Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Everything i love about a mystery and thriller is here. It kept me reading and it kept me guessing. The ending was a little over the top but I really enjoyed the intriguing moments. Thanks to Netgalley for the opportunity to listen to this audiobook

Was this review helpful?

I loved this- it had me hooked from page 1 and I was excited to hear what would happen next. The twists were crazy! I will 100% be picking up more of her books and reading this while in this January snowstorm is such a mood.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun mystery/thriller set on a secluded mountain. While some parts were a tiny bit predictable, I did not guess some of the reveals and overall it was a fun, quick read with enough possible suspects to keep the reader guessing to the end.
Recommended for fans of locked room style stories, secluded winter vibes, rich people drama, and mysteries involving repressed memories.
Quick, fun popcorn read. (3.75 rounded up to 4)

Was this review helpful?

First of all, since this is an audio-ARC, the narration was phenomenal. It's honestly the only reason I was motivated to continue in the book. The narration of the story gets a 5/5.

Unfortunately I'm beginning to think Kate Alice Marshall just isn't for me. I thought the story was just a very predictable "rich family" story. I really wanted to go almost crazy to bring something unique and interesting to the book. It didn't do that. It was just a classic rich people protecting rich people thing. I did like that one of the characters actually made good decisions the entire time, which normally that specific character never does. So that was a nice little break from this genre, but it didn't help the rest of the story. I'm also not a huge fan of a story revolving around major coincidences and forgotten memories. The whole story was based on something so ridiculously impossible to happen so it was hard to suspend that disbelief. I also felt that the ending was MASSIVELY anticlimactic. We got no real closure for the characters and it was honestly just super depressing. Our main character went through so much and for what?

Was this review helpful?

This is fine but I didn't really like it. I guess I was somewhat curious enough to make it to the end? But simultaneously not that invested?

The novel feels like a pretty standard thriller that annoyingly has a protagonist with memory loss who can conveniently regain certain memories as the plot needs it, but never enough memories to know what's happening. I get why it's a useful trope in the Thriller genre, but it's just so tired and frustrating imo.

The reveals are fairly obvious, and there are a bunch of red herring secrets that end up just being irrelevant to the plot?

Audiobook Notes:
The narrator has a pleasant voice and cadence and does a good job interpreting the text. I think I probably wouldn't have finished it without the audiobook.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 ⭐️ A Killing Cold is the perfect book if you’re looking for a wintry thriller! This locked door/snowed in mystery had the perfect setting, which was both chilling and isolated, and very atmospheric.

The characters were rich, wealthy and very unlikeable. Our FMC, Theo, quickly realizes that she isn’t just meeting her fiancé’s family, but is trying to find out why their secluded estate is so familiar. Secrets are quickly revealed and there are twists that keep you guessing to the very end.

While I enjoyed the suspenseful build up for majority of the story, I felt that there were maybe a few too many twists that made it a little unrealistic. While I don’t normally mind unrealistic endings, in a way I almost felt that the ending was a bit predictable as well? Overall the setting was perfect, the unlikeable characters were great, and the build up was well paced.

The audio was absolutely fantastic and added to the chilling atmospheric vibe for this wintry story!

Thank you @netgalley and @macmillan.audio for the ALC ✨

Was this review helpful?

Kate Alice Marshall’s A Killing Cold is a masterclass in suspense and storytelling, delivering a narrative brimming with unexpected twists and unrelenting thrills. From the opening pages, the author captivates readers with a plot that feels both unpredictable and utterly engrossing. Each turn of events defies expectations, making it impossible to put the book down.

Marshall’s skill as a writer truly shines in the way she guides readers through the story. Just when you think you’ve figured out where the plot is headed, she flips the script, leaving you reeling in the best way possible. Her ability to balance tension with richly drawn characters and a gripping pace sets her apart as a standout voice in the genre.
• A Killing Cold* is more than just a thriller; it’s a showcase of storytelling prowess that keeps readers guessing until the very end. For those who enjoy tightly woven mysteries with an edge of surprise, this novel is a must-read. Marshall’s talent is undeniable, and this book will leave you eager to explore more of her work.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc and alc.

This was a fantastic thriller. I did not think it was predictable at all, and the ending left me speechless. Kate Alice Marshall is a fantastic thriller writer!! Furthermore, Karissa Vacker does a great job (as always!) with the narration. I definitely recommend this thriller and can't wait for KAM's next book!

Was this review helpful?

Theo is heading to the mountains to meet her fiance Connor's family, and something isn't right. She's receiving warnings to stay away and is starting to remember fragments of her childhood. Theo's fairy tale suddenly turns into a nightmare.

There wasn't anything groundbreaking here, but I enjoyed the read. The narration was good.

Thank you to #NetGalley and #MacmillanAudio for a free copy of #AKillingCold. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Theo fell in love with Connor in a whirlwind romance six months ago. Despite anonymous texts telling her to stay away from Connor, Theo knows it's her chance to win over his wealthy family when she visits Idlewood, the family's remote winter retreat. But at the family cabin, Theo finds a photo of herself as a child and begins to recall long-repressed memories that someone in Connor's family will do anything to keep buried.

Kate Alice Marshall draws you in with a story of a rich family where everyone has a secret to hide. The icy isolation of Idlewood provides a smothering atmosphere that amps up the tension as twists are slowly revealed. While the slow burn tension was captivating to read and the audio narration was spot-on, the conclusion didn't wrap up satisfactorily.

Was this review helpful?

I felt like this was a very basic thriller. The idea was interesting but there was nothing really special about it. It was bland for most of it, and then the end did pick up a bit.

Was this review helpful?

i had the audible version and it was perfect entertainment for my lunch breaks! I’d recommend this book to any thriller lover!

Was this review helpful?

Get the popcorn 🍿 popping and the hot chocolate ☕️ bombs dropping because this winter ❄️ thriller is combining chilling tropes for an explosive romp where the elements are dangerous, but the secrets are deadly.

Theo and Connor travel to his wealthy family’s secluded winter estate, Idlewild. Connor’s family’s reluctance to warm to Theo makes her feel discomfort, but there’s more. Idlewild produces an eerie sense of familiarity for her. She receives phone messages warning her away. When she enters an abandoned cabin fragments begin to emerge one more disturbing than the last. Too many things don’t add up.

Could Connor have an ulterior motive for bringing her here?

What does a past she can’t remember have to do with her future?

I was stranded in the midst of a snow ❄️ and ice 🧊 storm while listening to this which is rare for my neck of the woods and it added to the ambience.

I had to suspend belief in a few places, but honestly it didn’t detract from how much I liked this. The audio narrated by Karissa Vacker is an absolute dream.

A riveting listen 🎧 that I didn’t want to end!

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for providing the Advanced Listening Copy for review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a twisted and chilling thriller set on a mountain property in the winter. I liked the complex backstory of the main character, Theo, and her soon-to-be inlaws. The family drama and secrets are hidden so well, yet they eat away at some of the characters who are less prone to violence and pain. I enjoyed the gradual unravelling of events in the past and the present and the sense of danger and suspense that had me wondering which characters I could trust. The narration was also wonderful and entertaining—a thriller fan's delight.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very good book and kept me engaged for the whole thing. It kept me guessing throughout the whole book up until the very end. I would definitely recommend this book for someone that loves a quick thriller!

Was this review helpful?

As soon as I see the names Kate Alice Marshall and Karissa Vacker, I know I'm in for one great ride. And A Killing Cold was absolutely that!

This book follows Theo, who has her secrets and forgets her traumatic childhood, but she loves Connor Dalton and will do anything to win over his wealthy, skeptical family. So they head to his family's isolated winter retreat to do just that. Only Theo is getting threatening messages and has a strange familiarity with Idlewood. She starts to piece together her fragmented memories when she finds a photo of herself at Idlewood as a child. Someone is hiding something. And Theo is going to find out who, even if it costs her everything.

This book was full of secrets, lies, twists and turns in all it's isolated, locked door glory. I was completed swept up in the story and couldn't put it down. I ping ponged between who had what secret and which person was guilty. I love that it's set in winter and detested each member of the Dalton family in all the best ways!

This was a thrilling ride with a tiny bit of romance thrown in for good measure. You won't be disappointed with this one.

4.5 stars and a high recommendation from me!

Was this review helpful?

While I wanted to enjoy this one, I felt like there were a lot of missed opportunities to make it great and a lot of it was too far of a stretch in coincidences for me. I guessed the ended early on and did not find it thrilling. I did enjoy the writing style though and would love to read another one by this author.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 4.5

A Killing Cold by Kate Alice Marshall had me on my toes in this new thriller! I have enjoyed Marshall's previous works and was very excited to receive an ALC for A Killing Cold.

The juicy family drama had me swept in and so invested. When Theodora (Theo for short) Scott travels up to Idlewood with her new fiancé, Connor Dalton for a family trip, memories come rushing in about her past as his family tries to figure her out. This book was so twisty and addicting that I could not put it down. The small bits of information about Theo's past was so interesting and I found it all tied in so nicely. Marshall's writing is so easy to follow along with and pulls you in right away.

Thank you to Macmillan Audio & NetGalley for the opportunity to read A Killing Cold early for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this thriller. There were a lot of twists and turned as the story progressed. I also enjoyed the atmosphere Marshall created along with the pacing. Themes of family, loyalty, and trust were explored. Marshall stands on her own long side Alice Feeney, Lucy Foley, and Ruth Ware.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars, rounded up because Karissa Vacker's narration and Duchess are everything.

I've been a fan of Kate Alice Marshall for awhile now and have enjoyed her adult, YA and even middle grade books (seriously, I love Extra Normal and the oldest sibling representation). And A Killing Cold is up there. It was 12:30 in the morning last night and I had two hours of the audiobook left and had to argue with myself about going to sleep. And the first thing I did when my dog woke me up at 6:30 am was finish the audiobook.

So I feel like Marshall does elevated thrillers? Not pretentious or inaccessible or anything like that. But this is just as much about a dysfunctional family as it is about the mystery of Theo's past. There are plenty of flawed characters making terrible decisions that still somehow remain sympathetic to a degree. I was almost moved to tears at one point. Also, Marshall really does a nice turn of phrase. There were several times throughout the story where I was like, ohhh, that was said so prettily.

And Karissa Vacker! One of my favorite narrators. And I love that she continues to collaborate with Marshall on her stories and hope she does so for the foreseeable future.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and the publisher for this. Made my day.

Was this review helpful?