Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I absolutely adored Over the Sea to Skye! Returning to this series felt like coming home — the vivid, emotional storytelling and the stunning setting of the Isle of Skye swept me away once again. Valentina’s journey through heartbreak, healing, and rediscovery was so moving, and I couldn’t get enough of her connection with Xander. Their chemistry leapt off the page, and the warmth of her time with her sisters added so much heart. This book is a beautiful reminder that sometimes, the most unexpected detours lead us exactly where we’re meant to be. I already can’t wait for the next installment!

Was this review helpful?

Set against the stunning backdrop of the Isle of Skye, this book is a heartwarming addition to the trilogy about the adopted 'Skye Sisters'. While it works as a standalone, having read the previous books definitely adds depth and makes it more enjoyable to reconnect with familiar characters. It’s not just a compelling romance—there are several unexpected twists that keep the story fresh and engaging. My only real disappointment was how quickly it wrapped up, but overall, it’s a fantastic read with rich characters and a beautiful setting that pulls you in from the start.

Was this review helpful?

Just lovely to catch up with Valentina, Ezzie and Thea. This story is Valentina’s and her life with her son Barnaby and the news that her and Gary are no longer together. It’s another lovely, well written story that still makes me want to visit Skye.
My thanks as always to NetGalley and to publisher Avon Books UK | Avon

Was this review helpful?

A lovely return to Skye with the Wynter sisters. This book delves much deeper into Valentina's life and family situation. It was lovely to catch up with all the characters and once again the setting of the book was beautifully described. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book in the series which follows the Wynter sisters. It was wonderful to be back in Skye catching up with the characters from the previous books but, if you haven't read these don't worry as it can very much be read a s a stand alone story. This story's focus is Valentina who has recently separated from her husband (Gary) who has run off with her very young assistant making home and work awkward. Deciding to take voluntary redundancy she is going to spend the summer with her son near her sisters.
Wanting to get away from everything and recharge her batteries before she starts the next stage of her life she knows her recently beautifully renovated holiday cottage will provide the escape and family support she needs.
However, as we know things never go to plan and a blast from the past, an American tourist and a few other surprises make this summer quite a rollercoaster and definitely one she won't forget.
Beautifully written, in a stunning location with heart warming characters - a perfect summer read and definitely one i would recommend as a holiday read to my friends.

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn’t love a book about this family? It’s like visiting old friends and just falling back into place as if you’ve never been apart! I really loved this story, the writing is so good, and the descriptions really help you feel like you’re actually there. Valentina much deserves her happy ending, and I loved Xander’s story. I think my favourite part though is the friendship between MacDonald and Barnaby, so sweet!
Go and read this book, it feels like holidays, sitting on the beach with a cocktail and loving life!

Was this review helpful?

Reading this book was like sinking into the embrace of a well-worn armchair, the kind that knows your shape and welcomes you back every time. It’s like walking into a room full of people you know well, but haven’t seen for a while, and your heart sings. This is a gorgeous series and I’m sad it’s just a trilogy.

When Valentina’s husband left her, for her assistant – a good 20 years younger than him, Valentina was devastated – not least for her seven-year-old son Barnaby who missed his Dad when he disappeared without trace. Valentina took Barnaby to her summer cottage on the Isle of Skye to be near her two sisters and for some morale support. When her husband finally gets in touch and wants to meet up, he doesn’t turn up. What has happened? Added to that Valentina plays good Samaritan to Xander and his nephew McDonald at the station when they are stranded, and gives them a lift. From then on Valentina and Xander’s paths seem to intersect fairly often – which helps Barnaby and McDonald as they keep each other amused despite the disparity in their ages.

A gorgeous story, well told, and it was wonderful to revisit so many ‘old friends’.

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7506153065

https://maddybooksblog.blogspot.com/2025/04/over-sea-to-skye-skye-sisters-trilogy.html

Was this review helpful?

What a fantastic book to finish this trilogy.
I love all the characters and the setting is amazing. I need to visit the Isle of Skye. Thank you Sue Moorcroft for providing us pure escapism reads.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Valentina is heading back to Skye with her son Barnaby after the break up of her marriage. She meets Zander on the train with his nephew who her son takes a shine to they are both heading to Skye as well trying to piece together their own family history.
Skye offers Valentina a great healing place as she starts to feel much more like herself along with her two sisters she bumping along nicely so she dosnt need Zander Courage to mix things up. Can she let go of her past to forge a future.
Great to catch up with the sisters and be back in Skye. Loving this series brilliant.

Was this review helpful?

"Over the Sea to Skye" is the concluding novel in Sue Moorcroft's wonderful Wynter sisters trilogy. It's sad to think that this is the last we will read about them and the wonderful island where they have chosen to live.

This book focuses on the oldest sister Valentina in the aftermath of the breakdown of her marriage. She is the last of the sisters to complete her DNA test and follow up on the results. Meanwhile Thea has her baby, and Ezzie continues to manage her partner's "holiday home" as a a visitor attraction. Of course, there is also some romance and plenty of wonderful descriptions of the Isle of Skye.

Thanks to Net Galley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to receive this third book in the Skye sisters trilogy as I’d really enjoyed the first two. This third instalment did not disappoint. Another really warm read about Valentina this time, the eldest of the sisters who is adjusting to life after separation in her new holiday home. It’s a beautiful setting, the bond between the sisters is well written and the story kept me engaged.

Was this review helpful?

I have really loved this trilogy about three adopted sisters living on the Isle of Skye. Each book is about one of the sister’s life story. They have all been fabulous reads and this final instalment has been a wonderful conclusion. I am a great fan of Sue’s books. I highly recommend you read this series you won’t be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Another great book in this series, bringing an emotional journey along the way as we get to know Valentina in more detail but still not forgetting her sisters and their own stories.

Was this review helpful?

Read and reviewed in exchange for a free copy from NetGalley. I really enjoy Sue Moorcroft's books, and I particularly loved this one. Although I read the first in the Skye Sisters trilogy, I don't particularly remember it (not a reflection of the book by any means, just my poor story retention), the second unfortunately passed me by. While I feel I missed out on some of the backstory having not read the second, it did not hinder my enjoyment of this one. Moorcroft completely brings you into her characters' worlds, and I was engaged through out. A lovely read.

Was this review helpful?

Book Review: Over the Sea to Skye by Sue Moorcroft
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

Sue Moorcroft once again crafts a beautifully emotional and uplifting tale with Over the Sea to Skye, the third installment in the Skye Sisters Trilogy. Set against the breathtaking scenery of the Isle of Skye, this book is a soulful blend of escapism, romance, and the power of starting over.

Valentina Taylor, reeling from the fallout of a broken marriage, seeks solace on Skye with her adorable young son, Barnaby. What starts as a summer retreat slowly turns into a journey of rediscovery—of love, self-worth, and the kind of peace that only a windswept shore and crashing waves can bring. Enter Xander Courage, the charming American with a heart full of secrets and just enough emotional baggage to match Valentina’s. Their chance meeting on a train is pure romantic fate, and their undeniable chemistry brings warmth to even the stormiest chapters.

The novel perfectly captures the magic of Skye—its wild beauty, close-knit community, and calming rhythm—while delivering a story rich in heart and emotional complexity. Moorcroft explores themes of motherhood, healing, and found family with a light but meaningful touch. Valentina’s relationships with her sisters, Thea and Ezzie, offer moments of laughter and tenderness, grounding the romance in a deep, familial core.

Verdict: Over the Sea to Skye is a stunning conclusion to a beloved trilogy, perfect for fans of second chances, windswept romances, and strong women finding their way. It’s an ideal summer read that will leave your heart full and your suitcase metaphorically packed for the Scottish coast.

Was this review helpful?

This book is the third in the trilogy about sisters Thea, Ezzie and Valentina, set on the Isle of Skye. This is Valentina's story, and it does work as a standalone, however I would suggest they are read in order due to ongoing story elements that flow throughout the books.

Valentina and young son Barney head to Skye for the summer after the break up of Valentina's marriage, meeting American Xander and his nephew Macdonald on the journey. The book follows the story of Valentina's summer, with familial mishaps and new found friendships occurring along the way. I loved revisiting Skye and old favourite characters, it was comforting to read more about them. This was probably however my least favourite of the three books in the series, it felt drawn out at times with an abrupt ending, however it was well written and I cannot wait to see what Sue Moorcroft writes next.

Was this review helpful?

The third book in the trilogy and a thoroughly enjoyable read. Delivered with the heartwarming and emotional goings on in the family dynamics of the Wynter sisters. I do really enjoy Skye and the surrounding area settings and it really sets the tone for a lovely afternoon read. I read feeling like I wish I was there too!
There's always so much going on without being too heavy and weighted, with the continued themes of adoption and family throughout as with the previous two books for Ezzie and Thea's characters too. I really like the realistic approach and viewpoint of Valentina with her situation.
Plus, my own hometown was mentioned which is always a nice little bonus!!

Book number three in a series, but could be read as a standalone- however catching up with everyone and watching their stories and lives develop and entwine together is something I would definitely recommend

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book in a trilogy, all of which are excellent reads. It is helpful to read the other two books first to get the full pleasure from how each of the three sisters develop in their lives. This book focuses on Valentina, the oldest of the three adopted sisters and how her life continues after her husband leaves her for her assistant, who is half her age. The book takes a good look at the nature on Skye, the weather, the beach and what life is like on a calm island. This is a great backdrop to Valentina finding who she is as a single mum to Barnaby and exploring what her life means to her now.

Was this review helpful?

this is the last in the series where we have been following the lives of three sisters. and i tell you what i was just done to perfection. i have loved all of these books. infact scrap that because its Sue Moorcroft and i have loved EVERY single one of all the books of hers ive read. like many of my favorite authors of this genre i could just feel my heart beating harder, cozier and warmer as i read this. i could sit and read them all day. or maybe its because i want to be adopted by the place and people in these books. or at least know them? go stay with them? come on surely one of the characters wants to invite me over for the summer too?
alas it looks like i will simply hav to love the book and wait for Sues next when. and love every minute of the time i spend in this community while i can.
in this book we are back in Skye. with the summer season bringing new sight and smells and descriptions that perfectly bring back what i remember of the island. this book we look to Valentina. but what i also love about this book is how just because the main focus is on her story, the others never fade and are still as important. it feels real and makes a bigger connection to all three of them and their tales.
Valentina is not doing ok. her marriage has collapsed and so she flees to the island of skye with her young boy to be with her sisters.
but Valentina isnt going to be given an easy ride. and when another event happens she has to face even more challenging times. not only that but a seemingly chance meeting on the train leaves her with all sorts of unexpected and what she deems unwanted at this time!
i loved just how real Valentina and her emotions at this time were. the relationship with her young son was fantastic and i could relate so much to his little feelings and interactions which were often confused and heightened by what was going on for his mum and dad. how Valentina handled this was not always perfect but felt full of love all the same. it was a woman doing the best she can and not always making wise choices or behaving rationally at such an emotionally impacted time.
oh add to that there might be a brother on the horizon? being adopted this brings a whole other level of emotional strife to our sister. and shes going to need her sisters and the island all the way. which of course she has whole heartedly. and this is actually the biggest story of love throughout all the books. ive been rooting for them all from the beginning. and im only sad now thinking this is the end? no! do we not need to go back and learn something more? cant we come back to them please? you see this is the problem with brilliant writers and brilliant books. you never really want them to leave or end.
the relationships are all so beautifully told. not only with eachother but how interwoven they are with the island, with the scenes set you can imagine the landscape and island around them.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for this ARC.
I have read many Sue Moorcroft books, I love her Christmas books. I have read the two preceding books in this trio logo and loved them both….
I thought this was an easy read, and it was good but it felt too predictable from the start. And although the other characters had had their own stair idea previously there wasn’t much about them at all in this book.

Was this review helpful?