Skip to main content

Member Reviews

What a cute read!

One thing I've always loved about Foley's writing is her ability to tackle the hard stuff, especially in middle grade. And it's no exception here. We're dealing with a lot throughout the book, such as drug addiction and death via weather disaster, but it all naturally comes together in a coherent matter. It's one of my favorite things about Foley's books.

Nadine and Francis' friendship is really cute, too. Their dynamic was very enjoyable, and I loved the adult friends they had/gained in the story. All of them have their quirks, but they're grounded enough to be believable and bot be too silly.

The one thing that dragged this book down a lot was the magical realism (i.e., the cause of the tornado). It came up suddenly and completely contradicted the consistent message the book had ("Tornadoes aren't a good or bad thing. They just are.") because the person who caused the tornado had evil intentions, therefore the tornado was a bad thing! It just didn't make any sense.

Overall, despite the book having all the staples I've come to expect from Foley, the magical realism element really dragged it down.

Was this review helpful?