Skip to main content

Member Reviews

My students like this type of book, a group of students, told both in the initial adventure abroad at college and current time reunion in Australia where one of their bodies has been found , after being missing fora decade. We learn right away who killed her and the rest of the book is twisty and I think my students will enjoy the ride. It reads young so adults might find it boring at times and predictable

Was this review helpful?

Where to start? This book had so many twists and turns that as soon as you think you know what happens it’s something new. It keeps you on the edge of your seat until the very end. I couldn’t put this book down as it was written very well, but also I just needed to know what happened. This book is one of the best I’ve read this year, and I absolutely love every twist and turn in the book. Thank you NetGalley for allowing me this ARC to read and review!

Was this review helpful?

Wow—what an amazing thriller! I absolutely loved this book. The dual timeline was brilliantly executed, seamlessly switching between present-day (Claire’s POV) and the past leading up to the murder (Phoebe’s POV). This structure added so much depth, allowing us to truly get to know Phoebe—even though she was already dead in the present-day sections. It made the thriller feel multidimensional and kept me constantly guessing.

I’ll admit, when the killer was initially revealed, I felt a bit disappointed. But then—boom—the final twist at the end completely changed that for me. It was such a shocking and satisfying moment that tied everything together in the best way.

If you love suspenseful, cleverly plotted thrillers, I absolutely recommend This Stays Between Us!

Was this review helpful?

10 years ago a group of college students from all over the world go on a study abroad trip to Australia. One of them ends up dead and now 10 years later, her body has been found. The remaining 9 meet back up in Australia and are questioned by the police to figure out who killed her. Almost everyone is a suspect and the story goes through how the main character, Claire, figures out what happened. There are multiple

The story line was great but I just couldn’t connect with a single character and the twists were pretty predictable. The book was just lacking that spark for me.

Thank you, Sourcebooks Landmark, for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Talk about a book that will keep you up late reading because you could not put it down! This book was one of my favorites of the ones I’ve read by Sara Ochs! Follow along as these friends try to solve a murder! This book had me playing along and speculating on who did it!

Was this review helpful?

Another character dynamic deep dive from this great author. I loved this.

A group of young college students on an Australian abroad program are having the time of their life when the trip ends with one of them going missing. Now, it is 10 years later and the group reconnects… because police have found their friend’s body.

Now, each of them back in Australia, they must confront what happened to Phoebe all those years ago. With twists and turns, I had a great time unraveling the truth. I enjoyed the differences between the characters in their college years - who they were as people, to who they become in the present.

This one kept me on the edge of my seat and I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

I was hooked by the premise - a group of students doing study abtoad in Australia. One disappears and 10 years later the group reunites back in Australia from all over (coincidentally the richest one now lives in Australia and has space for everyone in his giant waterfront mansion). Everyone has secrets. Phoebe thought she was responsible but what really happened?

Unfortunately this was boring. Most of the characters were unlikeable. The reveal at the end is a big tell all which annoys me if not done well, which this wasn’t. This was a slog and just felt meh.

The writing itself wasn’t bad, just lots of hinting at secrets without revealing them. This just wasn’t for me. Lots of great reviews from people who enjoyed it.

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebooks for a copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This Stays Between Us by Sara Ochs starts with an intriguing premise—an old friend group reunited after a decade, secrets bubbling to the surface, and a murder mystery unfolding in dual timelines. The setup is gripping, and the writing is engaging, with well-paced reveals and some truly tense moments. The alternating perspectives between Claire and Phoebe add depth, and I enjoyed how the story slowly unraveled their past.

However, the novel ultimately fell flat for me. The biggest issue? It was painfully predictable. Every twist, every character reaction, every reveal felt phoned in, making it more tedious than thrilling. And then there's the frustrating portrayal of Phoebe—her character arc leans into fat-phobic messaging, suggesting that she only became worthy or likable after losing weight. That choice felt unnecessary and detracted from the story’s depth. Claire, our protagonist, also didn't help matters. She was frustratingly naive, making choices that felt forced just to drive the plot forward rather than being natural extensions of her character. In a genre where sharp, layered protagonists are key, she just didn’t stand out.

Overall, This Stays Between Us is a good thriller, but it doesn't bring anything fresh to the table. If you love reunion-based mysteries and don’t mind a predictable plot, it might still be worth a read—but don’t expect to be blown away. Find this on shelves July 15!

Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for the complimentary eARC. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Great book couldn't put it down. Thank you for letting me read this in advance. Five stars for sure.

Was this review helpful?

Claire has been encouraged to make a visit to Australia as part of a reunion of classmates on a study abroad program, but she is quite hesitant to attend. A decade earlier she traveled to Oz to travel around the country for a month. She quickly bonded with the other participants, who began to refer to themselves as "The Mob" named after the same moniker that is used to describe a pack of kangaroos.

This small group of students from all around the world quickly grew into a family like unit. And, as within a family, there were disagreements. Claire's roommate Phoebe got into it with the well put together Adrien, after both hooked up with heartthrob Kyan. Ellery, Thomas, Josh, Hari and Declan round out the group. Cracks begin to form when there is a terrible accident with one of the students and eventually Phoebe goes missing.

I enjoyed this book. The descriptions of the Australian setting jump off the page, immersing the reader down under. With a gaggle of interesting characters and lots of twists and turns, This Stays Between Us by Claire Ochs is a winner. 4 stars.

I received this advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review and feedback.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved “This Stays Between Us”. I’ve never had the pleasure of reading Sarah Ochs books before, but I do love a good thriller. I devoured this one in a day and I’m not sad about it. Set in the diverse, unique, and stunning Outback of Australia, a group of travel abroad friends is reunited years after their original adventure. What they think is that it’s just a reunion, but they’re thrown into a police investigation of their missing friend and her remains being discovered. Forcing the group of Claire, Josh, Declan, Adrien, Kyan, Tomas, and Hari to be reunited together and relive the loss of their friend; however, one of them isn’t who they seem and Claire seeks to find the truth of what happened to Phoebe.
The twists and turns of who can be trusted, who’s being honest and real, and who has withheld more than what they’re sharing we seek to discover and find out. I really enjoyed the twists and turns, trying to put the pieces together. I really loved the alternating viewpoints of the characters from then and now as we discover what happened to Phoebe and the events that happened that summer. I also appreciated the setting. I mean, Australia?! It all came together in the end and buckle down to read and reread the epilogue!
Thank you so much to NetGalley, Sourcebooks, and Sarah Ochs for this wonderful read! I’m looking forward to recommending it to my friends and bookclub groups!

Was this review helpful?

This Stays Between Us by Sara Ochs is a gripping and emotional domestic thriller that explores themes of trust, betrayal, and the consequences of secrets. The story centers around two women, Phoebe and Claire, whose lives become dangerously intertwined after a devastating event. As the story unfolds, Claire is forced to confront the darkness lurking in her past and the impact her choices have on her future.

Ochs does a fantastic job of creating a tense atmosphere, with clever pacing and well-developed characters. The psychological tension between the characters is expertly crafted, leaving you questioning what is truth and what is manipulation.

While the novel is engaging, some of the twists may feel somewhat predictable, and the motivations behind certain characters' actions could have been explored a bit further. However, the emotional depth and the complex, realistic portrayal of human relationships more than make up for these minor shortcomings.

Overall, This Stays Between Us is a compelling and thought-provoking thriller that will keep you hooked from start to finish. It’s a great choice for fans of character-driven mysteries with plenty of twists and emotional weight.

Was this review helpful?

I'm calling it now: This Stays Between Us is going to be one of the psychological thrillers we see EVERYWHERE this summer.

Let's talk about who this book will work for and why it should have worked for me. If you love thriller elements, alternating timelines and perspectives, unlikable characters, immersive settings, and volatile friend groups, this one is for you. This is also my list of pros because this is what pulled me in and kept my focus.

But where it fell short was in a lot of the structure. Now, this isn't to say it's a fault of the writing as it could be personal preference, as I do struggle with repetition and the issue that started things off on the wrong foot for me was reading over and over about the thinness of a specific character. There were also moments that seemed forced in as an afterthought, as they didn't add much in terms of plot and weren't necessary for the reveal(s).

Overall, this thriller comes together with an intriguing plot and enough twists to keep readers interested. The pacing works well for those who prefer things to move quickly, and the short chapter crowd is going to be thrilled. If you're all about popcorn thrillers with toxic characters and summer destination vibes, add this one to your TBR ASAP!

((While the viewpoints shared are my own, I want to thank NetGalley, Sourcebooks Landmark, and Sara Ochs for this complimentary copy.))

Was this review helpful?

2 stars

Ten years friends Phoebe and Claire went to Australia to study abroad for a month, but Phoebe disappeared. Now, Phoebe’s remains have been discovered and the rest of the study group returns to Australia (um, why?) All of them have secrets. Especially Claire. Because she killed Phoebe.

But, of course, it’s most complicated than that. The shifts in POV between Phoebe and Claire were a little confusing for me. Oh, and Phoebe only becomes an acceptable human being when she loses weight, which is awesome. Ugh.

Was this review helpful?

Ten years ago, Chloe and Phoebe were roommates during an Australian study abroad trip. Now 10 years later, Chloe is the trip reunion and everyone is being interviewed about what happened the night Phoebe disappeared. Everyone has their secrets they've kept over the years, and what will it reveal about the real events a decade earlier.

I really enjoyed this thriller! The dual timelines & POVs (Phoebe then, Chloe now) were woven together very well, slowly revealing more about each student and what happened on their trip. There were both predictable bits and some surprises, so overall a great read as I was able to stay engaged throughout.

Thanks to Sourcebooks and Netgalley for the ARC for my review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow- another page turner by Sara Ochs. This is a twisty thriller that takes place 10 years after a month-long abroad program for college students in Australia. Through a series of flashbacks, the haunting story of what took place during that month long program is revealed and the consequences of those actions in the present unfold. There are many surprises and unexpected twists in both the past and present. I could not put this book down. I highly recommend this book for anyone who likes a good suspense-filled mystery.

Was this review helpful?

The premise of this book is a familiar one but the author definitely still put a unique spin on it. The multiple POVs and flashbacks helped you build tension surrounding the central mystery and all the clues felt like they were delivered at the perfect times to keep me intrigued. The cast of characters were distinctive and believable and the exploration of their relationships to one another was interesting.

Was this review helpful?

This Stays Between Us is a gripping, beautifully written novel that explores secrets, trust, and the complexities of relationships. The suspense keeps you hooked, while the emotional depth of the characters adds layers to the story.

Was this review helpful?

A super fun twisty thriller. Set in the Australian Outback and moving back and forth between the present and the events of 10 years ago. This one kept me engaged and eager to try and guess what would happen next! For me that is the hallmark of an excellent thriller. I'll definitely be picking up Ochs' other book The Resort. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

An alternating POV thriller with Claire in the present day 10 years after a travel abroad program and her friend Phoebe giving us a glimpse into the past that ultimately ended her life. Claire and the rest of their friends from the program reunite after the police discover Phoebe's body. With morally ambiguous characters everywhere you turn, the secrets and confessions are non-stop.

For better or for worse, I tend to be very good at seeing the twists and turns coming in most books. However, Sara Ochs debut novel, The Resort, blew my mind and left me reeling in shock. Unfortunately, I think that left me putting to much pressure on this book to do the same. This was a very good thriller, hence the 4 stars but, I found the ending disappointing.

Was this review helpful?