Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I *loved* this. The illustrations were great, very vibrant and colorful, and the text was dynamic, which is always great for a read-aloud. It's also a great reminder to consider the kind of language we use, even when well intentioned, and to work towards empowering our kiddos--especially girls--to focus more on their abilities and attitude than their physical appearance. Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for letting me read

Was this review helpful?

So cute and absolutely heartwarming! The illustrations are beautiful and really bring the story to life. I loved Fiona and seeing her family from her perspective! It was really sweet, funny, and has a lovely message for young readers about how who you are matters more than how you look. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

In a Nutshell: A cute picture book about being seen for more than your looks. Great thought and message, but the execution could have been smoother. Still, I appreciate the point it makes. The illustrations are wonderful.

Plot Preview:
Fiona, short for ‘Queen Fiona of Apartment 4C’, is a white Persian cat, and as amazing as all cats are. She stays with her human parents and sister Lou, and does her best to show them varied aspects of her personality. However, they notice only her looks. Why can’t they see beyond Fiona’s beauty?

The cutie on the cover was a big factor in my getting this picture book. The title also played a role in stirring my curiosity. “Peculiar Praise” – great alliteration, but what could it mean? The story covers this aspect well.
The lesson the book aims to impart is a necessary one. Today’s society is big on physical appeal. So much so that a majority of those who post personal photographs on social media use filters. Even in real life, the first point of judgement is almost always based on how someone looks. Women resort to artificial measures to keep looking younger than their years, even if the result makes them look like plastic Barbie dolls. As such, the book offers a good reminder that looks are just superficial and behaviour counts more. Every article on effective parenting states that one should praise/criticise not the child but the behaviour. This is just an extension of the same thought: focus not on looks but on behaviour.
While the intent is good, the execution could have worked better for me. We see the humans only through Fiona’s eyes, so they are distanced from us. Lou doesn’t get any chance to speak, except at the end when she suddenly changes everyone’s opinions – a bit abrupt. Further, the whole story takes place on a single day, which doesn’t explain why the “trouble started this morning.” Fiona’s reactions would have made better sense if the plot indicated how she is always judged by looks instead of restricting it to one day in her life.
Moreover, despite what the title suggests, the humans in Fiona’s life aren’t really “praising” her in the true sense of the word in most of the scenes. Fiona seems bugged by how the humans address her (‘lovely’, ‘gorgeous’, ‘pretty’), which is not the same thing as praise. The only scene where Fiona’s stand on ‘praise’ is valid is where she plays with the cat toy and her family sees just her cuteness and nothing else. The reasons for Fiona’s irritation could thus have been handled better in order to justify the title.
Finally, the corrective behaviour suggested by the book is needed more by adults than children. Most kids don’t judge based on looks or skin colour. They imbibe these negative habits from the adults in their lives. As such, I can only hope that the moral of this picture book gets out to at least those adults co-reading the book with their little ones. For kids, this might just end up as a cute kitty story.
The story is written in Fiona’s first-person perspective, so her reactions to the human comments come out well. I love how she indulges in typical cat activities with one intention, but her human family always mistakes it for something else. (The toilet-paper antic was left unexplained though.) There are many funny moments in the story, thanks to Fiona’s thoughts as well as actions. (Fiona is such a purrfect feline name, right?😍)
The illustrations are really cute, with the soft pastels suiting the vibe. (A shoutout to the cute cat-face table mat!) As Fiona’s fur is snow-white, the sketches use shadows and shading well in making her look even floofier. Her expressions are also amazing! The human parents appear too young and the mother seems overdressed for an ordinary day at home, but after reading such a book, it would be ironic if I judge them for their appearance, right? 🤭
Overall, this was a decent picture book with an important message, but the illustrations outshine the content, which needs a bit of finetuning. I still appreciate the intention.
Recommended to little readers, whether cat lovers or not. The text makes this a suitable option for ages 3-7, though the message is probably more relevant to parents and would work better with discussion.
3 stars.
My thanks to 4U2B Books & Media for providing the DRC of “Fiona and the Peculiar Praise” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.

Was this review helpful?

I love this! What an apt reminder to be conscious of the words we are using to describe the children in our lives. Beautiful, lovely, pretty, cute, and gorgeous are sweet descriptor words but that shouldn’t be only reserved for our daughters and it shouldn’t be the only words we are using for them.

I really enjoyed that learning this lesson was done using a cat! It was the perfect avenue for this particular problem to take emotions off the table and to look at this from a new perspective. Additionally it’s silly enough for the kids to remain engaged!

Great book and lovely illustrations!

Was this review helpful?

What a fun and cute read! Would be great for a story time or learning that you are more than what you look like.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Cute little book! I know for a fact that my own child would love this book as a cat lover. I loved that it was told from the cats point of view. Very cute! Would definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

As a Children's Librarian and Cat Lady, I am always drawn to cute picture books of cats. This book about Queen Fiona of Apartment 4C was super adorable, from the 'day in the of life of a pampered cat' storyline to the cutesy illustrations. This will sure to be a hit with younger readers.

Was this review helpful?

A cutesy children’s book that reminds kids that who you are is more important than how you look.

Fiona is the resident queen of apartment 4C, but she has a problem. Despite how fast and smart and considerate she is, her people only comment on how she looks! Fiona and the Peculiar Praise takes the reader through Fiona’s day, and her raising frustrations with the compliments she receives.

This is a perfect children’s book. It had beautiful, eye catching pictures and a nice message. Plus, it follows the life of a very energetic cat, which is always a bonus for my young readers.

I really can’t say enough good things about the art-style. It’s soft and colorful without being too busy. It’s extremely well-done and sure to be a win for checkouts.

Was this review helpful?

A delightfully illustrated children's book with a beautiful message about a persons content being more important than their appearance.
Fiona, the cat, loves her family but feels like they only notice how cute and adorable she is. She desires for them to see that she is fast and strong ; so much more than just her looks.
This will be a welcome addition to our library's catalogue.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars
⭐️⭐️

Thanks to Netgalley and 4U2B Books & Media for this eARC. I confirm this review is honest and that all thoughts are my own.

This was a cute little book. I was drawn to it initially as I wanted to see how it addressed praise and what it meant by ‘peculiar praise’. As a parent, I am more aware of how I speak to my son and like to learn about new ways to incorporate positive praise in a productive way to help fuel his inner dialogue and self-worth.

As a society, we often give praise to people in regards to their appearance without realising and this book lightly addresses that via the Cat (Fiona) and how easily it can be to say certain words we think are positive, but in actual fact lack depth and true value. Confidence and acceptance (including self-acceptance) shouldn’t revolve around how ‘pretty’ and ‘lovely’ a child is. It is helpful and more valuable for them see their self-worth in more creative and different ways.

Although this did give an example of an alternative word the Cat preferred as praise, compared to the surface level compliments that were initially given throughout the book, it would have been nice to have had a few more. I did however enjoy the Cat’s inner thoughts and there were parts in the book that did make me giggle. The illustrations were also very sweet and not too overpowered by colours which can sometimes be too bright and intense - contributing to children being overstimulated.

Sadly the ebook had some formatting errors which stopped the flow of the book for me a few times as it was difficult to decipher some context of things. This could have been a software/conversion issue with the file itself, but it did sadly affect my overall experience of the book. In that case, I would say this would be better read in paperback form and not via an eReader unless these formatting errors are resolved.

Was this review helpful?

Omgosh!! This was so cute. It highlights that you can be beautiful and smart too, and just because you are one doesn't mean that you aren't the other! Love this so much.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a cute story! The illustrations are adorable and the overall message is very positive and clear. The clever way the kitty wanted to be seen for more than her beauty really resonates and I think it’s conveyed beautifully. The ending was also perfect, because she did in fact get the compliment she wanted without having to ask for it. Really cute message in a beautiful story.

Was this review helpful?

Fiona is a cat who lives with her family in apartment 4C. She’s smart and hardworking, but everyone only notices her beauty, not her talents.
This is a very sweet story that teaches children that beauty isn’t the most important thing—what truly matters is the kind of person you are!
There were also lots of funny moments. I also liked that the cat actually let the mice go after catching them.
The illustrations are incredible—they complement the story perfectly!

Thank you to NetGalley and 4U2B Books & Media for this eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute and silly children's book with a great message about how you are more than just how cute and beautiful you are. I appreciate that the message isnt heavy handed and its more naturally intertwined within the story. I do love an in your face message as well, don't get me wrong, but sometimes it's more fun for little ones when the message comes hand in hand with a cute story about a silly kitten yah know?

The artwork is another great one with a pretty color scheme. I, for sure, give this book bonus points for using bigger words that will encourage a larger vocabulary as well. I appreciate it being a children's book geared for toddlers, that also treats them like they are capable of understanding more than overly simplified speach. Overall both the toddler and I liked this one, and I can see it being read again ❤️

Was this review helpful?

Fiona is five stars and kid approved. if you have kitten lover kiddos, Fiona is sure to be a hit. truthfully, I hope they make Fiona into a series. we will be adding them all to our carts, especially as my kitten lovers learn to read.

the book has a very sweet message. we are more than our bodies. we are more than our looks. we are funny, strong, and smart (although my daughter declared that 'fiona is not as smart as me.'). and those illustrations are truly to die for - absolutely stunning!

Was this review helpful?

I will be perfectly honest, I only snagged this book because the cat of the cover looked like my childhood cat that my mom got when I was 2 and lived until I was 21. My two-year-old self named him fluffy, and as we grew up together, his favorite place to sleep was on my head in the middle of the night or on my computer in the afternoon every time I tried to do homework.

So imagine my surprise/joy/bittersweet sentiments when Fiona did the exact same things in this story? 🥹

Anyways. On to the actual point.

This was a really fun read. The art is wonderful! And I like the lesson it teaches. It can be burdensome when the only complements you receive are on your looks and not on the things you have accomplished. This was written in a way easy for kids to understand. Of course it's nice to compliment someone's looks if you really mean it, but it also feels nice to acknowledge when something has done something to help you. I imagine this story would be a hit in library/classroom reading times. It's fun, beautiful, and great for starting a nice discussion!

Was this review helpful?

While I like the message and feel it's an important one to impart on the youth, it felt forced to the point of pandering. Fiona's frustration with being labelled as 'pretty' starts immediately, whereas it should've built up as more and more people ignored her skills. More focus on her skills and less on her frustration would've been a nice 'show don't tell' route.

Was this review helpful?

Fiona is a typical cat in so many ways. She is always in the way, and demands attention. She doesn't, however, want to be thought of as "cute". Read this very sweet book to find out what cats really want from their humans! Thank you to Netgalley for this free ebook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Adorable short story to children about a cat, who's up to mischief. I'm not a cat person, but I definitely like Fiona a lot. The illustrations are gorgeous, and it has a sweet message about beauty not being everything. I definitely would read this to a child I don't have.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a cute reminder for kids that looks are not a character trait.
Unfortunately the cat was so cute I couldn't take her seriously.
Thank you for the digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?