Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I actually REALLY enjoyed this ! It is such an adorable and FUN read with Great banter !
Different family dynamics and amazing character development with such lovable characters from the start !

Beau reminds me of my ex girlfriend… smooth talker, natural charmer, and sensitive, EXCEPT mine was a hoeee . 🤣 🙄
Charm is sweet as sugar !

It was such a heartwarming book that had me smiling the entire time and the author did amazing with making the reader feel the emotions through the characters!
I will def be purchasing a physical copy once it’s published !

Thank you NetGalley for my ARC copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This is a fun, revenge romance, friends-to-lovers story where Beau and Charm, both played by the same popular girl, Maia (who flirted with each of them, made them feel all kinds of things, and then went back to her boyfriend!), team up for a revenge plot to get Maia to fall in love with Charm, who will then dump her to give her a taste of her own medicine. But as Beau and Charm work closely to enact their plan, their "practice sessions" start to blur the lines between the fiction they’re trying to create and the reality of the feelings they’re both trying to avoid. It’s one of those stories where a good heart-to-heart conversation to clear up misconceptions could’ve alleviated most (if not all) of the drama. But it’s done well, so that it doesn't feel like a cliche.
Both main characters are dealing with their own traumas that make them hesitant to lay things out on the line blatantly, so they dance around the issues and hesitantly initiate conversations that *might* give them the answers they’re looking for *if* the other person knows how to respond properly, but these conversations only serve to confirm the other girl's fears and misconceptions about where they stand in this relationship. So there’s a constant clash of miscommunication, but done in a satisfying way that moves the story forward, instead of leaving the frustrated reader to wonder why they don’t just *talk* to each other!!
My only issue with this book is that I had a hard time distinguishing between the two point-of-view voices without the chapter headings to clarify who was narrating. Usually, when there are two authors for a dual POV book, I assume that one author wrote each voice... but either these two authors have very similar voices, or this was more of a collaboration where they polished it all together, and the two POV characters ended up blending into the same style of voice, making it hard to distinguish who was actually speaking on the page. The chapter headings made this not so much of an issue, but I always like stories that have very distinctive voices so I don’t need to rely on those chapter headings, which can feel like an interruption to the narrative flow. (I would give the book 4.5 stars because of this issue, but rounding it up to 5 stars, since I can't do half-star ratings.)

Was this review helpful?

Call Your Boyfriend is an amazing queer coming of age story and my little bisexual heart simply adored it.

Beau has been hooking up with a girl who won’t acknowledge her existence. Charm has been into the same girl. What happens when they both end up in the same cafe angry at the same girl? Enter The Plan. The plan has rules of course, one being that Charm and Beau cannot fall for each other. However as time passes, The Plan starts to evolve into sometime neither one saw coming. Refreshing, funny and real this book checked all the boxes for me.

Was this review helpful?

Just two idiots in love being idiots and not telling each other how they feel for an absurd amount of time while they pretend they don't have feelings for each other and are just friends. all while trying to get revenge on a confused queer girl.... really cute and quick queer YA romance. outlining the struggles of someone trying to come out and how it feels to be out and be hidden.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED Charm and Beau and was rooting for them the whole story. The entire cast was sublime (Enzo and Ezra? Adorable!), and the characters were real and messy--just like teenagers are. Absolutely loved this story.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this! This was such a cute YA Rom-com, and I was kicking my feet throughout the entire story. I loved the main characters, and the romance was PERFECT. When I pick up a YA book, these are the vibes I always want. I was smiling so much throughout the book and thought it was such an amazing read. If you're wanting something sweet and romantic, I heavily recommend giving this story a try!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster Children’s Publishing for the eARC!

This was such a cute fun read that really embodies what it feels like to be a teenager, while also having a very interesting plot!

This book had me hooked from page one and it was such a blast.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely LOVED this book. The authors seamlessly did a wonderful job of co-writing this book. The main characters, Beau and Charm, are well throughout and the plot has depth that goes beyond the surface of a typical YA Romcom.

Both character are showcased in their own unique way and have distinct personalities that elevate the book and has a way of really breathing life into the storyline. The supporting cast is phenomenally written and the dialogue was executed in such a way where every characters authenticity was deftly explored and used to fully give the reader an appreciation for the complexity of what each primary character was ultimately going through and teenage life in todays realities. Impressively, the book does explore and do justice to the each character’s intersectionalities.

Truly a witty and fun book that lives up to the hype. The line that states that if you liked the movie Bottoms you’ll enjoy this book is 100% accurate. The highest praise I can give this work is that is was immediately placed on my reread list and recommend to those readers who typically don’t read YA Novels; you won’t be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

i sadly have no interest in this and will be dnf’ing. it had the absolute cutest premise and the cover was amazing but there’s something i’m not quite connecting with at the moment.

Was this review helpful?

This one is very cute! If you're a fan of lots of pining and crushing, miscommunications, and a slow burn, this one is a great choice! I really liked learning about Charm and Beau's lives, and the side characters felt like they had their own stories too.

I only had a few complaints about the story, namely that even though Maia did them both wrong, I think The Plan was cruel, especially after we learn more about Maia.

I also didn't like how they (particularly Beau) talked about certain "straight" girls and assumed their sexuality for them. Just because people aren't out yet doesn't mean they are necessarily straight or just messing around. However, this was somewhat addressed further in the book which eased my mind a bit.

Finally, my biggest complaint is that there wasn't nearly enough of them shown as a couple. They admit their feelings and kiss and then the book just abruptly ends. I would have really loved to read more about their relationship or future lives in some kind of an epilogue.

Overall however, the book is still enjoyable. It's funny, full of heart, and has a very cute romance at the center. 4.5/5 stars rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read this prior to publication.

You never know how much you are missing out with representation until you read a book that has us in it. It was refreshing and felt good. This was the sweetest read! Beau and Charm have my heart and I'll forever be beefing with Maia. The authors do a great job of invoking anxiety, fear, joy, anger, etc. You can really feel the characters emotions as they happen. There were parts that had me grinning as I read. If you're looking for a heartwarming, coming if age, baby gay book. This is the one. 10/10

Was this review helpful?

5/5 stars

WOW! This was such a treat to read! I love the revenge plot as well as our two main characters, Beau and Charm, growing and improving throughout the course of the book. These characters felt very realistic, making me root for them as well as breeze through the story!

If you loved Bottoms, you’ll definitely enjoy this book! I 1000% recommend it!

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for a free copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This book had me hooked from the first line. It was such an amazing read! The character development and the plot was so well done. I loved both of the main girls. They felt so relatable and you really wanted to root for them.

Was this review helpful?

this was a DELIGHT. I loved both of the characters so much. However, something I deeply appreciated was that things were not tied up in a perfect neat bow for either of the girls in regards to their familial struggles. I like the messaging for teens that good things and personal growth can happen, even if your circumstances haven't changed/aren't ideal.

Was this review helpful?

Teaming up and playing a little revenge on the girl who broke your heart sounds like a great time until you start falling for your partner in crime.

I love this so much. It was such an enjoyable read with such lovable characters. If you liked the movie Bottoms I feel like you’d enjoy this book, the humor was simply amazing. I really liked seeing the character development through this story and really enjoyed how it mixed well with the plot as well. I would love to see this get a movie adaptation, it was genuinely so good.

Plot: 8/10
Pace: 8/10
Ending: 10/10
Characters: 10/10
Enjoyability: 9/10
Writing Style: 8/10
Would I Recommend? Yes
Favorite Character: Charm

Favorite Quote: ❝ "But I've never felt like I really fit in anywhere. I never felt Black enough, or smart enough, or skinny enough." The queer or straight enough feels tucked into the air between us, though she doesn't say it. ❞

Was this review helpful?