This powerful and deeply heartfelt story is an emotional journey of self-discovery, first love, and breaking free from the constraints of an oppressive environment. Valerie’s awakening—sparked by a single book—feels raw and real, making her struggle between faith, family, and identity incredibly compelling. The romance is tender and hopeful, offering moments of joy and connection that shine through even in the face of overwhelming obstacles. The bond between Valerie and Riley is beautifully developed, making every stolen moment feel significant and deeply earned.
Beyond the romance, the novel explores themes of resilience, belonging, and the courage it takes to challenge everything you’ve ever known. The emotional stakes are high, and the writing captures the intensity of Valerie’s experience with honesty and care. This is a gripping, thought-provoking read that blends longing, fear, and hope into a story that will stay with you long after the last page. Perfect for anyone drawn to coming-of-age stories about love, identity, and the fight to live freely and authentically.

Okay wow. The undercurrent of dread I felt reading this was top notch because the main character is suffering and so unsafe at home and I FELT THAT. I loved how realistically awful her parents were, and how her religious cult was full of the conservative talking points we hear all the time. I read this one in one sitting and have zero regrets. Can’t wait to add it to my library’s collection!

This book isn’t just about falling in love, it’s about fighting for your identity and realizing you don’t have to live by someone else’s rules. It’s emotional, honest, and full of hope, showing that choosing yourself is always worth it

Gay the Pray Away feels like such a vitally necessary book that I know it will be immediately met with book challenges. This is a strength, not a weakness. Naudus sheds light on the life-saving potential of queer literature, particularly in the hands of queer adolescents. It is unflinchingly brave, and I hope it finds its way into the hands of young readers who, like Valerie, need to see themselves represented in the pages of the books they are reading. The final passages brought me to tears, and I look forward to adding to my shelf once it is published.