Skip to main content

Member Reviews

1 star for me for finishing it.
1 star for the narrator who did an excellent job.

I'm afraid this really wasn't for me. The first half of the book could have been condensed into a couple of chapters following, as it does, Harriet's complete lack of faith in herself. There was so much procrastination that I began to fast forward quite early on.

The story itself could have been really interesting but it only really gets going in the last quarter.

I always try to look for some good points in every book I read so the story was interesting but ruined by repetition and the narration by Anna Burnett was excellent. The production was also good on the audio.

Thankyou to Netgalley and RB Media for the audio advance review copy.

Was this review helpful?

After a life of trauma living under the oppressive and abusive thumb of her father, Harriet finds solace in her wild and overgrown garden. She is questioned and ostracised for living alone in 19th Century London, when a marriage could save her house and her social status. But is her husband any better than her father?

The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt explores trauma. And I mean A LOT of trauma (Massive trigger warnings for SA and DV). I was initially interested in this book, because the marketing made it sound very fantastical, whimsical, and witchy. However, after listening to this, the marketing is done all wrong. This was essentially, “How many traumatic things can I do to this poor girl?”
The garden itself played a very small role in the book, and right from the beginning the magic was so understated that I thought the author was being metaphorical, or making a juxtaposition between Harriets life and the small solace she gains in the garden. Don’t get me wrong, the descriptions were beautiful.I could almost feel and smell the garden from my headphones. It was just very understated.
There were also some plot points and characters that were forgotten about, namely Nigel Davies, which the author could have done so much with. The mentions of him culminated in one scene at the end, which felt like a cop out to end the story.
The Audio was fantastic though, and I think the narrator was great for this book!

This had the potential to be a beautiful and unique story, with a magical garden, the mystery surrounding her father (which wasn’t wrapped up), and the potential for incredible character development. Unfortunately, the book missed the mark on all these points.

Unfortunately, I would not recommend this to most of the people I know that are interested in Fantasy or Magical Realism. I do however recommend this as an interesting book club book.

In the end, while I felt that this was generally well written, there were some plot holes and forgotten plot points, and I think it was marketed wrong as a fantasy. For this reason I have given this a 3 star rating.
Thank you to Netgalley and RB Media for the Advanced Listener’s Copy (ALC) of this book. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

While I was reading this book it felt reminiscent of a different story but I couldn’t put my finger on which one and I’ve just figured it out a week later. It feels similar to We Have Always Lived in the Castle but not at all the same.

I LOVE when a man chooses to gaslight the wrong woman. It really tickles my feminine rage in such a satisfying way.

There were parts of this book that felt a little redundant but overall I really enjoyed it, especially the fact that the garden was like the best friend willing to do what had to be done.

Was this review helpful?

If I could focus a bit more on audiobooks than physical books than I'd have loved this book so much, but I didn't really have to worry about that because I was really engaged in this story for the majority of it. I thought it was really great. The aspect that stood out to me the most was the incredible world building. Whenever I heard a vivid description of the character's surroundings or just the atmosphere/location in general, I was locked in. Congratulations to the author on that. A few of the characters had great growth in this novel. Amazing supernatural imagery and elements with the garden. Some dark undertones with the evil, cruel male characters but the magical realism hooked me into a journey that was mostly beautifully written in my opinion, and I'm hoping to listen to audiobook again or read the physical novel!

Was this review helpful?

2 tortured Stars - 1 of which is for the fabulous job done by the narrator of this audiobook (only 1 star for the written word).

The synopsis of this book sounds mainly magical, with a bit of bother heaped upon the main character, first by her father and later by her husband. Actually, it is more true to say that the first 3/4 of this book is ongoing, repetitive TRAUMA-PORN!!

Harriet is held captive by greedy, deceitful men, a fully traumatized perspective (skewed sense of guilt and “deservedness”), and the perverse mid 19th-century prospects of any woman. She has zero idea that she holds any power whatsoever, because she has been emotionally abused, physically held captive and gaslit for the majority of her life.

The very latter part of the book (last 1.5-2 hours of a 10.5 hour audiobook) allows some light into the darkest forest of Harriet’s and life…. though incredibly slowly.

The ONLY reason that I didn’t completely abandon this book a third of the way in is (1) I had committed to reviewing it and (2) it would have given me nightmares!

The written word itself was well rendered, but so incredibly repetitive that no true validation can be given. And while I understand that this is how a traumatized person continues to think, the author leaving her to stew in these toxic thoughts for the vast majority of a book was ugly and torturous. I also strongly question the mid 19th-century setting.

But as not every book read can be to any one reader’s tastes, I maintain huge gratitude to Netgalley and the publisher, RB Media, in exchange for my (likely far too) honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Haunting. The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt effortlessly toes the line between magical realism and gothic horror.

Harriet Hunt has spent her whole life locked inside Sunnyside house with her abusive father, terrifying housekeeper, and the ghosts of her mother’s love. Her only solace has been the garden that seems to bend to her will and a cousin who refuses to give up on her. When her father goes missing and suspicion starts to turn towards Harriet, she must venture outside her garden gates to find the answers she seeks. When a chance encounter a handsome, kind stranger leads to a whirlwind courtship and marriage, she thinks her luck has finally turned- but her husband has secrets and she’s about to find them all out. In the end, Harriet has to choose- will she be the fragile, mad girl everyone thinks she is or is she brave enough to choose herself and her garden?

Filled with twists and tangled vines, this is the story of female rage, empowerment, and courage. I loved that throughout the story you are trying to figure out if Harriet is being gaslit by the men around her or if you as the reader are being manipulated and Harriet really is insane. Atmospheric, lyrical, and emotional, The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt is a stunning ode to the classic gothic novel.

Was this review helpful?

This was a hidden gem of a book for those who like a little magic realism and want a very character focused plot. It is definitely more of a slow burn of a story but it's hard to be bothered by that when the writing is so smooth and just thorough enough to be immersive without going overboard.

Was this review helpful?

4.5⭐️s rounded up.
Story- 4⭐️s
Narration-5⭐️s

Thanks to NetGalley and RBmedia | Recorded Books for the advanced audiobook!
Narrator- Anna Burnett
I listened to this audiobook in tandem with an eARC.

The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt is a gothic-adjacent mystery with magical realism centering around Harriet Hunt herself.
Burnett was brilliant in bringing Harriet's voice to life. Having a physical book or ebook wasn't necessary to enjoy and keep up with this audio.
The sadness, helplessness, and anxiety was felt in full.
Abandonment, isolation, verbal and physical abuse are only a few of the horrors Harriet experiences at the hands of men that should love and care for her. The garden is her only constant friend yet also a huge source of anxiety. It was cathartic to follow Harriet's journey in opening herself up to trusting others and herself, all while avoiding an asylum and the limitations that society forces on women.

This would've been a complete 5 star read for me had we got to spend more time with Harriet's garden. Regardless, I'm still going to need a physical copy.

Was this review helpful?

Harriet Hunt has always been known as an odd child- a spectacle of everyone around her. After a tragic accident as a small child she losses her mother and is left to be with her neglectful father. With no love she is forced to be alone with her magical garden and as she grows she accepts the loneliness. It isn't until her father suddenly disappears she is finally alone to be herself. Through a marriage with malicious intent she is forced once again in neglect by her now husband. if only she could be brave and finally leave him she and her garden to be wild and free. i absolutely loved the magical realism in this book and enjoyed getting to know and love harriet hunt.

Was this review helpful?

This is a historical sci-fi fantasy that I really really enjoyed. This book had hints of many books that I have read, but the one that stood out to me the most was Jane Eyre. I don't really know why, Maybe it was just a feeling of a book or the feeling of Harriet, Her loneliness or her seclusion. But poor Harriet had rotten luck and a rotten father. I really felt sorry for her.

Many thanks to Net Galley and RB Media for an audio ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Audiobooks can be a hit or a miss sometimes for me. The minute this one started, I was hooked. I absolutely love the narrators voice. I feel so bad for Harriet, her father is an abusive man. It’s definitely a bit of a dark story. I definitely think there should be some trigger warnings listed at the beginning. Harriet went through trauma which affects all parts of her life. I just wanted the best for her. I enjoyed the ending of the book. If it wasn’t for the narrator, I’m not sure I would have gotten through the book. She did a wonderful job. I personally could listen to her voice all day! Thank you NetGalley, Chelsea and RBmedia for the advanced audio copy!

Was this review helpful?

It's 19th Century England, and Harriet's Father has disappeared. Her Mother passed away when she was young and she's doing her best to keep living in the family home on her own, selling anything of value and enjoying her new found freedom, especially in the garden that she has a very special connection with. However, a young woman can only get by for so long on her own before people begin asking questions, the debt collectors close in, and the funds run out.

I adored Harriet and I loved the connection she had with the flowers and plants in the garden. I do wish we'd seen even more of that through the book, but I loved exploring her connection to the flora around her. There was a mystery that ran through the story, as Harriet tries to find her Father, and there's also an undercurrent of tension and unease that builds steadily as it progresses. I was almost instantly hooked by this book, and by Harriet's character, and I really struggled to put it down.

I will flag however, that although it's described as a cosy fantasy, I'm not sure that really fit 'the vibe' for me. There are some heavy topics, and it's worth checking the trigger warnings before reading, especially if you find domestic abuse a difficult topic.

I listened to the audiobook (narrated by Anna Burnett) which was fantastic and wonderfully told.

Was this review helpful?

This book has some wonderful themes of a character finding her own voice and power in the middle of what feels like a hopeless situation. The slightly spooky, Victorian era vibes would make it a perfect October read. That said, I would check the content warnings below for certain readers, as the main character Harriet goes through some brutal experiences (some of which felt gratuitous to me) to advance the plot. The middle third of the book felt like it plodded along a bit as we waited for Harriet to make the connections and find her strength, but it resolved well. I loved seeing her realize the resources she had at her fingertips all long, as well as the friendships she had-both known and those that revealed themselves.

The audiobook narrator was absolutely fantastic though, and made it a perfect listening experience!

CW:

Parental abuse, SA, attempted SA, murder, institutionalization

Thank you RB Media for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Let me start by saying this is the first fantasy book I’ve read in a few years. It was the perfect thing to get me back into reading this genre!

First, I loved the narrator! The thing that truly brings an audiobook together is the narrator and Anna Burnett did a wonderful job!

It was so beautifully written, and Anna captured the essence of Harriet so well that through her voice I could feel the sadness of Eunice’s departure affecting her. There were tears shed during this chapter on my part, I was completely and utterly moved.

I thought the novel was beautifully descriptive and captured the garden so well in both its kind and wicked ways. I really enjoyed the murder wink game chapter and the added fun, suspense it brought to the novel!

Overall, this was an amazing novel. I found a powerful statement in it on changing yourself to please other people. As well as the power women possess once scorned.

“Being a woman means being constantly vigilante”.

Thank you to NetGalley, and RBmedia. Chelsea Iversen, you have found a fan in me.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

I wanted so much more from this story. It actually took me longer than usual to read it because the other books I was reading kept pulling my attention away.

The first half of the book felt repetitive and I believe could have been condensed to allow the story to focus more on Harriet and her garden . The last 50-75% pulled me in and I enjoyed it much more.

I wanted the story to have more about Harriet’s garden. Specifically, how its behavior mimicked Harriet’s emotions.

The narration was amazing.

Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Audiobook/Book Review 📖🎧🪴

Thank you so much partner @bookmarked @recordedbooks for the gifted copy and audiobook.

The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt
by Chelsea Iversen
Narrated by Anna Burnett

About the book 👇🏽

A lush, enchanting story of a woman who must use the magic of the fantastical plants that adorn her crumbling estate in Victorian London to thwart the dark plots of the men around her...

Harriet Hunt is completely alone. Her father disappeared months ago, leaving her to wander the halls of Sunnyside house, dwelling on a past she'd rather keep buried. She doesn't often venture beyond her front gate, instead relishing the feel of dirt under her fingernails and of soft moss beneath her feet. Consequently, she's been deemed a little too peculiar for popular Victorian society. This solitary life suits her fine, though – because, in her garden, magic awaits.

Harriet's garden is special. It's a wild place full of twisting ivy, vibrant plums, and a quiet power that buzzes like bees. Caring for this place, and keeping it from running rampant through the streets of her London suburb, is Harriet's purpose.

🪴 My thoughts:

Not what I was expecting but surprises can be good! It was a little darker than I was ready for but the author is a beautiful writer. With the writing and fantastic narration by Anna Burnett, it set this story up for an overall enjoyable read. I ended up mostly listening to the audiobook over reading the physical book because I just loved the narrator. I also really enjoyed the idea of a magical garden and I thought that this story was done well. I highly suggest checking the content warnings if there’s subject matter you’re sensitive to, otherwise this is a pretty atmospheric read! The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt is out NOW!

Happy reading 📖🎧🪴

Was this review helpful?

This is a gothic, low fantasy mystery with magical realism.

Harriet's father has gone missing and the whole town thinks that she has something to do with it. The people in town have always seen her as a very odd woman, especially since Harriet is always spending time in her magical garden that responds to her emotions.

When a new neighbor moves in next door, she thinks that she has finally found someone who can accept her for who she is. However, this new man in her life begins to control Harriet just as her father once did. With help from her new friends and her garden, she begins to gain independence and learns to fight for herself while facing the many challenges of being a woman in a male dominated world.

I really enjoyed this book! The writing style reminds me of A. G. Slatter's gothic fantasies which are some of my favorite books. The magical garden in this
book also reminds me of the one in In the Shadow Garden by Liz Parker which is also a good one :)

I thoroughly enjoyed the writing style and every character had their own distinct personality. I really liked the narration as well, it was very smooth and easy to listen to. Anna Burnett did a great job. I definitely want to read more books by this author in the future!!

**Make sure to check TW before reading.

Thank you to NetGalley, RBMedia, and Chelsea Iversen for this book in exchange for my honest opinion!!

Was this review helpful?

The Peculiar Garden of Harriet Hunt follows the titular character, Harriet, whose father has gone missing leaving her alone. She rarely leaves her house and instead spends time in her garden, a place that she has a special relationship with. Harriet meets a seemingly charming man and decides to get married but people aren’t all that they seem and she finds herself in a dangerous situation. How will she get out?

I really enjoyed this book. I listened to the audio and Anna Burnett’s narration kept me invested in the story the whole time despite it having some slower moments. I loved Harriet’s connection to her garden. It added a layer of magic that I always enjoy. I love how this book delved deep into heavier subject material. I was expecting this to be much more cozy but it took some dark turns.

This book was pretty average for most of the book. I was enjoying it but I wasn’t loving it. But the way it ended felt so perfect, it really raised my enjoyment of the book! This is a book that has a lot of feminine rage but on a sort of quiet way that I don’t see often and I think it really worked for this story.

I would recommend this to people who enjoyed Weyward or The Magician’s Daughter from last year.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book from beginning to end and recommend reading it for yourself! A beautiful and powerful story filled with magic. This book is a powerful example of feminine rage against being used, ignored, or neglected by men and society. It's about what it means to be different than expected societal constraints and how to find our strength here.

Was this review helpful?

This was a book I really wanted to love. I don't often read summaries before I dive into a story, but I glimpsed the first few lines about "a lush, enchanting story of a woman who must use magic..." and I knew it sounded right up my alley for reading.

I give this book 3.75* but will round up to 4 since I can't give partial stars and don't want to round down to 3.

This book had so much potential with the allure of magic and a woman finding her way among men who are plotting against her. The issues I ran into were the magic was scarcely referenced and though it seems Harriet has had this "garden ability" nearly her entire life, she seems completely in the dark about what she can do and the magic she holds.. her naivety and helplessness starts to grate on my nerves as she seems to be able to do almost nothing for herself. She is able to go out and pawn or sell items from around the house to keep them afloat month to month, but after her father disappears, she acts as though she is completely helpless and ends up marrying the first man who even shows vague interest in her because she is scared to reveal anything about being alone.

She does have a cousin and a female maid do enter the picture which seem like stronger females for her to take the lead from, but she still floats through life, almost waiting for someone else to come along and save her from herself. We don't get a lot of resolution until the very end and I do feel as though some of it was rushed and not fully explained. We spend the whole book wallowing in self-pity with her but do not get time to share in the joy when things turn out for the best.

The plotting and planning as well as her mother's hidden secrets are fun storylines but I do wish Harriet had been a stronger more independent character.

Was this review helpful?