Skip to main content

Member Reviews

When Santa Wrote Back is a fun look at just what the title says. I loved every moment of this story. I made certain it was in my store and will be reading it for story time.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness…this book is adorable! I think we should all be reminded it’s better to give than to receive, and the author demonstrated this in such a clever way. It’s light-hearted and fun, and the illustrations are amazing, but the message and soul of the story shines through, and I believe children (and adults too) will benefit from it. I can easily see this being a favorite Christmas book passed down from generation to generation. Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

THIS BOOK WAS INCREDIBLE. My big overgrown self was smiling and enjoying this book, I’ll definitely purchase this to read to my son as he gets older. Such a beautiful message, it’s better to give then to always take. We have to remember to think about others and just not ourselves. Such a beautiful message. I really enjoyed this read.

Thank you NetGalley & Nathan for the opportunity to read this Arc!

Was this review helpful?

This book was so incredibly cute!! Christmas lists have always been a favorite activities that I’ve done with my sisters, daughter, nanny kids, etc. I love seeing all the heartfelt messages to Santa so reading this I couldn’t help but giggle. The message of giving was so sweet and special and I think is a perfect reminder that it’s not about what you get but it’s the thought behind it and what you give! It’s also cute to see Santa have a break and a kid take a walk in his boots. The illustrations were also so fun and pretty. I think this book would be the perfect gift/holiday book!

Was this review helpful?

I received an electronic ARC from SOURCEBOOKS Kids through NetGalley.
Jake learns a hard lesson about giving rather than receiving when Santa responds to his letters that include a 10-page list of toys he wants. Santa tries a gentle approach but then moves to a stronger lesson when Jake refuses to change his "give me" tone. To Jake's shock, Santa listens to his advice and goes on a vacation. This leaves Jake to be Santa. He discovers how much work this is and how rewarding it is when all of the letters and requests start arriving at his home. Of course, Santa returns and helps get everything back to normal. I appreciate the message and hope readers will also understand it. Christopher even offers tips for writing to Santa at the end of the book. The illustrations capture the various emotions in a humorous manner.

Was this review helpful?

This book is so adorable, and a very fun read! The main thing that I liked about this book was the fact that it was written exclusively through the letters between Jake and Santa. It added to the overall uniqueness of this book and, in my opinion, made it a more interesting read. Yet another great thing about the writing was the rhyming pattern that the author used. It added a comfortable tempo to the story, and every single rhyme made sense and fit into the book perfectly. Lastly, since I have nothing bad to say about this book, the humor that was woven into the heart of this story was perfection. I have zero doubt that little kids will be giggling time after time as they read this book during the holiday season. Bravo!

Was this review helpful?

I remember writing letters to Santa as a kid, but he never wrote back. In When Santa Wrote Back, Jake writes a letter to Santa with his list of things he wants. He writes another and then Santa writes back. Jake answers with even more requests for Santa. There is a back and forth until Santa throws his hands up and abdicates his position, with Jake now becoming Santa. This book has a great message about the meaning of giving vs receiving gifts, but in a fun and amusing way. Although it was almost 100 degrees out when we read this book, my youngest got right into the idea of a long list of things he would want. He thought Jake was pretty greedy though and said he would never want all that stuff. We talked about the joy of giving and how it makes you happy to see someone enjoy what you gave them. It actually made me think about how I always tell my kids they don't need to give me anything. I know it makes my grandkids happy to see me open a gift and make a big deal over it. This story has a rhyming cadence, and is easy to read aloud. The illustrations are wonderful, large, colourful and fun to look at. Although the oldest doesn't believe in Santa, he understood the message of giving gifts vs receiving them. We enjoyed this book and I know we will read it again as it gets closer to the holiday.

Was this review helpful?

A quite joyous slice of sprightly seasonal fun. Jake writes a letter to the North Pole with his request list from Santa – and then another. So exasperated with the greedy kid is the old man that he for once replies – but that's not it by far. No, after a few swaps of missives Santa arranges a job swap – he gubbers off with his beach umbrella in his sack, leaving young Jake with the responsibility of being chief global gift-giver. And with the beard.

And all this is in verse? You betcha. Wonderful art, that is kinetic yet not OTT, great characterisation and lore regarding Santa and those who benefit from his delivery service – and of course the child as Santa, really make this distinctive. You can get Christmas films galore where some random old bloke ends up obliged to be generous and giving, but surely it makes more sense to force that upon any relevant child first. Greed is bad, Santa is good, and hopefully kids are too. This to me did so much that is fun and enjoyable and novel – and yet it shouldn't have, for the concept as I say sounds so bleedin' obvious. I should have seen this book years, decades ago – but the fact it came my way more recently is still a great pleasure. There's very little to get in the way of this being awarded a full five stars.

Was this review helpful?

BLUF: a great reminder about the true spirit of Christmas, gently distilled into a humorous back and forth between an initially cluelessly selfish little boy who learns a tough lesson from a fed up Santa.

Overall: 5
Lesson/Plot: 5
Illustrations: 5

Suggested Ages:
Read To: 2-6 y/o
Read By: 5-8 y/o

Mom's Review:
This was such a cute story for the kids! As hard it can be, teaching graciousness, the art of giving back & not taking, less is more, thinking of others, etc., at a young age is crucial. And this book did it superbly!

"A's" Review
(Pending)

"C's" Review
(Pending)

Dad's Review
(Pending)

(Full Traveling Book Family reviews to come!)

A very jolly thank you to Nathan Christopher and Sourcebooks Wonderland for the opportunity to read and review this giggle-inducing, feel-good book!

All reviews are our own.

Was this review helpful?

This is the most adorable book about how to write to Santa and the attitude you should have about requesting gifts. It even has suggestions in the end on how to write a letter. I don't know that I agree with all the hints, but the book is so charming and has a great message.

Was this review helpful?

The best Christmas book I’ve read this year (so far)! The rhymes are delightful, and while I truly felt sorry for little Jack, it’s clear he learned his lesson — and I hope my kids will take the hint too! A wonderful, festive, and meaningful read for the holiday season.

#CampNetGalley

Was this review helpful?

This one is fabulous. I absolutely loved it! Jake's voice is hilarious, the rhymes are fun, and the twist when Santa writes back is perfect. It gave me The Santa Claus vibes in the best way, especially as Jake becomes Santa Claus in job and physically! The illustrations are full of charm and holiday cheer, and the scenes with Santa on vacation are laugh-out-loud funny. One of my favorite parts was the letter-writing tips at the end. It's a smart and meaningful way to tie it all together. This is a definite add to any holiday collection. Funny, festive, and full of heart. A new holiday favorite for sure.

Was this review helpful?

A boy writes a letter to Santa and needs to discover that Christmas is not just about receiving gifts. This would be a good holiday read and good for teaching letter writing. A cute christmas story that reminds readers of Christmas spirit. For grades K-3.

Was this review helpful?

This will be a great addition to holiday picture books! A great lesson about the trappings of wanting more and more during Christmas. The letter writing between child and Santa is perfect!

Was this review helpful?

Just a sweet story of how Jake kept writing Santa and adding more and more things to his list. Santa responds each time with messages of it better to give that receive and Jake doesn't get it. Santa surprise him and he learns the lesson. I appreciate how it is written in letter format, the rhyming, and the message. As a librarian I can see this being read for years to come.

Was this review helpful?

THIS WAS SO FUN. My 3 year old LOVED reading this one before bed and it sparked up a great conversation about the importance of being a good boy and how it's way more fun to make people happy than to receive a gift.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun and silly read with a wonderful message at the heart of it. The back and forth letters were a great way to show the spirit of the holiday. It was especially fun getting to see Jake in the role of Santa. I also appreciated the rhyming used as it created a nice reading cadence for the kids. Also, the illustrations are darling. They’re vibrant, cartoony and fit the festive vibe perfectly. I definitely recommend this one.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited for an opportunity to review a new Christmas book as my kids are big fans of Christmas and anything Santa. This book was advertised as being for kids ages 3-7. The illustrations were great and detailed. While I appreciated the overall morale of this story, I think it may be better suited for ages 5 and up. I am not sure if I will be reading this story to my toddlers.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for this e-copy of When Santa Wrote Back by Nathan Christopher in exchange for a honest review. This is a wonderful rhyming story about a boy named Jake who is more of a taker than a giver and has a long list of gifts he wants from Santa.Santa tells him to change his ways but what happens when he doesn’t.? Santa turns the tables on him and teaches him a valuable lesson.Perfect read for preschoolers!

Was this review helpful?

I read this with my son who is five and he enjoyed it as well as I did. We love Christmas and I teach him that it is not just about receiving gifts but giving-whether that's a gift or help needed. This book was beautifully illustrated and written, cannot wait to buy a physically copy to read more closer to December!

Was this review helpful?