The premise of the book is compelling; however, I found that the execution resulted in something too dense, yet still lacking in clarity, in its approach to education and equity. It’s evident that a great deal of care and research went into it, and some personal reflections provide helpful context. While some parts resonate, the structure and depth did not appeal to me, and they may not suit every reader—though it remains a valuable contribution for those interested in policy and reform.

This book is essential for anyone in education policy, school reform, or just curious about the real limits of diversity as a fix. It’s smart, sharp, and serious. It is obvious that she put a lot of time and research into this and I appreciated that.

as a former teacher turned lawyer who will soon work predominantly in the juvenile/child welfare fields, i think this should be required reading for everyone to "get their feet wet" in understanding how diversity initiatives such as DEI and school integration are only the tip of the iceberg in resolving deeply rooted issues that still permeate our society from segregation and slavery. though this is primarily based on experiences, interviews, and data from NYC schools, i taught at a school in the bay area (like the author) and saw so many parallels between the stories in the book and my own experiences with my students and their families (could go on and on!). having taught 6th grade, the middle school chapter especially hit SO hard; so many similar feelings, particularly of frustration and helplessness😭
there has never been a more urgent need to ensure our kids have the support and the high quality education they need than the present when our department of education is crumbling before our very eyes. our children deserve way better and education/schools continue to fail them every single day. the future of our country depends on them.

This is an interesting look at the public school system. The info can be dense. I appreciate the times when the author talked about the decisions she made as a parent and the inside knowledge she had to do that. She is aware of her advantages that lower income families do not have. The info is great for parents and guardians, who may not get it elsewhere.