Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to Random House Worlds for the advanced digital copy of this book.

This dad read The Mask of Fear by Alexander Freed, the first installment in the new Star Wars trilogy, Reign of the Empire. The Republic has faded, and an Empire has risen. Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, and Saw Guerrera—three future leaders of the Rebellion—must define their purpose and, more importantly, act amid political upheaval and galactic change.

I’ve been excited about The Mask of Fear since its announcement in 2024, as Alexander Freed is one of my all-time favorite Star Wars authors. A book about this specific period in galactic history sounded intriguing and ripe for exploration. I knew it wouldn’t be a Star Wars book filled with a breakneck plot and action scenes, and I’m all for having familiar faces ground a story. However, I found that The Mask of Fear struggled to keep my attention, mainly due to its strong political storyline. While Freed’s skills are exemplary, I often found myself yearning for a more exciting plot.

Being the first book in a trilogy, The Mask of Fear has to do some heavy lifting. It must establish an entirely new segment of the timeline and lay the groundwork for what readers can expect. Freed is more than competent in this task, but I found that the first half of the book was so focused on setting things up that I struggled to stay engaged. I’m not the most patient of readers, and this book didn’t hook me from the outset. Additionally, political stories aren’t really my thing, so I found the nitty-gritty details of the state of the galaxy during this time hard to get through.

Where Freed excels is in his characterizations. In his hands, established figures like Mothma, Organa, and Guerrera are handled with the utmost care, and Freed puts his own unique spin on their personalities at this point in time. I especially enjoyed seeing Mon and Perrin’s relationship (or lack thereof) during this period in their lives. Freed beautifully captures the complexities of these two characters and how, even without much love between them, they still need and care for each other. Freed also successfully introduces a brand-new character whose storyline I believe is the most exciting part of the novel. Without giving too much away, I’ll just say that this character is introduced under a shroud of mystery, and his actions left me shocked and thrilled until the very end.

By the final third of the novel, I was hooked; the storylines converge, and the book ends on an explosive note that left me craving the next installment. I have a feeling that by the time the Reign of the Empire trilogy concludes, I’ll look back on The Mask of Fear differently than I do after my initial read. Fans of political slow burns will undoubtedly enjoy this book, but for me, it lands at 🧢🧢🧢/5. Freed’s writing and the solid ending make it worth the read, and Star Wars fans with a love for politics will eat it up.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a great disappointment. I have read several of the Star Wars novels and this one is towards the bottom of the list. It takes place between the time that the Jedi are wiped out by Palpatine and A New Hope begins. The author portrays key characters to the rebellion as indecisive, self centered and non strategic thinkers. Instead of filling in the gap it leaves more questions in my mind as to how the rebellion grabbed hold and became a functioning organization.

I received a free Kindle copy of this book courtesy of publisher with the understanding that I would post a review on Goodreads, Net Galley, Amazon and my nonfiction book review blog.

Was this review helpful?

As a political scientist, I’ve always been interested in the depiction of politics in the Star Wars Galaxy. I enjoyed Chris Kempshall’s The History and Politics of Star Wars, and rate Claudia Grey’s Bloodline as one of the best Star Wars novels of the past decade. So, I was understandably excited when I heard about the upcoming Reign of the Empire trilogy, which would focus on politics between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope. Alexander Freed, author of the first book in the series, described it as “nuanced stories of ‘ordinary’ citizens—people living inside the machinery of the Empire, still figuring out what’s happened to their government and in violent disagreement over ideas of democracy, resistance, revolution, and complicity.” Freed’s The Mask of Fear fulfills that promise, and then some.

True to the premise of this trilogy, Mask of Fear isn't a story about Jedi, blaster shootouts, or space battles, but rather about politicians and soldiers tying to find their way in the months following Palpatine's declaration of Empire. In this way, it's a spiritual prequel to Andor and Rogue One, although it doesn't feature any of those characters aside from Saw Gerrera.

Most readers know Senators Bail Organa and Mon Mothma as leaders of the Rebel Alliance, but at this point in time they're not necessarily allies. Mask of Fear portrays them as very different politicians with very different goals. Bail investigates clues about the true nature of Order 66, while Mon introduces a bill to limit the Emperor's powers. Bail is more idealistic and wants to openly condemn the Empire's crimes, while Mon thinks they need to work within the system. Bail searches for the truth, while Mon searches for powerful allies. It's a nuanced reflection of the decisions and tradeoffs anyone working in politics faces on a daily basis.

Saw Gerrera also has to decide if the end of the Clone Wars means his insurgency is over or has only just begun. Saw at this point is a hardened warrior, but not yet the fanatic we see in Rogue One. Perhaps more importantly, the book shows why his followers are so loyal. Saw isn’t just a warrior, he’s a leader who knows how to speak to – and manipulate – people.

Mask of Fear isn’t a particularly violent book, but the way it describes the suffocating oppression of Palpatine’s Empire makes it one of the darkest Star Wars books I’ve ever read. The filth of the Imperial detention centers makes them all the more realistic and terrifying. The pervasiveness of surveillance and passivity of most citizens makes opposition to the Empire appear fruitless. Indeed, readers know that Bail, Mon, and Saw do not succeed and that the Empire survives another two decades. And, yet, how they fail says so much about this political moment in Star Wars.

Mask of Fear doesn’t have much action or adventure, but kept my attention like few Star Wars books have. I highly recommend to readers looking for a political thriller set in the Star Wars Galaxy.

Note: Thanks to NetGalley for providing an advance review copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Plot
This book starts right off with action. This is a very well known time in the Star Wars Universe, shortly after the fall of the republic and the start of Palpatine's reign. As the book continues there are moments of high action and more relaxed areas as well. This book is close to 500 pages, but it never felt long; Freed did a wonderful job with the pacing of this book. I loved how each chapter had a different character's point of view, but quite often the characters in the book will join others (some expected, some not) and see the meeting from a multiple character’s view. My only problem with the plot is at times it felt very sudden at times and jumped from one scene to the next, especially with action sequences. If you were also worried about this book being too political based, then do not worry. I found that it was very action filled with the senate politics throughout the book, but nothing that was too overwhelming.

Characters
The main characters include Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, and Soujen. Soujen chapters allowed us to see most of Saw Gerrera. I do think Freed did a great job with Soujen’s character and you never knew his true motives or feelings, which helped with the pacing of the book. My favorite was Bail Organa. He is naive in a way because of how strongly he believes in his cause. I loved how Bail was the only one that truly cared about what happened to the Jedi during Order 66. If he was not there, the Jedi would be a very small portion of concern. His close relationship with Padme really shined in this book and was one of my favorite parts. Now if you are a fan of Andor, then Mon Mothma’s sections of this book will definitely be your favorite. She is where you will find the most political aspect of the book. These parts were a little harder to get through personally, since political books do not interest me as much. However, she is such a strong character and I loved seeing how she is able to deal with everything that went wrong around her in an admirable way. My problem with the characters is sometimes that there are way more points of views in this book than needed. In a senate meeting when they switched to the point of view of a senator for only one chapter throughout the book, I thought that worked so nicely. But there were other characters that I felt the point of views were unneeded and ruined the flow of the current storyline.

The Present and Future
The book could easily be read as a stand-alone. However, I can see where the next two books in the trilogy will go due to this trilogy taking place over 19 years. I hope we do get more Saw Gerrera in the next book. This is a fantastic book for any Star Wars fan! I will definitely be adding this to my list of books any fan can pick up and easily understand, whether you only like the movies or everything.

Was this review helpful?

I feel like this book tried to blance more narratives than it could handle, and because of that none of them were as compelling as I really wanted them to be. did appreciate the casual nonbinary representation, but as a whole this wasn't as good as I expected for a novel centering around some of my favorite star wars characters (guys i am a saw gerrera apologist sorry not sorry)

Was this review helpful?

My thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Del Rey, Random House Worlds, Inklore for an advanced copy of this book set in the Star Wars Universe during the chaotic time of the fall of the Republic, the rise of the Empire and those caught in between, wondering their place in the new order, and how to stop it.

One of my biggest questions about Star Wars, and over the years there have been a lot, with the numerous retcons, and old universe stories, legacy stories, what if stories, was how the Empire became so powerful, so fast. In the original Star Wars, I had thought the Empire had been around for at least a century. Turns out it was only 18 years. The Jedi were besmirched, thought of as an old religion, not worth thinking about, but still in memory there had to have been people who had seen them. Served with them. And yet they were forgotten As I got older I could see how this happened. People don't like to remember, and many in power don't want to risk that loss of power that comes from standing out. Nor does it seem do they want to give up power at all. Many in American politics look about Yoda's age. With as firm an understanding of what is going on in the world as Yoda did hiding on Dagobah. I was not a fan of Episodes 1, 2 and 3, but the historian in me, did enjoy the political side of the story. The change from Republic to Empire. One that seems a little more real today. I think Alexander Freed enjoyed that also, and being a great writer has crafted a story set in the time of change between Republic and Empire. Where a rebellion was being conceived. Star Wars: The Mask of Fear is the first book in the Reign of the Empire series and tells the story of the end of the political war against the Empire, and the start of a Rebellion that would light up the stars.

The book takes place shortly after Episode 3, with a still ravaged Coruscant recovering from the siege that lead to the death of many, and the man known as Palpatine to secure his grip on the fledgling Empire. Astute eyes notice that humans are being hired for security forces, but who these security forces are looking for, or protecting is still in question. Mon Mothma is a secure Senator, save from election, whose last stand against the rise of the Emperor led to her arrest, and a bit of enhanced interrogation. Mon knows that there are other forces still in the Senate willing to fight the Emperor, but has no idea how to go about it. Soon it becomes apparent that Mon Mothma is considered a threat, as political groups friendly to the Empire begin to protest her, and much More. Bail Organa is also a Senator, a firebrand with friends, a powerful wife, and a plan. Bail does not believe the propaganda coming out about the Jedi, and has vowed to find out what the Jedi knew, and why the Emperor wanted them stopped. Bail's plans will take him all over the galaxy, meeting new people, and creating whole new problems for many. Saw Gerrera is a fighter, who has found the ultimate weapon, maybe. This might cause bigger problems for him, or help Saw find a purpose to his life. One that will lead to much destruction.

I really enjoyed this book, not just as a Star Wars novel, but as a parable for today's modern world. Freed is a very good author, able to balance a lot of storylines, characters, and write beloved characters in a uncharitable light. These are not the beacons of the Rebellion yet. These are politicians, willing to deal, trade, twist arms, bow down and beg, and do anything to keep their power. Also help people, but really keep power. The book has quite a lot going on, with plots mixing, twisting and ensnaring each other, but Freed is really good at keeping it all together. The examples of modern politics fill the book, adding to the story, and the reality of what is going on. One of the better Star Wars books I have read. Probably since the last Freed novel.

Star Wars fans will enjoy this new look at characters. Some will complain about politics being in Star Wars, one which makes me laugh all the time, as even a cursory look at George Lucas will let one know he was political. Even non-fans will find much to enjoy, though a familiarity with the characters would be helpful. Freed is a very good author, with a lot of good ideas, and a good eye for mixing what is happening today into a galaxy far, far away. I hope to share a cell with him in the Empire reeducation camps.

Was this review helpful?

The Mask of Fear takes place in the aftermath of Revenge of the Sith. It mostly features three important characters from the Star Wars universe: senators Bail Organa and Mon Mothma, and leader of a rebellious band, Saw Gerrera. Organa and Mothma are struggling to accept and deal with the new Galactic Empire. Organa is dead set on finding evidence that the Emperor set up the Jedi in hopes of proving his false claims and possibly getting the galaxy to reject his leadership. Mothma is still hurting from reprisals from being part of the 2,000 senators who made a stand against the formation of the Empire, and still hopes there are diplomatic avenues for restoring better governance. Gerrera is still fighting against the corruption he perceives in government with his loyal followers when he discovers a being left over from the war - one designed by the Separatists to be a final weapon against their enemies. As the three follow their own specific yet similar agendas, their stories will eventually come together in an attempt to stop the Emperor from becoming a dictator.
For a Star Wars novel that's heavily loaded with politics, it was a surprisingly engaging read. There was enough action mixed with the political intrigue, and even knowing where the Star Wars story eventually goes, managed to keep you anticipating what would happen next in the novel. A bit depressingly, the politics were a spot on critique of what's happening in the world today. While I felt Bail Organa was very reasonably written, I'm not sure I fully buy into how Mothma was portrayed - granted, she's never been given a lot of screen time in the universe, mostly by name and reputation - but a lot of what happened to her and how she reacted didn't feel organic to the character. Saw Gerrera's portrayal was also off somewhat - at first his self-serving,angry and rebellious ideology was there, but he seemed more like a reasonable freedom fighter the longer the book went, and that's not how I recall him from the cartoons or Rogue One. My biggest issue with the book is, as well-written as it was, it was just way too long. Star Wars books shouldn't be 500 pages. Easily, 100-150 pages could have been excised and still kept the ore story in a much tighter, on-point read. Overall I did really enjoy it, those minor-ish points aside.

Was this review helpful?

Alexander Freed has delivered all I was hoping for in this novel and more. Freed’s portrayal of Bail Organa both evolves him from and anchors him in the character as we left him at the end of the prequel trilogy, and Freed’s depiction of Mon Mothma sets the stage for the character we see in Andor and Rogue One. We also get compelling glimpses into Saw Gerrera and his rebel cohort. Best of all, this first book of a trilogy — I’m really looking forward to the next volume by Rebecca Roanhorse! — provides the same kind of insightful political commentary that has made Andor such a powerful and timely addition to the Star Wars universe. The issues wrestled with here are uncomfortably relevant today, and I’m glad Freed tackles them in his thoughtful novel. Highly recommended! Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Worlds for providing this copy in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Nobody writes Star Wars like Alexander Freed, nobody.
His Star Wars are often dark, full of gray characters who face moral dilemmas, but there's hope in them. And you know what's built on hope. (sorry I had to)

The Mask of Fear is the first book in a trilogy focusing on the first years of Empire, and the people who created the Rebellion: Mon Mothma, Bail Organa and Saw Guerra. Well, in the case of Saw, the story focuses more on a new fascinating character of a Separatist assassin, which is a great addition and creates some interesting points about the Separatist cause.
And if you know these characters, then you know that their approach to the Rebellion is vastly different. (If you don't know them, then you have some watching to do)
Especially in those first days of the Empire when they don't understand how evil Palaptine actually is. They have different priorities, so each one has a different story, but they're still connected at some points.

I love the way Alexander Freed writes his characters, especially Mon Mothma, who is my favourite character here. She's the future Chancellor of the New Republic and you can see why. She's a skilled politician, but she also has her weaknesses, as do other characters. And her transformation in this book is just amazing. You can clearly connect it to her behaviour in Andor.

As for the plot, this book is a mix of politics, espionage and adventure. It's not short and while there are things happening, it's not super action-packed. I don't want to spoil anything but there are some jaw-dropping scenes. 

I would think that all Star Wars fans would enjoy this book, but as we know, this fandom is very picky. So, to be safe, I would definitely recommend it to people that enjoyed Andor and Rogue One. And, of course, the ones that liked the Alphabet Squadrons.

Was this review helpful?

Taking place weeks after the events of Star Wars Episode 3: Revenge of the Sith, we find Senator Bail Organa on the pilgrim moon of Jedha during a procession mourning the fallen Jedi in search of absolution. Not for himself, but for the Jedi that have been blamed by the newly crowned Emperor as traitors to the Republic. With the help of a former Republic, now Imperial admiral, Bail was looking for the supposed evidence Palpatine used to blame the Jedi for their treason. If the keepers of peace were corrupt and deserving of annihilation, where was the proof?

Author Alexander Freed brings us The Mask of Fear, book 1 of the Reign of the Empire trilogy, and has the daunting task of setting the board for the state of the galaxy mere days after Order 66 and the fall of the Republic. With all we know about Star Wars, this is a time period with abundant opportunities to explain how a regime like the Empire can virtually pop out of nowhere, when in reality, the pieces had been set into motion years prior.

While Bail Organa chooses to fight by exposing Palpatines crimes against the Jedi, Senator Mon Mothma still relies on politics to save the day. We are used to seeing real-life politicians visit the sites of natural disasters, in their raincoats and rubber boots and here is where we find Mothma as she and other senators tour the aftermath of the Siege of Coruscant. Experiencing first hand the lack of resources and help provided to those on the lower levels. Away from the political sphere, Saw Gerrera attacks a pirate ship in search of Separatist armaments and supplies, and comes out with something more valuable. A Separatist agent. An operative whose main mission was to continue the Separatist cause in the event they lost the war. This came in the form of Soujen Vak-Nhalis, Star Wars version of the Winter Soldier. A cybernetically-augmented human from Alvadorjia. As these main “rebels” set out on their missions, Mon Mothma starts recruiting senators, from both sides of the aisle, anti-empire, pro-empire, and even ex-Separatist leaders to help her craft a bill that will limit Palpatine’s power grab.

Freed has such a command on these types of stories that at times I felt angry, not about the book but about how much these situations mirror our current political landscape. How you can see things building up but how those in power chose to either look the other way or believe that continuing on the same path, the one that brought us to this point, will work out the next time. I liked seeing that Bail and Mon didn’t see eye to eye and each went on a separate journey. Bail was dead set in proving the Jedi’s innocence, not for his conscience but for that of his daughter as he didn’t want Leia to have to shoulder his burden. He suffered from the same ailment as Mothma, believing that one noble act would be enough to bring back what they lost. The Republic.

Was this review helpful?

The first installment in the Reign of the Empire trilogy, Alexander Freed’s Mask of Fear, is a triumph of political intrigue and masterful storytelling. While marketed as a political thriller, the book leans heavily into its political foundation, with thrilling moments simmering beneath the surface of deliberation and maneuvering. Told primarily through the perspectives of Mon Mothma and Bail Organa—two senators navigating the oppressive and labyrinthine halls of Palpatine’s newly formed Galactic Empire in the aftermath of Order 66—the book captures both the idealism and desperation of those trying to enact change in an Empire determined to quash it. As the story unfolds, other voices—each with their own stake in the Empire's survival or collapse—emerge, enriching a narrative as multifaceted as the galaxy itself.

The depth of research underpinning this book is staggering. Freed doesn’t merely tell a story; he crafts a universe rife with political nuance, cultural complexity, and institutional decay. It feels as though he has lived within the Galactic Senate, absorbing its rituals, rules, and power plays to deliver a narrative that feels hauntingly accurate. Those seeking traditional Star Wars action may find this a different experience—and while there are moments of incendiary action, this is fundamentally a story about the strategic groundwork of a rebellion still in its infancy.

To be kyber clear: Mask of Fear is a slow burn. For those unprepared for such a cerebral experience, this book might feel like wading through galactic bureaucracy itself. But don’t let that deter you—the aim here isn’t to discourage readers, but to set the proper tone and expectation for a story that rewards patience and attention to detail. For those who rise to the challenge, the reward is as great as the demand. The emotional core of the story lies in its exploration of hope in the face of overwhelming odds. These are not the tales of Jedi knights or hotshot pilots, but of public servants trying to preserve democracy through bureaucratic resistance. Freed's portrayal of Mon Mothma and Bail Organa is profoundly poignant. Their efforts, noble as they are, feel hopeless in the immediate term, but Freed sows the seeds of rebellion with quiet precision.

This is vintage Freed, at the height of his craft: intricately structured, saturated with sophisticated vocabulary, and uncompromisingly dense. It requires your full attention and intellectual investment. Freed offers no reprieve; every sentence serves a purpose, and every page challenges readers with layered subtext and cascading details. The characters' emotions—fueled by their inner turmoil and unspoken thoughts—leap off the page, adding visceral depth to the political landscape.

Fans of Andor will find familiar territory here, though with deeper introspection and more deliberate pacing. Mask of Fear is an unflinching examination of institutional defiance that collides with Imperial reality. It's not a book for casual readers; it rewards those who seek substance, nuance, and a story that lingers long after the final page. A true commitment for those who embrace it, Mask of Fear is an unforgettable start to what promises to be an extraordinary trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

It’s thrilling to know that a trilogy of books illuminating the years before the Rebellion when three individuals, who believe the Jedi still exist, slowly and carefully maneuver within the new Galactic Republic.

In the first book published, The Mask of Fear in the Reign of the Empire trilogy, Chancellor Palpatine has promised to bring a “Safe and secure society,” but we know differently -- come on, this is Palpatine!

Main characters Mon Mothma, Saw Gerrera, and Bail Organa also know -- and fear -- the Galactic Republic.
It’s creepy to be in the perspective of a justifiable paranoid, trying to work out what steps they can take without being killed.

The creepiness notwithstanding, I found the first part of the novel to be very difficult reading; the extent of details made it hard to follow what Mothma was thinking. Perhaps that won’t be true for other readers who are better versed in the Star Wars universe. Unfortunately, I did not finish reading the book.

I received an advance copy of this book from Netgalley. This is an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

All of the intrigue of Andor set in the earliest days of the empire, The Mask of Fear is for fans wanting to know how different factions and well-known leaders came together and founded the rebel alliance. As the first in the Reign of the Empire trilogy, Freed's book had its ups and downs. It has strong characterization and excellent political scheming, but the writing lacked emotional impact at a few key points in the narrative (though there are emotional scenes to be had). Despite that, Freed manages to give us a believable first-hand look at the newly-formed empire through the eyes of characters closely tied to the old Republic and the rebel alliance, and I'm excited to see what's to come.

Was this review helpful?

Alexander Freed adds to the Star Wars mythology with skill, developing the story for new readers and those steeped in this world. The book works as science fiction all on its own, with an entire universe for additional connecting and enjoyment.

Was this review helpful?

Cracking, ambitious entry into Star Wars canon. Utilising the classic Star Wars world building and characters to great effect this is not to be missed.

Was this review helpful?

The Mask of Fear is a gripping and ambitious entry into the Star Wars canon, set in the tumultuous period between Revenge of the Sith and Andor. This first installment of the Reign of the Empire trilogy explores the fragile and dangerous early days of the Rebel Alliance through the perspectives of Mon Mothma, Bail Organa, and Saw Gerrera.

Told through alternating the points of view, the story weaves a political thriller that highlights the characters' contrasting approaches to undermining the newly established Galactic Empire. Mon Mothma’s calculated diplomacy, Bail Organa’s subtle resistance, and Saw Gerrera’s more radical tactics showcase the diverse ideologies and strategies that would later shape the rebellion. Each character’s journey is distinct yet interconnected, creating a tense narrative full of intrigue, moral conflict, and action.

While the empire’s fall is still far off, The Mask of Fear effectively lays the foundation for what will become a galaxy-wide resistance. The story is not only a prelude to Andor but also a deep dive into the personal and political struggles of its key figures. Fans of the series will appreciate the novel’s careful attention to continuity, as well as its exploration of themes like sacrifice, hope, and the cost of defiance.

As the first chapter in this trilogy, the book sets a strong tone for what’s to come. With Andor returning in 2025, The Mask of Fear feels like the perfect companion piece, offering new layers of context and depth to the Rebel Alliance's origins. The next two books promise to delve even further into the evolution of the rebellion, and I, for one, can’t wait to see where the story goes next.

This is Star Wars storytelling at its finest—complex, thrilling, and steeped in the weight of its characters' decisions. A must-read for any fan eager to explore the darker, more nuanced corners of the galaxy.

Was this review helpful?

This is being promoted in many ways as a tie-in for Andor, but it's also a tie-in for Clone Wars and Revenge of the Sith, and going in, I was curious how Freed was going to handle that. Star Wars is a franchise that spans genres and age levels. The tone of Clone Wars--a TV-PG-rated animated military fantasy adventure show for tweens and teens, full of Jedi hijinks and quippy, sometimes bombastic dialogue--doesn't really match the tone of Andor, a TV-14 political drama and spy thriller. I like them both for what they are, but I couldn't see how they were going to come together. Was Freed going to lean more toward one or the other, or attempt to blend them into a middle ground?

The answer is neither. Mon here is very much Mon from Andor (or at least, a younger and slightly less despairing version of Mon from Andor), concerned with the minutia of legislation and the difficulty of finding, trusting, and keeping allies in an atmosphere of increasing political paranoia. Bail is very much Bail from Revenge of the Sith and Clone Wars, fixated on the Jedi as the best and purest force in the galaxy and ready to ditch his office duties and fling himself into action at the slightest excuse.

And it works better than I could have imagined, because that difference in genre origin has been reified into a difference of political perspective. Mon is an institutionalist, a centrist, a schemer who believes Palpatine can be held in check via political means; Bail is a firebrand populist convinced that exposing The Truth of Order 66 and the murder of the Jedi (if he can just find evidence) will cause the people to revolt against Palpatine in horror. They both want Palpatine out of power, but they're both convinced the other is going about it a completely wrong-headed way, and that divide is the tension that drives the novel.

(Which is, frankly, a better source of tension than "will they succeed in defeating Palpatine in 19 BBY," because we the readers know perfectly well the answer to that is "no." But "will Bail and Mon succeed in putting aside their differences working together"? We-ell, eventually yes, we know that, but exactly when and how willingly or grudgingly is something canon has never before explored.)

I like Mon. I like Bail. I spent a significant part of this novel thinking at both of them, "I understand why you think this will help, but it will not and I wish you'd make better choices." And that to me is a sign of quality characterization: building characters I understand and empathize with even when I think they're very, very wrong.

You may note that this point that this is a novel with three protagonists, and yet I've talked about only two of them. That's because I think the Saw Gerrera sections work rather less well than the Mon and Bail ones. I will admit upfront that I find Saw tedious as a character across the franchise, so I'm not the best reviewer to judge how effectively he's used here. But I don't think it helps that we get almost no insight into Saw's thoughts; Mon and Bail are POV of their own sections, but the Saw portions of the novel are told through the POV of a new character. That character is fine as a plot device, but never really grew on me as a person despite fairly extensive attempts to build sympathy via backstory.

There are several other new-to-the-novel characters who get POVs at various points, and all of them work much better for me than the one who's our viewpoint on Saw. I hope we see more of them in the future, though it's hard to say with the way the trilogy has been split between three authors. (I also hope we get more insight into Saw, and that seems likely; perhaps Roanhorse will be more comfortable writing from his POV than Freed was.) But either way, I'm excited to see where the narrative goes. If you thought "there's nothing new to say about this period of galactic history," this novel will prove you wrong.

[I received a free copy from NetGalley for review purposes]

Was this review helpful?

What an honor to read! I really really enjoyed this one. Granted, I know little about the whole world of SW, just from the movies, but this was really fantastic and I hope I can read more.

Was this review helpful?

The Mask of Fear is everything I hoped for and more—an electrifying start to a new Star Wars trilogy that promises to redefine the Rebellion’s origins. Alexander Freed delivers an intricate, character-driven story that not only explores the immediate fallout of Padmé Amidala’s death but also dives deep into the fractured relationships among Mon Mothma, Bail Organa, and Saw Gerrera. The result is a tense, emotional journey through a galaxy on the brink of rebellion.

The novel shines in its portrayal of these iconic figures grappling with grief, distrust, and the weight of their roles in the face of the Empire’s ever-expanding tyranny. Mon and Bail are allies but not entirely aligned, while Saw’s radical approach creates a friction that feels both raw and authentic. Freed balances this character work with an equally compelling array of new faces, ensuring that the stakes never waver for a moment.

What stood out most for me is how Freed highlights the Empire’s real strength: isolating individuals, convincing them that resistance is futile. Watching these characters fight against that isolation—while still unsure of where their paths will lead—makes this novel an unmissable chapter in modern Star Wars storytelling.

I’m beyond excited for where this trilogy goes next. If The Mask of Fear is any indication, Star Wars: Reign of the Empire will be essential reading for fans old and new. Bring on book two!

Was this review helpful?

An excellent addition to the Star Wars universe. Well, written, compelling, and intriguing throughout, it does an interesting job of examining the early stages of a dictatorship through the eyes of individuals intent on bringing about its downfall. I will without question be recommending this book once it is released

Was this review helpful?