Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Id like to start off with stating I did like the book; However I am not the target audience. I did read the two previous books and again I enjoyed them but they aren't my favorite. This series is geared to a younger audience, and I do believe that it is good for the Middle grade and Highschool readers.

You do need to read the first two books before reading this one , these are very much a series and not intended to be a stand-alone

What I didn't enjoy in this book was it felt like it lost a tad bit of momentum that the first two books have started to build up.

I do like the blend of mythology and fantasy built up together in the world. I also do enjoy the continuation of the story that the first two books have started to build on.

I do enjoy books with multiple POVs, however this book felt like we were flipping a lot more frequently than I like. I think longer chapters in one POV would have been better.

The story gets a tad predictable, However for a younger reader this may no be the case.

Again I enjoyed the book, however I am 34 and probably not the target audience. This is a series id be happily gift a younger reader and be confident that they would enjoy it.

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press | Wednesday Books for the Digital Arc.

Was this review helpful?

When I was first tasked to read this book before release, I had no idea it was a part of a series and went back and read the first two before starting this one and I am glad I did. This series hooked me right at the beginning of the first book and has kept me intrigued throughout the entire series. Each book has been as good as the first and I think this one might actually be my favorite of the series so far. The author does such a great job of representation of the LGBTQ community and is great at normalizing the community. How she writes is how we want to feel, no one saying we're wrong when we tell them our names or pronouns, just acceptance and respect when finding out. Not only is the writer inclusive, but the story is wonderful and the magic she created is unique and enjoyable to get in to. I am in love with this series and can't wait for the final book!

Was this review helpful?

👍 Solid installment in the series. I enjoyed the world building and getting to know more about the Northern kingdom. I think this one had the most cliffhanger ending thus far BUT we are gearing up for the final boss fight in the next book.

👎 The political intrigue could’ve been better BUT the characters were wrapped up in the demon threat so it’s all good.

Was this review helpful?

5 plus. So sad. The author did it again and pushed further. I love all the Guardians, but Yuli is so cool. She is a princess, but her life is not as easy as many may think. This princess, who is a guardian too, is going to work double in this book, helping the guardians and also dealing with the subsection problem in her kingdom. They need an heir, and Yuli's rival is no less than her best friend Kho. But the sleepers aren't just a problem of book 2. They are a horde of problems in book 3 with a big Demon leader infiltrating high ranks in the court. We have a bit more palace intrigue and trials. Politics in this one, and lots of action. As always, the last part of the book is a great battle, and this time, there is no place for celebration. I need book 4 right now.
With vivid imagery, it is easy to imagine the elements, petals, flowing sleeves, glowing familiars, and terrible demons. The kiss scene was sweet.

Was this review helpful?

this fell a bit flat for me, especially compared to the other two books in this saga, the multiple povs really threw me off, i thought we were switching characters too often. with that being said, i liked the pacing and as always i loved the world building and all the magical lore.

Was this review helpful?

I did not realize that this book was part of a well established series and just dove in. Even though I missed the backstory, I was able to keep up with the storyline of this book. I got the impression that a different Guardian of Dawn is discovered and comes into their power with each book, and this book focuses on Yuli. The world building is phenomenal, and the magic blends around the characters and through the community in a delightful way. I got caught up in the battle against the sleeping dreamer sickness, and found this to be a very exciting book. Thank you to Wednesday Books for granting me an ARC of this book in exchange for my review.

That said, I was distracted by the overuse of the word 'they.' This may not be politically correct today, but I find it very difficult to follow who is being referenced by this pronoun. When a group of people leave, and someone who stays behind says that she misses them, it should reflect that she misses everyone that left. I understand what the pronoun is supposed to indicate besides a group of people, but I felt that the overuse of the word resulted in a book about a community that is completely gender fluid. I am not homophobic, but this made it hard for me to connect to the characters (despite my similar magical nature).

Was this review helpful?

This book is emotionally charged, rich with themes of power, responsibility, and sacrifice. It had me captivated from beginning to end, and I couldn’t put it down. I adore the way the magical world feels so lived-in. The Guardians of Dawn, with their elemental powers, are fascinating, and the connection between Yuli and the other Guardians adds a sense of unity and tension, all while highlighting their individual struggles. The magic system is richly detailed and impactful, with the consequences of failing to restore balance feeling so real and immediate. If you love stories filled with complex characters, action, and an enchanting world, this is absolutely for you.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Wednesday Books and Netgalley for this eARC, these opinions are my own. A great next installment! Princess Yulana (Yuli) returns to the north along with Zhara and Ami. Their goal is to close the northern portal to the demon realm. But there is unrest and the other Golden Families are attempting to take the throne. In order to save it Yuli must compete in the Grand Games, trials to prove her worthiness. This is on top of searching for the demon portal. Can she close the portal and save her families rule? A page turner that had me hooked! I enjoyed the Grand Games and think they had an exciting element to the story! S. Jae-Jones continues the Guardians of the Dawn with a fast paced adventure full of love, difficult choices, and sacrifices!

Was this review helpful?

✨Thank you to both NetGalley and the publisher, Wednesday books for allowing me access to this ARC in exchange for an honest review. ✨

This is the third book in the YA fantasy series Guardians of the Dawn. This is the fight between chaos and peace, demons and magicians, magicians and anti-ki (people with no magical abilities). This story follows Yulis as the people are continuing to fight for equality. This has great themes on individuality, orientation and love.

This book has similar beats to the second book in this series. I would have preferred if this book had focused on Yuli's story and less on the characters around her as the constant change in adventure gave a bit of whiplash on what was going on. I did like the relationships represented in this story and I liked Yuli's character.

I was pleasantly surprised by the ending and it did give the story more depth. I am looking forward to the next story and how this will continue.

Was this review helpful?

I just The third installment in the Guardians of Dawn series brings readers back into the intricately built world of elemental warriors, demonic threats, and brewing civil war. Princess Yulana (Yuli), now the Guardian of Wind, is juggling more than her fair share of crises—from an empire on the brink of collapse to a personal rivalry that hits a little too close to home. The premise is undeniably ambitious, and the Asian-inspired magical and political world continues to be richly imaginative. I appreciated the continued presence of Ami, Gaden, Zhara, and Han as they further uncover the mysteries of their world, particularly the portals and demonic forces threatening their realms.

That said, this book feels like it’s carrying too much weight. With multiple major plotlines—a mysterious illness, a deadly competition for leadership, political instability, and supernatural chaos—the narrative often lacks clear focus. Add to that the four or five POVs that switch every few pages, and it’s easy to feel lost in the shuffle. While the writing itself flows well and the descriptions are vivid, the overall experience can become overwhelming, especially if you haven’t read the first two books, which I had to go back to read because I did not realize this was the 3rd in a series when I requested it.

Was this review helpful?

"You told me once that I could never make the hard decisions. I'm making it now. For the greater good."

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press/Wednesday Books for an ARC of Guardians of Dawn: Yuli in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions that follow are my own.

Guardians of Dawn: Yuli continues the story of the previous two books in this series, this time focusing on Princess Yulana of the North, who has the power to spirit=walk. Yuli has returned home to the far north alongside Zhara and Ami in order to close the northern portal to the demon realm as well as to find the northern portion of the Songs of Order and Chaos. Little does she know that one of the other Five Golden Families is making a play to take power in the north as well as taking control of the Sunburst Throne. To ensure that her kang remains in power, Yuli has to compete in the Grand Game, a series of trials to prove her worthiness, against the First Daughter of the Maltak Kang while at the same time, searching for the demon portal.

I loved this book so much! It is by far my favorite in the series right now and Yuli is my absolute favorite character. She was not afraid to do whatever she had to in order to ensure that her family remained in power for the safety of the entire Morning Realms. Her relationship with her former best friend, Maltak Kho, was full of twists and turns from beginning to end and kept me rooting for them both. I thought that the Grand Game was an interesting addition and added a fun element to the overall story, showing a little bit more of Yuli's character, skills, and personality. I was kind of sad that Gaden and Han didn't get a whole lot of page time in this book but I also understood why they didn't. The last 5=10 chapters of this book had me in an absolute chokehold and I loved every minute of it. I would definitely rate this book 5/5 stars!

I cannot wait for the next book in the series! If you enjoyed Zhara and Ami, check out Yuli's story when it hits shelves on August 19, 2025!

Was this review helpful?

This was a lovely, refreshing book and heartbreaking in so many ways. There is love and sacrifice and making hard decisions. It follows not just Yuli, butvthe other two Guardians as they face new lands, a frozen land that has a new danger. Seeing Yuli grow more into her powers and seeing what she could really do shone here. I really enjoyed the intersecting storylines and learning more about Yuli's culture. Fairy tale and real life landscapes come to life in this book and I'm very much looking forward to the next.

Was this review helpful?

🌬️ World & Plot
What I loved:

The Asian‑inspired steppes and the concept of forbidden magic give the Morning Realms a unique flavor—you can almost hear the wind howling across the grasslands and sense the weight of ancestral spirits in every corner.

The Grand Game’s trials offer high‑stakes drama and showcase Yuli’s ingenuity under pressure.

What gave me pause:

With so many factions vying for power, there were moments when I had to flip back to keep track of who’s aligned with whom. A brief “Who’s Who” would have been handy.

🎭 Characters
Yuli (Princess Yulana): Her evolution—from a princess under siege to the newly awakened Guardian of Wind—felt earned. I especially related to her struggle between duty and self‑discovery.

Kho: Initially set up as rival‑turned‑ally, Kho’s loyalty felt heartfelt, and their slow‑burn friendship ticked all the right boxes for me.

Supporting cast: The ensemble is large, and while I enjoyed moments with characters like the cunning Vizier Anwen, a couple of them could have used just a bit more page time to avoid blending together.

🖋️ Prose & Pacing
Prose: S. Jae‑Jones’s descriptions are lush without ever slowing down the narrative. Lines like “the steppes rippled with the ghosts of battles yet to be fought” stayed with me long after reading.

Pacing: The middle of the book dips a bit—partly because multiple POV chapters disrupt the urgency of Yuli’s own journey. That said, once the Grand Game kicks into its final trials, the momentum hurtles forward again.

đź’­ Personal Reflections
Emotional resonance: The novel’s centerpiece is Yuli’s relationship with her people and with Kho. Their moments of quiet camaraderie—sharing stories by campfire light, offering silent support—felt particularly moving.

Themes of balance: As Guardian of Wind, Yuli’s struggles to balance power and compassion echoed real‑world questions about leadership and responsibility.

Room to grow: I’m eager to see how the next installment handles the fallout from the Grand Game and whether we’ll get deeper dives into the cultural textures of the Morning Realms.

Was this review helpful?

Sweeping and magical, this was so wonderful to read. Yuli is the guardian of the wind, and is charged with righting the chaos that's been reigning. It would be much simpler if her former best friend and now rival wasn't such a hindrance!

Was this review helpful?

What a great 3rd installment! I don't usually love multiple povs and plot lines but this author always makes them feel so seamless! The prose is stunning

Was this review helpful?

In Guardians of Dawn: Yuli by S. Jae-Jones, the story unfolds in a richly imagined, Asian-inspired fantasy world where magic is forbidden. Princess Yulana, known as Yuli, must contend with the weight of her grandmother's legacy—a heritage steeped in mysterious powers that the empire seeks to suppress. As Yuli's abilities awaken, she becomes a pivotal figure in the rebellion against the empire's tyranny. Alongside allies who each harbor their own secrets and strengths, Yuli navigates a dangerous path filled with betrayal, intrigue, and sacrifice. This third installment in the Guardians of Dawn series beautifully interweaves themes of resilience, identity, and the fight for justice, offering readers a gripping and thought-provoking adventure.

Was this review helpful?

Book three in the Guardians of Dawn series really kicks things up a notch. The world is still just as rich, and the character growth continues to be one of the best parts.

It definitely felt heavier and more intense than the first two, though maybe not as tightly put together. The multiple POVs got a little confusing here and there, but I loved how the trials brought Yuli and Kho closer. Not my favorite of the series so far, but still really good and kept me invested.

Was this review helpful?

A genuinely fun series. Do not seek grimdark here. It’s funny, it blends action and romance, and it fully has my attention wanting to know what comes next.

The guardians are almost all together as a group, like we’re really close to the big boss battle. The narrative does recap some exposition. I needed that (poor short term memory), but I know that some readers find that annoying. 

Another caveat is that there is lots of “telling”, but there is also an expansion of mesmerizing world-building. The book is great at “set dressing.” Every setting had its own characteristics, culture, weather, vibes, etc. We get to see the North in this one, where vies for power are fracturing the aristocracy.

We get to see how our characters see themselves and see others, such as each Guardian thinking they’re the worst one, that the others have cooler powers and better personalities. There are more POVs in this one, so if that’s not your thing, just warning you.

My favorite element of the book is its humor. Funny interactions between characters. Subtle modern pop culture references: the totally-not-BTS Bangtam Brothers, references to Squid Game and those Korean sweets, and I swear there were others, those are just the two I made note of.

There is awkward wording in the ebook ARC I read (so not the final printed version) regarding the one explicitly Black character, usually referring to him as “black-skinned” with few other descriptors. It feels weird, maybe a little racist. It’s definitely not intended racism, and the narrative doesn’t include anything racist. It would be an easy fix for editing.

The story ends on a massive cliff hanger, but it also feels like a complete story told. I can’t wait for the finale. 

A highly subjective 9/10. Still an enjoyable read for everyone else.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the story, the world building and meeting the different characters. I felt completely immersed in the story and couldn't stop reading it.

Was this review helpful?

Guardians of Dawn: Yuli is the third book in the Guardians of Dawn series by S. Jae-Jones. I found it a little more difficult to get into compared to the first two, but I think that it is building up for the fourth book in the series. Some of the settings are great, and it really has the “magical girl” style, though the political intrigue didn’t quite work for me. I feel this book is more setting the stage for the fourth. As a side note, I was introduced to this series from Illumicrate, and the physical books for this series are so lovely. Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books, and S. Jae-Jones for a copy of this ARC.

Was this review helpful?