This is not the first Mazey Eddings book I've picked up, and I don't think it will be the last, however, I do need to say right away that this one was not for me, unfortunately.

This story follows a show host, Eva, who interviews B-list celebrities whilst eating hot dogs (hello, Chicken Shop Date!). She accidentally calls out her ex from college, and it spirals from there. RIley is loved online, he works very hard on deconstructing toxic masculinity, he is committed to growth.

Well, Eva.... Eva! That's an FMC that I struggled to connect with. I felt like she was supposed to be portrayed as a "black cat" but she just gave off mean girl energy. She was cruel at times, closed off and overall offputting.

On the other hand, Riley Cooper, the love interest, is a dream of a man. He is kind, emotionally mature, self-aware. He listens, he owns his mistakes, he commits to improving and learning from his actions. He is a darling and I think he deserves better than Eva.

I did appreciate the mental health representation, queer side characters, commentary on influencers/ "wokeness". It's a strong suit of this book. But the romance itself felt like it was too lustful, it went 0 to 100 very quickly.

Overall, this is a 3/5 read for me.
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's for the eARC!

Well, Actually by Mazey Eddings is a wonderfully written second chance, black cat x golden retriever romance!
I’m obsessed with Eddings are her writing.
In my eyes she can write no wrong!
I’ve read and loved every single book she has wrote and Well, Actually is no different!

Honestly, this was breathtaking, refreshing and so raw. I loved every moment about this book.
Eva is witty, sharp, sarcastic.
Rylie is fun, smart, engaging and their chemistry is electric. I truly loved the banter and humor in this one. It made me fall in love with all the characters even
This book is hot, funny, and romantic.
And I’m so excited to read her next novel.

Thank You NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!


https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7281545316

https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/well-actually-mazey-eddings/1146167679

This was so fun and heartfelt! I laughed, I almost teared up a few times. A second chance, black cat x golden retriever romance! I loved the concept of going on a few dates and one of the dates being therapy! Hilarious, but also so sweet!
I also listened as an alc and I liked the narrator
Thank you St Martins Press for an arc in exchange for an honest review

This ended up finishing stronger than I expected, but it took a while to get there. For the majority of this book (70+%), the FMC was highly unlikable and the book read like a manifesto about how terrible men are.

On a drunken rant, Eva posts a video about Riley, her college crush/hookup, that goes viral. Riley is now a podcast host that speaks about how men can be better partners/citizens, but the video Eva posts is about her lackluster experience with Riley in the past. Riley says he's changed and wants to make it up to Eva so they agree to go on 6 dates to get to know each other now. Can Eva let her guard down to see who Riley truly is now?

This was an interesting read. I appreciate a feisty heroine. Eva was not that. She was mean for the vast majority of this book. Riley was a total golden retriever. Yes, he acted abysmally in college as a 20 year old kid, but he was going through a lot. As they reconnect, Eva has a lot to work through before she can trust Riley again including workplace issues. This is where she lost me. It felt like a rant against men when she should have just stood up for her career and life goals. I'm glad these two (mainly Eva) could be vulnerable together toward the end of this book because it finally made their relationship believable. I still rate this book 3 stars because these two do have great, funny banter, and the ending is strong. It just took me a minute to get over the drama of the first 3/4ths of this book.

Thank you to Net Galley and St. Martin's Griffin for the e-book in exchange for my honest review.

I was really hoping to love this book, but I just could not connect with the characters or story. I found the FMC to be very mean and a bit whiny. This book was just not it for me.

This was so good! First, I’ll start by saying that if you’re someone that hates pop culture references and plots that are obviously influenced by tiktok then this will not be enjoyable for you. Me on the other hand, I love tiktok humor and I was cackling the entire time.

Second chance romances are my absolute fave, especially when the man WORKS for that second chance. And Rylie definitely put in the work. He’s a bi man that spent years in therapy and wears slutty little glasses so obviously I’m in love with him. The fmc Eva is the black cat to Rylie’s golden retriever. She probably needs therapy too but who doesn’t? She’s hilarious and sarcastic, and she’s constantly mean to Rylie but he fucking loves it. I loved them together and I think their relationship was actually really believable. I mean who doesn’t know at least one man irl who is head over heels for a woman that is constantly picking on him?
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Oh! And on top of this being a really fun read the smut is hot as hell ❤️‍🔥 definitely recommend.

This may be my new favorite Mazey Eddings book! Eva Kitt is the host of Sausage Talk, where she interviews moderate celebrities over hot dogs. Rylie Cooper is a popular podcast host whose mission is to deconstruct toxic masculinity and to teach men to be better partners.

Eva and Rylie went on some dates in college, but it ended with Rylie ghosting Eva. Six years later, Eva puts Rylie on blast via video, and it goes viral. Wanting to capitalize on the drama, Eva’s company books him as a guest on her show.

During the live show, Rylie puts Eva on the spot. He wants to make up for his toxic behavior by taking her out on some dates. Eager to prove herself to her current company, Eva reluctantly agrees.

What starts as a very rocky reunion turns into swoonworthy second chance romance. Eva is very closed off and protective of herself. She was really hurt by Rylie in college, and it really took a toll on her relationships. As a result, she’s very skeptical of Rylie’s intentions and is antagonistic towards him. That doesn’t phase Rylie. He may be the most steadfast, and patient MMC in the history of romance!

I loved Eva and Rylie’s dynamic. It takes some time, but Rylie is able to break down her walls. I think he is truly the most perfect partner for Eva. He understands what she needs and delivers it 100% of the time. I also really appreciated that there wasn’t a third act breakup. Eva needed someone to stand by her, and that’s exactly what Rylie did.

Lastly, I ADORED the cameos from characters from Mazey’s prior novels. It was so fun to see some beloved characters again.

Mazey has been and will continue to be an auto-buy author for me!

I went into this book blind, and had no idea what to expect as it was my first Mazey Eddings - let me say it will not be my last one! I LOVED THIS! The banter, the pining, the humour - ugh, please sir, give me more!

There were times when I wanted to smack Eva, the MFC - but that is nothing new for me. I usually find females in romance novels annoying at times, but that’s definitely a me problem. She just went a bit too overboard on the whole “no one loves me/everyone leaves me” schtick and needed soooo much constant reassurance from Rylie. That said, I did think she was a really well-written, realistic character (as realistic as a Hot Ones-esque social media interviewer can be).

Rylie Cooper is just one giant walking green flag of a book boyfriend. That man needs to be cloned and created in the real world (no shade against my real-life husband, who is also a giant green flag and incredible). The way he constantly showed up for Eva, the way he refused to allow her to push him away, those slutty little glasses - seriously, that man is making a run for my list of top book boyfriends of 2025.

The humour was silly and fun and perfectly suited for me. At one point, Eva tells Rylie that he is “the human equivalent of Comic Sans” and for some reason that made me snort out loud. So stupid, but again - right up my alley for humour. Another line that made me laugh out loud - “His face is open and inviting, eyes twinkling. What a shithead.”

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me an ARC of this one, and beginning what is sure to become a Mazey Eddings obsession…

5/5, all the gold stars for this one. A physical copy is a must for my bookshelf in the very near future.

My rating is truly a matter of this book just not being for me. I don’t keep up with a lot of pop culture and there were so many references (at least I felt like there were) that I didn’t get or know will be outdated in just a year or so. I do think the author’s writing is fantastic. The characters were interesting and unique. The fmc was definitely a bit too mean for me though.

💕 second chance
💻 workplace
🐈‍⬛ black cat / golden retriever
👏🏻 no third act breakup

single POV
3/5 stars ⭐️
2/5 spice level 🌶️

I adore Mazey Eddings's work and haven't disliked a book yet. Well, Actually delivered on Eddings' brand of humor and banter combined with LGTBQ+ representation and thoughtful, relatable depictions of mental health and neurodivergence. The premise has shades of romcom silliness - sharp-edged Eva hosts a Chicken Shop Date-type show that inadvertently goes viral when she calls out her ex Rylie, who happens to be a social media personality focused on deconstructing toxic masculinity - but Eddings weaves in issues of confidence and self-worth, vulnerability, and more. This wasn't my favorite book by Mazey - I love how voicey she is but this is perhaps too much so, and some of it got old - but I'll still read anything by her.

So far, I have enjoyed the Mazey Eddings books that I've read. And I know that not every story will be for me. But boy, I disliked this book so much.

Eva Kitt is a journalist-ish, and is hoping to someday break free from her crass online interview series (think Chicken Shop Date but hornier) and move up the chain into hard-hitting news stories. After one drunken video stitch with an ex-situationship who is a non-toxic masculinity dude influencer, she garners tons of attention overnight, and now, she and said dude have to do her interview show together. Dude, AKA Rylie, wants a do-over of their time together. She has to go along with it for her job. Overall, it seems pretty cutesy.

Except that Eva is a grade A jerk. Rylie calls her witty and brilliant but all this lady is is mean. I would not spend more than one minute with her if I had to. She has next to no redeeming qualities, no actual care for other people exhibited, and no good reasons for the insane amount of HUGE mistakes and poor decisions she makes. But Rylie is hung up on her, and he is determined to redeem himself.

The thing I hated the most in this book was the banter. Eva couldn't take anything seriously ever, and Rylie, though in theory he called her on it, never held her accountable in anything. The conflict in the workplace was awful, though it probably does happen, realistically. The ending was way too short and I didn't see any real character growth.

In conclusion, I super disliked this book. I wouldn't recommend it myself, but if you liked Hannah Brown's book, Mistakes We Never Made, then I think you'd enjoy this one.

Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Griffin for the e-ARC!

WOW I loved this book so much! Even more than I was expecting, and I am a big fan of Mazey Eddings!

Eva Kitt can come off a bit abrasive and angry, but deep down she is afraid of being hurt, and has her walls up high for some valid reasons. And dang did I relate to her!! Rylie Cooper could come off as playboy who is pretending to say all the right things, but when it comes to Eva, he is DOWN BAD. These two were hilarious. They had a rough start, with a first date that was so bad I was cackling. But as both of them opened up, and talked about what actually happened when they were in college, there was some real healing and rebuilding for them both!

I loved this book. I loved the communication. I loved how soft Eva let herself be with Rylie once she gave in to him. I loved that the 3rd act conflict was not a breakup. I loved the way these two fought for each other. I also loved how funny this book was!

I read some of this but will admit that I was also able to get the audio ALC, and let me just say: the audio of this was so good!

Second chances and a praise kink. Say less.

I devoured this book in one sitting. Each page was perfect.
To me Eva was super relatable and the relationship between her and Rylie shows raw emotions that I don’t feel like a lot of second chance romances have.

The banter between the two was everything. I love the sassy back and forth.

This book has a delicate nod the issues the LGBTQ+ community faces and it was written in what I feel like was a very tasteful way.

Very thankful for the opportunity to review from Mazey Eddings, St. Martin’s and NetGalley.

Highlight the whole first chapter as noteworthy, this might be Mazey’s best work yet.
The maniacal glee I felt, knowing chapter one was obviously FULL of dramatic irony had me clapping as I read.

Chicken shop date inspo? HOW has this never been done before?! But thank the world it’s been done by Mazey, the perfect author for this writing style. & ever since @amedliadimz tagged her and Jonathan Bailey in the cover recreation image, SWOON.

Taking snark to a new level, Eva instantly became one of my favorite hot mess main characters, right up there with Olivia from Lynn Painter’s Mr. Wrong Number. Nothing like knowing a book will be a five-star read before you’ve even officially met the love interest. Throw in their second-chance romance throwback and I was SOLD.

And it’s not all hot dog puns and piney hatred, Eddings covers tough topics in a way that feels brutally honest with a side of banter that SERVES y’all! I’ve never felt for characters in such a visceral way, with each new moment I felt like their relationship was messy and real and something I NEEDED more of.

READ IT, love it, learn and grow from it, this one’s a must-read!

It’s hard to put into words how ‘splodey my heart was with this warm, hilarious book. My heart just kept filling with every insult, every endearment, every time Rylie knew exactly what Eva needed. And then it exploded. In a great way.

So, Eva is lonely in her tiny apartment and drinking deeply while doom scrolling. She comes to a screeching halt when she sees a guy she used to date explaining red flags in dating. Hold up. *This* guy thinks he can advise about dating when he was the literal worst. Not on Eva’s watch.

She stitches his video with her truth bombs and never expects what happens. Viral video. Boom. Her bosses at Sausage Talk, where she interviews D-list celebs while eating hot dogs, wants her to have a live conversation with Rylie.

This doesn’t go the way she thinks it will. He convinces her to go on several dates with him so he can make up for his past behavior. It’s all supposed to be for the exposure and a possible promotion. But I think you know things start to feel very real very quickly.

On the surface, Eva is a classic black cat, but dig deeper (as we do) and she’s a char-roasted marshmallow- only black and bitter on the outside, but warm and tender on the inside. That being said, her outward confidence, looks, and way with a stunning slight is bar none. She is, as Rylie says, brutal. And I wouldn’t want her any other way. Neither would Rylie.

I truly cannot express how much I love this book and this couple. Please please please read this book. You’ll be giggling and kicking your feet. And probably sweating because the heat is…so hot. Tell me more, Rylie.

Highly recommended for lovers of second chances (my personal favorite), sexy nerds, lethal femmes, and all the freaking banter you could want.

I received this eARC via #netgalley and @stmartinspress. All thoughts are mine alone.

romance novels | contemporary romance | spicy romance| well actually | Mazey Eddings | book recs | book reviews

This book does have delightful banter and great LGBTQ+ and mental health representation going for it, but I just couldn't click with this overall. I think if the lust had taken a slower burn it could've worked a lot better, because I could not believe that Eva was getting so immediately hot and bothered by a man who once gave her terrible sex then ghosted her after one of her most vulnerable moments. Between that and the humor that didn't land for me, I was spending a lot of time cringing unfortunately. Eva also had so much bite in her but stayed so quiet when she should have unleashed, I wanted to see her have much more of a big moment than she got!

I’ve been looking for a romcom to hit all the buttons for me and this was it!

Eva was definitely the grumpy black cat to Rylie’s golden retriever personality. Their banter was excellent. Their personalities were fleshed out very well. Rylie had one of the healthiest redemption arcs I’ve seen.

The plot was interesting, reminiscent of Amelia D’s Chicken Shop Date. Communication was an important plot development tool, which was rather refreshing. Every time Eva backtracked, Rylie supported her through the conflict. The LGBTQ+ and mental health rep was great!

The audiobook narration by Ariela Crow was done really well. I usually prefer dual narration but this was great just as it was. Wouldn’t change a thing.

Complementary copy received and voluntarily reviewed.

Thank you Netgalley for the advanced reading copy! This came off to me as a Chicken Shop Date, Andrew Garfield fan fiction, and it worked in many ways. I liked the black cat/golden retriever vibe of the two main characters, Eva and Riley. I liked that they worked through their trauma together, I thought they were hot together, I liked they both had queer found family. I thought the book paced pretty well, and had some funny banter. My only issues with it were that I thought the ending was kind of rushed and for the complexity of the topic, felt a little trite. But overall, the vibe and writing and steam and banter pushed this up to four stars for me. I recommend this book for fans of Eddings, contemporary romance, and Chicken Shop.

5 trillion stars, absolutely no notes. Everything about this book was fantastic. I just finished it and I'm already ready to dive back in. Where's the screenplay, let's make this a movie ASAP. Mazey, I will always read whatever you write and thank you for this absolute gift of a book.

Eva & Riley. 3.0 ⭐️s. It took me a bit to get into this book and while the book was not necessarily bad, I do think it was longer than it needed to be. I really liked Riley’s character. Out of both main characters he was the only one with actual growth and substance the entire book. He and the other side characters are what mostly kept me engaged. Eva was contradicting and at times annoying. I get her having mental health problems and family issues she had not dealt with, but her façade was not believable. She was supposed to give this black cat energy but it poorly masked her insecurity. Overall the book just felt dragged out, it’s supposed to deal with modern issues and it has representation, which I loved, but to me it just felt too much like the real world, which in all honesty is not what I enjoy reading. The spicy scenes were great but again a bit overdone and they added nothing to the plot. The hopeless romantic in me just wish it had been a lot shorter. Thanks to St.Martin’s press for allowing me to read and review ahead of publication.