I love this! Im going to NEED the audio asap. Karl the grumpy man that you are!! Molly is sunshine and sass. I really loved this romance and getting to know the characters more. This was swoon-worthy and fun!

Olivia Dade continues to knock it out of the park. Karl and Molly may be two of my favorite characters from her and their story made me laugh and cry at times. I can't wait for more stories from Harlot's Bay.

Loved, loved, loved this book by Olivia Dade! Olivia Dade always always has amazing body positivity in her books and I loved this book so much. Karl is the best, grumpy mmc and the twist is the sunshine isnt all that sunshiney because or her previous trauma, but somehow it works.

I can't say enough great things about Olivia Dade! I have loved every single one of her books and this is no exception. She has perfected the art of romance with enough substance to feel like real life. Don't sleep on any of her work!

4.5 out of 5 stars

This delightful beauty of a book had me kicking my feet and giggling more than I have in a long time.

I am so in love with Karl and Molly's witty, dry humored dynamic. Their banter is written so perfectly, to the point they felt so real. I WANT to be their friends. I want to see their love play out in front of me, so I can see it first hand.

Molly's lack of trust in herself and others is so relatable. Karl's absolutely devotion to Molly is so very refreshing. I loved seeing them fall for each other again and really find solace in one another.

I think the only reason this book didn't get a 5 star, was due to the repetition. People keep telling the two of them to communicate, over and over again and it takes for ever for them to really due so. This is not miscommunication, it's just pure no communication. It does resolve but it takes a lot to get there.

I really loved this book. It was sweet, even with two cynical main characters.

4.5 stars for a solid example of what the title promises: a second chance romance between two well-written characters.
Docked half a star because the circumstances that reunited Molly and Karl were so far-fetched. But once they reunited, I was invested in seeing them reconnect and learn to trust each other. They show love in different ways (some of Karl’s sandwich and latte creations would mean more to me than a piece of jewelry), but their eventual openness with each other gives me hope for their future.
Because I had read and loved AT FIRST SPITE, I felt like I was meeting up with old friends while also making new ones with the new characters in this book. But if you haven’t read that book, you’ll still be able to enjoy this one, and hope for more stories out of Harlot’s Bay. I know I do, and feel like the groundwork had been laid for more in this richly created community.

What a fun follow up that I loved to pieces. Karl’s grumpiness was so endearing and I just loved him and Molly. What a pair and what a book. Olivia Dade has another smash hit!

Thanks NetGalley for the early read!

Absolutely loved it!! A wonderful romance.. I loved the premise, the tropes, and the spice level!

Have already started talking it up to the romance readers in my life that they need to be excited for the release.

I also continue to enjoy Dade's depiction of real bodies in romance.

10/10 can't wait for the world to read!

I think I liked this one a little better then the first Harlots Bay book. I really like the dynamic between these two characters. He is a real cinnamon roll.

Olivia Dade became a must-read for me when I discovered her Spoiler Alert series ( Ship Wrecked being my favorite) a few years ago, and I greedily read her entire catalog. Now, Harlot's Bay may be edging Spoiler Alert out of the top ranking.

In book two, Karl the grumpy baker reconnects with his high school friend, Molly, whom he's always loved but never told. Molly hustles back to Harlot's Bay when she hears that Karl was killed, which turns out to be a misunderstanding. When that gets cleared up, Molly clearly wants to bang him with no strings attached, while Karl wants more. He asks her for a month in Harlot's Bay to prove he can be her person.

What I liked about Second Chance Romance is that while it is a friends-to-lovers romance, Dade doesn't mess around with laying the chemistry right out there at the beginning of the book. Usually, some is pussyfooting around with the will they or won't they, but Dade gets right to the point and makes it clear that neither character is afraid to be open and honest about their sexual desires.

Dade's signature understanding of the human condition and dealing with difficult topics is in top form in Second Chance Romance. I admit there were a few tear-jerking moments which really solidifies that Dade really knows how to tug at the heartstrings.

I cannot wait for book 3 in Harlot's Bay!

Olivia Dade is an insta-buy for me, and always will be! Her stories are full of such heart and humor that I find myself chuckling and crying all the way through her books. I adore the way her female heroines are portrayed, and how smart, witty, and kind they are. I love that they are always sex-positive and confident in what they want in bed, even if they aren't always like that outside it. I also love how adoring her male heroes are without tipping into toxic tropes. Her characters consistently make me think differently about my own life and what I want from it, not only in romantic relationships, but also in the way I live my life. I cannot say enough about how much I love the stories and the writing.

Olivia Dade writes romances that are so emotionally poignant, and this one is no different. It is such a joy to see two emotionally stunted people fall in love, even though that prospect is one of the most terrifying things imaginable, for both of them.

Another fun read from Dade - funny little town full of lovable characters who all seem to read interspecies love stories. Huzzah

Dean & Dearborn- what a match! Second chance at love- Olivia Dade has done a great job following up with At First Spite with the fun match up of Karl (“Grunts and Illegal Threats of Violence are my Love Language”) and Molly the narrator of fiction & romance books. It was wonderful to visit Harlot’s Bay and follow this new couple as they discover love can be communicated with more than words.

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!

This was super cute! A second chance between high school friends Molly and Karl. for a second chance I liked it because it didn’t have a ton of flash backs which I really appreciate. Molly was a cute character and I felt like I connected to her.

content warning: there is a lot of swearing in this book and open door scenes. Seriously so much language so just be prepared for that!!

Rating: ★★★½

I really wanted to love Second Chance Romance, and there were definitely parts that stood out in a great way. First off, I loved the plus-size representation—it felt refreshing and authentic, and I truly appreciated seeing a character who looked more like real life in a genre that often overlooks that. The beginning pulled me in quickly, and I was invested from the start.

That said, the grumpy/grumpy trope just isn’t my favorite, and I found myself getting a little worn out by the back-and-forth tension. The miscommunication and quick judgments between the characters started to feel repetitive and frustrating. I eventually set the book down because I realized I was spending more time annoyed than enjoying the story.

Still, I know this could be a perfect fit for readers who enjoy that kind of slow-burn tension and angst. The writing was solid, and there’s a lot of potential—I just needed a little more heart and a little less head-butting!

I received an eARC of this book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.

I thought this book was good. It wasn't the best thing I've read but it was decent. It took me a while to finish it because I was easily distracted away from it. It is a cute romance but it has a lot of miscommunication and stubborn characters who refuse to talk about their feelings. That is literally what the entire book is about. These characters keep showing how they feel and tip toeing around everything but they both don't realize each other's feelings because they don't want to talk! They spend the book doing trust exercises and trying to open up to each other. It was well written but I just personally found it to be boring. I enjoyed the characters as I usually do with Olivia Dade books but it was kind of a slog to get through. It may just not be for me due to my hatred of the miscommunication trope.

I was excited to return to Harlot's Bay, especially with so many of my favorite tropes. I love second chance, and I love two grumpy Gusses finding each other! This did have a lot of the stuff I love about Dade's work, particularly the themes of trust and community, but it overall fell flat for me.

I was really excited when I started reading- I loved the premise, and the misunderstanding that kicks things off. However, the story seemed to grind to a halt and frankly never picked up again. I liked both of the protagonists, and their journeys to each other, but I guess I was just bored? So much of the scenes felt like trying to get from point A to point B instead of flowing naturally. Some of the dialogue did sparkle in the way I'm used to from Dade, but mostly this was a struggle to get through.

I was so excited when I figured out this was about Karl, the baker who listened to smutty shapeshifter audiobooks! I love Olivia Dade and this was a great read. I enjoy the side characters, I loved both Karl and Molly and their backstories. They are both pushing 40 and I love that their life experience gives them both baggage and the ability to not have that baggage derail their entire lives. Their friendships are some of the highlights of the book, as was the emphasis on trust and open communication in a relationship. Highly recommend this one!

In the second installment of Olivia Dade's ‘Harlot’s Bay’ series, ‘Second Chance Romance’, is a heartwarming romance between two characters who were once on the brink of something more, only to be separated by a misunderstanding (not the fondest trope for most readers, I know). Now, years later, they reconnect under the most unexpected of circumstances—a mistaken obituary—and sparks fly as they navigate their complicated pasts.

Olivia Dade has always managed to create signature blend of humor, body positivity, and emotional depth that always make her books worth the read. The grumpy x grumpy dynamic between Karl and Molly is as irresistible, juicy, and down right spicy in all the best ways possible. When I say the chemistry will keep readers turning the pages I mean it. This book has the exact charm needed to cozy up by the fire and just read.

‘Second chance romance’ is a must-read for fans of slow-burn romance, second-chance, witty banter, and a new twist to the grumpy trope. I am so excited for everyone to pick this up!