Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you St. Martin's Griffin Press and NetGalley for the eARC of this book.

Sadly, I did not love this as I would have hoped. It was maybe a 2.5 star read for me if I' being generous, but really probably closer to 2. I didn't love the characters, the writing was not my favorite, I really did not jive with the voice of the book. There were consistent typos. The premise was fun, but the execution was subpar for me.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely ADORED this! This is a literal dream for any Austen fans. A mixing pot of tension, humor, whimsy and sentiment, this story was both engrossing and cozy. I love love LOVED this

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful read that was clearly well researched and stayed true to the Austen values. Absolutely loved this. Jane Austen would be proud!

Was this review helpful?

The Austen Affair is a fun, fast-paced enemies-to-lovers romance with a time-travel twist. While I enjoyed the chemistry between Tess and Hugh, I wish there had been more setup to their animosity and stronger world-building. The Regency setting lacked vivid imagery, and the romance would’ve benefited from a deeper foundation. Still, the side characters shined, and the story was enjoyable overall—just not as fleshed out as it could have been.

Was this review helpful?

If you're into that enemies-to-lovers, time-traveling chaos, then you NEED to add this to your TBR. Basically, these two actors, Tess and Hugh, who literally can't stand each other while filming a Northanger Abbey adaptation, get zapped back to Regency England. And let me tell you, the fish-out-of-water moments are hilarious! Their banter is just chef's kiss, and watching Hugh, the super serious method actor, try to navigate Jane Austen's world while Tess, who's a bit more of a hot mess, somehow thrives? Iconic. The chemistry is totally there, and I was genuinely rooting for them to figure out how to get back to their own time and admit their feelings. It's giving "Outlander" meets "Bridget Jones" meets "Pride and Prejudice," but in the best way. Seriously, it's witty, charming, and just a perfect escapist read if you're craving some Regency romance with a modern twist.

Was this review helpful?

Well this was adorable!

I do love Jane Austen, but often I hate when books use her works to make their characters seem deeper than they are. This was thankfully not the case here. I'm glad this book references her lesser known works.

I enjoyed the plot. The influence of Austen can be felt throughout the story and not just when the characters talk about her or her works. The FMC and the MMC feel like they go on their own Austen adventure and I enjoyed the ride.


Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the e-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Cute and fun
Felt a lot like reading a lifetime movie, I wish that it had just a bit more emotional depth

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun read! Two actors find themselves back in time during the time of Austin. Cleverly plotted, character driven and a enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Time travel? Regency era? Jane Austen references? Enemies to lovers? Comedy? If any of those caught your eye then I highly suggest reading this book! Madeline Bell wrote such a good read with this story! I didn’t find it to be a “hard read” but more of an easy and refreshing read, one that just gave me the feel goods every time I picked it up. I read alot of horror and thrillers and this was a PERFECT palate cleanser!

I will say….its always good to study and do your “homework”!

Thank you NetGalley and St. Marten’s Press for the opportunity to read this!

Was this review helpful?

This book is for everyone who went to go see the 20th anniversary of the movie in the movie theaters.
This is not for someone who casually read a Jane Austin book once in their life.
there are so many little tidbits that are gonna go over your head and not make it hit as hard if you’re not a big fan.
I absolutely love this. I’ve read every Jane Austin book multiple times and seen the movies multiple times.

If you take out the time traveling aspect; the familial issues, the friendships, the drama, the romance, all of them take inspiration from the breadth of Austen’s work.

It was so fun to bring in a fantasy aspect to what is for the most part a Regency drama.

It’s like if you took some behind the scenes, movie documentary smashed it outlander and then sprinkled it. Liberally with sense and sensibility. That would be this book.

The FMC is desperately trying to pull herself out of a black hole. The grief that has swallowed her from losing her mother, the anchor of her life, has almost ruined every thing in Tess’s life. The attempts at romantic relationships just fall flat, the tenuous friendships seemingly mean nothing and the job she used to enjoy isn’t enough for her to even try.
So, she battles for her dream role, Catherine Morland, in Northanger Abbey. (FYI MY FAV!)
Through a little luck and no small amount of work and fortitude, she gets the part only to be met with hostility and censure from her male costar who sees her as nothing but a twit in comparison to his gravitas.

I will not lie, I wanted to push the MMC off his high horse straight into the mud for a long time in this book! Ha ha ha, but of course you find out not everything is what it seems with him either.

I enjoyed the complexities in the characters that you’re used to when it comes to Jade Austin novels, how character development is slow and methodical.

Saying all that I still think this book was a fun read, and even if you don’t get every single inside joke, you’ll still be able to feel the heart within this book.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the writing and all the main characters in this story. Reading about this time period and the hints of Jane Austen were really fun. I did not see the romantic chemistry between the couple, and could see them more as friends. I also thought the spicy scene was kind of out of nowhere. Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martins Press for an early copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

Truly the best ARC I have ever read through Net Galley. Stunning. I laughed, I cried. "My dear, no one can be trusted with their own heart. That is why we give them to others for safekeeping". I AM SOBBING.

Was this review helpful?

Given that it is the 250th anniversary of Jane Austen’s birth, this is such a timely tribute to her work and readers who love her books. Madeline Bell crafts a fun, time traveling romance that gives nods to many of Jane Austen’s classics including iconic quotes and locations that readers will identify and enjoy.

Bell kicks off this romance by instantly pulling on your heartstrings for the heroine who has recently lost her mother who was a big Jane Austen fan. I felt for Tess and the grief she carries for her mother. She is currently cast in a movie of Northanger Abby where she is having a tough time connecting with her Method-acting costar, Hugh.

But despite rubbing each other the wrong way, they are thrust back into Regency Era England in a twist of fate and while trying to find a way to return to their time, end up sparking some real chemistry.

This book started off really strong for me because I loved Bell’s humor and writing. I instantly felt like I knew Tess and the grief she was carrying and how important this movie was to her given her mother and her failing career. I also really liked seeing how she used her improv skills so many times in the past to help them blend in.

Yet, soon after their arrival in the past, the story started to lose its charm for me. The storyline seemed to lose its focus (was it more about her grief, Hugh’s cold demeanor, Tess’ history of going all in too soon?) and I didn’t quite buy into their connection despite the need to work together in the past to get home. Unfortunately, I found myself skimming the last bit to get to the end since I wasn’t feeling their chemistry.

While I think this is a fun read for anyone who loves Jane Austen and illustrates Bell’s writing skills, the storyline itself just didn’t pull its weight for me to love it.

*I received an advanced reader copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I just could not get into this book or the world. I appreciate what the author was trying to do and I do think other readers might appreciate it— I just couldn’t buy in.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars - Really enjoyed “The Austen Affair” - a super FUN mash-up of historical romance, time travel & Austen fan-fiction! The two leads (in both Northanger Abby and the Regency time jump) were well written (Hugh’s quite hunky & Tess is quite ditsy) and I loved all the Austen references and call backs. Reminded me so much of “Austenland” too, though that was quite a while ago! Very enjoyable, especially if you are into Jane A. My thanks to Net Galley & the publisher for my advance readers copy - always appreciate the opportunity to read & review early!

Was this review helpful?

This one’s for the time travel romance/ Jane Austen fans

I love when books have a little bit of a magical realism element so this was a fun premise. While you got a good bit about Tessa’s backstory, I felt like we didn’t get a whole lot of her and Hugh before they were thrown j to the past. It kind of just happened very suddenly. Once they are in the past they have to put aside their differences to find a solution to get back as well as to blend in. I wish we would’ve gotten more about why they disliked each other as well as more buildup to them starting to get along but I did enjoy their dynamic.
There were a lot of fun moments between Tessa and Hugh as well as with Hugh’s family and I thought it was fun that they met Jane Austen.
Towards the end of the book Tessa really needed a reality check (which admittedly she does get). It felt like her character did a 180 for no reason and she wasn’t making good choices anymore. Because Tessa and Hugh figure out the solution to their problem very early on and just have to wait for it, most of the book is just them biding their time and we don’t really get a sense of how they feel about being in the past or about going back home. I feel like because of this it was very jarring when Tessa suddenly says she wants to stay and I hadn’t felt like there was a buildup to that.
Overall I did have a few issues with the book and the pacing but it was a fun time travels romance. Thank you to NetGalley and St Martins Griffin for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

A fun enemies-t0-lovers story with a time travel twist. Tess is a bit of a mess. One and a half years after her beloved Mom died, she still awash in grief and loss. She’s just been fired from the staring role in a fantasy TV show and the internet is definitely not happy the she’s been cast as Catherine Moreland in the Northanger Abbey movie remake. Her co star, Hugh is a “stiff upper lip” Englishman who doesn’t like Tess, her messy, big personality, her Americanness, and her desire to pester him to become friends. Despite the fact that they are supposed to be on-screen lovers, they have absolutely no chemistry. After another batched scene, Tess and Hugh end up getting an electric shock in a rain storm and wake up in real Regency England. The two must work together to live 200 years in the past and figure out how to get back to the present. Their mutual dislike and distrust must be overcome and they begin to discover things about themselves and each other that draw them together in many ways. Will they be able to get back to present day, will they learn to trust each other and maybe discover deeper feelings? How would you handle meeting the real Jane Austen at a country ball?

Was this review helpful?

THIS WAS GENUINELY SUCH A GOOD TIME!!! as a girly who will ALWAYS eat up time travel - I LOVED THIS SO MUCH! and these characters had me loling throughout the whole book. if you love the regency era and beautiful, cinematic writing you will LOVE this!!!!

Was this review helpful?

'The Austen Affair' is a delightfuly charming debut that whisks readers away to the Regency Era. Tess Bright, a talented but troubled actress, lands her dream role in a Jane Austen adaptation, only to clash with her co-star, the annoyingly handsome and serious Hugh Balfour. When an electrical accident sends them back in time, they must navigate 19th-century society, relying on each other to survive and find a way back home.
This book shines with its clever dialogue, humorous situations, and a slow-burn romance that will leave you smiling. While it wasn't my absolute favorite, it was an enjoyable read that paid tribute to Jane Austen's legacy and explored themes of second chances and love.
Rating:3.0/5 stars
Would I recommend it? Yes,to fans of historical fiction, comedy, and romance, especially those who enjoy Jane Austen's works."

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the ARC!

This was a cute read featuring time-travel, celebrities and Jane Austen’s regency times. The couple were cute, their discussions were realistic and the setting was described really well, making me feel like I am in England in the regency. Tess was funny and her conflicting feelings due to a recent loss were believable. Hugh was rather annoying at the beginning but grew on me. I’d definitely recommend it

Was this review helpful?