the makings of more superb writing to come. If you've ever read Jess Kidd before, you know I speak truth loud and clear. Bravo, Jess Kidd.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Atria Books and to the talented Jess Kidd for the opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

Jess Kidd excels at creating an environment for her stories. This novel, set in coastal Britain, gives off the mood of gulls, damp air, clouds. It is a cozy mystery, and while there is some gore, it is mostly mild.

Sister Agnes has left the monastery to find a friend, Frieda, who also left the monastery for her health. Frieda landed at Gull’s Nest, a tattered boarding house on the coast. When Sister Agnes suddenly stops receiving letters from Frieda, she feels compelled to try to find out what happened to Frieda. It’s back to being Nora Breen after 30 years as a nun.

Nora takes over Frieda’s room at the boarding house, but does not tell the other inhabitants that she knew Frieda. Her investigation begins of the rather diverse population. Stella and Teddy, newlyweds. Professor Poppy, a puppeteer. Bill, the bartender. Then there is the proprieties, Helena and her mute daughter, Dinah. We cannot forget the very domineering Irene, the housekeeper and cook.

All have taken refuge in this locale which is known for its people who come and go. All have secrets as well. Nora is convinced that Frieda didn’t just take a train out of town. Especially once murder happens at the boarding house. Murder becomes quite the theme of this house, with fingers pointing at all the occupants and then some. While the local constabulary seems to think it’s coincidental, Nora thinks otherwise and is out to prove them wrong. All the while becoming something of a companion to Inspector Rideout.

I love that this is going to be a series of books. Nora is such a pleasant, fun former nun. The time and setting are perfect for mystery and crime solving. I look forward to the next installment.


Reviews will be posted to:
BookwormishMe.com
LibraryThing: BookwormishMe
The StoryGraph: BookwormishMe
Goodreads: BookwormishMe

Reviews will be posted after publication to:
Barnes & Noble
Amazon

Was this review helpful?

This is Kidd's best book! The characters are kooky and heartfelt and the twists are fun, told in her signature voice. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

First book in a new series. The book started out feeling a bit depressing for some reason. Not sure why, maybe it was just me. I think all cozy mystery lovers will enjoy this book

Was this review helpful?

Taking place shortly after WWII, Nora requests to leave her sisterhood and goes undercover to try and find out what happened to her missing novitiate. What follows is a cozy with so many twists and reveals that it seems like hard boiled thriller! Everyone has something to hide. Adding to the feel of the book is Nora herself who not only has to figure out her place outside the nunnery but also has to face her own past and secrets. the character development needed for a new series did not overshadow the mystery and plot of the book and I am looking forward to future books in this series. While the murder at Gulls Nest was solved, the mystery of Nora Breen continues!

Was this review helpful?