Skip to main content

Member Reviews

An absolutely stunning retelling! I went in a little nervous, especially knowing it was inspired by Beauty and the Beast. I was afraid it might tread too close to some other popular series (ACOTAR, anyone?). But wow, was I wrong. This story carved out its own magical path, full of unexpected twists, lush worldbuilding, and characters I couldn’t get enough of. And the dragons and mermaids?? Completely took it to another level. Every chapter pulled me deeper into a world I didn’t want to leave. I’m counting down the days until my OwlCrate edition arrives! I already know this is a book I’ll reread again and again. One of the best retellings I’ve ever read!

Was this review helpful?

A lovely mix of western and eastern fairytales in a way that perfectly fits in the world that Lim has already built. I love her expansion into different pockets of her world like this, interconnected but still separate and stand-alone.

I do think for a standalone we needed a little more on the Dragon King and the hierarchy that restrains Elang as well as the other immortals and demons - there's enough that you aren't confused, but that part of Elang's motivation is much more vague. That said, I really enjoyed all the parts in Ai'long and watching Tru and Elang work together and fall in love.

While the twists are telegraphed, the emotional impact of them isn't lessened at all, which I appreciate for a YA book. As always, the imagery is lush, though I did have a little more difficulty this time while they were underwater and trying to figure out how people were moving, as it seemed to switch between moving as one would on land and swimming or floating as the descriptions needed, which lead to some double-takes.

While the plot on this one might not stick with me as long as some of Lim's others, the imagery as always will, as will Tru and Elang. I wish we had a little more towards the end for their resolution, but I can't deny that I did gasp at that last chapter.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing this eARC,

A Forgery of Fate is a Beauty and the Beast-inspired romantasy which follows art forger Truyan Saigas as she enters a marriage contract with a mysterious dragon lord in order to save her family and find her missing father.

It's rare that I'm hooked on a book before even reading a word of the story, but when I opened A Forgery of Fate to Elizabeth Lim talking about her aunt Mary introducing her to Beauty and the Beast, I immediately knew I (an aunt Mary who loves Beauty and the Beast) was destined to adore this book. One of Lim's great skills is selling a fairy tale in a way that feels like the oldest fairy tale in the world, but also feels fresh and new. A Forgery of Fate hits that nail on the head, drawing inspiration from and breathing new life into the various fairy tales, myths, and folk legends that inspired its plot. Tru is such a fun main character, easy to root for and a joy to read from. The magic system is relatively familiar to me as a reader of Lim's other work, but this book also introduces new nuances and aspects such as Tru's gift of vision. For all that I felt like I knew exactly what would happen -- in a we're-diving-headlong-into-an-inevitable-conclusion kind of way -- I was still surprised, heartbroken, and full of joy through the final series of events.

A beyond worthy installment in Lim's broader body of work, A Forgery of Fate is an excellent pick for existing fans and new readers alike. I can't wait for my pretty copies (yes I ordered multiple copies leave me alone) to come in the mail!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 Stars
A Forgery of Fate has convinced me to pick up more Elizabeth Lim books. It was such a well-written book?!!?? The plot was executed splendidly; I really liked how the author included Chinese folktales while also being truthful to Beauty and the Beast. The book felt like a retelling, but it was also very Elizabeth Lim.

A lot of the time I don’t feel connected to the main characters in standalone fantasy books because we have limited time, and most authors tend to focus on the plot more than the characters, but that was NOT the case here; the balance between being plot-driven and being character-driven was immaculate.

Tru and Elang were well-crafted characters, and I really liked them. I was genuinely invested in them; I didn’t want anything to go wrong; I just wanted them to be happy. I really liked the dynamic of Tru’s family, they were the cutest, and they deserve all the happiness.

If you are in the mood for an excellent fantasy book, do pick this up!

Was this review helpful?

I'm so happy, Netgalley approved my eARC request. The newest book from Elizabeth Lim just sets her in concrete as a continuing auto-buy author.
Tru and Elang are an amazing couple. This book is described as a Beauty and the Beast meets Six of Crows AND Lim delivers.
The romance of Beauty and the Beast with Tru learning to love Elang for who he is (grumpy grouch and all). The found family/overthrow a government from Six of Crows hits hard.
I TRUly (see what I did there?) think this will be a comfort read.
She's sparkly and gorgeous and officially releases on June 3rd, 2025.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Knopf Books for Young Readers and Elizabeth Lim for the e-arc of this book! As a massive fan of the Six Crimson Cranes duology, I could not believe I was granted an opportunity to read this before publication day! It delivered everything I needed and more. It swept me off my feet into A’landi and the underwater kingdom of Ailong, with brilliant side characters and gorgeous descriptions. The whole book; the characters, the settings, the foods, felt tangible from the beginning. Breathtakingly romantic with such a strong journey, A Forgery of Fate is a must read!!!

4.75 🌟

Was this review helpful?

A delightful new twist on a familiar tale, I loved this reimagined Beauty and the Beast. The fast paced story telling kept me interested and the updates to the story kept me guessing and wanting to find out what would happen next.

Was this review helpful?

I had a good time with this one. When I heard that it was a beauty and the beast retelling I knew I had to give it a go and not to mention how gorgeous this cover is - another sell!

I enjoyed Tru as a main character and loved that she was equal parts brave, bold and caring. Elang seemed like a bit of a jerk at times but their interactions were fun and it kind of all comes together and eventually it makes sense why he acts the way her does. There was one trope in particular that I didn’t know to expect and I was so pleasantly surprised by it!

I think my favourite thing though was the uniqueness of the world building - at least to me. This was the first time that I read a book where an over half of it actually took place in the undersea. I enjoyed the way that is was described and the uniqueness of having a mix of mermaids, turtles, sea dragons, sharks and jellyfish.

Oh and the ending totally got me. Those last 4 chapters totally had me in tears, it was romantic, tragic and hopefully and couldn’t help the tears. I was grateful that it did wrap up still with a happily ever after and I liked how we got there. All and all a good plot overall and satisfying ending.

Was this review helpful?

A Forgery of Fate is a romantic fantasy that beautifully blends elements of Beauty and the Beast and The Little Mermaid within an East Asian-inspired world. Truyan Saigas is a gifted art forger with the unique ability to paint the future. To save her family and discover the truth behind her father's mysterious disappearance at sea, Tru enters a marriage contract with a mysterious dragon lord with a hidden agenda of his own.

I’ve always loved the magical realms Elizabeth Lim creates, and this book was no exception. My nostalgic heart delighted in the echoes of Beauty and the Beast, while the underwater dragon realm of Ai’long offered its own unique charm, sprinkled with small nods to The Little Mermaid. Tru and Elang’s journey captivated me from the start. The tension between them was undeniable, and I found myself fluttery with anticipation (and butterflies - if you know, you know). Just when I thought I had the twists figured out, the story would pull back another layer and surprise me all over again.

Though this novel works wonderfully as a standalone, I’m so glad I read the Six Crimson Cranes duology first. As soon as I saw this was part of the Legends of Lor’yan and a Beauty and the Beast retelling, I couldn’t help but hope: "Please be about Elang!" You don’t need prior knowledge to enjoy the story, but having a deeper connection to the world and its characters made the experience all the richer for me.

This is a beautiful journey of fantasy by Elizabeth Lim, and I cannot wait for more Legends of Lor'yan!

Thank you to Random House Children's and NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 4.25 stars

A beautiful retelling of Beauty and the Beast. I loved how the author preserved the essence of the original fairytale, but yet still made it her own. It was magical, whimsical, and adventurous, filled with high stakes and secrets. The world-building was deeply inspired by Chinese folklore. Very unique and captivating. The characters were well developed and relatable. I loved Truyon’s (aka Tru) strength, compassion, protectiveness, and loyalty. She was a very genuine character and I loved how perceptive she was in difficult situations. With regard to Elang, he was very mysterious and calculating. At first, he may come off kind of cold hearted, but as we slowly learned about his past, you realize he is not the demon people made him out to be. He may not be someone who openly expresses his emotions, but his actions show how much he cares and cherishes the people around him. However, my favorite character was probably Shani, the water demon. Morally ambiguous, sarcastic, and sassy as hell, but I loved her! As for the romance, it was a beautiful slow burn filled with stolen glances, near-touches, and yearning. I just wished we had more moments with them together. However, I loved the mystery surrounding their relationship, and the reveal at the end was definitely emotional.

Overall, I loved that this story is rooted in family (both immediate and chosen), friendship, and love. Definitely recommend!

Oh! One last thing, be prepared to be hungry when reading this story. My recommendation is prepare a bowl of noodles on the side just in case :).

Thank you Netgalley and Random House Children’s Books for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

When con artist and forger Tru finds herself unexpectedly engaged to a mysterious dragon lord, it'll take all her wits to survive. These were fun characters with a solid slow-burn romance, great worldbuilding, and a twisty plot that kept me guessing until the end.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a HUGE fan of Elizabeth Lim and this book solidifies her as an auto-buy author for me.

The story of Tru and Elang was heartwarming and fun. I love their banter and relationship so much. I kept wanting to squeal throughout the book. A Forgery of Fate is definitely Lim’s most romance-forward story and I’m LOVING that.

Lim weaves a wonderful journey for her main female character in a beautiful setting of A’long. This time, with a marriage of convenience!!

Definitely recommend!!

Tropes: marriage of convenience, forced proximity, beauty and beast vibes, dragons, fated mates, Chinese fantasy

Book: 4.5
Spice: 1

Thank you NetGalley and Random House for the eARC! I always appreciate it!! My review is honest and not contingent on receiving the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for this arc in exchange for an honest review. This book was so good ahhhhh!!! Tru and Elang are just adorable. The intricate underwater world of Ai’long was so well thought out and fascinating! I’m obsessed with the magic. I love how this story is woven and how Tru is so defiant and such a cool character. I love her family as well and how much she loves her sisters. As the oldest of 3 girls this was captured very accurately. The expectations of the oldest sister to put on a strong face so your sisters don’t have to worry. Or to take on everything alone. I’m looking forward to reading more Elizabeth Lim in the future!

Was this review helpful?

A Masterpiece Forged in Wonder: "A Forgery of Fate" by Elizabeth Lim
From the moment I turned the first page of "A Forgery of Fate," I was once again completely immersed in Elizabeth Lim's storytelling magic. What truly elevates a novel for me are the characters, particularly Tru and Elang. Lim has a rare gift for crafting protagonists who feel so achingly real, so beautifully flawed, and so incredibly resilient. Their individual journeys are compelling, but it's the evolving dynamic between them that truly shines. They both navigate a complex web of loyalty and duty, and it's particularly poignant to witness their internal struggles to understand the true character of each other. Their bond, tested by trials and revelations, forms the beating heart of this narrative, making you root for them with each page you read. Beyond the characters, the pacing of "A Forgery of Fate" is nothing short of masterful. Lim weaves a narrative that is both beautifully deliberate and thrillingly swift, guiding you through moments of quiet introspection and heart-pounding action with seamless grace. There's never a dull moment, yet every beat feels earned and perfectly placed.
And the world-building? Simply wonderful! Each location visited in this book is so well drawn, so vividly imagined, that I feel as though I am walking alongside Tru and Elang, breathing in the air of these fantastical realms. From bustling markets to ancient, mystical landscapes, every setting is painted with such rich detail that I found myself yearning to explore them firsthand. It's a testament to Lim's descriptive prowess that these places feel utterly alive.
Elizabeth Lim has an unparalleled ability to create stories that are profoundly immersive. Every time I open one of her books, I do so with a thrill of anticipation, knowing I'm about to be swept away into a world I won't want to leave. "A Forgery of Fate" delivers on that promise and then some, wrapping you in its embrace from the very first sentence.
While categorized as Young Adult, I wholeheartedly recommend "A Forgery of Fate" to readers of all ages. Its themes of identity, sacrifice, understanding, and the enduring power of love transcend genre and age categories. This is a book that will resonate deeply, leaving you with a sense of wonder and a profound appreciation for a story well told.
"A Forgery of Fate" is a triumph – a truly stunning adventure that will linger in your heart and mind long after you've turned the final page. Don't miss this phenomenal book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Knopf Books for Young Readers, and Random House Children's for this advanced copy! You can pick up A Forgery of Fate on June 3, 2025.

Elizabeth Lim is an absolute master of incredible world-building and creating an immersive atmosphere. I loved exploring the dragon realm alongside Tru and Elang, a place full of mythical creatures and gorgeous (or decrepit) palaces. I definitely picked up on the Beauty and the Beast vibes in this story, and I loved the use of Tru's painting as a magical device. People using art to express visions of the future is prevalent throughout several different histories and mythologies, so I was excited to see it used here!

While I loved Tru and Elang individually as characters, I wish we saw a bit more from their romance. There's a plot point in the book that I won't spoil here but that's used to excuse their lack of time spent together/his attitude toward her up until the last third of the book. The twist felt a bit like a cop-out to me because Elang maintains his "beastly" attitude toward her for so long that their switch to lovers felt a bit jarring. For this being a standalone novel, I would've rather seen his iciness toward her melt on page rather than having this mask unveiled, so to speak.

Other than that, I thought this was a fun YA fantasy with gorgeous writing and an engaging story.

Was this review helpful?

Once again, Elizabeth has exceeded my expectations! I love the way she writes! I get sucked into the world that she creates and I fall in love with the characters! So addicting, that I was up until 2 am to finish reading lol.

Was this review helpful?

This retelling blends Beauty and the Beast with Chinese folklore while adding dragons and a reverse Little Mermaid subplot.

Overall, it was a pretty solid 4-star read. I did find the set-up took more time than necessary, though, and I wasn't really interested until the 25% mark when the Fake Marriage trope was introduced.

The writing was pretty and easy to understand, and Tru was a strong FMC. The MMC was aloof and brooding and actually quite mean for the first half of the book, but there were reasons, and I liked them together.

It was also nice to see a Beauty and the Beast story where the FMC has loving sisters, and I appreciated Tru's relationship with them.

I felt the two big twists needed more explanation, though. Tru just suddenly realized her husband's secret identity and how to break the curse, and I have no idea how she connected the dots to solve those

Was this review helpful?

I would recommend this book to any teen who likes fantasy, especially romantasy, and I will be going back to read more Elizabeth Lim! This retelling of The Beauty and the Beast is sweet, fun, and not spicy. But I liked it more than I have liked previous YA romantasy.

What I loved:
✨Age gap of 3 years instead of 3000
✨Eastern inspired dragon folklore, plus merfolk, soldier turtles/sharks, and did I mention DRAGONS? I’m a sucker for dragons
✨My favorite part was the relationship between Tru and her two younger sisters. It felt very genuine and was a nice antidote to the plague of fantasy sisters that hate each other and treat each other badly
✨what impressed me most was the writing itself. I think Lim’s writing is really good prose, especially compared to other YA romantasy.

What could have been better:
🫧I need more world building in my fantasy books, so I would have loved to see more of the underwater world. There were some strongpoints, like the potion used to travel between worlds was a cool detail, but I typically read much heavier fantasy and needed a more immersive world to really hold my attention. It’s a pet peeve of mine when authors slip a random god’s name into the writing—in this case, a “Thank Amana”— and think that counts as world building. I don’t think most teens will feel as strongly as I do about this.
🫧More banter/camaraderie between secondary characters. This is one of those tropes in romantasy that I don’t mind. The main reason I end up liking the male protagonist is usually from his banter with his friends/servants, and there wasn’t much of that, just a few isolated scenes that didn’t do it for me.

Was this review helpful?

I love reading the books written by this author! Full of magic, familiarity of certain fairy tales with the delightful Asian mythology twist to make them fresh and beautiful works of art that flow easily and keep me hooked the whole time! This one has touches of Beauty and the Beast (though Tru is awesome and an art forger along with a touch of magic to see the future through her paintings) and a Demon Prince with a curse that only Tru can lift. This book is full of dragons, turtles (who knew they could be such great warriors, even against sharks), demons (I love Shani, complicated character though she is!) and a rebellion to overthrow the Dragon King and free the land from his wrath. That is no small task and that does not include awkwardness of Tru and Elang pretending to be in love to fool the Dragon King long enough to get to Yonsar and finalize the plans for ending his reign.

So you get a love story, an adventure, and thrills and tears. This book has it all and it flows so well, though I wish I could see the art that Tru makes (she is so talented, even if she totes herself as just and art forger) and I loved every minute of it. All of the characters are interesting, from Tru's family to the court of Elang with the mermen and mermaids, turtles, and of course Shani. It was all woven well for the reader to feel all the emotions and while there are tears at the end, there is also a sweet sigh and a wonderful ever after!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me a chance to dive into this book and experience and wonderous story!

Was this review helpful?

This was probably my favorite Lim book so far. The Beauty and the Beast retelling mixed with other myths and fairytales in ways that made this story unique. Returning to parts of her world and seeing a few characters from her other stories. Spending time in the dragon realm. The epilogue, which about destroyed me.

Overall, a wonderful story that stands alone but does contain some richness for those who have read Lim's work previously. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?