A fun Y2K coming of age love story. The characters are super fun to read about. This book was enjoyable overall.

This is the story of Cora’s love life. It is a good story, full of the emotions and angst that go along with first loves. The author truly captures that connection and how all consuming it can be, especially at that age. Lincoln himself is such a complex character where his family dynamics and history to play into the story well. With Aaron, the story is told very differently. There is a whirlwind component that feels strong and immediate. I loved that Cora ended up getting therapy and that it was referenced several times in the “future” chapters. You can tell she was really putting in the work.

My only issue is that the love stories are the only topic of the book, it does not pass the Bechdel test.

Notes:
I thought this book handled the issue of unplanned pregnancy incredibly well and realistically
It felt weird that 9/11 was barely mentioned., it is was such a big part of that year.
She absolutely made the right choice, to me the choice was obvious

This book really surprised me in the best way. I thought that it was going to be a basic love triangle story with a second chance romance, but it was so much more. All the Men I’ve Loved Again is really about growing up and figuring out who you are and who you want to be.

Cora is such a relatable main character. I really connected with her journey, especially watching her go from a shy college freshman (in 1999) to an adult trying to make sense of where life has taken her. I loved the moments with her roommates and the relationship with her father. These sort of side plots added a lot of depth to the character.

The back-and-forth between timelines worked really well, and I liked how each section focused on a different “man of the moment.” It made the story feel layered and the overall storylines were still told well. I did think that the love interests could have been more developed/had more depth to them, but overall it was an enjoyable read.

This story will definitely stick with me for a while!

This was such a thoughtful and heartfelt read. I picked it up expecting more of a traditional love triangle, but it ended up being a much deeper story about growing up, figuring yourself out, and how the people in your life—friends, family, exes—all shape who you are.

Cora is such a relatable character, and I really connected with her journey. Her relationships with her best friends and her dad were just as moving (if not more) than the romantic stuff, which gave the book a lot more emotional depth than I expected.

The writing felt really honest and grounded. My only tiny complaint is that one of the love interests could’ve been fleshed out a bit more, but it didn’t take away from how much I enjoyed the story overall.

If you’re into character-driven books with strong emotional pull, definitely worth picking this one up.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

I picked up this book as a palate-cleanser, expecting a light romance to clear my mind. What I encountered, however, was a deeply engaging coming-of-age saga that completely took me by surprise.

At its core, this story is more than just a romance; it’s an intimate exploration of Cora, the lead protagonist, as she navigates the bumpy road from girlhood to adulthood. Her journey is beautifully crafted, filled with poetic moments that resonate long after the last page.

The nostalgia woven throughout the narrative was particularly striking for me. Set against the backdrop of the late 1990s—coincidentally when Cora and I were both in college—I found myself reminiscing about my own youth and experiences. The added mention of Rehoboth Beach, my hometown, was a delightful touch that made the story feel even more personal.

This book is simply excellent. It swept me off my feet with its swoon-worthy moments, balanced with just the right amount of steaminess, laughter, and tears. It truly encapsulates everything one could hope for in a rich, emotional read. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a story that stays with you!

Thank you to the publisher, author and Netgalley for this ARC. The book is released July 8, 2025. get it from your local bookstore.

Christine Pride delivers a soulful, time-spanning love story that’s equal parts nostalgic, heartbreaking, and deeply reflective. All the Men I’ve Loved Again is not just a story about romance—it’s about identity, growth, and the winding, often painful path to self-discovery.

Set against the vibrant backdrop of 1999—with No Scrubs on the radio and Y2K looming—Cora Belle begins college ready to find her voice after years of playing it safe. But nothing prepares her for Lincoln: smooth, sincere, and utterly unforgettable. Their first love story is intoxicating and messy, and it sets the stage for years of questions, heartbreak, and longing.

Then comes Aaron. Quiet, grounded, and wholly different from Lincoln—but no less magnetic. Cora’s letters to him reveal a vulnerability that feels so intimate, you’ll feel like you’re peeking into someone’s soul.

Fast forward two decades, and Cora—now successful but emotionally guarded—is forced to confront the very same crossroads that once broke her heart. The return of both men into her life forces her to answer questions she’s avoided for years: Who is she now? And who deserves her heart?

This book is a love letter to firsts, to second chances, and to the messy in-between spaces we often live in. Pride’s writing is lyrical, poignant, and packed with emotional insight. It’s for anyone who’s ever replayed a moment in their mind and asked what if? Christine Pride delivers a soulful, time-spanning love story that’s equal parts nostalgic, heartbreaking, and deeply reflective. All the Men I’ve Loved Again is not just a story about romance—it’s about identity, growth, and the winding, often painful path to self-discovery.

Set against the vibrant backdrop of 1999—with No Scrubs on the radio and Y2K looming—Cora Belle begins college ready to find her voice after years of playing it safe. But nothing prepares her for Lincoln: smooth, sincere, and utterly unforgettable. Their first love story is intoxicating and messy, and it sets the stage for years of questions, heartbreak, and longing.

Then comes Aaron. Quiet, grounded, and wholly different from Lincoln—but no less magnetic. Cora’s letters to him reveal a vulnerability that feels so intimate, you’ll feel like you’re peeking into someone’s soul.

Fast forward two decades, and Cora—now successful but emotionally guarded—is forced to confront the very same crossroads that once broke her heart. The return of both men into her life forces her to answer questions she’s avoided for years: Who is she now? And who deserves her heart?

This book is a love letter to firsts, to second chances, and to the messy in-between spaces we often live in. Pride’s writing is lyrical, poignant, and packed with emotional insight. It’s for anyone who’s ever replayed a moment in their mind and asked what if?

for this book, blurb can be a bit deceptive as it suggests love triangle and a journey of adulthood and relationships. But for me this book is a better fit as a women's fiction than romance at it is more of her self discovery journey.

It is a well written book that dwells in raw and deep emotions and vulnerable moments.

Lighthearted exploration of love in the present and the past. Questions the what if of our choices. At times makes you think and at times makes you smile.

I enjoyed this book and Cora's coming of age. It was beautiful to see her finally find herself after years of floating. There was a lot of back and forth between Cora and her loves. I also enjoyed how the story was told and the writing.

Thank you to Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Interesting and unique premise. Chapters broken into to time periods and man of the moment.
One of my favorite parts of this book was watching the friendship of the main character and her 2 roommates form and ebb and flow during the timeline of the book.
Of course though- we want to hear about the men! As we grow up do we change? Do we want the same things? Do we have the right for other to change or remain the same?

Definitely a very good read.
Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for giving me early access to the book in exchange for my honest review.

“All the Men I’ve Loved Again” is a delightful romance novel that has love, loss, and self-discovery. Cora Belle is a woman who finds herself torn between two men she loved in her twenties, but twenty years later. I found that this book had a fresh take on second-chance romances and really enjoyed it. Cora is a very relatable character which in turn, makes this an easy to get into novel.


Thank you #NetGalley and #Atria books for this ARC!

Thank you to NetGalley, and Simon and Schuster for this eARC! As a huge fan of We Are Not Like Them, I was so excited to read this novel by Christine Pride and boy, was this book a wild ride!

All The Men I’ve Loved Again is about a girl, Cora, heading to college where she meets her 2 best friends and embarks on a love triangle that spans decades. Throughout different phases of life, Cora finds herself in love with either Lincoln, her college sweetheart, or Aaron, her weekend fling. This story is well-written, although I found it to be slow at times. I love the depth of Cora’s friendship with her two best friends, Kim and Neisha. They experience so much together in college, and after. I could relate to the bonds formed as I have similar closeness to some of my college friends still 15 years later. Over the decades, Cora finds herself crossing paths with Lincoln, then Aaron, then Lincoln again, and then Aaron again. It was a wild ride and Christine keeps you guessing until the very end with who Cora will choose. I definitely knew who I was rooting for in the end! Throughout the entire book, Cora has a closeness with her father that’s admirable, and she goes through the different phases of life with him as well. It’s a beautiful relationship we all hope to have with our parents! Overall, I really enjoyed this show and all the ebbs and flows. You find yourself rooting for Cora to just find happiness with herself, regardless of the men in her life, and that’s what happens. I would definitely recommend this book to a women’s fiction fan!

Arc received from NetGalley. Opinions my own.]

The book was…just okay… but I found myself wishing the main character would just allow herself to move on from her past.

All the Men I’ve Loved Again was well-written and certainly has some great pop culture references for the time (the story is set in 1999.) This is a coming of age story about Cora as she goes to college and is eventually forced to choose between two men who she connected with.

While this book was well-written, I just couldn’t relate to Cora and I didn’t feel very invested in the story. I felt like things were dragging and I had to make myself read more. I think it just wasn’t a good fit for me, and it could certainly be a great book for someone else!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read and review this book.

I received a free copy of All the Men I’ve Loved Again from the publisher and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I tried really hard to get into this book but unfortunately, I just couldn’t.

Our team did not like this book. It was not well written, some team members called it “dry” and decided it wouldn’t fit the brand. Thank you, NetGalley, for the advance copy!

The book was fine, but I didn’t love it. Lincoln was quite unlikable to me, and he’s such a big part of the book. I wish Aaron was a bigger part of the book. I loved Neisha, but Cora was a bit pretentious to me.

All the Men I’ve Loved Again had such an interesting premise—a coming of age story that dives into love, friendship, and self discovery with a fresh spin on the love triangle trope. The writing was solid, and I was invested in Cora’s journey as she figured out who she is and what she really wants.

One of my favorite parts? Cora’s dad. He was such a great character and brought so much heart to the story. While I enjoyed certain aspects, I didn’t connect with it as much as I’d hoped. Still, it was a unique take on a classic trope, and if you’re into introspective, character driven reads, this one might be for you!

Wow. All the Men I’ve Loved Again by Christine Pride took me on such an emotional ride. It’s one of those books that makes you reflect on your own life, the “what ifs,” and the loves that shaped you.

Cora’s journey—falling in love young, losing it, and then reconnecting with past loves in her forties—felt so real and raw. The way Pride captured nostalgia, regret, and hope all at once? Stunning. I found myself rooting for Cora, cringing at some of her choices, and totally swooning at others.

That being said, I did wish some relationships got more time—Aaron, especially, felt a little underdeveloped. But the story’s heart? It’s all there. If you’ve ever wondered about the one that got away (or the one you’re glad did), this book will hit home. A beautifully messy, heartfelt read.

Thanks for the review copy. This is a great coming-of-age story. It was very compelling and rich. I know people are going to love this one.