The Proposal Project was a light, fun rom com that had two rivals who had to work together to plan their best friends' proposal.

As someone who is a self proclaimed hater of the miscommunication trope, I actually though this was done really well in this book that it didn't make me want to throw the book across the room. I loved getting into Priscilla and Oliver's story. This gave me such hard 2000s rom com vibes with the way this made me laugh out loud and had moments that had me kicking my feet at the adorable cheesiness.

I really connected with Priscilla with her over thinking inner monologue and I found her silly choices so on brand for an early 2000s rom com. Oliver had me kicking my feet and blushing while I read at night his POVs. He was so swoon worthy and had me powering through this book so fast.

This book was such a fun ride, I would 100% recommend this. This would be such a fun breach or pool read.

I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

This was an engaging read! I enjoyed the plot and would read it again.

This fake dating/frienemies-to-lovers story had me hooked! And when you start to see the clues that Oliver has liked Pricilla the whole time…excuse me while I swoon! The dynamic between these two throughout the whole book was electric. When Oliver and Pricilla spend more one-on-one time it had me kicking my feet and squealing! It’s so clear that they are meant to be together.

My one small critique is the theme of the miscommunication trope was present through about 75% of the book. To me, this is a very frustrating trope when it is drawn out. I will say however the author did a great job at keeping me hooked and wanting to see what happened! The spice took a while to heat up but when it did oh my!! I was clutching my non-existent pearls!

Overall this is a great read if you are into rom-coms and fake dating!

When Priscilla is laid off from her event planning job, but her tech bestie Tina wants to propose to her boyfriend Ryan with a huge spectacle, you’d think there would be smooth sailing. Except, Ryan is also planning a surprise proposal and the only way to prevent Ryan from spoiling Tina’s grand plan? Priscilla has to work with Oliver, Ryan’s best friend and her sworn enemy, to join forces and plan a double surprise proposal.

This is an easy read of enemies to lovers involving fake dating and forced proximity.
Priscilla comes across a bit immature, even after we find out the miscommunication that happened in the past between her and Oliver. It’s the lack of conflict that doesn’t contribute to the character growth for Priscilla, but you still like her as a FMC.

I would have loved Oliver’s POV throughout this story. It did have some laugh out loud moments, as well as some tender moments too.

While we see everyone get their HEA, the plot hole of Malcom (the whole reason behind Priscilla’s firing) left me wanting a level of conflict to support Priscilla’s growth.

Overall, 3.5 ⭐️ 1 🌶️

Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for the digital ARC of The Proposal Project by Donna Marchetti!

Ahhh! This book was so good—I’m obsessed. Donna Marchetti’s writing style is so fun and engaging; I flew through this.

Priscilla was such a well-rounded, hilarious character. Her flaws felt real, her growth was satisfying, and she had me cracking up with all the little things she did. I adored her friendship with Tina and the group dynamic overall—it gave the story so much warmth and energy.

And Oliver? That man was sweet, swoony perfection. The tension between him and Priscilla? Off the charts. I devoured every single interaction. He was so obviously down bad for her from the jump, and I kept internally screaming for her to see it.

The proposal planning premise was super unique, and the flash mob scene? I was tearing up. Watching all the planning come together—and Tina and Ryan’s reaction—was just so beautifully done.

If I had to nitpick, there were a couple of moments where the phrasing felt a bit repetitive or clunky, but honestly, it didn’t take away from my enjoyment. This was an easy 5-star read and one I’d absolutely recommend!

This was such a fun read! After thoroughly enjoying Hate Mail, I was really looking forward to diving into The Proposal Project—and it absolutely did not disappoint. The banter was spot on, the humor had me laughing, and the chemistry between Priscilla and Oliver was palpable. The miscommunication trope was a little much for me, but honestly, I still flew through the book and had a great time. A funny, charming romance that kept me hooked! I absolutely devoured this book.

3 stars. I really wanted to like this book, since I loved Hate Mail, but this book just doesn't hit the same. I think the biggest issues I had with it were that some of the scenes and responses felt a little juvenile (like the 3rd Act Breakup), theres far too much miscommunication and assumptions that should be getting called out by other characters, and most of the characters were just SO unlikable. I disliked Priscilla because she seems immature, clueless, and stuck in her head too much. Tina is an awful best friend, and I hated every time she made Priscilla uncomfortable when an actual best friend wouldn't do such a thing nearly as often as Tina does over the course of this book. Ryan is like a ghost character, there just enough to be part of the story but there's not enough there for the reader to really get to know him like the others. Oliver is probably the only normal and likable character in this book, though I do wish he called Priscilla out on her shit when it happens.

I like the slow burn but when we finally get the first open door spice scene, the writing just kind of falls flat and bland for some reason? Overall the writing is just not my style, too many short sentences, so the story never really flows for too long in my brain.

Don't get me wrong, I think this story and plot had some real potential, but I think the execution and the characters just let it down.

If you are asking yourself "how many more pages are left" then its time to give up the read. I technically DNF'd at 85% but I read enough and skimmed the last 40 pages that I'm marking this as read.

This was SUCH a good time omg I loved it. I had average expectations going in but it really exceeded that and more. I would find myself thinking about going back to this book any time I wasn’t reading. I loved the characters and the story and the setup.

Priscilla was litch the cutest button I swearrrr she’s adorable but also competent and really loveable. She did make some silly decisions which I ignored lmao. Her inner monologue was so comforting bc she’s an overthinker and I felt that on a deeper level 😭

Oliver had me blushing twirling my hair biting my finger waiting with bated breath for what he would do next. Whenever he’d enter the scene I’d magically find the strength to blink back sleep and read one last chapter.

The only reason this isn’t a five is bc the reason for the misunderstanding was very blown out of proportion but it also wasn’t given enough importance when it came time to resolve the matter. I hoped she would mention her dad to Oliver and how the word triggers her but that never happened. It felt a little rushed. But that was the only thing that was the con of this book. Other than that I genuinely had the best time.

ೃ⁀➷ Thank you NetGalley and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter for the ARC! ♥︎

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the digital ARC!

Okay, I have to admit...I ended up DNFing this one.

I found the main character very annoying, and the main male character didn't seem to have any admirable traits outside of 'he looks hot'. Priscilla was an irritating character to read - her main personality trait seemed to be 'obsessive', followed quickly by 'childish'. She apparently becomes obsessed with Oliver after first meeting him ages ago, even though she didn't know anything about him. After he finds out and makes light of it (I feel he didn't take it too seriously, even though he could be justifiably weirded out by being told someone he barely knows is obsessed with him), Priscilla decides he's like...the demon spawn or something. A bit extreme. Even Tina points out that Priscilla has an attitude in that she thinks 'everyone is rude', which frankly says more about her than anything else.

But then this is also the character who gets fired at the start of this book and childishly fights with her soon-to-be boss about...a tape dispenser? Because it's shaped like a shoe?

Priscilla doesn't redeem herself in the parts I read - if anything, her flaws are pointed out even more for me, and I had no interest in finding out whether she grows as a character. After deciding to start her own business, her best friend gives her a check for six figures. That's right, six figures for...doing nothing, so far. Let's not get started on Tina. Why were all these characters five-year-olds in adult bodies?

When Priscilla's dad rightly points out that she's renowned for basically being immature, obsessive, and not thinking things through, she does the adult version of sitting there with her arms crossed and pouting. But here's the kicker - he's right! She did not think about any actual business stuff (outside of taxes?) and didn't want to face the music when her dad pointed out what she needed to think about. Instead, she just decided they were being overbearing.

So yeah, I have no interest in reading about such an annoying character. I know others will love this, and that's great because every book should have readers and fans, but unfortunately, it's not me!

ARC Review: *The Proposal Project* by Donna Marchetti
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (5 sparkling, slow-burn stars)

The proposal might be fake—but the feelings? Absolutely real.

Donna Marchetti’s *The Proposal Project* is a swoony, spicy, laugh-out-loud romcom that serves up all your favorite tropes with a side of secret glances, fake dating shenanigans, and one very clueless planner falling for the last man she expected.

Priscilla Cain is a meticulous, type-A event planner determined to give her best friend the ultimate proposal experience. The only problem? The groom-to-be has plans of his own—and his broody best friend, Oliver, is now *her* co-conspirator. What begins as a secret alliance quickly becomes something way more complicated (and deliciously swoony) as sparks fly between two opposites who can’t seem to stay out of each other’s orbit… or bed.

From fake dating at pre-engagement parties to one bed mishaps and secretly soft MMC vibes, this book is pure romcom gold. The banter is fast and flirty, the tension is toe-curling, and Oliver? Yeah, he’s *obsessed* in the best possible way. No third-act breakup here—just all-in feelings, mutual pining, and a pitch-perfect happily ever after.

**Tropes You’ll Love:**
💍 Enemies to Lovers
💍 Fake Dating
💍 Forced Proximity
💍 One Bed
💍 Grumpy/Sunshine vibes
💍 Clueless Planner vs. Obsessed Architect
💍 Proposal shenanigans with a twist

If you’re looking for a spicy romcom with humor, heart, and serious "marry me already!" energy, *The Proposal Project* delivers in every way. A must-read for fans of Tessa Bailey, Lynn Painter, and anyone who loves a man who falls first—and hard.

*Thanks to One More Chapter, Harper Collins UK and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!*

This book was so fun, it would make a fabulous movie! I loved the premise of the proposals, and then then Priscilla and Oliver dinsinf their way. Thank you for the early read

If you're looking for a light, easy rom-com read then this book will check the boxes for you. I went into it in the mood for light rom-com, but for me, this wasn't my favorite trope within the genre (miscommunication). The FMC especially felt too immature for my liking. The surrounding characters were enjoyable enough and the story is predictable enough to be a comforting read. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me the ARC!

4.5 stars rounded up
How can two people be so perfect for each other? I absolutely adored Priscilla and Oliver's chemistry, banter, and interactions. The story starts off slow, but once Priscilla and Oliver gets mushed together, I couldn't put the book down. I loved the whole premise of them working together to plan a proposal for their best friends. This book is the perfect amount of lightheartedness, fluffiness, and silliness. The little moments between Priscilla and Oliver really had me giggling and cheesing hard. My favorite part of the story was everything that went down in the cabin. This would be such a perfect spring/summer read!

I really enjoyed this romance. It’s enemies to lovers, fake-dating and close-proximity done really well. It’s slow burn that is actual slow burn, the yearning and the tension between Priscilla and Oliver was really well done. I normally hate the miscommunication trope, but it was really well executed in this book! I enjoyed watching them both plan their best friend’s wedding, and the humour in this book. I loved how supportive Oliver was with her business and how he encouraged her ideas.
Such a fun rom-com with a cabin getaway and one-bed moment. It also has a playlist included, if that’s your thing. Highly recommend!
Thank you to One More Chapter for the ARC received via Netgalley.

Thank you to Harper Collins UK for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

After losing her job event planner Priscilla Cain is roped in to helping her best friend Tina plan the perfect marriage proposal for boyfriend Ryan. However the groom Ryan has his own ideas and might just beat her to it, so she teams up with Ryan’s best friend Oliver to plan a joint proposal under the ruse of fake dating so their friends don’t suspect what is going on.

Oliver was the perfect book boyfriend, the chemistry between him and Priscilla was sizzling. These two were so perfect for each, I was laughing my head off in parts and at other parts torn between wanting to bang their heads together. This book was just what I needed it was cozy, romantic and funny, that ending swoon. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this book, I might just go back and reread this book as I’m not willing to leave Priscilla and Oliver just yet. Overall this was a really well written book and the romance between the two felt so authentic. I look forward to reading more from this author.

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC.
I really enjoyed Hate Mail so I was excited to read this book next! I love a fake dating story & enemies to lovers. It was predictable (clear that Tina knew they were faking it, the bench, etc) but I still really enjoyed it and was hooked the whole time. I flew through it! There was a good amount of spice, & not at all cringy as I sometimes feel when writers use certain words, unrealistic scenes, etc. I would definitely recommend this book.

This is an ARC review. I want to thank Donna Marchetti and HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter for allowing me the chance to read this book ahead of release day! any book that starts off with a playlist immediate catches my attention! Did I immediately go and create the Spotify playlist to listen to it while reading? Yes, yes I did! And thankfully another win of playlist books not letting me down!

Priscilla and Oliver started out as friends who turned into banter buddies and back into friends before it quickly slid into lovers. The spice on this book was medium but the tension was at an all time high. The amount of times I yelled for them to just kiss it out was at an all time high! They truly have the cutest love story. While creating the perfect proposal for their best friends they find their own love along the way. There was absolutely way too many miscommunications between these two but it really did make their story very unique. I enjoyed this laugh out loud cute rom-com with a splash of spice.

I thought this book was so cute!! I’m kinda starting to love Donna Marchetti because she always has such original stories and this was no exception🫶🏼 i loved the characters and their dynamics so much, it’s definitely worth the read! And also, it’s fast paced and not very long which i loved!🩷

This lovely book is coming out november 11! So excited to get my hands on it when it comes out, because let’s be honest the cover is soooo cute🤭

Thank you so much @netgalley and @donnamarchettiauthor for this amazing arc!🧡

thanks to the author, publisher and netgalley for the copy 💕

this book was so good that it managed to get me back into kindle reading!! the whole idea of the plot was so cute and executed perfectly and had me smiling as well as on the edge of my seat in anticipation for what would happen next. I may be a little swayed since fake dating is one of my favourite tropes ever but Priscilla and Oliver are perfect and I absolutely love them and their relationship from how it started and how it developed through the book

I thoroughly enjoyed this second book by Donna Marchetti, a gorgeous slow burn enemies to fake dating to lovers. I love the tension between the two main characters whilst they plan the proposal of their best friends. Hooked on their relationship just felt the getting together chapter was a little rushed and the ending could have been not so abrupt. Definitely a go to author for me now though!

Thanks Net Galley for the ARC!