I enjoyed this one! I liked Jorie's sections the most, but overall I really liked the whole book. I loved the portions about the film, and I thought it did atmospheric horror really well. I loved the interstitial sections! Very creepy and highly recommended, especially for people that love horror movies!

I really wanted to love this one. Despite the wonderfully eerie and ominous vibes of the story and despite the fact that I myself would have loved to join a young Jordi on her film haunts, I was left disappointed. The book ended up dragging and what I originally felt was atmospheric became tedious. I would be willing to give the author another chance in the future but unfortunately this one didn't work for me.

I think this concept had potential, but honestly I was bored by this book. I found myself wanting to skip long sections, especially the interlude chapters which didn’t feel like they added anything new to the lore we already got from the narrative. I also didn’t think that including Trevor’s POV was necessary; you could have removed all those chapters and the book would’ve had the same plot structure. [SPOILER HERE] Jorie wasn’t nearly freaked out enough by Beth’s death (which was so annoying because I actually liked Beth as a character) in my opinion. That scene was like two pages, but we spent ten reading blog posts about demons? [END SPOILER] The ending was way too abrupt, especially in a nearly 400 page book. It felt really unsatisfying to spend all that time and (sometimes excruciatingly slow) build up to kind of just… end. [SPOILER HERE] Also, the “Helene Enriquez is Leah Compton” reveal was somehow both entirely predictable and completely nonsensical since we got so little characterization of Leah beyond “she’s kind of a strange neighbor.” Plus Enriquez was SO corny as a villain at the end. [END SPOILER] The author clearly loves the analogue horror genre, and again I liked this concept and the imagery of the film, but overall I was not super engaged with this book.

"The October Film Haunt" is a short story by Michael Wehunt, an American author known for his work in the horror and weird fiction genres.

Michael Wehunt's work is often praised for its atmospheric and unsettling storytelling, and "The October Film Haunt" is no exception. The story explores themes of horror, nostalgia, and the power of film to shape our perceptions of reality.

Michael Wehunt's The October Film Haunt is a captivating horror novel that delves into the unsettling intersection of urban legends, the influence of media, and the collective psyche. The narrative centers around a cursed horror film that blurs the lines between fiction and reality, ensnaring its viewers in a web of fear and obsession.

Wehunt's prose is both poetic and chilling, creating an atmosphere that is as thought-provoking as it is terrifying. The novel's exploration of how shared beliefs can manifest tangible horrors is reminiscent of classic horror tales, yet it offers a fresh perspective that resonates with contemporary anxieties. The blending of past and present timelines adds depth to the story, allowing readers to witness the origins of the curse and its evolution over time.

The characters are well-developed, each grappling with their own demons and connections to the haunting film. Their personal journeys are intertwined with the overarching mystery, adding emotional weight to the suspenseful plot. The novel also raises intriguing questions about the nature of belief and the power of media in shaping our realities.

While some readers may find certain aspects of the plot predictable, the novel's emotional depth and exploration of modern themes offer a fresh take on the horror genre. The atmospheric storytelling and complex characters make it a worthwhile read for fans of psychological horror and those interested in the darker facets of human nature.

In conclusion, The October Film Haunt is a masterful blend of horror and psychological thriller, showcasing Michael Wehunt's talent for crafting stories that are both intellectually stimulating and genuinely frightening. The novel's exploration of media influence, collective belief, and personal trauma offers a compelling narrative that will resonate with readers long after they turn the final page.

The October Film Haunt is a perfect read for fans of cursed movies / films and possession stories! This was very much a cover-read for me at first, because wow, that cover is absolutely gorgeous and unsettling; and this turned into a great experience of judging a book by its cover.

Jorie and her friends once ran a successful internet group about their favorite films, sharing their love of movies through behind-the-scenes, on site explorations. But when they got on location for the infamous movie “Proof of Demons”, things went very wrong. Years later, a VHS tape is mailed to Jorie, and she learns that the nightmare that began that night is not over yet.

I really enjoyed the mixed-media elements in The October Film Haunt; I am a huge fan of mixed media incorporated into novels, especially horror books. It draws me into the story and makes everything feel unnervingly realistic, and I thought this book did that very well. For me, the atmosphere of The October Film Haunt is probably its strongest element; the whole book had this creeping sense of dread and paranoia that compliments the story beautifully.

There are parts of the book that were a little slower for me, but the pacing makes sense for the story; this book isn’t a slasher, it’s more of a dread-inducing slow burn. There were a few characters I didn’t relate to as much as others, but Josie the main character is very well written and sympathetic, so that balanced the story out for me.

I would recommend this book to fans of Silver Nitrate and Burn the Negative, as well as to readers who love stories about cursed films with elements of mixed media and dread-inducing pacing.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the arc! All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.

Proof of Demons a mysterious film by an unknown occult film creature, the Pine Arch Creature, a demonic entity summoned by a transfiguration ritual that also opens up a moving hole that allows you to look into hell, the October Film Haunt, a group of three who travel to horror film locations and document their findings, COUNT ME IN!

After the October Film Haunts episode on The Proof of Demons leads to a teen death, harsh backlash from the online community, and the breakup of the group (Jorie, Beth, Colin) Jorie moves away with her young son trying to put it all in the past. Over ten years later a VHS film shows up and recommences the mystery of the film with the start of a potential sequel. Jorie is forced to play out the sequel and all its evilness in reality.

The set up was exceptional, Jorie the main character and her son were engaging, and the demonic entity was hair raising. The pacing lagged a bit in the middle of the book, could have cut a bit out, but the intensity of the ending makes up for it. The book was a nice blend of the supernatural, the occult, and reality. Fans of found footage films and books will definitely love this one. It was a very entertaining read so put this one on your list. The book was based on a short story in Greener Pastures written by Wehunt, I’ll need to read that as well. The book will be available September 30, 2025.

I wanted to love this one but unfortunately it was a struggle to finish. Some parts were amazing while other parts dragged and felt clunky. I loved the elements and overall premise but it also felt entirely predictable. It was more of a good try, not so good execution.

The October Film Haunt
Michael Wehunt
Publication Date: September 30

4.5 / 5
I friggin loved this book.

VERY ominous and creepy, atmospheric horror.
Nothing about this book is fast paced though, so it's not going to mesh with everyone's horror sensibilities, but I thought it worked perfectly as a super eerie, "haunted film", meta-horror slow burn.

A smorgasborg of horror... this book felt like a hybrid of Suzuki's Ringu, Tremblay's Horror Movie, Pessl's Night Film, and Danielewski's House of Leaves .... with a healthy dose of creepy pasta on the side.

If my comparisons intrigue you in any way, I urge you to pick it up, and give it a read... It's a hard novel to shake.

4.5 / 5

The title of this book is the name of a trio who visit horror film sites and blog about them. One film, titled ‘Proof of Demons,’ gains a hardcore following, and after a real life tragedy, a sequel is being made by a cult of the film’s fans. But now, Jorie, a member of the Film Haunt who has left the horror scene, is being forced to star in the sequel by the original film’s fans/cult and director, who have oddly enabled a supernatural creature to help them.

I’ve been loving the trend of horror film-themed novels, and author Wehunt blends this with another recent trend, Internet influence, and has created a genuinely unsettling tale where the reader is often required to decipher what’s actually happening or what is part of an otherworldly slant.

This could’ve used a bit of tightening up, as a few areas drag for a bit, making the story slow down at times, which is difficult to say about an otherwise very well-written novel. But the payoff is certainly worth the reader’s time, and one chapter features a possession scene from the human point of view that hasn’t been done this effectively since Michael Laimo’s novel THE DEMONOLOGIST 20 years ago.

A fine addition to the crop of horror film-themed horror novels, Wehunt’s debut was well worth the wait for those who have been following his short fiction (he has two published collections). I’m eager to see what’s next.

5 stars

Ten years ago Jorie Stroud, Beth Kowalczyk and Colin Davies made up the October Film Haunt, a popular online group that visited the locations of their favorite film haunts. They were really going places…until the night it all went bad, when they visited the Arden, North Carolina (my parents used to live there! It’s a suburb of Asheville.) graveyard location for the cult classic “Proof of Demons,” a film by Helene Enriquez. What did they see that night? What did they experience? And why did a high school student named Hannah Kim have to die?

Now Jorie lives life as a semi-recluse with her young son Oli when she gets a VHS tape in the mail. Is someone filming her? Is there a connection to “Proof of Demons?”

This horror story won’t necessarily work for everyone, but I absolutely loved everything about this. First, I’m a sucker for well done stories about haunted film…NIGHT FILM by Marsha Pessl is one of my all time favorites. This has that vibe. The story is told primarily from Jorie’s POV, but also from several others and there are also scattered Interludes which are articles, blog posts, etc. The story works as great horror but also has interesting things to say about religion and faith. It’s not a perfect book, but it was perfect for me and I appreciated everything the author had going on here. Gimme more!!!

I really struggled with this one. The writing felt clunky, making it hard to stay engaged, and the story dragged more than it built suspense. It’s definitely more in the realm of cultish, found-footage-style horror—think Blair Witch rather than anything remotely like Stephen King. The atmosphere was unsettling, but the execution didn’t work for me. The disjointed storytelling, mixed media elements, and slow pacing made it a challenge to push through. If you enjoy ambiguous, meta-style horror, this might be for you, but it wasn’t for me.

I was excited for this one. It’s been awhile since I read a good horror book.

This one had moments where you could see the glimmer of a good book but it never fully got there. The characters didn’t land for me and there were parts where I struggled to read them and times I considered DNF. I added an extra star since I did make it through the book.

Thanks to NetGallery and the publisher for this Arc in exchange for my honest review.

I really had high hopes for this novel—it seemed right up my alley, speaking to the "weird horror movie" fan in me. And while parts of it were fantastic, others just didn’t hold my attention. There were moments I really enjoyed, but others dragged, making the story feel sluggish. I had no clue what was going on for a good portion of the book—which is usually something I love—but by the end, when everything was finally introduced, I just felt... dissatisfied.

I definitely enjoyed the beginning more than the end. The storyline surrounding Jorie, Beth, and Olie kept me engaged, but the side stories with Coleman, Trevor, etc., while necessary for the final outcome, didn’t hold my interest. At times, I just wanted to push through to see how it all played out. Honestly, up until the final 20%, I had no idea if this would be a 1-star or a 5-star read. In the end, it landed at a solid 3 for me.

That said, I can see why others might rate it higher—maybe even a 4 or 5. It just didn’t hit that level for me. But don’t take my word for it! This might just not be my trope. If the summary intrigues you, give it a shot—what fell short for me might be a hidden gem for you.

𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬
I want to start by expressing my gratitude for the effort and dedication that goes into being an author. It truly pains me to say this, but I did not enjoy this book at all. I almost put it down without finishing, but I felt it was important to complete it for a fair review. I struggled to engage with the story, as it often seemed to prioritize horror elements over delivering a compelling narrative. I was hoping for a deeper connection with the characters, but they felt more like props to enhance the atmosphere rather than fully realized individuals. I found myself confused by some of the characters, and it took me much longer to finish this book than I expected, despite its relatively short length.

Thank you NetGalley and St Martin Press for allowing me to review this ARC.

This review is kind of hard to write because I thought the idea was good, and I liked a lot of the elements in the story, but for some reason, I just couldn’t get into it and stay into it, and I’m not sure why because this is the kind of book I usually can. It really has everything I want and enjoy in a book and a plot. I don’t know if it’s the way it was written. It seemed a little drawn out and repetitive at times. I felt like I was being talked at, if that makes sense. I also had a hard time keeping track of all the people and all the different things going on. There were a few POVs, which I usually don’t have issues with, but for some reason, I had a hard time with this one. Maybe it’s just because there were a few POVs that I wasn’t all that interested in. I just didn’t connect with all of the characters the same.

I did enjoy the premise of the story and the way that the internet, found footage, and epistolary media were included. It did give me an eerie, paranoid feeling as I read it. I wouldn’t say fever dream, necessarily, but a little bit like when you’re in a dream and things feel disjointed and just out of reach. I think he created a creepy and unbalanced (in a good way) atmosphere really well— because of that, I went ahead and gave it four stars. Just because I couldn’t get into it well, doesn’t mean someone else won’t be able to.

The end wasn’t what I was expecting, but it felt a little longer than necessary and there were a few times I had a hard time not being a little bored. It was mentioned in the acknowledgments it started as a short story, and I think maybe as a short story it would be great, but as a whole book it seemed a little long. I think I might revisit the book around Halloween and see what it does for me then.

With all that being said, I do think you should give it a try! It’s not a bad book at all!

P.S. Jorie Stroud? Laurie Strode? Eh?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this ARC.

This had a great premise, but I ended up feeling like the story dragged on a bit. I loved the twists and the plot, but felt it was a bit stereotypical and predictable, Didn't love it, but was still a fast paced thriller!

Something was missing through out this whole book. It took me out of the book many times and I just couldn't keep my mind in the universe of the book.

This was such a good book. I loved the story and the writing so much. The characters were great and the story flowed smoothly. Will definitely read more books by this author in the future.

This book was so much fun. If you’re a fan of classic horror, you’ll love all the little references sprinkled throughout. The first one I noticed was the main character’s name — Jorie Stroud — an homage to Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) from Halloween. I’ll leave the rest for you to find.

The horror in this book is somehow both visceral and ambiguous. Like I could feel it in my bones while reading, but the actual horrors (to keep it spoiler free) kept morphing and changing in my mind. Not because of lacking descriptions, but because that was just the nature of it. A little glitchy like an old roll of film. I loved that.

If you prefer to have everything super concrete and spelled out for you, I don’t think this is the book for you. But if you’re willing to roll with the vibes and let your imagination run a little wild, definitely pick this one up.

Throughout reading this book I couldn’t help thinking about the show Supernatural, specifically Season 1 Episode 17, Hell House. The episode asks the question, is it possible to bring a monster into being simply because enough people believe in it? Is a viral post on the internet enough to make your worst nightmare a reality?

This book asked some similar questions and I’m still mulling them over well after finishing my read.