Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was my first ever pirate romantasy and I really enjoyed it!
What to expect:
• witches, pirates, mages, sea creatures
• badass FMC & all female crewship
• enemies to lovers
• searching for treasure

I do wish there had been more dreamwalking - it connects our 2 main characters in the beginning but we only read about it happening twice. I absolutely loved the power and fierce-ness of the woman aboard the Sea Witch. They're truly a force to be reckoned with. The ending was gut wrenching and I wasn't expecting it, can't wait to see what happens next! Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

An adventure at sea with an enemies-to-lovers that blooms on ship. It was such a great read with everything from action to romance. I love that the pirate was a women and a witch instead of it being a man. A ship full of only women until Ben follows the captain onto her ship. I can not believe this ending, it was a surprise and left me wanting to know what happens with them next.

Was this review helpful?

I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

This was an engaging read! I enjoyed the plot and would read it again.

Was this review helpful?

This book had me at witch pirates but kept me with solid characters and an even better plot. I definitely recommend this book to fans of Pirates of the Caribbean, fans of V.E. Schwab, or anyone who loves badass women being badass.

Our FMC Alys is very Anne Bonny coded. She’s strong, she’s independent, and she doesn’t need a man. But not if our mmc Ben, who’s giving Commodore Norrington (iykyk), can help it!

I thought the plot was very interesting and moved at a good pace. The hunt for the failsafe was the perfect way to keep them moving along. I also appreciated the inner struggles of both of our main characters. I liked that typical gender roles were a little subverted with Alys being the one to draw Ben out of his shell and teach him that he didn’t have to conform to society’s expectations. She was also the one who was more experienced sexually, which was refreshing to read in a romantasy. Alternatively, Ben was the one who showed Alys it was okay to admit/show love and vulnerability. The relationship between Alys and Ben also had some queer undertones, even though they are both presumably cishet (but pirates and witches are queer coded so).

I caught some subtle nods to Pirates of the Caribbean throughout the story, which I very much appreciated. As with any romantasy, I think the magic system and world building could have been established a little better during the exposition, but the plot was honestly really really solid. Everyone add this to your tbr and read it in August!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read! This was a pirate romantasy book that was all about female empowerment. I found it to be very immersive and I love that the banter matched the time period. Can’t wait to read book 2!

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, what’s not to love? I’m a huge fan of pirate books and add in witches! Fantastic. Alys is such a badass leader of her crew and I loved her immediately.
Ben was DREAMY and perfect and I love love love him so much! Reading their love story and them adventuring was a blast. Can’t wait for more!

Was this review helpful?

Holy cliffhanger Batman! Wasn't expecting that ending but I had the best time getting there. Some seriously good spice, a literal boatload of feminism and a hero you can't help but love. Highly recommend for anyone who likes witches, pirates, or pirate witches and just wants to have a great time in a new world.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very fun romantasy with pirates that would be perfect for Sea of Ruin fans. While some things weren’t to my taste and I wish there was a cliffhanger warning, I still enjoyed.

Was this review helpful?

The Sea Witch by Eva Leigh is a steamy, feminist retelling of The Little Mermaid that totally surprised me in the best way. This isn’t the Disney version—it’s darker, bolder, and packed with sharp wit, magical intrigue, and sizzling chemistry.

Margot, the sea witch, is such a standout. She’s powerful, clever, and unapologetically herself—definitely not your typical villain. Prince Alaric is layered too, and their dynamic is full of tension and slow-burning heat. Leigh dives deep into themes like freedom, sacrifice, and identity, all while keeping the romance front and center.

Some of the pacing lagged a bit for me, especially when the story shifted gears from politics to passion, but overall I really enjoyed the ride. If you like fairy tale retellings with teeth (and spice!), I highly recommend this one.

Was this review helpful?

I love Eva Leigh. I love romantasy and pirates and everything that this is. But this felt a little cluttered and was difficult to get into. I love a strong female lead, but Alys was hard to like at times. I appreciate the opportunity to try it out and support her!

Was this review helpful?

Pirate Witches. Witch Pirates. Two of my favorite things smashed together in one book and it was so much fun.

The concept of a crew as a coven? Yes. A captain I don't know if I want to be or be with? Yes please. Seriously, Alys is so cool. Ben was nice too, but I would Do Things for Alys.

I do think there was something slightly awkward about the spicy scenes - too much talking maybe? Also I really wanted more development with the crew - a lot of times they were interchangeable (except Stasia, I want a whole book on Stasia!).

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

tldr: Who said witches had to live in the woods waiting for the unwary when they could just take what they want? 4/5

Was this review helpful?

This was definitely a interesting pirate romance for me! I was definitely drawn to this book because of the tropes that were listed, and it just sounded really fun! I was definitely immersed in the first half of the book because the banter was so good, and I liked the chemistry between our characters. There is little to no world-building, which was a bit confusing, but I feel like after a while, you kind of get the gist of what is going on. The enemies-to-lovers trope was definitely my favorite part of the book, and the forced proximity. I also really enjoyed the all-female crew.

Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The Sea Witch is a historical fantasy set in 1720 with pirates, witches, monsters, and the reliable British Navy as villain. Alys Tanner escapes the colonies, where her sister was hanged for witchcraft, and takes a stolen ship to the Caribbean to live as a pirate captain of an all-female crew. In this alternate history, men are trained as mages but women are persecuted for using any magic, and the British Navy enslaves sea monsters as well as humans. When a naval officer pursues Alys and ends up imprisoned on her ship we get forced proximity, enemies to lovers, and a predictable romantic subplot that lacked any real emotional heft. Additionally, the story felt overloaded with creatures, spells, familiars, dream walking, sea monsters, flying, humans transforming into beasts, and more! Sadly this was a miss for me.

Was this review helpful?

I really adored this book and what all it stands for! This is a pirate romantacy book that is full of passion, magic and female empowerment! This story takes us on an exciting adventure at sea! It is an enemies to lovers romance, has mythical creatures in it and includes battles with the British navy. It is bold, daring and full of action! This book was far from boring and kept me engaged throughout the entire time I was reading it. It is well written, thought provoking, fascinating and easy to read!

“The Sea Witch” revolves around the female main character named Alys, who is both a witch and a captain of an all female crew. Even though this is a world where females are not allowed to use their magic, they go against it! As the story unfolds, we see themes of resistance and oppression and the power of magic! This book left me feeling satisfied! I highly recommend it to anyone that is interested in reading a pirate romantic fantasy book! I give this book a 3 out of 5 stars!

Thank you to NetGalley, author Eva Leigh and Harlequin Trade Publishing | Canary Street Press for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review!

This book is expected to be published on August 26, 2025!

Was this review helpful?

I am new to the pirate romantasy universe but this was a great start! The prose is so immersive and I loved all the era-appropriate banter and phrases. There's not a lot of world building in the beginning of the book but there's a lot of setting the scene with introducing characters, the plot and mission and what will be the central conflict. It makes for a slow start but worth it to keep going! There's a great enemies to lovers plot with forced proximity (she keeps him locked in her cabin lol) and love the all-female pirate crew. Be warned, there's a cliffhanger! It's not too bad though.

Read this if you're in the mood for...
- a bad *ss FMC
- pirates
- enemies to lovers
- hunting for treasure
- forced proximity
- banter
- dream-walking

Is a meet hate a thing? His crew is hunting her and all of a sudden she captures him and locks him in her cabin and it's the best thing and a great start to the book. The characters are easy to like and root for and I love the all-female pirate crew dynamic. It feels like a Pirate of the Caribbean vibe with also make them a girl group? It's great.

Here are a few of my favorite things...
- he's tied up in her cabin. period.
- the dream walking! I loved that as a way for them to be connected and learn about each other when things are too hard to say
- the crew! We only got glimpses of them but so many great personalities and banter

Overall I enjoyed and would recommend!

Was this review helpful?

In a place where women are not allowed to have magic or powers, Alys Tanner must fight for survival. With the unexpected passing of her husband, and murder of her sister, she realizes she needs to leave her village or else be hunted as a witch. She escapes by stealing a ship, crewed entirely by women from her village with magic.

With a world filled with pirates, monsters, and the raging sea, I was fully drawn into this new fantasy world. A beautiful and sexy romance emerges from capture, and opens even more truths to the surface.

And that ending?!? Very strong start to a new series, and I’m looking forward to what’s ahead for our favorite female pirate witches.

Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC of this novel; all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

An all-female witchy pirate crew on the Caribbean high seas? Yes, please! This book was an amazingly fun, hot, and suspenseful adventure. This will be a summer blockbuster!

Thanks for the opportunity to read in advance!

Was this review helpful?