Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was one of the absolute cutest graphic novel I’ve ever read!! Illustrated in a cartoonish, yet whimsical way, was a perfect for this book to embody this allegory for working at Disneyland. Not only that, but Tabi is the BIGGEST fan of Summerland and had such passion and joy, even when she isn’t exactly getting what she wants. She’s got a touch of mischief and I loved her! This was a very cute, fast-paced story about chasing your dreams, not being ashamed to be yourself, and the joy of joy.

Was this review helpful?

Marissa Meyer does it again! I love Marissa Meyer and this graphic novel was so cute. As someone who loves Disney and did the DCP, this graphic novel was definitely relatable. I really liked the main character and like the messages around her character. She had big dreams and worked hard for those dreams, but also had to readjust the idealistic view she had of her life in Summerland. It was nice to see a character work through the reality of what her dreams look like. And not to mention, the romance was so sweet! Obviously with it being a graphic novel, the story is shorter and it can be difficult to develop a story, especially a relationship, in a graphic novel format. I felt like Marissa Meyer did a fantastic job with that. Even though it was short, I still felt like the relationship was believable and made sense. And she was able to pace it in a way that felt like the natural progression of a relationship.
Overall, the graphic novel was really cute and I would highly recommend it, especially for people who are fans of Marissa Meyer or Disney.

Thank you to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group for this Arc!

Was this review helpful?

I think this was super cute and I liked the representation! I know it's a graphic novel but the pacing felt soooo fast.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this! I loved how Tabi is a bigger main character and to me I love to see this! She give us all hope. I loved how Tabi went after what she deserved and got it in the end! This was so enjoyable and I read it in one sitting.

Was this review helpful?

I love all things Marissa Meyer, so I was excited to read this graphic novel!

We Could Be Magic follows Tabitha in her journey to achieve her dream. Ever since she was little, Tabitha wanted to become a princess at Sommerland. However, once she starts working at the park, she learns that she may not fit the typical role of a princess. This is such a great story about body image, confidence, reaching for your goals, and had a touch of romance mixed in. I loves reading this story, the art style, and the color choices.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, MacMillan Children's Publishing Group, Feiwel & Friends, Marissa Meyer, and Joelle Murray (artist) for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

We Could Be Magic is an exceptionally beautiful graphic novel with a heart-warming story. Think Disneyland, but it's Sommerland, with all the fun of the happiest place on earth.

Ever since she was six, Tabi has dreamed of being the princess from her favorite show. Near the end of high school, she is eligible for a three month summer program where she can stay in the Sommerland dorms and work there. While she wants to play the princess role, still, after all these years, she'll take anything, because working at Somemerland is its own dream.

After landing a nacho stand job, she continues to pursue her dream of being a character, specifically a princess. Auditions are more than she expected, and she puts so much effort into fulfilling her dream. What's stopping her? Society. Tabi doesn't "look the part" of the princess characters. She's black and plus-sized. And maybe that's the image people should have of a princess. It's a very diverse world out there!

I love the "follow your dreams" aspect of this novel and how hard Tabi works. Despite society's view of her in relation to the characters she wants to portray, she continues to try hard and never give up, an excellent lesson for young readers. I also love the representation and overall message. Society does place us based on our appearance, but people come in all shapes, sizes, and colors, and a need for more diverse representation in our world today has never been higher!

Meter is a fantastic writer and has executed a flawless story about hard work and determination. Murray makes for gorgeous illustrations that really make this book come to life and give the reader that feeling of magic-making that this story is truly going for.

Was this review helpful?

I love Marissa Meyer, but I was a little reluctant to read this one, both because it was a graphic and because I feared that it would be about discrimination (and it was, but not in the way I thought it would be). I was delighted by the story. I grew up as a big Disney Fan, and dreamt of working at Disney World, and the behind-the-scenes setting at a theme park was the stuff I dreamed of as a girl. I read the ARC (thanks, NetGalley!) as a test to see if I should buy it for my middle school, and I will order it. It has a very sweet romance, both good and bad characters, a very hopeful heroine, and a pastels-colored theme park based on fantasy. 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

We Could Be Magic is a heartwarming and enchanting graphic novel that beautifully captures the magic of dreams coming true. Marissa Meyer weaves a sweet and uplifting storyline that feels like a love letter to hope, self-discovery, and the power of believing in yourself. The Disney-esque parallel adds a delightful touch of whimsy, making it feel like a modern fairy tale. What truly sets this story apart is its representation—having a plus-sized main character who becomes the most beloved princess is a refreshing and empowering choice. This book is a celebration of diversity, self-love, and the magic that exists within us all. A must-read for anyone who loves stories that inspire and uplift!

Was this review helpful?

This was such an amazing book. The art style was dynamic, I was invested in the characters, and the overline plot and storyline was interesting to read.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness I loved every single second of reading this, I couldn’t put it down! The artwork, the characters, the magical that filled my heart, all of it was the perfect comfort

I can see myself coming back to this every time I need a little pick me up, just feel that moment of magic in my heart again!

I would love to see more about Sommerland in the future, maybe some other characters finding their happily ever after as well! There is just so much to explore in that park, and I want to hear all about it!

Was this review helpful?

A joyful jaunt in a spoof of working for The Mouse.

We Could Be Magic follows Tabitha, who desperately wants to be cast as a princess to create the magical moments she remembered as a child. Through hard work, dedication, and passion, she works tirelessly to chase after her dreams.

The art style is charming, and I love seeing the parallels to another famous amusement park, and an emphasis on creating spectacular moments.

Was this review helpful?

🌟ARC🌟
Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan Children's Publishing Group for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

This comes out on June 3, 2025!

📚 We Could Be Magic
✨ by Marissa Meyer
📖 Genre: Comic, Romance
⭐ Rating: 5/5 stars

📝 Review:
I could not put this one down! When I went out I couldn't wait to get back to read more of this one. It's pretty obvious what it relates to in real life, and is probably similar to what a lot of people have gone through. I fell in love with the characters immediately and was on the edge of my seat wanting to know what happened next, wishing for the happy ending. This was enjoyable and I highly recommend it!

🤔 Why You Should Read It:
This is so relatable for anyone who as a kid looked up to a princess, or superhero, and wanted to be them but don't fit the "mold." I was in tears at certain points and at the ending. You will love the heartwarming story and the reminder to make magic.

Was this review helpful?

Ever since she was a little girl Tabi has always wanted to be a Sommerland princess and has a chance at her dream when she lands a summer job at the Sommerland theme park. Unfortunately, she doesn’t look like the park’s idea of a princess. A heartwarming story that shows that with hardwork, determination, and a little bit of magic your dreams can come true.

The story was well-written and believable. Young readers will be able to relate to the characters and their experiences. The illustrations complemented the story and brought their own magic with vibrant colors and settings. Highly recommended for all young adults!

Was this review helpful?

Okay, I loved this!! Such a cute and wholesome graphic novel with a plus size main character who finds love and goes after her dreams. For anyone who has loved Disneyland and dreamed of working there (of course, for copyright reasons this theme park has a completely different name and different princesses, but basically Disney) We Could Be Magic has a character who does just that.

Tabi has dreamed of playing her favorite princess since she was a little girl and lives for the magic of the parks. So getting into a summer employment program is a dream. Or...it starts out that way. Because the truth is that not everyone wants to be there or cares about making magic for guests, and no-one thinks a plus-size girl could play a princess. But Tabi will do whatever it takes to prove them wrong, even as she becomes a little disillusioned with parts of it.

This was exactly what I would have wanted to see as a teenager who loved going to Disney parks every few years with family, and who really could have used this kind of body-positive representation with an adorable romance. If this sounds like your thing I definitely recommend it! I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really cute graphic novel. Tabi has dreamed of being a princess at Sommerland since she first went as a young child. She gets into a summer program at the park, but instead of being a Princess, she is tasked with making nachos. Enter somewhat carry roommates, a cute friend, cliquey royalty, and a summer that doesn’t quite go as she planned.

Overall, this was a really cute story and I loved the art. There were some parts that felt a bit rushed, but I still enjoyed it. Also, I’m not sure if it was just because it was a digital ARC, but some of the pages were a bit blurry and there were a few times the text was outside the text box.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who also resides in a larger body, it was nice to see that representation in this book and how Tabitha navigates her own struggles with her dreams and how they match up with the unfortunate reality of places like Sommerland. I enjoyed the characters, the art, the story, and thought it was a very sweet book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a super cute YA graphic novel. Good message and well executed artwork. Perfect for a young teen! I love Marissa Meyer and this doesn't disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I ever read by the author although several of her books are on my TBR. I LOVED this graphic novel. I read it in one sitting. I loved the message of following your dreams, being confident and believing in yourself even when others do not. This was beautifully written AND illustrated.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun read! Sommerland is very clearly a stand in for Disney, and watching Tabitha learn just how unmagical working at the most magical place on earth can be hit me in the very core as a former theme park employee myself. Highly unrealistic, but still super fun ending that made my cold, dark heart tingle. The art was beautiful and the characters were fun, which led to the best cozy reading experience, especially on a rainy night. I finished this with some Disney World fever, that's for sure!

Was this review helpful?

E-arc provided by Netgalley

This was cute but a very clear disney rip off to the point that it was taking me out of the story a bit. Also this was pretty short so a lit of development happened in a very short amount of time/ wasn't super flushed out

Was this review helpful?