Skip to main content

Member Reviews

There was something quite cozy about The Alchemy of Flowers despite the sensitive subjects it broached by a hurting and angry main female character who struggles with infertility, the guilt associated with failure to do that which she feels she was made for as a woman, and agonizing through the trauma of losing a marriage as well as the children she miscarried.
The message repeated over and over again through the book is 'making flowers from shit' - which is so very fitting given that Eloise is running from a life unfulfilled and hired on as a gardener at a beautiful estate shrouded in mystery. I really enjoyed watching her make something out of herself as she worked through some of her dark traumas while being tempted time and time again by the eerie magical nature of what happens at dusk when all staff are required to remain indoors. There was a spunky charm to her continuing to question what others were too afraid to, to not let herself be silenced when things didn't make sense, and to push forward even if she stumbled back a few steps.

This was the first book I've read of its kind and I can't compare it to anything I've read before which makes it stand out as being quite enjoyable even if it's not exactly my cup of tisane. I think the magic and mysteries of the book is really understated, focusing mainly upon character growth and development over time.
Eloise's connection with flowers and her creative outlets are precious. The world within The Alchemy of Flowers is whimsical and never truly gets too dark without offering a bit of levity between the hurts. I think that this book has within it an incredible display of feminine strength and while I have never experienced the agonies associated with the loss of marriage, children, and infertility, I think that those who have might find the words within this book to be quite empowering.

Was this review helpful?

Another story of an American woman moving to France to find happiness. This one at least speaks French. She gets a job as a gardener in an off grid castle with many rules. Of course, she finds friends that become family and a hot Frenchman. A bit of mystery, a bit of romance, a bit of gardening, a bit of magic realism, but mostly life drama, and not so believable character development.

I support the fact that the book tries to show how (in)fertility journey can be hard and my heart goes to all those who struggle with tracking ovulation, medications, IVF and all the mental and social problems and pains that goes with it, but I can't make myself to love this book. ☹️

The second part was a bit more interesting, but all in all c’est pas ma came.

Was this review helpful?

I had the honor of being an early sensitivity reader on this book and fell in love then. Now I had the chance to read the final edition and just fell in love all over again. This book was for me THE SECRET GARDEN meets A GREEN AND ANCIENT, set in the South of France. It weaves the hard work of healing within the landscape of a mysterious job in the gardens of a locked castle, scrumptious dinners under the stars, flowers that whisper to to those who can hear, and secrets held and revealed. Preorder now!

Was this review helpful?

A terrific combination of magic and compassion. A woman goes to a mysterious, magical garden after a difficult loss. The story is a lush, mysterious vibe, but explores an often talked about grief of infertility.
This book is truly not for everyone, but for the right audience they will be rewarded with strong messages of found family and working through our issues.

Thanks to Harper Focus / Harper Muse and NetGalley,

Was this review helpful?

A very big thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this eARC!

The Alchemy of Flowers intrigued me from the blurb alone, and the novel as a whole completely delivered. As I read, I truly felt transported into seeing things through Eloise's perspective. It's hard to get that right in writing, but Resau manages it with ease.

I also thoroughly relished the refreshing narrative of womanhood and motherhood, the discussion that one needn't birth their own child to feel that strong maternal urge, or be a true mother. It was utterly beautiful, and I can only hope many women read this and feel comfort that their stories are being told.

Was this review helpful?

This book isn’t for everyone—myself included. It feels like it was meant for a specific audience, one that shares the main character’s trauma and grief, and would connect with the story on a much deeper level than I did.

That being said, the writing is stunning—florid and poetic. The setting is captivating, with its vivid descriptions, the unique talents of each character, and the magic woven into the whole place. These elements bring the world to life in a way that feels almost tangible.

But for all its beauty, the book has its drawbacks. Descriptive passages often cross into info-dump territory, dragging on to the point of frustration. The protagonist’s past is intentionally kept in the shadows, leading to a repetitive cycle of rediscovering the same fragments of their story over and over again. And then, there’s the excessive use of French phrases—mon ami, mon chéri, merde—which, rather than adding charm, felt forced and overdone.

Albeit the book wasn’t for me, I believe every book finds its reader. This one touches on important, often-overlooked themes, and for the right audience, it may be exactly the story they need.

Was this review helpful?

What a charming read. I loved the focus on nature and plants as a way to carry the analogy throughout the story. It wasn’t the easiest read at points, but it was so sensitively handled that I was glad I was reading it. Beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

First things first, a huge thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own. Second of all, when I picked this up, I picked this up for the cover and the description. The cover is jaw-dropping and the blurb sounded amazing. The Secret Garden meets Sarah Addison Allen, an author who writes magical realism and stories about women, an author whose work I have enjoyed. It seemed like something I would very much enjoy!

To continue, The Alchemy of Flowers is about a woman who moves to France to take care of a magic garden with a bunch of other people who need a little bit of healing in their lives. This sounded really nice and I was excited to read it. Except I was bored to tears, I couldn’t connect to any of the characters, and the writing was a touch too purple for me. However, I liked the magic and the found family aspect. There were some really good lines in the novel. But, ultimately, I struggled to finish this. It probably would have been a DNF if this wasn’t an ARC. I was really bummed because I so badly wanted to love this.

Overall, I’m unsure of whether or not I would recommend this. This didn’t work for me, but it might work for someone else.

Was this review helpful?

4,5/5 stars

This was a lovely surprise. A delicate story about finding a family, about feminine power, and the trauma experienced when struggling with fertility. The symbolism of flowers and goddesses felt like a sensitive way to talk about such deep traumas, for Eloise and all the women in the book. The men are also interesting and have deep, and I soon found myself caring deeply about all the people of Paradise and their stories.
If anything, the aura of mystery in the first arc of the story - surely intended to hook us with the oddity of the gardens - stretched the build up for the reveals a tad long, to a point I questioned whether any questions would ever be answered. Fortunately, it payed off.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Truthfully, I did not think that I would get into this book until about third chapter. It was the way she was willingly able to leave everything just to go to this foreign place to find herself again because she seemed to be lost in the world. The chemistry between the other characters and the main character was a buildable moment because at first they seemed closed off and secretive and in reality they had no clue until the main character was more curious about where she was then them. it was a big healing experience for them all and the ending was a little dark and twisted. It made no sense for paradise to have rules .

Was this review helpful?

The Alchemy of Flowers is a visually charming and fantastical read.

**We follow Eloise who, having reached rock bottom, seeks escape as she starts a new chapter in her life as the new gardener at Le Château du Paradis. There are few rules to follow in her new role, enforced by the illusion La Patronne, her employer, but the consequences of breaking them could be devastating.

Among the flowers (some more welcoming than others) she finds solace, companionship with her new colleagues, and more than a couple of dangerous secrets. **

The main character suffers from infertility and I believe that the author does a very good job of describing the soul crushing sadness faced by the millions of women affected by similar issues.

The side characters were well fleshed out with heart wrenching, truthful stories and I thought they added a huge amount to the story. Every single one of them felt real to me, and I loved that as the reader we peeled back more layers to their stories as our MC opened up and learned to love herself again.

I found the pacing a little staggered at the start and had a hard time connecting with this book until about 30% in where I was fully invested with the story. My only mild criticism was the inclusion of some French words, creating a mismatch of English and French, sometimes flitting back and forth in the sentence. I understood the inclusion when Eloise was struggling to place a word, or translate it into a similar English meaning, as this put us in her head, but the use of chocolat or other similarly recognisable French words was a little jarring to me.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and thank NetGalley, the publishing house, and the author for granting me access to this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The Alchemy of Flowers is an enchanting tale that seamlessly weaves together magic, mystery, and personal healing. Set in a secluded French garden with an air of quiet enchantment, the novel invites readers into a world where flowers hold secrets, and transformation blooms alongside grief.

At the heart of the story is Eloise, a protagonist whose journey from loss to renewal is both heartbreaking and heartwarming. The novel beautifully explores themes of found family, resilience, and self-discovery, all against the backdrop of the mesmerizing ‘Garden of Paradise.’ The author’s lush, atmospheric descriptions make the setting feel almost tangible, transporting readers into a world brimming with magic and quiet wonder.

Beyond its whimsical elements, The Alchemy of Flowers also touches on deeper, more emotional themes, including loss and reproductive health. While these aspects add depth and richness to the story, they may be challenging for some readers.

With a blend of magical realism, mystery, and even a touch of horror, the novel carries a unique charm that may appeal to both adult and young adult audiences. Whether you’re drawn to witchy aesthetics, immersive settings, or deeply personal character journeys, this book offers a captivating and beautifully written escape.

Was this review helpful?

‘The Alchemy of Flowers’ is the perfect read for anyone looking for witchy vibes and a whimsical world to fall into.

I really enjoyed this book. It utterly captivated me, and I was left wanting more with every chapter. This story is both heartbreaking and heartwarming as we follow the main character (Eloise) on a journey to recover from devastating loss with the help of her found family. It’s beautifully written and full of stunning descriptions that really helped to set the scene and transported me to the ‘Garden of Paradise'. Each character has their own set of complexities, which we get to learn about throughout the book, and I think most people will find something in a character they can relate to.

The only thing I would advise people to be mindful of when picking this up is that there are themes and topics throughout, including loss and reproductive health, which some people may find difficult to read.

I would like to thank Harper Focus / Harper Muse, NetGalley, and Laura Resau for the complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the found family aspect and the flowers talking to Eloise. I wish I had a better background in French because I kept forgetting what some of the words meant. There's a lot of talk about "merde", which got a bit old/boring.

Kindly received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A magical garden in France with strange employment conditions. I loved the setting and the French language elements. Magical mysterious events take hold. Part magic, mystery, a little,sprinkling of horror and a female leads personal journey. Enjoyed it and wondered if it was pitched more to a young adult audience. Thank you to the author, thank you to #netgalley and the publisher for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The Alchemy of Flowers is a gorgeous, atmospheric escape into a world of blooming magic and quiet self-discovery. Eloise’s journey—from heartbreak to renewal in a secluded French garden—feels both deeply personal and enchantingly mysterious. The lush descriptions transport you straight into the walled Jardins du Paradis, where secrets lurk beneath the petals, and the flowers seem to hum with their own quiet power.

Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley fro the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

The Alchemy of Flowers by Laura Resau is a masterpiece! I loved this book with my soul. I couldn't stop reading this. This author is a genious!

Was this review helpful?

I was quite intrigued by the story of this magical realism book, where a woman rebuilds herself in an idyllic mystical garden in the South of France, cut away from all technology.
It had lots of potential, but I quickly realised I was not the audience as this felt more geared to the pure romance fan. So if you liked the movie Chocolate, or Eat, Pray, Love this is for you. If you're a fantasy fan first, you might find the book lacking.

Being bilingual, awkward French bothers me a lot... so that got on my nerve first.
However, I could have forgiven that if I had enjoyed the writing or the voice. But the tone was strangely immature. It didn't feel like the point of view of a deeply wounded 37 year old . I didn't connect with the main character, never believing her pain - despite the topics being trully tragic. Emotions were rather superficial and the immediate attraction love plot didn't help at all, it felt like it lacked tact.

Was this review helpful?

The Alchemy of Flowers was an interesting read with elements off fantasy and reality intertwined. The characters were believable and the overall tone was consistent. I would recommend if you have a sensitivity to certain topics, to look into the book a bit more before reading. Overall, I enjoyed the story and was invested in the characters.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really good book!! I love the themes this book covered, and I loved the way this book went. I do think this would be an amazing book to read for a book club. I recommend it to my book club!!

Thank you to NetGalley, to the author, and to the publisher for this complimentary ARC in exchange for my honest review!!!

Was this review helpful?