Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The FMC was refreshing and the story was really great once you got into it. I can’t give it above four stars because the start of the book was so slow that I DNF’d it for a month before picking it back up.

Was this review helpful?

What a fantastic book by Kingfisher! This book had a desert/garden mood which I thought was a unique setting for fantasy. I adored the world-building. The main character is clever and I love her knowledge of poisons - she is very capable. Creepy but oddly nostalgic take on Snow White. I am glad I finally read one of Kingfisher's books - the author is as talented as I had imagined. She had me at Grayling, the talking cat!

Was this review helpful?

A retelling of Snow White from the point of view of Anja, the healer. Actually she isn't an actual healer, her specialty is poisons. Snow White's father is desperate to discover why the princess is sick. Everything points to poison, but how is it being consumed? I loved the character of Anja, an older heroine (yay!) who loves her job yet realizes that not everyone believes poisons are that fascinating. The dialogue is smart and funny, especially between Anja and her love interest. T. Kingfisher never disappoints! Thank you NetGalley for letting me read this wonderful adventure. I will never look at a mirror the same way again!

Was this review helpful?

T. Kingfisher never disappoints! This was a bit of a slow start, but once the story really got going I was completely hooked. I really enjoy T. Kingfisher's blend of down-to-earth protagonists, understated humor, and genuine creepiness, and Hemlock & Silver has all three in spades, combined with a lot of information about poisons. I also enjoyed the desert setting, as it's rather different from most fantasy titles.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc! Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was another solid and enjoyable work by T. Kingfisher! My 5th book of hers in 2025 alone...I have a problem. This was dark and a fun twist on Snow White. Kingfisher lost me a bit with the mirror-gelds because they sound absolutely horrifying and the descriptions were very visceral, but I was somewhat-ish charmed by them in the end.

I will always, always adore her heroines who just look like normal people and are in their 30s. Refreshing and much needed.

Was this review helpful?

T KINGFISHER YOU DID IT AGAIN. I adored this book and everything about it. I can't wait to see this become a fall obsession for the booktok community.

Was this review helpful?

Going into T. Kingfisher's "Hemlock & Silver," I should be upfront: while I deeply admire her unique writing style, I often find myself drawn more towards original concepts, perhaps leaning towards literary fiction or truly unique genre takes, rather than fairytale retellings, which I sometimes struggle to fully immerse myself in. So, I approached this 'Snow White' reimagining knowing it might be a challenge for my personal preferences.

However, T. Kingfisher truly has a way of making any premise distinctly her own, and I found myself quickly captivated by the wonderfully creepy atmosphere she builds here. Anja, the practical healer protagonist, felt instantly familiar and engaging in the best Kingfisher way, grounding the story beautifully. The blend of unsettling folklore, genuine horror elements, and unexpected warmth is handled masterfully, creating that signature tone I enjoy so much in her work.

Now, regarding the 'Snow White' framework – while I could certainly recognize the clever ways Kingfisher twisted and built upon it, I have to admit that awareness of the source material did occasionally surface for me during reading. Yet, the strength of her original additions – the inventive mirror world, the engaging mystery surrounding the poisoning, the compelling character dynamics – often commanded my attention and significantly enriched the experience beyond what I might expect from a typical retelling. Her unique voice really took center stage.

Ultimately, "Hemlock & Silver" stands as a testament to how a truly skilled author can elevate any concept. While fairytale retellings aren't my usual go-to, the sheer quality of the writing, the fantastic atmosphere, the strong characters, and the unique horror elements made this a genuinely enjoyable and impressive read for me. It absolutely reaffirmed why I appreciate T. Kingfisher's work so much.

Was this review helpful?

I stayed up late reading this; it was so good. Anya is a healer. Well, she is will try to heal you if you are poisoned. She has spent her life obsessed with finding anti-dotes for various poisons. She hasn’t succeeded – yet. The King has heard of her and asks her to save his dying daughter snow. Once she meets Snow, a wild adventure/investigation begins with apples, a snarky cat, an evil queen and magic mirrors. This twist on Snow White is compelling. Her distractions and her enthusiasms make her a wonderfully relatable character.

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for this DRC.
#HemlockandSilver #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

If T. Kingfisher’s name is on it, I’m reading it—and *Hemlock and Silver* did not disappoint. This dark, clever *Snow White* retelling is everything I love about her work: eerie, witty, heartfelt, and deeply human. The atmosphere is haunting, the magic is strange and wild, and the heroine is unforgettable.

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Books for the ARC—an instant favorite!

Was this review helpful?

This was just ok for me. I really love Nettle & Bone and Thornhedge, but I found this one to be less well-done. The first half was excellent with a lot of cool information about poisons and the mirror stuff was spooky at first. But after the halfway point I found myself getting pretty bored. I do think fans of T. Kingfisher’s horror will like this one more than I did, but it was just ok for me.

Was this review helpful?

Slow to start, as it only picked up about halfway through. But even then it never fully pulled me in and the pacing felt off — basically the entire first half was build-up, so I wish we got less of that and more of the main part of the story. Also the romance didn't do much for me — it would've been better with more tension and development, because there was barely any chemistry between them throughout most of the book so tit didn’t really seem too believable

Nevertheless, the premise and world itself were really cool, with everything to do with the mirror dimension. Plus I do really enjoy kingfisher’s storytelling and the darker elements included in this story

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This book was such a refreshing take on a classic. Honestly, the premise alone had me hooked: “A dark retelling of Snow White steeped in poison.” Normally I avoid retellings, but my inner child and outer goth were both hyped, and this book delivered the entire vibe. 💚☠️💚

The story is beautifully unique with plenty of T Kingfisher’s usual wit. It’s nice that the main character wasn’t Snow, but instead we followed Anja, a poison healer hired to cure Snow. Once again, T Kingfisher blessed us with a snarky, intellectual, plus sized FMC and I ate it up like a shiny 🍎.

There are some pretty dark themes throughout (check your triggers jic) as well as some particularly creepy imagery I don’t want to spoil. The romance subplot was an unexpected but welcome little slowburn that was the cherry on top of a dark, enchanting story.

Some things I liked:
- Smart, independent, plus sized FMC
- Bodyguard trope
- Unique world building
- Soooo much info about poisons
- Sassy cat
- Creepy crawlies

Thank you NetGalley & Tor Publishing for sending me this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

T. Kingfisher is one of those rare authors who effortlessly spans multiple genres, consistently delivering captivating stories. Hemlock & Silver is no exception, standing as another shining example of her versatile storytelling. In this dark reimagining of the classic Snow White tale, Kingfisher injects a more sinister tone, focusing on poisons and betrayal. The narrative weaves through a web of deception, where every corner hides a secret, and the stakes are steeped in treachery. Kingfisher’s ability to blend elements of fantasy, suspense, and gothic horror makes Hemlock & Silver an engaging and atmospheric read.

Was this review helpful?

T. Kingfisher is a wonderful writer and her style always keeps me entertained! Hemlock and Silver is a dark, yet fresh, Snow White retelling with unique magic and memorable characters. I appreciated the hint of romance, building of intrigue, and twists and turns! Thank you, NetGalley!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Tor Books, and T. Kingfisher for the chance to read this book early, all opinions are my own.

Hemlock & Silver is another fun, witty, slightly spooky fantasy by T. Kingfisher. If you are a Kingfisher fan this book will have everything you love about her brand of fantasy - reluctant, older FMC forced to save the day, humor and sarcasm, grumpy MMC, sassy animals, unique twists on fantasy tropes, some pretty creepy horror elements, and a satisfying ending.

Hemlock & Silver is the story of Healer Anja, who lives a solitary life, studying poisons and their effects, and seeking to find cures for their various afflictions. When she is summoned by the King to save his daughter, who seems to be poisoned, she leaves behind her home and travels to a creepy, isolated castle, with some really suspicious mirrors. And a talking cat.

The book is billed as a Snow White retelling and while all the original elements are there, I love the way Kingfisher twisted them to create this story. It felt like a fresh and interesting take on a fairytale I usually have zero interest in.

I also loved all of the details about poison and the study of poisons. I was actually hoping there would be even more poison in the book based on who the character was. For me the most interesting scenes were at the very beginning and when Anja was doing the scientific testing to see what was happening to Snow.

The story did drag a bit and I wanted the plot to move along a little quicker. I didn’t find myself sucked into the story like I often do in T. Kingfisher books. And while I really liked Anja, she felt like a lot of other Kingfisher FMCs (not always a bad thing). And Javier was a bit one dimensional for me and I didn’t really ship the romance.

Not sure if I just didn’t read this at the right time or if the book just didn’t click for me but I think this might be my least favorite Kingfisher book to date. That said, it was still a 4 star, as there was a lot that I did enjoy. It just wasn’t the 5 star home run I usually have with Kingfisher fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

Whenever there is a new T. kingfisher book coming out, I have to pick it up for she is one of my favorite authors. I was thrilled to get my hands on an arc of this and immediately had to read it. Unfortunately, it’s not one of my faves but falls somewhere in the middle. The issue that I had with this book is that it gets really bogged down by the descriptions of the magic system. Towards the end I found myself really not caring nor fully understanding. Initially, when the magical elements are presented, it starts out on a much smaller scale and the reader is able to understand what is going on. However, as the plot thickens, it becomes more complicated and that’s where I had issues. To be honest, I think it kind of took away from the storyline and didn’t need to be .

The pacing was not what I wanted it to be, and there were times where I was super invested in what was going on and other times where I found myself skimming towards the end.

What is is about you ask? We are following Healer Anja who focuses on finding antidotes. She has had a 20 year career in her town and prefers her work to town gossip or people. She has a satisfying life and she does not want for anything else. When the king comes to her and requests that she follows him to the palace to see about his daughter Snow she obviously cannot say no to him.

Hands down the best things are Javier and Anja I think that it would’ve been a stronger book if instead of having the whole silver world, we instead focused on the Anja and the antidotes in her town. I realize that some of the things would have to have changed because Javier is a king guard but it would have made for a smoother and more enjoyable book. Thanks so much to netgally for the digital copy. All opinions on my own.

Was this review helpful?

Hemlock and Silver by T. Kingfisher is a fantastic fantasy retelling with just the right touch of romance. I was immediately drawn in by healer Anja, who specializes in poison. Her expertise and steely determination make her an unforgettable lead, and I loved watching her step outside her comfort zone to save Princess Snow.
The story gets off to a strong start when a desperate king begs Anja to determine whether his 12-year-old daughter, Snow, is suffering from poison and if so, how to cure her before time runs out. As Anja begins her investigation, she uncovers a dark alternate universe accessed magically through mirrors. This mirror world adds an ominous, urgent feeling to the story

Working alongside Anja is her steadfast bodyguard, Javier, with whom there’s a touch of romance. Their teamwork not only propels the investigation forward but also adds warmth and a pleasant dynamic to the unfolding adventure.

While the narrative starts slowly as the world is built and quickly hits its stride with sharp, complex has high stakes, intricate magic and a richly imagined narrative.

Thank you NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for the advanced reader copy. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

T. Kingfisher has once again written a delightful, whimsical yet dark fairytale retelling that's so imaginative yet grounded with realistic characters I fell in love with. There's always such a since of realness to her stories because her characters feel like genuine people making genuine decisions. And this fairytale retelling manages to be fresh and fast-paced, with suspense that kept me reading late into the night.

Was this review helpful?

The author worked her signature magic again with Hemlock & Silver, a dark, earthy, and wonderfully off-kilter reimagining of Snow White that balanced gothic intrigue with a dash of grim humor and a lot of heart.
Healer Anja was a delightfully grounded protagonist—fiercely intelligent, pragmatic to a fault, and so deeply committed to her craft that she regularly poisoned herself in the name of science. Her voice brought a refreshing sharpness to the fairy-tale landscape, and I loved how Kingfisher let Anja’s compassion shine through without softening her edges. The slow unraveling of the mystery surrounding Snow was handled with a deft hand—tense but never overwrought, weird but never confusing.
The supporting cast also delivered, from the grumpy, honorable guard who grew on me like moss to the gloriously self-absorbed talking cat who practically demanded his own novella. The mirror realm? Deliciously eerie. It oozed danger and decay, and Kingfisher’s descriptions were both beautiful and unsettling—exactly what I hoped for.
The pacing in the middle could have been a bit better—it meandered slightly as the story transitioned from court intrigue to magical mayhem, but the payoff in the final act made it all worthwhile.
Darkly whimsical and surprisingly tender, Hemlock & Silver was a twisted fairy tale that managed to feel both fresh and timeless.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

T. Kingfisher never disappoints! Hemlock & Silver is a Snow White retelling told from the perspective of a woman who has been hired by the king to find out who is poisoning his daughter, Princess Snow. I’m not familiar with the fairytale Snow White and Rose Red but I think the book pulls from that story as well.

Anja has devoted her life to studying poisons since she was a teenager, and now in her mid thirties she is one of the foremost experts in the field. Still, when the king asks her to discover what may be slowly killing his daughter, she is at a loss. There is nothing suspicious anywhere in the castle. Then at night, alone in her room, she catches a glimpse of a reflection in her mirror. Something not in her room when she turns around. Is the exhaustion and frustration getting to her? She certainly does not believe in magic, so there must be a logical explanation, right? Yet nothing physical seems to be harming Snow…

T. Kingfisher excels at building complete worlds filled with characters who feel real even when their roles are small (I love Grayling so much.) The dusty desert country with animal Saints and spirit boxes to memorialize the dead is no exception. Without spoiling anything, it also contains the fantastical almost but not quite horror elements that I love from her books as well.

Was this review helpful?