Skip to main content

Member Reviews

OBSESSED. This has literally all of my favorite tropes and I couldn’t put it down. This was so incredibly enjoyable that it’s going on my list of top reads for the year.

Was this review helpful?

Another solid ARC! Where has this author been hiding my whole life (life = these last 4 years I’m been compulsively reading any romance book I can get my grubby hands on).

I really enjoyed this book and would’ve given it five stars if there weren’t so many cringe odes towards Taylor Swift. She is the white womans Jesus Christ.

I really like the pacing of this book, the characters, the storyline, supporting characters and the smut. I really appreciated how there weren’t any time jumps in the story was continuous and progressed. Can’t wait for this author’s next work.

This story follows MacKenzie and Sam (thank you for giving the characters normal names) as they reconnect two years after their respective bands broke up. Chemistry is really good and instant instantaneous and the character growth is good and they both behave like adults which is good.

Was this review helpful?

This book was incredible! The premise, the characters, the writing style. I loved it all. It’s not often you find a book where you genuinely enjoy both main characters AND (most of) the side characters. Mackenzie and Sam were interestingly complex as individuals and their relationship was depicted with such depth and care. Emma Lord did a great job carrying that feeling throughout the whole book. I appreciated how mature Mackenzie and Sam’s relationship was while still getting peeks into the past when they were at a point in their lives when that may not have been the case. The characters were very self aware and reflective on their past selves. It was lovely to have the third act drama not necessarily be a third act break up but more like a bump in the road they knew they would get through together. The ending itself did make it feel like a complete story but I LOVED the epilogue. It really tied everything together with a bow.

Sidebar- I felt like the author took aspects of Taylor Swift and divided them between the three members of the girl group. I loved the way their friendship was shown- both the good and the bad- and I appreciated how that story line got wrapped up in the end as well. I think those relationships were nearly as important as the main couple and I am glad that was never lost in the book.

Thank you NetGalley, Emma Lord, and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. I really enjoyed this read!

Was this review helpful?

So good I couldn’t put this book down. I love any book that’s based around music. This book had the perfect amount of humor, heartbreak, self growth and friendship!

Was this review helpful?

I have always wanted to read a novel by Emma Lord, and I was fortunate enough to do so through an ARC. The cover of the novel is so cute and the plot so intriguing. The story follows Mackenzie Waters and Sam Blaze, both famous singers who were once in rival bands that toured together. After two years away from the public eye, each with their personal reasons for retreating, their label suggests they return to the music scene as a duo, a proposition they reluctantly accept. Under a tight deadline, they revisit their old 'haunts' for inspiration, which brings both nostalgia and unresolved emotions to the forefront.

While this novel is primarily a lighthearted romcom, it also delves into heavier themes such as toxic parenting, illness, absentee parents, and the complexities of past friendships and relationships. I found the friendship between Mackenzie and Serena particularly difficult to understand. I felt Serena's actions were extreme and somewhat convoluted. Additionally, some scenes seemed overly lengthy and wordy, but overall, the novel was a fantastic read. I loved the dual POV and reading the stories from their past into the present and how much they have grown. The romance between Mack and Sam was so sweet and seeing Sam with Ben....swoon. I look forward to reading more novels by Emma.

My sincere thanks to NetGalley for providing the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Obsessed. Emma Lord is an "always immediately yes" for me, she just does not miss!

This will be the perfect beach read this summer! I devoured it in a day and smiled the whole time. I love a used-to-be-famous trope, I love a second chance, and I LOVE a chosen family/girl gang. These characters were so lovable (even when you want to shake them) and the TickTune drama felt quite relevant! My eyes were teary at the end, partly because it was so cute but partly because I wasn't ready to say goodbye to these characters and this story!

I loved every second of it, and I think if you enjoy Emily Henry, Abby Jimenez, or books like Honey and Daisy Jones & the Six, you'll really love this one too!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for my honest opinion!

Was this review helpful?

From the beginning I was obsessed with the characters. Honestly, I thought the whole band thing would be a con for me, but I ended up liking the dynamic a lot. The back and forth between the main characters was incredible. I loved that they had a past & that we were able to see into it as the book went along. This is such an easy, fun read and the perfect rom com to read in a day! The ending was fantastic and the epilogue was a great way to tie up the story.

I also really enjoyed the side characters and how they were brought into this to show other aspects of the main characters' lives. Not only were they dealing with their careers and romantic relationship, they also had friends and family that they were balancing relationships with. That added a dynamic to this book that I really liked.

There were a few tears shed, which makes me love a book even more. Will 100% recommend this book! + the cover is so so good!

Was this review helpful?

Ok was very excited for this one based on the blurb!! It definitely drew me in and I needed to keep reading. I finished it in one sitting! I loved the vibe of being old pop stars together with the tension they created for the public eye (but really it was real too). I loved how their love story played out. There were some cheesy things that were distracting (the snapchat/tiktok app she was posting music on) and the drama that came from it. The conflict was all blah to me but I'm glad it didn't really get in the way of their relationship.

Was this review helpful?

Mackenzie Waters and Sam Blaze are both in famous bands and have a pretty “historic” rivalry. Years after they’ve returned to normal life, their labels suggest a way to return on the music scene but, this time, as a duo.

With each song they co-author, they learn something new about the other that makes them realize they never gave real friendship a chance. They didn’t know each other back then, but now, through the vulnerability and transparency, the real Mack and Sam have a chance to come out. No need to be scared—the water’s fine.

As a millennial who exclusively listened to punk rock music in high school, this is how I imagined our protagonists:
Mackenzie was somewhere between Avril Lavigne circa 2007 with the pink streaks in her blonde hair and Margot Robbie’s aesthetic in the Barbie movie. Some moments between Thunder Hearts reminded me of the Cheetah Girls too. I’m a girl’s girl, so if you give me GIRLHOOD, I am sat. I loved the storyline of the girls and their musical career!
Why did Sam remind me of Captain Hook from Once Upon a Time? It’s the charm and the ease and the cockiness that then turns into a really sweet, tender admiration for Mack. I love that he didn’t waver and knew what he wanted. There was only forward with him—no steps back! His honesty and transparency shined through the whole book. I love how clear he was—he didn’t play games.

This book is filled with:
⚡️ a smooth, former punk-rocker MMC
💖 a glittery pop-princess FMC
🧁 hilarious dessert abominations
✨ secret identities and sparkly outfits
🎸 a “Music and Lyrics” collab songwriting vibe
💖 enemies to lovers and second chances
🎶 a glimpse into the music world
❤️‍🔥 found family and emotionally-mature conversations
🪩 lower stress and super cute ending

While this trope isn’t one that I always reach for, I have been nothing but impressed with Emma Lord’s writing. This book wasn’t stressful and was just the perfect amount of “running away from reality” for me. Mack and Sam felt like they were made for each other and once they understood who the other was, their love instantly bloomed. Emma Lord paced their growth as a couple—but also as individuals—in a beautiful way.

I love that it was set in New York City, the magical place where former band members can own a bar and host runway shows. I loved imagining the buildings and city streets and the walks down the block. It made me nostalgic for city life!

Thanks to NetGalley and Rivka Holler with St. Martin’s Press for providing this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this newest book by Emma Lord!! It’s a sweet romance novel told with alternating chapters between the main characters Mackenzie and Sam. As their story unfolds, parts of their history are slowly revealed, allowing the reader to understand things that Mack and Sam don’t yet see for themselves.

There are multiple themes woven in involving family, friendship, and the complexities of the music business. The main theme is finding oneself and being true to your heart.

There weren’t as many descriptions of decadent foods incorporated into this novel, but Ben’s creations were entertaining.

Thank you to #NetGalley and #St.Martin’sPress for an eARC of #FortheRecord by #EmmaLord - 5 stars - unputdownable

Was this review helpful?

This was good. The plot was fun and a cute second chance romance. It would make a good summer read. I liked the girl band background, and if you like celeb romances, you’ll enjoy this

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book! Musical rivals , second chance, found family and yearning what else do you need 😩Emma Lord always does a great job at writing characters with substance will giving you all the feels and just enough spice.

Was this review helpful?

There was a lot I liked about this book, especially in the first half. Mackenzie and Sam, the main characters, have interesting backstories that don’t feel rehashed. I often find myself not paying a lot of attention to or caring about side characters, so I was impressed with how this book really made almost all of them distinct, memorable, and relevant to the plot. The writing was good, but it feels like the book could do with quite a bit more editing. My biggest issue with the book is that the Serena/Rocket/Tick Tune plotline felt superfluous - the main relationship and the character development would work just as well if it was omitted or significantly reduced.

Was this review helpful?

This cute rom-com follows two musicians as they rekindle their prior romance. With strong character development and awesome side characters, the story is a fun read. Absolutely loved the banter and chemistry between our main leads! This book touches on a couple of serious topics delicately, which Emma Lord handles exceptionally well in all her books. As always, I can't wait to listen to the audiobook!

Was this review helpful?

Ruby, doesn't he love? She's okay, being by yourself, running her bookstore with her bestie and taking care of neighborhood star cat sampson rubies, roommate Sam and best friends, sense school dance. Unfortunately, believes in true love and believes in having a partner believes in the Fairytale. She uh unknowing to ruby signs them up for a singles cruise imagine rubies feelings when she gets on the boat and realizes what's going on forced to engage in the singles activities or deal with the lecturerous men on her own. And she goes all in and meets cameron, and they began a fake relationship, so they can get out of the singles nonsense they have a lot of missteps, and a lot of things calamity, that ensues, when in port and on the ship, in the end can Ruby let go of her past and her fears a d take the happiness or will she stay true to her belief she's okay alone, it was very cute.I enjoyed it definitely recommend. A very fun romcom

*** the main characters in the novel are from England not a big deal. But I like to know that when I'm going to read a book just because yeah, I can get ready for the slang and the different types of words that are used. So just uh, heads up.The main characters are from England

Thank you, net galley for the arc in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Two prior artist who have deep rivals, or so everyone is made to think.

Mackenzie and Sam have toured and played together for year as their bands were made to look like big rivals in the public eye.. After taking a break from the scene for a bit both have decided that they would like to jump back into the fray but not with their prior bands. As they write their new songs emotions from before start to come to the surface for the two stars. Little do the two know that their prior feelings will affect their current ones and the future of their careers.

Was this review helpful?

Mackenzie and Sam are rivals with their respective bands.... Their band falls apart and they move on with their separate lives.... They decide to revive their careers together with a joint album two yrs later....

Love the sass... so much fun and humour. Enjoy their chemistry too. The banter is top-notched. So many LOL scenes. A fun romance.

Thanks to the publisher for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Give me all of Emma Lord’s Books! This might be my favorite book yet. Honestly I don’t think there’s a book that I haven’t loved but this one is probably my favorite. Rivalry, music, love. Give me it all. Yes please!

Was this review helpful?

OK I actually loved this one! This was my first read by Emma Lord and I'm looking forward to reading more! This book was cute, funny, romantic and had just a touch of spice! Can't wait to read more books by this author! Thank you NetGalley for my ARC! 4 stars!

Was this review helpful?

"For the Record" by Emma Lord is a charming and heartwarming YA romance. It follows Natalie, a high school journalist with big dreams, as she navigates first love, demanding editors, and the complexities of staying true to herself. Lord's writing is witty and engaging, and the characters are relatable and endearing. It's a delightful read perfect for anyone who enjoys a sweet and funny story with a touch of journalistic flair.

Was this review helpful?