Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an e-ARC of this book!

When Ali first arrives in Oxford, bright-eyed and full of American positivity, he believes he is finally where he belongs. He finds a group of friends with whom he can discuss life and literature, miraculously reunites with his estranged father, and begins to rub elbows with some of England’s elite. What Ali doesn’t know though is that someone is playing a dark and manipulative game with him. One that may ensure he doesn’t leave Oxford alive.

Listen: I love some good dark academia, especially when it incorporates English literature. If We Were Villains is not only one of my favorite dark academia books, but one of my favorite books of all time. So, I’m always going to end up comparing any new dark academia that I read to Villains. The bar is high.

This book was chock full of literature references, and I really enjoyed the way they were layered throughout. It was super satisfying in terms of picking out patterns and themes between the events of the book and the literature that the characters were discussing. The writing and pacing are sharp and there was never a dull moment for me; I wanted to keep coming back in order to figure everything out.

What I found less satisfying was the ending. I was surprised when I went to turn the page and suddenly there wasn’t any more left to read. I didn’t feel like I came away from the book with a good sense of certain characters’ motivations. Just to be powerful? Just to be manipulative and evil? I’ve seen some things that indicate there are connections to the author’s previous book, Black Chalk. I haven’t read that one, so it’s possible that reading that book connects some dots that weren’t connected here.

All in all, this is a solid dark academia read. Do I still prefer If We Were Villains? Yes. Is this still an exciting read that scratched my ever-present dark academia itch? Also yes.

Dark academia is usually a genre that works for me, but I had to DNF this at 56%. I felt like it just took too long to get to the meat of the story! I really enjoyed the beginning and the set up and Ali learning about his father, but it seems to have just gone off the rails and "lost the plot". I'll be interested to read more reviews when this comes out, maybe I'll need to pick it up again!

"The Rabbit Club" is more than just a mystery novel; it is a profound exploration of privilege, identity, and the human condition. Yates' storytelling is both intellectually stimulating and emotionally resonant, making this book a must-read for fans of dark academia and literary fiction. It is a novel that not only entertains but also encourages readers to reflect on the intricate dynamics of ambition and belonging. Highly reccomend!

Thank you to #NetGalley and #HarlequinTradePublishing (along with #HanoverSquarePress) for the magical opportunity to read and review the newest (and long-awaited) novel by Christopher J. (CJ) Yates. Being a big fan of his two previous novels, Black Chalk (2013) and Grist Mill Road (2018), and interacting with him on a few social media platforms over the years, my experience with this book was next-level fun.

From approx. a quarter-way in, I had the thought - "this one is SO FULL of Easter Eggs it should come out in April, not July." There are literary easter eggs and references all over the place (and favorites too - Lewis Carroll, Shakespeare, Waugh, Nabakov - and then references within references. My mind LOVES puzzles and this book has absolutely everything AND pulls it all off by weaving that everything into one incredible narrative adventure. I'm being very careful not to reveal any spoilers but Mr. Yates, again, revisits the set of Oxford Uni (and creates a cast of characters who are layered, enigmatic, and, at times, both lovable and detestable)!

There's a Mick Jaggeresque, philandering, hard-drinking, rock star "dad" who gets a second chance at becoming (in my opinion) Father of the YEAR to his main-character son, Alistair. There are Ali's new friends (and enemies?) at Oxford, a coveted secret club membership, romance, and, as mentioned, a father and son reunion. CJ Yates even makes references to Black Chalk at different points within the novel (as well as Black Milk -- read it and find out).

My advice - READ THIS BOOK. But even more - READ THEM ALL. He is a talented and extremely knowledgeable writer and it shines through in all of his work. His literary, culinary, musical, and academic knowledge resonate outward from the most interesting and addictive characters.

Thanks again to all (especially the writer) for another home run. More please!

On shelves July 8, 2025.

pretty interesting and kind of like a Secret History-esque work and story. would definitely read again. 4 stars. tysm for the arc.

Overall this was a satisfactory read. The switching back and forth between multiple perspectives became tiresome as a plot device. This was especially true with the voice of Goodwin speaking directly to the reader. His tone and phrasing was so monotonously repetitive that I found myself skipping through those sections. Was that character designed to be a caricature of the other? Of course, but it was annoying and did not add to enjoyment of the story. Overall the plot lacked depth of development, with really only the one main plot line, which was not carried out with much suspense or mystery. If I had to give it a star rating, it’s a 2.5 out of 5, at best.

Thank you to Netgalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing for the advanced copy of this book. This book was just not my cup of tea. It was very hard for me to get into and I hated Ali. I did enjoy the atmospheric feel and the descriptions of Britain and Oxford at the time. I know someone else will really enjoy this book!

I really enjoyed this book. I think the characters and tensions were built up well and the pacing help to keep the story moving in a way where I was able to sit with what I had while also looking forward to each new revelation that occurred. I was looking for a good dark academia-type book, and this is what I needed. I really enjoyed it and I recommend it to others

The Rabbit Club by Christopher J. Yates, a good premise that failed for me, I do think others will enjoy it. Thank you for giving me a chance with this book.

This was a very intriguing story that I quickly got lost in. The writing is excellent and I liked how the story flowed. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

Prepare to be mesmerized by this dark academia tale set in 1990s Oxford. Christopher J. Yates, author of Black Chalk, introduces us to the endearing yet naive Alistair McCain, the bastard son of 1970s rock legend Gel McCain, who has just been accepted into the school of his dreams—one that happens to sit in the shadow of his estranged father’s infamous British rocker compound.

Yates masterfully blends insider knowledge of Britain's school system and Oxford’s old-world traditions with a gripping tale of secret societies, elite privilege, and hidden dangers. Inspired by the twisted whimsy of Alice in Wonderland and the haunting nostalgia of Brideshead Revisited, this novel is packed with villains and tricksters lurking beneath the grandeur of academia.

Rich with Shakespearean allusions, intricate character development, and an atmosphere that lingers long after the final page, The Rabbit Club is a spellbinding, layered mystery that will captivate fans of dark academia and literary intrigue.

I only wish it was longer!

#Harlequin #TheRabbitClub #ChristopherJYates #DarkAcademia

very the-secret-history-ish but with its own wonderful and captivating twist. i am very excited to see how the public rates it.

i was dragged in to every chapter and LOVED every moment. a plot twist i couldn’t predict and a thousand other turns to keep the reading interesting.

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC!

This was hard to get into for me. I understand the fish out of water perspective, but Ali was really difficult to get behind due to how grating he was. Other characters found him obnoxiously American and I did too