Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC! I enjoyed but didn’t live hilly black’s cruel prince series so was excited to see what she did here—this was better!

Was this review helpful?

This started off slowwwwww. I almost didn’t finish it due to this. The amount of backstory was overwhelming and the current timeline took over 100 pages to grab me. But once it dud, I enjoyed it. The last 30% of this book was great! I wish there had been more connection and chemistry between Char and Vincent in the beginning so the separation would have been more powerful. Curious to see what book 2 will be about since there was only a tiny cliffhanger.

Was this review helpful?

If the tale of Peter Pan, the ocean's enterprise, and an episode of law and order all walked into the same goth bar...that would be this tale! Charlie is an anti-heroine with the propensity to stumble through the world after one too many beverages. The magic system is creepy and dark and alot of fun to decipher as the past and present unfold together. I will never look at shadows the same.

Was this review helpful?

I devoured this book. Book of Night is dark, twisty, and full of the kind of shadowy magic that pulls you in and does not let go. Holly Black has always been great at writing the edges of fairy tales, but here she dives into something grittier and more grown up, and it absolutely works.

Charlie Hall is one of my favorite kinds of protagonists: messy, clever, stubborn, and just trying to survive in a world where shadows can literally kill you. She has a past full of bad decisions and a knack for getting into trouble, but her voice is sharp and real, and I was rooting for her from page one.

The magic system is fascinating. The idea of shadow magic, manipulating your shadow, giving it weight and personality, even weaponizing it, is just the right amount of creepy and cool. The world feels lived in and dangerous, and the line between con artist and hero is always shifting.

The twists hit hard, the atmosphere is moody and rich, and the ending left me wanting more in the best way. If you like noir vibes, morally complicated characters, and dark magic, Book of Night should be on your list.

Thanks to NetGalley and Tor Publishing for my copy of Book of Night.

Was this review helpful?

*I requested this ARC from NetGalley mistakenly assuming it was the sequel in the series. I'm still relatively new to NetGalley, so I did not expect a previously published book to have an ARC available. I had initially read Book of Night in 2023, and I own a physical copy of it as well. But upon learning that the sequel is expected to be published this year, I did a reread of the book and felt my opinions on it did not change since my initial review, which is pasted below. I am excited for the sequel!*

I genuinely really did like this book. As someone who didn’t love Cruel Prince, I liked the connections to the modern world and the dreariness of day-to-day adult life.

In so many other stories, the character has a job but it gets forgotten about at some point in the story… it sort of fades out. This story ensures that you don’t forget that while everything is going on, Charlie is still working every chance she can to earn money to keep up with responsibilities. I know that seems like a small detail, but it just made me feel more connected to the MC.

Many other fantasy stories these days glorify the MC and sort of paint them to be better than everyone else. I love that Charlie was so morally gray, and you got to see her battle with herself a bit to make a decision. I can see how people think she didn’t have much of a personality, but to me, it’s just because she wasn’t painted to be some unforgettable, super powerful princess. She’s a capable, struggling, emotionally traumatized and hardened 28-year-old trying to deal with murder, bad guys, and understanding magic while also making sure she doesn’t forget her responsibilities that will still be there when the story ends.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love when a fantasy book flips the script and trades in the usual medieval setting for something more modern while still keeping all the magic and wonder. This one does exactly that—it’s rooted in a contemporary world, but the fantasy and paranormal vibes are still front and center. There are Fae-like creatures, shadows that hold magic (and can even become sentient!), and a moody atmosphere that still gives off classic fantasy energy without relying on castles and swords. It’s the kind of blend that feels fresh but familiar in all the right ways.

What really hooked me was how shadows—something that usually freaks people out, especially kids—are used as this powerful magical force. It was so cool to see them reimagined as more than just something spooky in the dark. That contrast between everyday fears and mystical power made the story stand out. It gave the book a unique twist that stuck with me long after I finished. If you love fantasy with a modern edge and just a little bit of eerie magic, this one’s definitely worth checking out.

Was this review helpful?

I will be consuming this story for my own personal pleasure ;)
Holly Night, let's see what this hype is about.

Was this review helpful?

I decided not to finish this book. I stopped at 34% and I just cannot make myself read it. It has done a poor job at capturing my attention. I don't think thr characters are very likable. The world seems interesting but things are staying too vague for me to feel sucked in. This was unfortunately just not for me.

Was this review helpful?

Charlie Hall has spent her life perfecting the art of thievery. It has gotten her tied up into all sorts of trouble & now is spending her days trying to distance herself from her past. However, life isn’t that simple & when the Liber Noctem is stolen it puts everything she’s been trying to achieve into a tailspin.

Going into this I went in almost completely blind & with an open mind. I haven’t read any of Black’s other works which have given her fans some high expectations going into this as seen in some other reviews. So this will be an unbiased review.

With that being said, my main grievance is with how the first half of the book was slow. Having a slow burn isn’t bad but I really felt like I was pushing myself to get through it. I was intrigued enough to keep reading but it seems the first half has made a lot of readers turned off to the book.

Once things started to pick up & the pieces were fitting into place, I found this an enjoyable read. It kept building up until I was on the edge of my seat until the end. And that ending!! Set us up for the next book & I absolutely need to know what happens next.

3.5★ rounded up

Thank you to NetGalley & the publisher for the arc!!

Was this review helpful?

I am really struggling to give feedback on this. I love Holly Black and find myself picking up everything she has written, so I was very excited to receive this book. Writing-wise, amazing, as always. I needed more on the world in which the characters live. The story started out slowly, although it picked up by the end. I'd suggest sticking with it. Cool concept and premise of the novel.

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t love this one. The Book of Night follows Charlie, a retired bad girl thief. Shadows that come alive and a sketchy boyfriend. It felt very messy. I read a lot of fantasy and this was a bit hard for even me to grasp. I didn’t care for the characters or the plot. I don’t think I’ll be reading the next book when it comes out. This whole book just fell short for me.

Was this review helpful?

I was really hoping to love this, as I really enjoy Holly Black (cruel prince is just 👌👌), but truthfully I think it had been built up to a point I was more let down.

It's not a bad book by any means. It's just... Not the potential I was hoping for. It's slow, and the world building is lacking. The characters are a bit flat for my taste. It's just overall kind of bland. It's the slowest of slow burning plots.

The last part of the book really picked up (like the last 50 pages or so?) but personally it wasn't enough to keep me invested in the next book.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 ⭐

Not a big fan of the beginning, but loved the explosive ending.

I love Blacks writing style but I have to admit I struggled a bit at the beginning. Despite that, i fell in love with Char, one of my now favorite main characters!

Was this review helpful?

I feel like I am very behind on this bandwagon, but glad that I finally got the opportunity to read this book. Really good character development and world building, and a great story line!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for sending me this book to review! I absolutely loved Holly Black's The Folk of the Air series. The author does an amazing job of capturing the reader’s attention by immersing them in the characters’ emotions and motives, while also creating interesting character dynamics. While the author’s other characters resonated with me, I had a difficult time connecting with Charlie Hall. It’s not that I didn’t like Charlie; she just wasn’t as dynamic as the other characters created by Holly Black.

It also took me a while to get through the first half of the book because I didn’t understand the magic system. While shadows were mentioned as being powerful, I didn’t fully grasp what quickened shadows or blights were until Charlie and her sister visited the graduate student about halfway through the book. I also had trouble finding the world and magic particularly interesting. Besides shadows being used cosmetically and to increase one’s power, I didn’t completely understand shadow magic’s significance in the world.

Additionally, Charlie making a huge sacrifice for Vince/Red at the end of the book didn’t make much sense to me. I understand that their relationship was established before the book started, but Charlie didn’t seem that attached to Vince, and he was literally missing for half of the book. Therefore, I, as a reader, struggled to see how she went from “I don’t know this man” or “I don’t trust him” to sacrificing her freedom. I wish I’d seen more of their romance develop before he disappeared.

My favorite part of the book was the ending. Charlie outwitting Vince's grandpa was fun to read. I also enjoyed her proclamation to Vince that she’s going to “steal his heart” again.

I didn’t think The Book of Night was a bad book; Holly Black’s other books are just so good that this one fell a little short for me. Overall, I enjoyed reading it and would continue the series.

Was this review helpful?

Book one in Holly Black’s Charlatan Duology introduces a world in which shadows can come alive and those who can afford it, trade shadows underground. It’s a crime drama with magical elements, and the romance does not feel like the focus until the latter half. I think this story is perfect for fans of The Ninth House; it’s got similarly spooky vibes.

Don’t go in expecting the humor or whimsy from the author’s Folk of the Air series– this is her adult debut. You’ll find the characters grappling with subjects like discovering gruesome murders, dealing with child abuse, and anxiety.

“There’d always been something wrong with Charlie Hall. Crooked, from the day she was born. Never met a bad decision she wasn’t willing to double down on.”

Charlie Hall, our protagonist is a con artist whose world is turned upside down when she tries to find the Book of Night. In between chapters of Charlie’s increasingly dangerous present life, we get a look in to scenes from her tough upbringing. At times I found these chapters more interesting at the start of the book, until the pace picks up in the second half.

I’m looking forward to picking up the sequel after the heart-wrenching twist ending!

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Books for the advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

This hooked me from the first page. I love Holly Black's writing so I knew this would be good. I love the magic system with the shadows and the lore she developed surrounding it. Reminding me a bit of Peter Pan's lost shadow.

I honestly loved Charlie and that she is another morally grey FMC. Also love that she is a curvy girl.

My main issue is that the end of this book felt so abrupt, I got the end and felt like ok where is the rest? I know it has a sequel, but even then the ending didn't feel like a real ending. I feel like I needed at least one more chapter to wrap up this first book and set up for the next. So, I am really looking forward to the next book and seeing if it starts where this one left off or if we will have a time jump.

Overall great book, just felt very unfinished so 3 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this one! It took me a minute to get into it and wrap my head around everything going on but then I was really able to sink into the world. I really liked the shadow magic and dark magic… the vibes were vibing! The writing was very easy to read, descriptive, and satisfying. Charlie is quick witted, and I just loved her attitude. I loved getting a bit of morally grey in an FMC! Definitely looking forward to book two!

Was this review helpful?

Love Charlie. Great character. The writing style is awesome and Charlie sacrifices for the sake of others. Great world-building and compelling urban paranormal storyline.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Tor Books and NetGalley for providing me with a digital copy of Book of Night by Holly Black!

In a world full of shadow magic, power, danger, and deception, Charlie Hall is doing her best to stay out of it. A former con artist, Charlie is grappling with suppressing her darker instincts and building a better life for herself and her sister. When her old life comes knocking once again, will Charlie be able to resist doing what she does best? With secrets hiding around every corner and chaos suddenly at her doorstep, Charlie must use the skills she honed to survive and protect the people she loves.

As a fan of the Folk of the Air series, I have been so excited to read Holly Black’s adult debut, and I was not disappointed! Book of Night was just as dark and mysterious as I hoped it would be. The descriptive writing style drew me in immediately, magic system had me hooked, and the way Holly slowly unravels this story had me constantly wanting to turn the next page. It’s intense, secretive, and sinister. Part two of this duology, Thief of Night, is publishing this September and I will be eagerly awaiting the continuation of this story!

Was this review helpful?