So much fun! It was almost like the parties I had when I grew up in the 90s. It is a creepy read, almost like Goosebumps. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to review a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

A super fast and super fun read. Crammed with tons of 90s nostalgia, this book hearted book tells the story of a 16th birthday sleepover gone very very wrong. This definitely reads as YA Goosebumps or Point Horror and it’s such a blast with a truly killer ending!

Wendy Dalrymple’s Birthday Party Demon is a delightfully quirky and thrilling ride that perfectly balances humor, suspense, and supernatural chaos. The story follows best friends Tina, Eve, and Lacey, whose Sweet 16 slumber party takes an unexpected—and rather demonic—turn. What begins as a typical night of fun and friendship quickly escalates when the trio accidentally summons a powerful demon, leading to Lacey becoming possessed and her friends trapped in a surreal, high-fashion world straight out of a glossy magazine.

Dalrymple has a knack for creating a vivid, imaginative atmosphere that draws readers into this bizarre, fashion-forward realm where every page feels like a new adventure. The concept of the girls being trapped inside a fashion catalog is both original and hilarious, adding a unique twist to the typical possession story. The entire "fashion catalog" setting is beautifully realized, with vibrant, stylish imagery that contrasts sharply with the sinister threat looming over the girls.

The characters are a joy to follow. Tina and Eve’s quick thinking and deep bond make them a dynamic duo you can’t help but root for as they race against time to save their friend and escape the increasingly dangerous, fabulous world they’ve found themselves in. The friendship between the three girls is heartwarming, and their individual personalities shine through, making their interactions both entertaining and relatable. Dalrymple excels in capturing the humor and drama that comes with being a teenager while blending it seamlessly with supernatural elements.

Lacey, while possessed, adds an interesting dynamic to the story, and her transformation is both chilling and captivating. Dalrymple doesn’t shy away from the darker elements of possession, but the lighthearted moments and witty dialogue keep the story fun and accessible. The plot unfolds at a brisk pace, with plenty of twists and unexpected moments that keep the tension high, all while maintaining a strong sense of fun.

Birthday Party Demon is a wonderful, fast-paced romp filled with magic, mystery, and friendship. Wendy Dalrymple’s sharp writing and playful take on the supernatural genre will have readers laughing, gasping, and cheering for Tina, Eve, and Lacey every step of the way. Whether you’re a fan of paranormal tales or just looking for an entertaining read, this book is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a little bit of spooky fun mixed with a whole lot of heart.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for an advanced copy to honestly review.

This book is so much fun! It's campy, cute and totally retro!

Take me back please. I adored the setting of this book. I love all of the details about Lisa Frank and magazines and just 90s fashion and decor. I can picture myself sitting in my bubble chair with my butterfly clips and lip smacker lip gloss flipping through YM magazine.

This book delivers the frights as well giving Goosebumps vibes but not for children.

This was so much fun and incredibly nostalgic. Birthday Party Demon was like if R.L. Stine and Grady Hendrix had a book baby. All the 90’s elements were so perfectly done. The pacing was really great. It got a little slow about halfway through but picked right up. You can read this in a day and have the best time.

This is a fun callback to the kiddie horror of days gone by. The retro feel was strong and I was particularly fond of the play on the cool clothing magazine we all wanted to shop from as kids.

You'll be able to get through this in an afternoon. It'll provide a few laughs and a freaky fun demonic invasion. Give this a go if you liked Christopher Pike and RL Stein as kids (or if you're a kid who loves them today).

If you’re looking for a short, fun, and nostalgia-soaked read, this one is exactly what you need. My birthday was just two weeks ago, and this book sent me straight back to my own ‘90s teenage sleepovers—the ones filled with junk food, prank calls, and staying up way too late whispering about the supernatural.

Set at a sleepover with three 16-year-old best friends, this story blends the body glitter fun of the ‘90s with a darker, supernatural twist. Think *Are You Afraid of the Dark?* meets *Clueless*—a quirky mix of creepiness and fashion that feels just right. The book’s shorter length works perfectly. I never felt like it dragged or was missing anything. While the protagonists weren’t super deeply developed, they felt real enough to enjoy, especially since this is more of a plot-driven story. And as a plot-based reader, I was fully satisfied. There’s enough suspense, humor, and a twist at the end to leave you grinning.

The nostalgic details were what made this book shine for me. Little things like drawing on your backpack with whiteout - or the carefree vibe of hanging out with your friends, totally unbothered by the outside world, hit home in the best way.

If you grew up in the ‘90s, this book will absolutely hit you in the feels. It’s not trying to be highbrow or overly complicated—it’s just good, spooky fun with a big dose of nostalgia. Whether you’re a fan of retro sleepover vibes, quick reads, or stories with a touch of the supernatural, I highly recommend this. It’s the perfect throwback escape.

This was such a fun novella- It was my first dip into "Pink Horror" and what can I say- I get it, I love it, I want more of it. The amount of 90's detail and nostalgia that Dalrymple was able to squeeze into every page unlocked so many fun childhood memories. Reading this was like a peek into an old photo album or journal- you know, minus the whole accidental demon summoning...probably.

I really liked the characters and the story, but with such a short page count I feel like this one was incomplete. There were a few things that I wish had been expanded upon and fleshed out some, but all in all a great read that I binged in one sitting.

This was such a fun read ! Full of 90s nostalgia. Gave me the heebie geebies. Gives goosebumps/are you afraid of the dark vibes.
Teenage girls messing with a Ouija board at a sleepover what could possible go wrong.

Thank you to netgalley for the chance to read this as an Arc.

Birthday Party Demon is a quick, campy, and fun read that takes slumber-party chaos to supernatural levels.

The story follows best friends Tina, Eve, and Lacey as they gather for a Sweet 16 celebration that goes wildly wrong when an accidental summoning leads to Lacey’s possession. Things take a quirky twist as Tina and Eve find themselves trapped in a fashion catalog straight out of the ’90s. As the duo navigates this fabulous but dangerous world, they must hurry to save Lacey before the demon takes over completely.

Packed with ’90s nostalgia—think video rental stores, beepers, and clothing catalogs bursting with throwback trends—the book will delight readers who enjoy a blast from the past. However, the frequent pop culture references can feel a bit heavy-handed at times, detracting from the story’s overall voice.

While marketed as YA, Birthday Party Demon leans more toward a middle-grade audience in tone and execution. The premise is clever and entertaining, but the story would’ve benefited from being a full-length novel, giving more room for character development and heightening the emotional impact of the ending.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this nostalgic, supernatural romp! Fans of campy horror and throwback vibes will find plenty to enjoy.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

This is a very cool book - I missed out on the vibe of this book generationally just by a little, but it was definitely something that summoned up a lot of nostalgia for a bygone era nonetheless! I perhaps expected the ending to be a bit nastier, but I think it took a good direction, and more than anything, it surprised me.

The whole vibe of the characters was great (I was particularly fond of Eve) and there was a dedication to building the atmosphere and world here that you don't often see in these kinds of shorter stories. I do wish that this was a fuller length novel in that the ending felt a little bit rushed, but all in all it was very solidly done. This is the kind of book that I could have seen myself reading along with Goosebumps and Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark as a pre-teen (along with some Stephen King I should not have been reading at that age) but with a bit more edge.

I will say that I thought as well the end could have been fleshed out a little better, but the dream sequence in particular really did lift this story up and made the whole thing a trip well worth going on. Looking forward to reading more in the same vein!

This had everything that I was looking for from a tribute to 90s horror, it had that campy element that I was looking for and was engaged with what was going on. It had that horror element that I wanted and brought me back to the 90s. It was wonderfully done and was hooked from the first page. Wendy Dalrymple has a strong writing style and am excited for more.

3.75

This was a solid three right up until the end, which I honestly did not see coming. I think this would benefit from being a full length story, then the end would be a total gut punch.

Overall this was pretty fun, I would have liked even more 90’s nostalgia because I’m selfish.

Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

This book, while advertised as YA, probably seems more intended for a middle-grade audience. There was some true sparks of creativity here, including the sequence regarding the shopping catalog that scared a new spin on traditional demonic possession stories. The depth of character development was pretty thin, which probably seemed why this book should be targeted more towards the middle-grade audience. In the end, this book was more reminiscent of the quality of RL Stine books from the 1990s rather than Christoper Pike books, which tended to have more mature and developed themes. However, I can definitely see how 5th-8th graders looking for a horror novel that is not too frightening would enjoy this work.

I was an avid reader of Fear Street and Point Horror as a kid. I had high hopes for this book. It also came recommended from Cameron Chaney. Unfortunately, this book fell flat for me. The character development was lacking and the plot was quite unbelievable. Therefore, I kept wanting more from the book. I believe this is going to be a series so hopefully the books will become more developed over time.

It’s crazy how much fun BIRTHDAY PARTY DEMON is! Teeming with 90’s nostalgia (video rental stores, clothing catalogs sprinkled with all of the hot new trends, beepers —), girl power & so much heart, BIRTHDAY PARTY DEMON is such a fast-paced blast that will keep you reading through all ~103 pages. I recommend this to all who’s looking for a silly & very campy coming-of-age possession horror tale!

This was a decently fun book. I found it trying a little too hard in some places with the nostalgia but overall I think it’s a fun book for people who like to read goosebumps.

This novella had so much 90's nostalgia, it was so much fun to read! VHS tapes, scrunchies, babydoll dresses, beepers, demons- what's not to love? Wendy did a phenomenal job peaking my interest and making me wonder what's going to happen next! I loved how Tina was worried about inviting her friends over for a slumber party because she hasn't been hanging out with them lately, when there are way worse things that will happen up ahead. I am hoping to see more books like this from Wendy because I will devour them ☺️

This was a short fun, cute, and creepy read, though it wasn’t quite at the level of R.L. Stine or the master of ’90s teen horror, Christopher Pike. It was nice to have a sapphic lead, something that was a rarity back in the day. I also loved the ending.

I would’ve liked more voice and fewer heavy-handed with the ’90s pop culture references (those of us who were teens back then didn’t ONLY talk about the latest trends and hits). The dELiA*s speak, though amusing, didn’t really make sense since you can’t hear capitalization, and there were a few texting abbreviations thrown in like G2G and BRB that threw me for a loop since they weren’t something ’90s teens would have known or said (O.M.G. was fine though).

I recommend it to readers looking for some Fear Street nostalgia.

I received an advanced copy from the publisher and am voluntarily leaving this review.

This was a SUPER fast but fun nostalgic read. Everything about this book reminds me of my childhood and that alone just makes you feel good reading this. It was way more YA than I initially expected but it was still fun. Very “My Best Friend’s Exorcism” vs “Goosebumps”. Plus I’m obsessed with the cover!