Skip to main content

Member Reviews

*A Promise Delivered* offers a thorough and illuminating account of the recent bipartisan military committee’s efforts to rename U.S. military bases—an endeavor made remarkable not just by the historical weight of its subject, but by the dedication of those involved.

The author shines a spotlight on the committee’s exemplary work ethic, documenting their ability to operate *on time and under budget*. Their determination and cooperation across political divides is commendable, reflecting a shared commitment to justice and progress within the ranks of the military and beyond.

Equally impressive is the level of community involvement described throughout the book. Instead of imposing new names from above, the committee welcomed input from local citizens, advocacy groups, historians and even descendants of those whose stories had long been overlooked. This grassroots process helped ensure that each base now bears the name of someone whose legacy reflects valor, sacrifice and values that transcend old divides.

The contrast between the past and present approaches to naming is palpable. What was often done in haste for the sake of efficiency and “stencil-ability”, has now been done in a *deliberate, thoughtful process*. The new names are not just functional, but inspirational, chosen with a broad view and deeper understanding of their meaning and the honor they bestow.

Importantly, *A Promise Delivered* demonstrates a model for future naming projects, whether in the military, in government or in civic life. By combining bipartisan cooperation, historical research and community engagement, the committee set a standard that could guide similar efforts toward fairness, inclusivity and enduring meaning.

This book reads like a history textbook and because of each bio is separate, it can feel a bit repetitive to go through the same wars and battles from a different perspective. I look forward to the research and stories that are inspired from this. As the authors point out, it’s not that there’s a lack of heroes other than white men, it’s that their records and stories were often intentionally destroyed, erased or twisted into a negative bias. This work is the start to not only repair historic oversights but also points the way forward—toward a richer, more inclusive American military heritage. We, as readers and Americans, must continue the work of remembering and uplifting heroes whose deeds have gone unheralded.

*A Promise Delivered* is more than just a chronicle of renaming; it is a celebration of collaboration, community, and the power of remembrance.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of, A Promise Delivered, by Ty Seidule: Connor Williams, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. The Naming Commission was created to change the names of 9 army bases, which were originally named for Confederate leaders, who fought for slavery. In less than 2 years these army bases were renamed. I have never heard of the brave men and women mentioned in this book before, but Im glad I know them know. This was a really interesting read about or nations history.

Was this review helpful?

OK, so I don't believe in doing cover-ups on history regardless of politics and would march in favor of having Andrew Jackson's statues removed because of the inhumanity he represents. That being said, this book represents the involvement of both ordinary US citizens and military historians who sought to honor some of the heroes of the US military regardless of ethnicity or gender. It represents impeccable due diligence in researching the individuals presented and how the selection process was achieved. Besides, it is very readable to anyone who wishes to learn. Please note that the publisher is a public company not associated with any political or military agency.
I requested and received a temporary unedited electronic galley from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley.
#APromiseDelivered by Ty Seidule; Connor Williams Pub Date Nov 11, 2025 @stmartinspress
#10AmericanHeroes #RenamingUSMilitaryBases #militaryhistory #civilianinvolvement

Was this review helpful?

This book is well researched giving the reader in depth information about heroic Americans from our history. These people represent our country's values.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very good book. It was well-written. I would highly recommend this book. It's very easy to read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?