Skip to main content

Member Reviews

OH MY GOSH THIS BOOK WAS AMAZING!! I love Ali Brady, she literally never lets me down, but I think this is actually my favorite book from her! The bookish speak, the storyline, the romance, the witty banter, all of it added up to be such an amazing experience!

Was this review helpful?

I love this writing duo’s style and was so excited to get an arc of this. This one is a love letter to all book lovers and bookstore workers everywhere and gives major You’ve Got Mail vibes. It’s a grumpy/sunshine where the male is the sunshine, which I loved! It got a bit long and took me a while to really be invested, but I still really liked it.

(Will post a more in depth review and post closer to pubday)

Was this review helpful?

Josie and Ryan are such lovable relatable characters. I found myself in both of them! Ryan and his love of romance novels, and Josie and her quiet nature. I love a good enemies to Lovers trope, and the banter of back and forth was so good and kept me wanting more! The wait for these two to figure out they were talking all along online, was almost unbearable! Ali Brady has a way with writing that has you wanting more. I can't wait for this one to hit the shelves! its going to be flying off of them, I just know it!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. Social media had the characters meeting before he realizes they work under unusual circumstances with the another. I really enjoyed it because I'm as big fan of the movie You've Got Mail. Try it t. I know you'll like it!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much for the advanced reader copy!

What started as a charming, witty, and nostalgic read resembling You've Got Mail quickly faded into mediocrity. This is one I likely hyped up too much in my head only for it to fall short. There's also a lot of forced representation that breaks the immersion of the story and felt rammed down my throat - not sure why this was approached in such a way. I'm so sad this wasn't for me, and I had to DNF. Hopefully it finds its fans upon its June release!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the eARC!

Books are so personal and I am sure others will love this book, but I was not one of those people.
The chemistry between the main characters was so off. They had better chemistry as enemies vs lovers.
The story was cute. Expected, but cute.
Where it went wrong, FOR ME. - I like my men masculine and Brian, I mean Ryan ;) was way too feminine for me and Josie was too masculine. Don’t get me wrong, I realize we rule the world, but just sayin’! I would also say this book goes wonky where everyone has to have representation to the point that it feels forced.

Was this review helpful?

This is a rivals to lovers, secret pen mates, and work place romance. If you like You’ve got Mail then you need to check this book out. We have Ryan who is the manager at a romance only bookstore. He’s worked his way up to that position and has been with the store for over a decade. Then we have Josie who is the manger at a generic book store. When both of their stores and the cafe in the middle were bought out by the building owner he decided he wanted to make some changes. Big changes. All 3 stores would now become one and since there is 2 book stores there only needs to be one manager. In comes a big competition between the two so one of them won’t be out of a job. At first there is sabotage and insults between them but they realize they need to combine their knowledge to make the store more profitable. Definitely read this is you like banter, competition, and love.

Was this review helpful?

Josie and Ryan could not be more different, from their childhoods to their organizational skills, and their reading preferences, they seemingly have nothing in common. When their common landlord pits their bookstores against each other, can they come together to solve their problems or are they destined to be enemies forever. While Josie won't allow herself to open up to any possibilities, Ryan can't help but see what the future could hold, only if Josie will let him in.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars rounded up. I really enjoyed Josie and Ryan's journey from enemies to lovers. Ryan was my favorite character, but I could totally relate to Josie's back story. Josie made a lot of sacrifices in her life in order to get where she was and there were also missed opportunities due to her family situation. I liked the online aspect thrown in there as well, creating conflict and an interesting spin. I read this book so quickly. It drew me in and kept me reading. I have to find some more Ali Brady books to read now! Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars. This loose take on You’ve Got Mail is a love letter to bookstores and readers. Only here the two enemies to lovers are on more equal footing, as rival bookstore managers competing for a new job. What they don’t know is that they’re also friends online; friends who may be falling for each other.

It’s clear that the authors read widely and love books. Some of the best scenes are when Ryan and Josie discuss books or just read quietly together.

Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the ARC to review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

"But if I've learned anything from the books I love to read, it's that life is full of misunderstandings, raw emotions, and hard truths - and so are relationships."

What a beautiful and stunning read. This story covers the journey of two bookstore owners who happen to hate each other. But what happens when they are told to compete with one another for store manager, for a new vision, the owner of their respective stores has?!

We watch enemies become friends become lovers.
And this story. Oh my goodness - it is like eating the gooey and warm centre of a cinnamon bun - comforting, fun, pure love and joy.

I loved reading Ryan and Josie's story - and I will return to it again and again because love is everything. And so are books!

Was this review helpful?

Such a cute story, but a little inside baseball. A few too many references you needed to be chronically online to get (which I am).

Was this review helpful?

This was A LOT of fun. Very meta for booksellers or those who work in bookselling. I love me a cinnamon roll, romance bookseller hero. Enjoyed enjoyed enjoyed.

Maybe not for you if you get peeved by coincidences that seem a little too close in novels. There were a few moments like that scattered throughout. Didn’t bother me

Was this review helpful?

Ali Brady’s ‘Battle of the Bookstores’ is a charming enemies-to-lovers story between two bookstore managers. It was a delightful surprise to me since I hadn’t read anything by this author before. The book is filled with witty banter and a delightful mix of humor and romance. It was a quick read, and I’m already looking forward to reading more of Ali Brady’s books.

Was this review helpful?

TROPES
Enemies to lovers (obviously!)
Opposites attract
Online epistolary (you’ve got mail vibes!)
Only One Bed
Forced Proximity
He Falls First (and hard)
Dual POV male/female
Slow burn
Open-door
Casually diverse cast of side characters including disability and LGBTQ+ rep
Bookstore setting (with bookstore cats!)
Very Tall male main character (6’8”!!)
Jewish rep
Online banter
Boston setting
Dyxlexia rep
Lots of love for the romance genre, romance bookstores, indie bookstores, and all bookish people in general

Was this review helpful?

If you were a fan of You’ve Got Mail, then Battle of the Bookstores is just what you need to start your summer (pub date June 3)! The dynamic writing duo, Ali Brady, have done it again!

Meet Josie and Ryan - two dueling bookstore owners with a cute coffee store in the middle of them. In an interesting twist - it is Ryan who is the owner of the Romance bookstore, and Josie the owner of the Literary Fiction store. Ryan is a bit chaotic, Josie is total Type A. Enter the new owner of their stores who pits Josie against Ryan in a winner take all manager position. Only one will stand at the end.

What Josie and Ryan don’t know is that they have been talking to each other anonymously on an online book store owner forum and becoming quite “close”. Their banter is off the charts (I read this on the airplane and was literally laughing out loud), The Enemies to Lovers trope works brilliantly - their connection online and in real life is perfect.

Add in the Jewish representation, disability, and dyslexia representation and you have another incredibly perfect read by Ali Brady!

Thank you to Berkley and the authors for this ARC - all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Get your romance novel trope BINGO card ready! You will hit a handful of them and each one will make you chuckle, smile, and swoon. They're even better because our MMC Ryan, romance bookstore manager, is completely aware they are happening and is able to conquer them.

Then you have his perfect counterpart, Josie, who brings order to his chaotic life, even if she's unaware that she's doing it.

Josie and Ryan will be your new favorite bookish couple! This book was an absolute joy to read. It felt like a love letter to romance readers with insightful reflection on the truths behind the genre. This is a must-read and must-gift to yourself and all you romance book besties.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful love letter to books and indie bookstores. I thoroughly enjoyed the enemies to lovers story with other romance tropes called out a long the way. The writing was enjoyable and I read more title from Ali Brady.

Was this review helpful?

Reminiscent of The Shop Around the Corner and You’ve Got Mail, this is a fast, flirty read. The adversaries become friends who eventually become lovers is a familiar trope but the main characters have depth, experience growth and are very relatable. Their individual passion for each other is equal to their passion for bookselling. The book is a love letter to indie bookstores and those who inhabit them, employees and customers.

Was this review helpful?

I had a little trouble getting into this at first, despite being a bookseller myself. However, once I was in I was hooked. I found a few moments genuinely funny and I did not feel that the ending was too drawn out. I will for sure recommend this to romance readers!

Was this review helpful?