3.5/5

I read this when I was in elementary school and I've always loved the story except for the 'romance' that was shoved in here between Winnie and Tuck. Like she's a literal child? Other than that, this was a beautiful illustrated adaptation of the novel. The artwork really brought back that nostalgic feeling of when I first read the novel and the placement of the text within in nature was very clever. Winnie was excellently done and it was a wonderful remake of the classic.

What a beautiful graphic adaption of a classic! I loved the color palette that was used and the interpretation of each of the characters. This is a wonderful way to relive such an amazing book.

I forgot how much I loved this story. It has been several years since I've read the original but I felt like it all came back to me as I began reading. It translated perfectly into a graphic novel. I loved the layout and the artwork style. It is so beautiful and engaging. I am so excited for the new fans this will bring to the world of Tuck Everlasting. Now I am off to reread the original and watch the movie.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for letting me review this book. It’s been a bit since I’ve read this book and the graphic novel was a nice refresher. The watercolor pictures were a nice touch. That’s the question, if you could live forever, would you? Winnie realizes she could live forever but would she want too?

As a school librarian who first read Tuck Everlasting in middle school and fell in love with its timeless themes, I was thrilled to see it adapted into a graphic novel by K. Woodman-Maynard. Graphic novels often help reluctant readers connect with stories they might not otherwise pick up, and this adaptation beautifully opens the door for a new generation to experience Natalie Babbitt’s classic. The illustrations capture the heart of the story while making it more accessible, especially for visual learners.

What impressed me most was the art style and coloring choices. Rather than following the trend of bold, bright palettes seen in many modern graphic novels, the muted, earthy tones used here perfectly match the story’s nostalgic and reflective mood. It brings the same emotional weight I felt when reading the original. This adaptation remains true to the thought-provoking nature of the story, especially the central question: is living forever truly a gift? I will definitely be adding this to our school’s library once it is published—it’s a powerful addition for readers of all kinds.

I was fortunate to receive an ARC of the graphic novel adaptation of Tuck Everlasting through NetGalley, and I am absolutely blown away. This is more than just a retelling; it's a visual feast that breathes new life into a beloved classic.
The first thing that struck me was the sheer beauty of the graphics. Each panel is a work of art, and the way the text is integrated into the illustrations feels organic and intentional, enhancing the visual storytelling rather than feeling separate. The color palette is exceptionally vibrant, far richer and more captivating than what I've seen in many other graphic novels. It truly brings the magical and timeless quality of the story to the forefront.
Fans of the original novel will be delighted to see how faithfully the story has been adapted. The heart and soul of Tuck Everlasting remain intact, making this a wonderful way for both longtime readers and newcomers to experience this poignant tale.
Overall, this graphic novel adaptation is a triumph. The stunning visuals and faithful storytelling make it a must-read. Highly recommended!

I have always loved Tuck Everlasting the book, when I saw this on NetGalley I knew I wanted to read it. The drawings were done beautifully and the story was wonderful again to read. I absolutely loved it and would recommend it for anyone who loves the book. It was an easy and fun read. One of my favorite books this year.

One of my all-time favorite novels! The artwork is stunning and adds a new depth and layer to the story. Will definitely be buying a copy for my personal library and for my classroom!

Absolutely stunning. Tuck Everlasting and its adaptations have always been favorites of mine, and this graphic novel is no different. The illustrations are wonderful. I love the soft colors. The text was well adapted too, keeping many of my favorite quotes and staying true to the original themes. I absolutely recommend this graphic novel to anyone who loves the original book, and to anyone discovering it for the first time!

Thank you Netgalley and Macmillan Children's for the beautiful ARC of this book!

I really loved this book when I was a child and it stayed with me throughout the years. I was so grateful that I got an early copy of the graphic novel. The illustration in the book was amazing and they really enhanced the book. One thing that bugged me was the age gap which I didn’t remember from when I read it when I was younger for some reason I thought the FMC was older.

I enjoyed reading the book. I think it is a good adaptation from the novel. I enjoyed the pictures and the different graphic styles throughout the book. I think this could be a great lead in to reading the full novel and or a great we for people to enjoy the classic who wouldn’t have otherwise.

I absolutely loved this! I have always been a fan of the original and I feel that this was beautifully done. I often have a hard time with fonts in graphic novels but I loved the font choices in this book along with the words in the sun beams and things like that. 10/10.

This was such a delightful time! The artwork is beautiful and cozy and does an amazing job of introducing a new generation of readers to this wonderful story. Tuck Everlasting has a special place in my heart and I greatly enjoyed being able to experience the story in a brand new way.

This is an incredible adaptation of a wonderful book I loved in my childhood. The art is beautiful and the story is adapted to the new format faithfully. This book captured the exact feelings I had reading this book for the first time as a young girl

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this e-arc! I have always loved the story of Tuck Everlasting and this graphic novel brought it to life in a whole new way.

I loved the water color feeling of the art and the style choices with the text and how it was all illustrated in a way that felt interactive and captivating.

To celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of Babbitt's beloved classic, it gets a beautiful graphic novel adaptation.

Winnie Foster chafes at all of the restrictions that her mother and grandmother place on her in the early 1900s. She longs to run away from Treegap, especially in the heat of the summer when everything feels oppressive. When she ventures into the woods, she meets Jesse Tuck, who claims to be 104 years old. Winnie, at ten, knows this isn't true. When Jesse's mother, Mae, shows up, she says that Winnie has to come with them because they have a secret that the world mustn't know. Winnie's a little scared, but also wants adventure in her life, and Mae is a comfortable sort of woman who doesn't make her afraid. Winnie learns the Tuck's secret; they drank from a spring in her family's woods 87 years ago, and haven't aged since. Miles, Jesse's brother, is sad about this because he had gotten married, and his wife and children got to be older than he was, and left him because they thought he had made a pact with the devil. Angus, the father, is somewhat bitter, because he is left out of the cycle of life and will never die, since the spring keeps the family members from experiencing injury. A man in a yellow suit has spoken to Winnie, and sees her with the Tucks. He has come to investigate stories his grandmother told him, and offers the Tucks information about where Winnie is in exchange for the land where the spring is located. They agree, and the man and a police officer head off to retrieve Winnie. The man offers the Tucks a deal; they will come and serve as an example of what the water can do, and he will sell the water to a select few for a very high price. When they decline, he threatens to make Winnie drink the water instead. Angered, Mae hits him in the head with the butt of a rifle just as the policeman arrives on his horse. She is jailed, and will most likely hang for her crime. Winnie returns home, but knows that she must save Mae. They manage to get her out, and the family must leave town. Jesse has given Winnie a bottle of the water, asking her to drink it when she is 16, and the two of them can spend their lives together, traveling the world. We find that she doesn't do this, pouring the water on a toad that is in danger instead. In an epilogue, the Tucks come back to Treegap and find her tombstone that tells of her long life as a friend, wife and mother.


Strengths: I rarely rave about the beauty of writing in middle grade books, but Babbitt's prose is so beautiful that I couldn't envision this book as a graphic novel. To my great delight, Woodman-Maynard includes key portions of the text in her gorgeous illustrations. These have an appropriate soft and dreamy quality, and it made me ridiculously happy to find out that she hand painted all of the book in watercolors. Really, this couldn't have been digitally colored. The story follows the original (which was a little more violent than I remembered!), and is a great way to introduce this timeless tale to a new generation of readers. Both of my daughters own a copy of this, and have reread it many times. If you are involved with children's literature and haven't read this one, pick up a copy somewhere right away! If you want to watch the movie, don't look at the 2002 theatrical release; hunt down the 1981 made for television version, where Winnie is ten instead of 16.
Weaknesses: I may be imagining this, but there seemed to be a missing scene at a fair, when one of the boys falls off... the Ferris wheel? Since the symbolism of wheels figures largely, and this seemed like a pivotal scene, I was suprised it was left out. I could be wrong, because I thought Winnie put the water on a turtle instead of a toad.
What I really think: I am not only buying a copy of this, but also a copy of the 50th Anniversary Edition, which still has Babbitt's original artwork on the cover. The graphic novel includes a picture of Babbitt's house (that is now under a reservoir!) that looks just like this. This is such a sad and touching story that I can't bear to think about what the Tuck's lives would be like if they were still around today. So much change, and so much harder to move about undetected!

One of the prettiest graphic novels I have ever read! This adaptation of Tuck Everlasting is just beautiful. I was so impressed with how faithfully it told the original story while keeping the text short for graphic novel formatting. The art is truly beautiful, and I was struck once again by how moving this story is. Thanks to NetGalley, K. Woodman-Maynard, Natalie Babbitt, and Macmillan Children's for the chance to read and review! My opinions are my own!

This was a great adaptation of everyone's favorite coming of age story! I loved seeing some of my favorite scenes come to life, and all of the extras included in the book.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this graphic novel in exchange for my honest opinion!

My heart!!! This graphic novel was so gorgeously illustrated, you can really feel all of the love and care that K. Woodman-Maynard into creating this adaptation of Natalie Babbit's novel. I love that they included an interview between Natalie Babbit's daughter and the illustrator at the end of the book, it added so much depth to this novel and gave insights behind the conception/creation. If you ever loved the original book or movie, this Tuck Everlasting graphic novel is absolutely for you! I think it is so great to re-read books as an adult that you loved as a child, especially since you see them in a whole new light and can gain a different appreciation. I could gush about this book forever, it truly is so beautiful and I know so many people are going to enjoy it!

unable to read the text - what I could see of the illustrations was lovely. Loved the opening two pages!