Skip to main content

Member Reviews

So I do think I enjoyed this book… eventually. It was a slow start and I was at least half way through before
I was fully invested in it. Once I was into it though it was cute. Jack has a good mysterious side. But he also has a seriously wtf side? I was back and forth.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for a chance to read and review

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed listening to this! It was extremely fun and I really enjoyed the way the narrator read the book. I definitely recommend if you’re looking for something just downright fun with a touch of romance!

Was this review helpful?

#ThePerfectRomCom #NetGalley
This was a cute little story. I really don’t have much to say about it other than it was short and cute.

Was this review helpful?

The Perfect Rom-Com - Melissa Ferguson

The cover is what drew me in, I had no idea what it was about and I didn’t care.

So Bryony is trying to sell her manuscript… She goes to a writers conference and things do go the way she hoped. She doesn’t sell her manuscript but she is offered the chance to ghost write for a hot author… She never expected to write the kind of books millions of people read but it hurts that she cannot take the credit for her work and yet she can’t give up the hope of publishing as herself… Jack is the only bright side to her current predicament and it's up to him to keep her happy in her contract…

It’s cute. Too blinking CUTE!!! Jack… ah Jack!! I love their friendship. I love that he respects her as a person and author and admires the heck out of her. They are such good friends that they wordlessly do things like take the food the other person doesn’t like off their plates and swap it for something else. It’s intense. To build a friendship like that and move seamlessly to love. It’s too cute… SIGHHHHH I am not a massive fan of friends to lovers but I kinda feel like the lover part was always there they just didn’t know it yet ya know.

I love books that have book talk within them and this is clean cut and adorable! Great narration and I enjoyed the heck out of it.

4 stars

Was this review helpful?

I received this book via NetGalley and HarperCollins Christian Publishing | Thomas Nelson Fiction as an ARC. This review is my own opinion of the book.

This is a wonderful, heartwarming, and fun story. It did not feel as much romance to me as it did coming of age. It is perfect for those who do not like spice in their romances.

I thought I would list the topes, when it comes to contemporary romance books I find them very helpful.

-Workplace romance
- Forced proximity
- Friends to lovers
- He falls first

Was this review helpful?

The Perfect Rom-Com truly is the perfect rom-com!

First off, love the narrator! Karissa Vacker brought so much life to the story.

This book was funny, witty, and completely engaging. The chaotic, behind-the-scenes look at the publishing world was such a fun setting, especially as a reader. From the very first chapter, I was hooked, and I devoured the audiobook in just two days.

I knew I was in trouble when I found myself smiling, kicking my feet, and fully swooning. And the betrayal? I felt that in my soul.

I was absolutely engrossed every time the FMC talked about the writing process or the difference between how a reader versus a writer experiences a book. That aspect made this story even more special for me.

As an over-thinker, I have never felt more seen. This book had me crying and not only happy tears, highly recommend.

Thank you Melissa Ferguson, HarperCollins Christian Publishing & Karissa Vacker for providing me with an alc, this is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Audiobook review: The audiobook reader did an excellent job. I enjoyed her performance. I think if the book would have had more dialogue I would have enjoyed her performance even more. It’s hard to listen to inner monologue continually for pages but she made it bearable.

Book review:
⭐️3.5
just kisses

Bryony desperately wants 2 things; to save her beloved ESL nonprofit school “The Bridge” and to find a literary agent to represent her first novel SO she can use it to promote support for “The Bridge”. After all the rejections of her novel, in a last-ditch effort, she takes a meeting with famed literary agent Jack Sterling. When he asks her to critique another writers work and her comments are spot-on she unintentionally becomes the ghostwriter for famous author, Amelia Benedict. After years of ghostwriting and no published works to her name, will Bryony get to fulfill any of her initial goals and will she find something she didn’t even know she was looking for?

This was a sweet story. It did make me chuckle a few times. I loved the dynamic between Bryony and Jack, I just wish there could have been more banter. I also enjoyed the stories of the ESL students but rarely did they happen in real time as well. It felt like a huge chunk of the story was Bryony’s inner monologue where I wished it was playing out in the dialogue more.

Overall, a sweet and fun read.

Was this review helpful?

Book about a book my favorites! First off loved the cover, catchy and perfect colors. Reading the description dragged me even further in…! But I think it might have missed the mark a little, it was a long dragged out in the beginning and not enough banter, enemies to friends or something to make me devour the book but I found myself struggling to get into it. Wish we would have gotten to know more about jack and his side…and even some banter?!! Overall it was a good clean rom com and have a few friends in mind to recommend it to! Thank you to netgalley and the publishers for allowing the early read in turn for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

The Perfect Rom-Com by Melissa Ferguson (narrated by Karissa Vacker) is a lighthearted, feel-good read with a charming premise—but as a romance, it didn’t quite land for me.

Bryony is an aspiring author struggling to sell her first book when broody literary agent Jack Sterling offers her a ghostwriting gig. While she finds success writing under someone else’s name, her real goal is to get her own novel into the right hands—both to launch her career and to raise the funds needed to keep The Bridge, her grandmother’s financially struggling ESL organization, afloat.

The setup had potential, but the romance between Bryony and Jack never truly takes off. The book leans heavily into the cute side of romantic comedy—very vanilla, very safe—but ultimately, it lacked depth and real romantic tension. Jack’s personality shines early on at a literary conference, but after a time jump, he becomes much more muted, almost fading into the background.

About a third of the way in, I started wondering why there wasn’t more chemistry between the characters—then I realized this was a Christian romance. I read a mix of closed-door and mildly spicy books, so I have no issue with tamer romances, but this one felt too dialed-down. There’s nothing worth closing a door for. The connection between Bryony and Jack reads more like a close friendship than a love story. While there are a few passionate kisses, the emotional build-up and tension that make a romance compelling just aren’t there. If you prefer a romance that leans more into sweetness than intensity, this might be a great fit, but for me, it fell flat.

That said, the audiobook narration was a highlight. Karissa Vacker brought the characters to life, especially Amelia, the bratty romance author Bryony ghostwrites for. Her performance made the audiobook a more engaging experience than the story itself.

In the end, this wasn’t a perfect rom-com for me. The plot meandered, the characters lacked depth, and the romance felt awkward and unconvincing.

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson Fiction for the audiobook ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was incredibly.... fine. Predictable but cute, engaging but forgettable. It was very middle of the road and nothing overly imaginative.

My only major criticism (and even then, it was probably just a technical glitch), but my audiobook didn't finish until about 130%. There were probably 5 or 6 chapters plus the epilogue beyond the 100% mark which was super strange??

Was this review helpful?

Genre : Romance
Format : Audiobook
Rating : 3 stars

<b>Summary</b> :
<i> She’s written dozens of smash-hit romance novels. Too bad no one knows it. Aspiring author Bryony Page attends her first writers conference bursting with optimism and ready to sell her manuscript with long-shot dreams of raising awareness for The Bridge, her grandmother’s financially struggling organization where she teaches ESL full-time. But after a disastrous pitch session, she stumbles into correcting another author’s work in a last-ditch attempt to make a good impression with the agent. And she, as it turns out, is spot on. No one is more surprised than Bryony when the agent offers her the opportunity to be a ghostwriter for Amelia Benedict, popular rom-com novelist. Bryony agrees on one condition: she’ll write books for this vain, demanding woman just as long as Jack Sterling, literary agent of the legendary Foundry Literary Agency, works to sell her own book too. What nobody predicted, however, was that Bryony’s books would turn Amelia Benedict into the Amelia Benedict, household name and bestselling author with millions of copies sold around the world. And just like that, the Foundry Agency can’t let her go. But on a personal note, Jack is realizing he can’t either </i>

<b>Review</b> :.
The audiobook of The Perfect Rom-Com was well-narrated and the writing style itself is easy to follow, making it an easy read. Now, this one is heavy on inner monologues. I will address below how I think this negatively impacts the chemistry between characters. As for the ending, it was… interesting, but ultimately, I found the reveal of Bryony’s identity to be rather disappointing.

For me, this book didn’t quite hit the mark. However, I think you could enjoy this book if you’re looking for an easy read without spice or complex characters with intricate dynamics.

<b>Characters</b> :
I believe this book is a not overly obsessive take on “he falls first” and while the MMC did have his cute moment revealing his love for the FMC, it was nothing particularly worth a mention. Now, when it comes to the characters and their relationship, I didn’t find myself particularly invested. The relationship between the main characters felt underdeveloped and lacked emotional build-up as well as depth. I think if we would have gotten more scenes with just the two of them, you know little bonding moments, their relationship would have been much more believable. Which brings me to the fact that they wouldn’t have had little bonding moments right, because the FMC had a long distance mysterious boyfriend for a good portion of the book. For me, this was absolutely unnecessary. If the author was trying to depict her as emotionally unavailable, I believe this could’ve been achieved without adding the long distance cheating boyfriend we know absolutely nothing about.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely loved this book! I love bookish books and love that it gave a different perspective (from a ghost writer). I also loved the romance and Jack 🥰

Was this review helpful?

I kept meaning to share The Perfect Rom-Com last month and it just slipped my mind. I really enjoyed it and honestly just like everything that @ourfriendlyfarmhouse releases. This story had everything from embarrassment to silliness to excitement. The characters were all written so well and you can just see them when they were having conversations. Through some random happenings… Bryony ends up being one of the most sold romcom writers… but she happens to be a ghostwriter. She is working for Amelia the author and Jack the agent… just no one realized how good of a writer she would end up being and it throws a wrench in everyone’s plans!

If you want to read a fun one, I would highly recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

Amazing SOLO NARRATION

This was just a super fun & adorable listen and there's NO DOUBT that Karissa Vacker elevated this one for me with her crazy & wicked talent. She is so fun to listen to! Melissa Ferguson has a fun and unique writing style. I definitely know that I enjoyed this book more on audio rather than if I had eyeball read it.

Bryony is an aspiring writer. Her character was fun. She's determined, sassy & hard-working. She meets Jack at an author agency while pitching her idea. She's on a mission to save her grandmother's legacy & her book is part of that journey. She's been turned down over & over and jack is her last hope in getting this book published. Testing the waters, Jack offers her an opportunity to critique a well known authors book and to his surprise, Bryony goes totally off on it. Offering a list of things that needs to be fixed. This takes Jack by surprise but in a good way. He decides to offer her a position as a ghost writer.

She's thrilled but over time it starts to become tough watching HER work getting published & praised but not getting the recognition for it. She can't quit. She hasn't gotten her own book published yet & she's extremely frustrated.

There is fantastic banter between these two. Jack fell so bad for this girl and it was so obvious but Bryony is totally clueless to his lovesick heart. There's some miscommunication between these two & its frustrating. Things that could have easily been avoided.

🎧Let's talk narration: Karissa is so talented. She was the perfect voice for Bryony. She gives all the determination & frustration to this character. Bryony's character has such a passion for her project & Karissa was able to convey all of that & the deep and genuine love she had for her grandmother. She always delivers everything for me. Her ability to perform multiple characters with so many different accents is absolutely amazing. This is one of the things that makes her narration so enjoyable. Solo narration can be tough, but no one does it better than Karissa!

This really is just a light & fun listen. No spice. Kissing only. A really fun & interesting look into the publishing world. The red tape, hoops & roadblocks that a writer experiences. A great one if you're just looking for something easy to listen to. It's Chicklit that's about a woman finding herself, her journey & discovering love in the most unexpected of places.

📚Workplace romance
📚Strangers to lovers
📚Slow burn
📚Closed door romance/kissing only
📚Forced proximity

Was this review helpful?

Adorable and yet beautifully frustrating.

Amelia was the bane of my existence throughout this book and it was glorious to feel teamed up with Bryony against her. It was a story of triumph over a flawed system.

There was something very calming about the vase majority of this book. The ease of Bryony and Jacks relationship felt so centered and honest. They just clicked together and his support of her warmed each page. I liked that they just kind of came together.

Overall this was a heartwarming story and I find myself wanting to read more by this author.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute rom-com. (Although not perfect like the title would suggest) It had the friends to lovers trope, workplace romance, forced proximity, you name it. I really did enjoy the glimpses into the publishing world, and seeing how our own passion for a project can often leave us blinded to its flaws. The big surprise at the end seemed a little far-fetched, and I still am unsure how they got around the reveal of her ghost writing for Amelia. But I also was too glad to really care. My heart ached when she handed over “her baby” to the undeserving, ungrateful monster that Amelia’s character was.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

4.5⭐️ - I really am a romcom girlie, but I'll say that so many of the romance novels today has so much less storyline and so much more smut and I don't enjoy that. Imagine classic 90's romcom with all the silly giddiness and the infuriating "they just don't know how the other feels" and the ultimate big ending that brings the couple together and gives you that satisfying swoon moment. That is this book!! So much richness to the actual story and not just a romance built on sexual tension. I can appreciate that!!👏🏻

At one point in the middle of the book, I did start to lose a bit of interest. But the story looped me back in after a couple chapters and ultimately was so fun and attention-keeping.

Dare I say... this may be the perfect romcom.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved how awkward and oblivious Bryony is. She is by far one of the most relatable characters I've ever had the pleasure of reading.

Was this review helpful?

Is this “The Perfect Rom-Com”? No. Is this a super sweet story about an EL teacher turned aspiring author and the twists life takes her on to get her story published? Yes. Bryony is a fun and plucky character with a heart of gold, but she has become jaded while working for Amelia Benedict. While the characters lacked depth and the story stalled in some parts, the overall feeling and plot make for a fun read. I enjoyed reading about Bryony, Jack, and all the students at The Bridge. Think of this as a blend of Emily Henry, Emma Lord, and Katherine Centers. Add this to the top of your TBR.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed it but wouldn't say I loved it. The narration was really good (the reason I kept going), but the story lacked depth. Jack's character was a bit shallow, and I know the story wasn't from his POV, but I didn't find him very lovable. There wasn't much that happened between the couples, as you would expect in a romance novel. It was more like Bryony's struggle to be a cherished author and to have her first work published, she signed the contract for ghostwriting.
The concept was good, but it was hard to put it under the romance category as I couldn't find any love chemistry between Jack and Bryony.

Was this review helpful?