I was excited to dive back into this world, after reading At First Spite. I loved seeing all the characters all over again. I had a harder time getting into this book as I saw Karl as being so cranky, I couldn't imagine him in a relationship. I'm glad I gave it a chance and enjoyed seeing him open up and see their relationship rekindle and heal. What an enjoyable read!

Olivia! My girl!!! You always seem to make us bigger girls feel so loved and represented!!! That’s why I love you! And Second Chance Romance is no different! Molly and Karl have my full heart! I do not think I will ever recover. Reconnecting their love after 20 years is so wild but omg it had me tearing up! The banter, the comedic relief in parts, the love, it was all so perfectly done and I need more!

I was really hoping to love this as much as I did the first one of the series but, unfortunately, it falls into a bit of that second book slump. It’s not bad by any means. It’s fun, quirky, and a pretty easy read. The tension in the first half of the book is excellent. Definitely worth reading to continue along with the series. But the first book is so emotional that this one kind of had me confused. Like it didn’t need to be as long as it is, maybe? I sort of had moments where I wasn’t sure why I was reading it. And it’s a comparison thing. If I hadn’t read the first, I probably would have liked this a lot more. But comparing it to the first…it just doesn’t hit. Molly comes across as…needing a therapist and a reality check when compared to Athena who overcame actual depression in her book. Karl was so great in the first book and I was so looking forward to his story and then he’s just kind of flat in this. Maybe it’s the way he talks but I had a tough time following his side of the dialog. And compared to Matthew, Karl isn’t as flushed out and well rounded as a character. I got: big, hot, burly, grump. And sure…that’s fun to read about but I expected him to have more dimension than just “sexy monosyllabic baker”. The seeds are there with the whole no woman having returned professions of love, and his need to control everything at work but they don’t grow the way the lonely thing does with Matthew. Neither does the whole thing with Molly’s health. I mean, hell, even more about the whole “I thought you were dead” thing would have been welcome. Again…I think the comparison to how good the first book is kinda hurts my view on this one. The banter is funny and the confrontation in the ending is worth sticking around for. But manage your expectations of these two because they’re not as deep as Matthew and Athena.


Thank you to Netgally for the advanced copy of this title!

I enjoy Olivia's characters and writing style. I just really wish that there was less smut in it (or even none at all)
But, just because it isn't for me, doesn't mean that they aren't good books.

Fun, funny read! Loved the characters, including the supporting ones. I have enjoyed Olivia Dade before. I continue to do so!

It was a cute story Molly and Karl are so cute ☺️ I love her confidence! I love a grumpy baker 🤭 their chemistry was so good!
4.0⭐️

A quick note: I haven't read book 1, and while that's not usually an issue for me in romcom series format, I did feel lost at sea for a lot of this book. Would not recommend reading this without book 1.

I always appreciate Olivia Dade's commitment to body positivity, and loved that she included the MMC in that as well. (Even Fat Girl Romances usually have very Henry Cavill MMCs.) This book had fun moments, and the inclusive spicy scenes were worth, but overall the chemistry between characters was more told than felt. I didn't particularly like either Karl (and his constant sentence fragments) or Molly (and her bizarrely complicated dialogue). YMMV though - more seasoned romcom readers might enjoy those character quirks more and feel the feelings!

In this second-chance romance, sparks fly and old wounds heal when grumpy baker, Karl, and plus-sized audiobook narrator, Molly, find themselves back together in the small town they spent their teenage years in.

After 20 years away, Molly returns after hearing Karl has tragically passed away. She is an audiobook narrator with a voice that Karl has secretly listened to for years.

When it’s revealed that Karl, once presumed dead, is very much alive, their reunion is anything but smooth. He’s prickly, gruff, and guarded—yet beneath the flour-dusted scowl is the same man she once admired. What begins as a hesitant reconnection slowly evolves into something deeper, as the two navigate past hurts, trust exercises, miscommunications, and a simmering chemistry that never truly died.

With cozy small-town charm, mouthwatering baked goods, this story is a heartfelt exploration of forgiveness, friendship, and the courage it takes to love again. It’s slow-burn, swoony, and sprinkled with just the right amount of sugar and spice.

Perfect for fans of grumpy/sunshine dynamics, body-positive heroines, and second-chance love stories that feel both grounded and deeply romantic. My main critique would be that at times Karl could be too grumpy and say things that were a bit cringe-worthy.

⭐️: 3/5

It was so awesome to read Karl's story. I love the dialogue between the two main characters. Because this is the 2nd book of this series, I was already so invested form book one. I love how Olivia writes stories about plus size girls because I feel included and it makes me feel seen. I could not stop reading this book. It made me laugh and definitely shed some tears. I can't wait to see if Olivia continues to add to this series.

2.5 rounded up.

The synopsis grabbed me and I have liked Olivia Dade books in the past; however, this was not for me.

The story moved way too slow, what plot there was felt boring and while there was some chemistry I just did not feel the connection between the main characters.

Thank you to Netgalley, Avon and Harper voyager and Oliva Dade for this ARC.

This charming second chance romance follows Molly and Karl, former best friends who reconnect 20 years later. I loved the plus-size representation and the strong chemistry between the leads.

This was a cute story. The miscommunication Trope is not my favorite and it seemed like all their problems stemmed from communication. The characters were really sweet. Overall, enjoyable and my first from this author. Thank you!

Book 2 in the Harlot’s Bay series, Second Chance Romance, can be read as a stand alone without feeling lost. Friends from high school, Karl and Molly get a second chance to right the wrongs that kept them apart for 2 decades. It was good to have a break from the rock hard abs and Barbie like figures, having our mains be more the norm body types we see daily. Harlot’s Bay was described so fun and friendly, a far cry from my city life, and the townspeople were a riot. What gets Molly back after 20 years is a hilarious misunderstanding or prank depending on who in town is asked. There is a town book club that I totally want to borrow the name and start my own. And lots of laughs between the spice. I would say the pacing was slow, some dialogue seemed to run a bit on. But overall I enjoyed!

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC and for requesting my opinion.

Olivia Dade writes reliably wonderful fat girl romance, and we love her for it. She went above and beyond this time, though, by providing a male lead who truly grows throughout the book in the most satisfying way. #teamkarl

In the interest of full disclosure, I received an ARC of Second Chance Romance by Olivia Dade from NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

I loved All the Feels and really liked At First Spite, so I requested this book the second I saw that Karl, everyone’s favorite gruff and emotionally constipated side character, was getting his own story. I’ll be honest, I wasn’t enthused by the plot description, because I’m usually not a fan of second chance romances that hinge on unspoken high school crushes; something about 30- and 40-somethings obsessing over what could’ve been in homeroom just feels like kind of pathetic arrested development to me. That said, Second Chance Romance managed to make the trope feel more like "unfinished business" than "immature obsession," and I actually really enjoyed how Dade makes it work by grounding it in genuine warmth, humor, and growth.

The setup is gloriously unhinged: Molly, an audiobook narrator of monster erotica, returns to Harlot’s Bay after stumbling across Karl’s ridiculous obituary, only to find out he’s very much alive, still very much hot, and very much still in love with her. One thing about me is that I love absurdism that leans into the unhinged just enough to stay plausible, and this hit that sweet spot perfectly. The obituary mix-up is honestly one of my favorite meet-cutes ever, and Karl’s increasingly creative curses and threats gave me life.

Molly is great. Cynical, confident, stylish in a wonderfully nontraditional way, and refreshingly secure in herself, she brings an energy to the book that plays beautifully against Karl’s "gruff teddy bear who speaks in F-bombs" vibe. Their chemistry works, and even when I wanted to shake Karl for being allergic to multi-word sentences, I still rooted for them. They were each obtuse in their own own ways, but they tried for each other, which was refreshingly emotionally mature.

On the cozy small-town front, Dade leans hard into the whimsical and occasionally bonker vibes of Harlot’s Bay. From the delightfully unhinged book club (The Nasty Wenches, bless them) to a feud between rival sex shop owners, to My Kangaroo, My Kidnapper which lives in my head rent-free, Harlot’s Bay might be my favorite literary small town. I usually don’t enjoy books set in the same town with recurring characters—it often feels like fan service—but seeing Matthew and Athena again actually made the world feel more fleshed out, not less. Also, the next Harlot’s Bay book NEEDS to feature Lise, who might secretly be the most unhinged side character of them all.

I give this a full 5 stars. If you liked At First Spite, this is a must-read follow-up. And if you’re new to Harlot’s Bay, I’d recommend reading book one first just to ground yourself in the world. I’ll definitely give the next book a shot, especially if it involves rival sex shop owners.

Things I loved: Plus-size representation for both leads, without fetishization. Everything about Karl, who may be my favorite grumpy hairy dude since Roy Kent. This man listened to Molly’s unhinged audiobook narration for two years like a pining fool, kickstarting an entire town obsession because he was so down bad for his girl. And his sandwiches, swoon. Also, for some reason Matthew’s recurrent straight man foil to Athena’s chaotic energy just took. me. out, especially in the tux fitting scene.

Things I didn’t: Not much honestly, but if I had to nitpick, I’d say not hearing more about Lise’s side of the deal, which I understand might be the set-up to another novel but still feels like a loose end. I also didn’t love the timeline it both felt too short (one month is a short time to decide to uproot your life) and too long (kept rehashing the same issue over and over).

Perfect for fans of: Roy Kent energy, grumpy/sunshine dynamics, plus-size romance, cozy chaos, escape rooms, inspiring sandwiches (and if anyone knows where I can get a butterscotch latte, let me know!), busybody neighbors, second chances, and communication.

Molly and Karl spent so many years apart (2 decades)as a result of not telling each other joe they felt about each other. Que my lesast favorite trope of miscommunication. I really enjoy that Molly and Karl was a plus size man and woman in this book. After not talking to or seeing Molly in 20 years, Karl still recognized Molly’s voice and had listened to all of her audiobooks that she narrates. (That part had melted me. ) He still had a chance to listen to her audiobooks as a way to keep her close to him.
When they were in close proximity, after she came back to Harlets grove after 2 decades, they have a chance at a second chance romance but the plot was that they were to do these trust building exercises, I felt that was a bit silly because he wanted to actually build trust for a relationship while she just merely looked to hook up before building the trust.
During the majority of this book I did feel that Karl was cussing worse than a sailor, and had felt Karl could benefit from anger management. I do love the aspect of his and Charlotte’s surrogate dad/daughter role and the role that he plays in her children’s lives. However at the endnote book, I’m glad Molly didn’t sale to her narcissistic ex husband!!
This is really light and fluffy which is a breath of fresh air as to the dark romance I’ve been reading a lot about. Second chance romance by Olivia dade would make for a great read and I highly recommend it if you like the miscommunication, grumpy/sunshine, second chance romance, friends to lovers tropes.
I would like to thank @netgalley for a chance to read this advance copy in exchange for my honest review.

#netgalley #secondchanceromance

Second Chance Romance is a warm, heartfelt story about love, regret, and the power of reconnection. Olivia Dade delivers a tender portrayal of characters who have grown and changed—and still find their way back to each other. The emotional maturity of the characters was refreshing. Their second chance felt earned, and Dade’s signature blend of humor and vulnerability made the romance deeply satisfying.

3.5 ⭐️ rounded to 4.

I very quickly read At First Spite, so I could start Second Chance Romance. Karl was so lovable in the first book, so for him to be his own MMC was exciting.

Molly, a recent divorcee, reads an obituary for her high school friend, Karl. The unexpected timing of the obituary has her traveling home to mourn. Except when she returns, she finds that Karl is very much alive and incredibly attractive. Their rekindled "second chance" friendship might be exactly what they both needed.

My sweet, Karl. What's not to love about an emotionally stunted man who can bake and love monster romances? As for Molly, I admire her self-worth and confidence in herself. Together, I love their banter and genuine relationship. They felt very real in the sense that I could 100% picture their relationship in real life.

My favorite part of the book was the representation of plus-size main characters. The author wrote these plus-size characters in such an authentic way that it didn't feel forced. Just characters are portrayed as normal everyday people.

Thank you, Netgalley, Avon & Harper Voyager, and Olivia Dade, for the advanced reader copy of Second Chance Romance.

Thank you to Avon and Harper Voyager, and Netgalley for an ARC of this book which I voluntarily read and reviewed. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

SECOND CHANCE ROMANCE had a lot of great things going for it. First off, I loved the plus-size representation! It shouldn’t be notable and exciting that both main characters are in bigger bodies, but, unfortunately, it is still so rare. Even seeing one book out of one thousand where characters look like myself and experience love, joy, desire, and many of the same things I and so many other plus-sized people go through helps.

I also really enjoyed the characters who make up the zany town of Harlot’s Bay. Their antics and outrageousness (like the dueling sex shop owners and erotic book club!) helped move the story along and made me want to keep reading, especially when Molly and Karl’s story seemed to drag at times.

Molly and Karl were unique characters who won’t be for all readers. Molly is very exacting and doesn’t let Karl get away with any hyperbole or unrealistic threats of bodily harm and Karl can tend to skew almost too grumpy and oblivious. But each also had their own positive qualities as well that had me rooting for them to overcome the insecurities that would have kept them from living their happily ever after.

Overall, SECOND CHANCE ROMANCE was a good read and I’m definitely interested in reading more books in the series!

I love Harlot's Bay and all of the inhabitants. This is the second book and it is so fun to see the supporting characters! I was sooo happy to see a Karl book!

Teenage angst.... love it. Karl and Molly had crushes on each other but were never together - they were just good friends in high school - until they had a misunderstanding. He stayed in Harlot's Bay and became and baker and she went to LA and got married. One day, she reads a strange obituary that Karl died and Molly felt that she had to go back to Harlot's Bay to pay her respects while her house is being renovated following her divorce.

Grumpy/Sunshine, Karl's love of monster smut, and body positivity for the win! Total win - I hope we get to read about Lise next!