Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This would be a really good classroom book during a Haiku unit or a unit about the UK. The haiku themselves were really well done both individually and as a narrative, and the illustrations' softness matched the vibe of the book really well. Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for letting me read

Was this review helpful?

The illustrations tie in with the story really well and bring life to the words. This could be a really fun way to introduce children to how poetry can be about anything, including history. I personally don’t enjoy haiku, but this book presented it in an enjoyable way! I would have loved a bit more details or facts about what was being referenced to help put the story in context to the history/world, but even so, this was really delightful.
This book covers human impacts on the environment and the way that innovation needs to follow invention to help counter that harm. Getting to see and hear the changes that happen to one specific spot over the course of time really helps show how human actions can damage the land in the name of progress, but at the same time, how human actions can work towards fixing those problems.

Was this review helpful?

I am not sure about this one. The theme is interesting, but it seems to be too ambitious a them to cover in such a short picture book. Also, as it seems to be written in very simple English, I would imagine this book to be written for maybe KS1 students? If so, I think it will need a lot of preparatory teaching before a KS1 child can understand what this book is about.

I am sorry to only give it 2 stars. The illustration is amazing, but I think the them might just be too big for a short picture book to cover.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Austin Macauley Publishers for the chance to read and review this.

I requested this book because I thought it might be a cute thing to give to my little cousin or nephew. While the art is lovely and truly a treat for the eyes, the rest of the book is incredibly disjointed and not very good.

Was this review helpful?

A very cute and educational poem. The illustrations are beautiful and so very intricate. A nice read with the kids.

Was this review helpful?

This book takes the reader on a vague journey through time in the UK. Each double-spread has a haiku and full illustrations of the period of time it covers. I'm afraid that I found the whole thing a bit depressing. Everything was viewed negatively and in terms of what damage has been done to the planet. While I wholeheartedly agree that this issue is pressing and cannot be ignored, we are where we are and we need to be looking at what can be done now to reduce the impact of this damage. I also don't think we should ignore the vast progression that this damage is a byproduct of.

Was this review helpful?

Recently I 'read' Stanley Donwood's wordless picture book "Bad Island" (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7199440880) which showed us how humanity can make anything go to hell in a handcart, but showed us in a way that will make absolutely zero change to anything anywhen or anywhere. This book does – and does not do – the very same. It starts with the sylvan hills of fair Albion, then shows how humanity is kind of paving over the whole world and poisoning its air with war and industrial activity, and once again this is not going to create any affect. No, not even being in very traditional and very well-written haikus will help, nor will the competency of the watercoloured illustrations. As clever as either of these fleeting publications can get, their positive benefits will be minuscule. This might make me a liar with its teachers' questions at the end, but all the same.

Was this review helpful?