Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I wanted to like this book…. but I didn’t. An earnest YA novel about the dangers of beauty standards for young girls, particularly when they are POC, particularly when they have experienced trauma, I think this book tried to ask thoughtful questions and analyse them in a meaningful way. For me, it fell flat. Recommend for those who like simple writing and journal/diary types of stories. This book isn’t epistolary, but the writing has the feeling of a searching journal entry. Asking questions directly and thinking through them rather than slanting at the items being probed via actions and dialogue in a story..

Was this review helpful?

A dark, speculative, debut novel about two Indian American siblings ensnared in a rapidly growing beauty tech company for very different reasons. Kashmira, the younger sibling, wants desperately to remove any trace of her emotionally abusive father’s features from her own face by using NuLook, a facial reconstruction cream from a company called Evolvoir. Her recently estranged brother Nikhil is employed by Evolvoir, and is trying to use his position to influence positive change from the inside. Both siblings are unaware of the dangers associated with the product, and how it renders its users ill, and the chaos that ensues once this is brought to light.

I liked this book a lot, it hones in on the incendiary effect the beauty industry has on American youth, as well as expertly weaves in the societal pressures created by social media. The reality of working at a fast paced tech company where growth and expansion at all costs was eerily accurate. I also felt that the pacing, especially in the middle of the book, wasn’t consistent, and ultimately could have been edited a bit tighter to keep the thriller like feel of the plot in place from beginning to end.

Many thanks to Grove Atlantic + NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Ravishing reads a bit young at times but offers a very tender portrait of siblinghood and identity.

I was expecting a much darker story, something with a cooler, more inhumane atmosphere, but Ravishing is on the contrary very character-driven. It focuses on Kashmira & Nikhil's growth and how they grieve their relationship with their father. The sci-fi element is merely an excuse for them to realize the depth of his impact on them, heal, and understand who they are without him.
What I appreciated most were the friendships and their role in Kashmira and Nikhil's development. They were nuanced and had a softness at their core that both of them truly needed. I found the complexity of teenage girls friendships well represented, and Nikhil's romance lowkey gave me butterflies. It was sort of a relief to know they weren't truly alone in this but had loved ones there to support AND hold them accountable.
Plot-wise, I also found the technology at the core of the story fun -in lack of a better word-, and the various perspectives on it were actually believable and interesting.

However, I also must say I found the writing a bit clumsy at times. While I was really invested in both povs, I found the switch always a bit hard and it took me a while to get re-adjusted. I think it's because of the age-difference : Kashmira's 17, so her chapters felt like ya, whereas Nikhil is a young adult and widely different preoccupations.

3,25/5

Was this review helpful?

A big thank you to NetGalley, Grove Atlantic/Roxane Gay Books, and the author for an ARC of this book!

Ravishing is a wonderful book from debut author Eshani Surya. I've heard people describe this book as "a 'Black Mirror' episode meets 'The Substance (2024)' " and I'm inclined to agree, although I think it's a more optimistic bildungsroman take on the subject matter. It circles around siblings Kashmira and Nikhil as the navigate the world after their toxic father files for divorce and leaves. Kashmira, a teenager, is dealing with the crippling insecurity and self hatred of being a teenager, while Nikhil is getting acclimated to his life as a new hire for the beauty company Evolvir. When a new beauty product by Evolvir is introduced to Kashmira that promises to completely re-do the structure of her face, she begins to constantly use the product, unknown to her that the product will change more than just her face.

The premise of this book had me hooked when I saw it on NetGalley, so naturally I had to check it out. I think the way that Surya weaves multiple topics together - such as parental abuse, teenage angst, racial intersectionality, colorism, the world of social media, and the reckless abandon of today's billion dollar tech and beauty industry - was endlessly compelling to me. The siblings' motivations for getting involved with Evolvir felt so real and empathetic, with both of them trying to move forward in the world while being held back by their past. Another thing that stuck with me was how believable Eshani Surya wrote the digital landscape. Most authors try to either sidestep social media or write it with a dystopian technocratic twinge that mischaracterizes it completely - but Surya is different. She illustrates the isolating and simulated world of her Instagram, Slack and TikTok-likes, while also acknowledging the very real emotions behind its users. Nikhil's work group chats feel like chats I'd see in a Discord somewhere, and Yukiko is an outstanding interpretation of the beauty guru influencer.

The rising action of Kashmira's developing dependency on Evolvir's new product, NuLook, and Nikhil's feverish defense of his company's services had me hooked, almost to the point of un-put-downable, but after the 50 percent mark, I think it sort of spins its wheels in place, and that's where it began to lose me a little bit and I started to skim. Of course, it's not without reason - a pivotal event occurs that makes brother and sister reevaluate their priorities, and it's warranted - but the prose and constant documentation of circumstantial minutiae starts to feel bloating to the characters and the falling action.

I think with a little fat-trimming after the 50% mark, it'd be a perfect novel, but it's still a solid read in its current state. Look for this book when it comes out in November if you like speculative fiction about the current day!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the gifted copy of this gem.

It's not my usual read but it was intriguing and I enjoyed the portrayal of the lengths people will go to to change their appearances in favor of fitting a beauty ideal.

I did find some grammatical errors but nothing that drastically took away from the reading experience.

Was this review helpful?

Karishma faces the struggles of teen self-image, while her brother Nikhil wrestles with ambition and morality. Their story highlights the pressure and isolation of growing up as children of immigrants. A relatable read for anyone who’s felt unsure of themselves or their choices.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and Grove Atlantic (Roxane Gay Books) for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

While the premise intrigued me, I was expecting a more grounded dystopian or sci-fi narrative. Instead, the book leaned heavily into a YA tone that didn’t quite match my expectations.

The novel takes aim at the beauty industry, offering sharp commentary on its exploitation and manipulation, which I found to be its strongest element. However, the execution fell short for me. The prose felt uneven, and the pacing suffered under the weight of too many competing ideas packed into a relatively short novel. As a result, I struggled to stay immersed in the story.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Grove Atlantic (Roxane Gay Books) for the ARC in exchange of a review.

I thought it would be more of a dystopian/sci-fi story but came across as YA.

Interesting exploration of how manipulative and predatory the beauty industry is.

The writing style didn't quite work for me and I struggled to engage with the story. There was too much going on in only around 300 pages.

Was this review helpful?

Ravishing by Eshani Surya is a brilliant debut novel about an Indian American young woman who wants to change the way that her face looks. She gains access to a new beauty product that allows her to achieve this goal. However, the product causes horrible side effects. Ravishing covers so many issues including race, body image, health and family relationships. The character development is exquisite and I highly recommend this book.

Thank you to NetGalley, Grove Atlantic and Roxanne Gay books for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book is so. bad. The writing sounds like someone is just saying “and then this happened…and then this other thing happened…and then she went over there…and then…” just like a constant narration without any introspection or creativity. But then she wrote a make out scene where one dude “filled his mouth” with his tongue, “even the space behind the molars” and I’m sorry but WHAT. Oh and there were multiple descriptions of people shitting with more lurid detail than the sex scenes. Seriously, “she thrust, and thrust again” was talking about SHITTING. I kept reading parts out loud and no one believed this was a real book. What the hell. Roxane Gay your name is better than this drivel.

Was this review helpful?

A great read that will appeal to all ages and lovers of twisty novels and pop culture.
Loved it and will recommend it far and wide to my patrons.

Was this review helpful?

An impressive debut novel about the dark pitfalls of the beauty industry and its effects on the consumer, told through two protagonists who are both siblings.

Fresh from their parents messy divorce and daddy issues, Kashmira, a young indian-american teen is introduced to the innovative and life changing skincare cream, nulook and renulook by her former best friend, Roshni and with the help of the cream, her face literally transforms to something that she desires, anything to block out her dad's features on her. However, beauty is pain and she will experience the consequences of her actions and this is where the deuteragonist, Nikhil, who is her estranged brother and an employee of the company that creates this product will come into play.

Pace of this story is medium, not too fast but not too slow either and the characters are diverse. There's characters development especially on the two main protagonists.

Really recommended this book if you are looking for the horrors of the skincare or beauty culture as well as complicated family trauma.

Was this review helpful?

the best way i can describe this is as a mix of the substance, black mirror and a coming-of-age novel. i had a good time with this! interesting family and relationship dynamics wrapped up in an almost dystopian cosmetic advancement that has its effects on more than just the surface level.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 rounded up to 4

This is listed as a contemporary/lit-fic but I would say that this reads more like a YA novel. YA is something I normally don't read but I really enjoyed this book.

Ravishing is the debut author or Eshani Surya and I have to say I'm very surprised to see that this is her debut. Surya is very engaging with her writing and is able to provide a very unique and compelling read very reminiscent of Black Mirror. (Really reminded me of the Nosedive episode)

Surya also plays with so many themes such as the beauty industry, mental illness, family trauma, generational trauma, coming of age, and the struggle of embracing culture or assimilating into Western ideals. Cultivating into a commentary on how the next generation is coming into a world obsessed with obtaining a certain beauty standard, regardless of the cost.

I'm pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this, and I'm excited to see where the author goes next.

Was this review helpful?

I read this in a span of 24 hours. Ravishing is stunning. And a DEBUT at that? Surya promises to be a literary talent. Surya peels back our obsession with beauty in such a unique way - how beauty can tell a story of the trauma we hold and how our desperate need to unwind that can unwind ourselves as well.

Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

The Ravashing is set to publish in Nov. 2025.

Was this review helpful?

Ravishing is such a gorgeous, intense read—I couldn’t stop thinking about it. The stories dig deep into themes like desire, identity, and how we move through the world in our bodies. Surya’s writing is sharp but also really intimate, like she’s letting you in on something secret. It’s one of those books that sticks with you long after you’re done.

Was this review helpful?

The teenage angst of wanting to change how you look, coupled with the summer of changing adolescence and hormones is perfectly captured in Karishma's teenage experience. Conversely, her older brother Nihkil is also torn between wanting to make a name for himself and doing what is right as a human. The juxtaposition of these two siblings on different sides of the same coin brings the complexity and isolation that is both the epitome and struggle of being the children of immigrant parents. For anyone who has ever struggled with feeling confident in how they look or being torn to do what's right, this is the book for you!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoy book that deal with beauty industry and the dark side of it, so when I saw this was about face altering cream I thought it would be straight up my alley. In a sense it was but it also left me wanting more. The story was interesting but I found the writing style didn't really make me wanna pick up the book and I felt like the story could have been streamlined more.

Overall a positive reading experience and I'm interested to see what the author comes up with in the future.

Was this review helpful?

A thoughtful portrayl of the chokehold the beauty industry has on so many young people. Read like more of a YA novel as we follow the teenage protagonist through her struggle with her body image, and ultimately against the beauty tech company that has harmed her.

Was this review helpful?

This was a brilliant book, especially now, with all the impact of social media and plastic surgery, that also had the time the complicated family dynamics of the protagonist.
It somehow reminded me of the movie "The Substance", with this idea of sacrificing who you really are to get what you consider your ideal face.
The writing was good, and I enjoyed both the point of views, as well as the chapters feeling like news excerpts.

I would definitely recommend this book, and had a great time reading it!

Was this review helpful?