Skip to main content

Member Reviews

3.5 stars rounded up and my thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for the eARC.

I got so very close to DNFing around 20%, mainly because Mulan and Mushu were a little insufferable as characters. The Not-Like-Other-Girlsification of Mulan was a little rough to try to get past. Around the 50% mark, the characters finally solidified and got a little better.

Hua Mulan is on the partner track at her father's hedge fund company(?), but when her father has a heart attack the morning before meeting with a potential acquisition, she decides to use her father's name to gain the respect of this very masculine whiskey brand. Something like that? Honestly, the plot vaguely follows the Disney movie, but with some obvious changes here and there. Mushu plays the sassy best friend still, obviously. Shang is (also obviously) incredibly gorgeous and shuns traditional gender roles, to the derision of his male uncles and cousins.

I really love that Mulan and Shang bonded over their shared experience of being children of Chinese immigrants and how the expectations, family pressure, and heteronormative gender role stress hit both of them. I liked that we got to see them connect on something deeper than "hey, you're really hot."

Was this review helpful?

Mulan is great at her job in finance working for her father. She doesn’t agree with his desire to acquire a whiskey company, but decides to be open minded in the meeting. Unfortunately, her father falls ill and winds up the hospital. While Mulan is used to dealing with sexist finance bros, the sexism in the family whisky business is beyond. Since she will be taking the meeting, Mulan decides she must pretend to be her father and let the family think they have been emailing with her the entire time.

I love the Meant To Be collection, and love that some of my favorite authors are taking part! I mean Jesse Sutanto re-writing Mulan? What could be better? The sexism in this family was so insanely infuriating I wanted to jump through the page and fight them myself! Mulan did such a wonderful job of fighting back and sticking up for herself though, I just loved her. For some reason in this one that fact that her name was Mulan really stuck out and threw me while reading, and I don’t really know why. The other books all have main characters with similar or exact same names, but this one the name took me out of the story a bit. Besides that small detail, I enjoyed this one so much!

Thank you to @hyperionavebooks for my gifted copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

It makes me so sad to say, but I did not like this. I have loved every other book in this series, and I was really looking forward to this one. But this just really missed the mark for me. Mulan was not a strong/bad ass women like in the movie. She felt very weak. This book reads like a YA book. This author is very much or miss for me (more of a miss since I have only really liked one of her books). I also found the writing style of this book very repetitive. I am a huge Disney girl also and this really didn't give me the classic Disney vibes I was looking for. This might be my biggest letdown of the year. I was fully expecting to love this.

Thank you so much, Hyperion Avenue for the ARC of this book. This comes out on June 3.

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes for this one as I have loved the other books in this series of retellings but unfortunately it just didn’t hit the mark for me. I had a hard time connecting with the characters and the retelling aspect just didn’t seem very focal.

Was this review helpful?

I want to start by saying that although I DNF'd this, I did enjoy the Chinese representation throughout the book. It does a good job at displaying the culture, at least to an outsider (as I am), and I enjoyed reading about it. Now, to my issues with it. I stopped reading sometime through the halfway point, mostly because of the self-insisting feminist commentary and not-so-great retelling of Mulan. The dialogue, and sometimes internal monologue, felt very Gen-Z occasionally and dulled what were otherwise good points about the workplace patriarchy. Additionally, the audience is supposed to believe that Mulan, the main character, is much smarter than most of the egotistical men in finance, yet the book does more telling than showing. The showing it does do is marred by distractingly poor explanations of private equity firms and what they do. There was definitely potential, I just think I wasn't the target audience for this and expected a retelling more true to the original story.

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️.5 - This retelling was entertaining and it made me laugh quite a few times. For that reason, I’m giving the book 2.5 stars. But almost everything else was a miss for me. I had to try and suspend much disbelief and common sense to push through and enjoy this story, so it was a very touch and go reading experience.

In this retelling, we have Mulan as the VP of her father’s private equity firm. After her father suffered a heart attack and had to be hospitalized, Mulan stepped in to take his place in the acquisition negotiation of a family-owned whiskey company named Wutai Gold. Mulan used her father’s name and claimed she’s been the one communicating with the board members of Wutai Gold, since apparently they’re all very traditional (aka sexist) and wouldn’t want to deal with a woman. To keep up with her lies, Mulan even ended up getting roped into a trip out to the Li’s ranch for a few days to prove she was manly enough to run the company.

For a VP of a private equity firm to undergo negotiations with another entity under false pretenses the way Mulan did, was extremely absurd and obviously very unethical. I feel like in real life, there would be legal repercussions with that type of deceit. Mulan was supposed to be very ambitious and smart, having graduated summa cum laude from Princeton, but she just came off as really dumb with the stupid lies she told and the way she let it all snowballed out of her control.

It’s wrong to build any type of relationships upon a foundation of deceit, so I just couldn’t vibe with this Mulan retelling. in the original story it was honorable and brave for Mulan to take her dad’s place in the war to save his life, in this modern day retelling it just felt slimy and so unnecessary for Mulan to lie about her identity. I wasn’t sold on it.

Additional cons:
- Insta love. Mulan was simping after Shang from the moment she laid eyes on him.
- The frequency of which the term ‘finance bros’ was used.
- Shang was a hottie that loved to cook and clean, but he was too perfect to the point of being bland.
- We’re constantly hit over the head about the misogyny of the finance world.

Pros:
- Mushu! She was a riot, and honestly would’ve been a more interesting FMC.
- The Li’s complex family dynamic.
- The delicious food! The descriptions got me craving every dishes!

Even though this story was a miss, as I loved Sutanto’s “Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers”, I am still keen to check out future works by this author.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A modern-day retelling of Mulan, where Mulan pretends to be her father in order to secure a deal for her father’s finance company. The job? Acquiring a family-owned whisky company. A company, however, that is led by a traditional Chinese family who do NOT believe a woman’s role is in business. Does Mulan have what it takes to bring honor to her father and acquire this business by being “manly” enough to impress Shang and his family?

This was just the cutest story. I loved the romance between Mulan and Shang (it was definitely instant attraction), and the Mushu character was perfection. As Mulan’s cousin, she was witty and insightful, and a great pairing to Mulan’s reserved and dutiful actions. While reading, I imagined Mushu as Awkwafina. 😂

The overall message of the story really resonated with me - we are all wearing various masks as we navigate our day to day interactions, but who is the real me? How can I be true to myself? I enjoyed Mulan’s journey to find her true self and be confident with who she is. This one is definitely my favorite in the Meant to Be series.

Thank you to Hyperion Avenue and NetGalley for early access to this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was genuinely excited to dive into Worth Fighting For. The concept of reimagining Mulan in a contemporary setting, navigating the corporate world, and tackling gender expectations had so much potential. However, as I progressed through the book, I found myself struggling to connect with the story and its characters.

The premise—Mulan stepping into her father's role in a high-stakes business deal—felt forced and lacked the emotional depth I was hoping for. The romance between Mulan and Shang developed rapidly, leaning heavily on insta-love, which made it challenging to invest in their relationship. Additionally, the humor often felt out of place, and the narrative relied on clichéd tropes that didn't resonate with me.

While I appreciate Sutanto's attempt to tackle themes of identity and empowerment, the execution fell short. The story lacked the nuance and authenticity that could have made this retelling impactful.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to preview this book.
I liked how Mushu was portrayed as a cousin for Mulan.. This was a realistic retelling of the traditional Mulan story with a lot more auntie involvement.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the writing and the story—it was my favorite in the series. I loved how it kept with the whole Mulan theme and stayed true to yourself. 4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge Disney fan, so this series is definitely for me. This book was a retelling of sorts of Mulan. While I thoroughly enjoyed the book, I thought the previous one was a little better and enjoyed it more.
If you like romance and Disney this book and series is for you.
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The next installment of the Meant to Be series. This time it’s Mulan! This is romance, but it’s Disney romance y’all so don’t be expecting anything more risqué than kissing. You also really see the humor Sutanto brings to her ‘Dial A for Aunties’ books!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute installment to the Meant to Be series. For those unaware, this series includes contemporary reimaginings of everyone’s favorite Disney stories.

I was especially excited for this one because Mulan was always my favorite Disney movie growing up. I loved the “girl power” even at a young age. This book doubles down on the girl power, btw.

Jesse Sutano definitely delivers on this one. This book was filled with her signature humor. I found myself laughing often at Mulan’s inner dialogue. And instead of heading off to war, Mulan is fighting every day in the world of finance bros and having to prove herself and her competence to the Li family as they try to sell their business. I really loved the way Sutano reimagined this story.

Also, this retelling does have a Mushu! And the character is excellent.

I highly recommend this one if you’re looking for a quick, fun read. It releases on June 3, 2025. A giant thank you NetGalley and Hyperion Books for a free eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick and fun read! I'd read By the Book from the series before and when I found out there was a Mulan retelling, I had to read it!

I think Jesse Q. Sutanto did a great job recontextualizing the story of Mulan. Her being a woman in a male dominated industry and the way in which she has to pretend to be "the man" to protect her father was really smart.

That being said, I couldn't really connect with Sutanto's writing style in this book. The book was a little heavy-handed on the references and given its short length, the pacing didn't help much with character development or creating a convincing romance between the two main characters.

Thank you to Netgalley and Hyperion Avenue for the opportunity to read this book in advance of its publishing date!

Was this review helpful?

The animated Mulan is one of my all-time favorite Disney movies, so I was so excited to get this ARC. And let tell you - this did Mulan justice!! I loved the parallels between this and the classic Mulan. Mulan pretending to be her dad to get things done? Classic. The characters were great, the storytelling was wonderful, the authors writing was perfect. I highly recommend!

Thank you to the publisher for this arc in exchange for an honest review :)

Was this review helpful?

I really, really wanted to love this one, but unfortunately it was a little bit of a swing and a miss for me. I think I was trying to draw too many parallels between Sutanto's story and the OG Disney Mulan, and kept getting distracted by all of the ways that the characters were different. Hello? Mushu is supposed to be a dragon.

The "finance bro" and "hard-ass feminist" stereotypes also came on a little strong for me. Mulan's mom is so traditional she still wears a dragonfly brooch but tells Mulan that "Fate and Destiny are [her] bitches?" My pó po would never.

All in all, I think that this could be (and will be) a hilarious and engaging story for many readers out there- but it just wasn't for me!

**Thank you very much to NetGalley & Hyperion Avenue books for the eARC! All opinions are my own.**

Was this review helpful?

I've read the Cinderella version in this series and really enjoyed it, so I was SO excited to get approved for the ARC of this version! As much as I tried, I could NOT get myself to enjoy it. I dont know if its just too different than the classic Mulan or I just couldnt get past the fact that Mushu was a female, this book was not my favorite and it broke my heart!

Was this review helpful?

While I usually don't love "mistaken identity" tropes, this reimagining of Mulan is so enjoyable! In Sutanto's hands, the story is equally funny and touching. And her cousin Mushu is the PERFECT sidekick! Taking on her dad's identity and fighting his upcoming battle stays true to the Mulan legend while spinning it into a tale of being comfortable with letting people see who you really are. This is a great addition to the "Meant to Be" series.

Was this review helpful?

“Worth Fighting For” is the best song and now the most fun “Mulan” retelling! I adore Jesse Q. Sutanto’s writing style and humor. The contemporary retelling was creative and unique, yet still in line with the original story. She even included many winks to original beloved “Mulan” scenes. In this story, Mulan is a “finance bro” working alongside her father. He’s trying to make an important deal go through when he has an accident. Thankfully, this potential acquisition has never met Zhou in person, so Mulan can pretend to be her father and try to save the deal. Mushu was also included as a character, and she was the best!!

For those who love:
🪷Mulan retelling
🪷Workplace romance
🪷Mushu!!!!
🪷Forced Proximity
🪷Only One Tent
🪷Ranch life
🪷Large Families

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

When I heard about this book in the Disney movie re-write series Meant to Be, I immediately knew I wanted to read it! I heard the author speak and she was very fun and dynamic. She absolutely brings that energy to the writing.

As a re-telling of Mulan, I thought this had just the right balance of movie homage and independent story. I've watched the movie but am not an ardent fan. This book sets Mulan in the cut-throat world of finance, a bro-dominated field complicated by misogyny all the time but even more-so when the company is working to acquire a whiskey company that only sees value in masculinity through a narrow lens. When Mulan's father, the head of the finance company, is unexpectedly out of commission, Mulan has to prove her worth to everyone in the family-owned Wutai Gold company in order to close the deal. She pretends she has been communicating with the family, not her father, and that she is the one with a long history of performing manly, outdoorsy tasks. Shenanigans ensue.

Mulan, aided by her cousin Mushu, do their best to win over the family at their ranch by performing all the tasks set before them. Mulan falls for CEO Shang and immediately has to reckon with her deception. It's enough to make her feel bad but not tell them the truth and ruin the budding relationship with a guy that's perfect for her.

This closed-door romance was fun, funny, and sweet. The dynamics between Mulan, Shang, and Mushu were definitely strongest. Some of the ways that Mulan interacts with her parents were strange and fell a little flat considering they were supposed to be a lynch-pin of the story. Overall it really hit the spot and I enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?