A wonderful read!
This novel drew me in from the very first page and kept me hooked until the end. The characters were vibrant and relatable, the writing was engaging, and the story had just the right balance of heart and humor. Highly recommend!
Many thanks to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for my ARC. All opinions are my own.

Sisterhood
Romance
Forgiveness
Trust
Doubt
Fate
I flew through this! This book is beautiful and will keep you pulled in. If you enjoyed The Crescent Moon Tearoom, you’ll definitely enjoy this second book with the Quigley sisters. I love how (I’ll try to not spoil book 1 if you haven’t read it) it goes from finding their path to coming back together. Each sister has their own problem when it’s time to come together but they are holding back from sharing it with the other sisters.
This is just beautiful! You get a wonderful lesson from each sister (and don’t get me started on the romance, I do have a favorite)! They’ve now gotten comfortable living their own lives and embracing their paths but it’s time for them to come back together. Anne seems to be piggybacking a bit from her issues in book one. Beatrix is being hard on herself and Violet is working towards forgiveness. It’s also so lovely to see how their issues impact their relationships and sisterhood. The enchanted tearoom seems to be a second mother now, seeming to be more emotional and that personification just had me smiling! This book is definitely for the reader in your life, who has a love and passion for books. Who can spend hours wandering the aisles and appreciating all the covers and words that sit on the shelves.

I am so overly excited to have received this book as an ARC. I didn’t know this was a series but I am so excited to read the first one now!

I love anything to do with witches and thus couldn't wait to read this one. I just don't think cozy fantasy is for me, as a genre. The Quigley sisters are adorable and I know my own sister would absolutely love this series so I will absolutely be recommending it to her and friends who love a cozy fantasy.

The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski is a bewitching sequel to the Crescent Moon Tearoom (though it can be read as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading both!) of the Spellbound Sisters series. 🪄 This novel welcomes readers to or back into a world of tea leaves and entangled destinies and sisterhood. The three Quigley sisters return--each having followed their paths, only to be called back home. ✨

Stacy Sivinski has again given me that magical and cozy feeling with this novel. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and I could not put it down. It is perfect if you want a novel with magical fall and winter vibes. There is such a storybook (or whimsical) feeling throughout this novel that follows the Quigley sisters. Similarly to the first one, if you like Practical Magic and Charmed, then this book is for you! I mean, who doesn’t love a sentient house. 🏠

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for providing me with an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
5 out of 5 stars ⭐️

The expected release for this novel is October 7, 2025!

I truly hope there will be more in the Spellbound Sisters world, and I can’t wait to get my hands on a physical copy of this book!

Stacy's Crescent Moon Tearoom blew me away last year and her second instalment we are reunited with the Quigley sisters again. I'm so happy that we got to return to the warmth and spooky world Stacy's painstakingly created for readers. The amount of highlighted moments I have for this is book is outstanding. The descriptions are vivid, the world expands, and the reasons I fell in love with Book One continue in Book Two.

I'm going to be a bit greedy and ask for a third book. I just don't want the adventures to end! Stacy's created such a beautiful world that just ensnares me. The perfect read on a cold night in the fall, The Witching Moon Manor delivers! Thank you so much Atria Books for the digital arc.

This is the perfect cozy, witchy read for October! I was immediately drawn in by the first chapter and enjoyed it through and through. I always enjoy a book with a magical tea room and bookshop. This story follows 3 witch sisters and their quest to complete a fallen witch’s task before their worlds fall apart. I loved seeing how everything and everyone connected. Thank you for a great read!🤍

Thank you to Netgalley and Atria Books for the ARC! If you're drawn to cozy magic, emotionally rich relationships, and storytelling steeped in mystery, Witching Moon Manor is a must-read. Building on the charming world introduced in The Crescent Moon Tearoom, this sequel dives deeper into the emotional core of its characters, especially the sisters at the heart of the story. As a therapist, I love the way Sivinski tackles the various issues the sister’s wrestle with. It’s a deeply authentic portrayal of the different ways individuals seek to find their purpose and meaning in early adulthood but through a warm and cozy lens. The writing is suspenseful but never heavy, keeping you turning pages while weaving in tender moments and thoughtful introspection. It’s a book for readers who crave more than just magic, they want heart, healing, and a space to feel seen. Sivinski clearly writes from a place of love for stories and the readers who find comfort in them. I can’t wait to see where she takes these characters next!

Cozy, magical, and full of heart—this sequel brings the Quigley sisters back together in the best way. I loved the first book and being wrapped up in their world again, with its tea leaves, fate-tangling adventures, and just the right touch of chaos. Funny, warm, and charming as ever.

The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski is a wonderfully atmospheric read that blends mystery, magic, and family secrets into a spellbinding tale. The setting is rich and immersive, with the manor itself feeling like a character in its own right, and the plot pulls you in with its twists and turns. While the pacing occasionally slowed and some elements felt a bit predictable, the strong character development and enchanting world-building made it an engaging read. Sivinski's ability to weave magic and intrigue together kept me hooked until the very end—definitely a book worth picking up for fans of witchy mysteries.

Joining the Quigley back in the Crescent Moon was an absolute delight only added to by some new characters and some equally quirky settings. The forward movement of the sisters' lives keeps me gripped in the story, and the cozy hearths and tea and books keep me grounded. I'd love more of these sisters and their futures, but for now I'm more than content to sit in the comforting stories of the first book and now its equally delightful sequel.

Stepping back into the Quigley Sisters' world and the Crescent Moon is like getting the warmest hug on the coldest day of winter. Stacy Sivinski's writing has actual magic laced into every single word. I'm not the biggest fan of tea (don't tell the sisters), but every description of tea and cinnamon buns had me craving all the treats that are served at the Crescent Moon. I also loved the winter setting in this book, as a Chicagoland native, it was so funny reading about all the characters braving the cold city streets. The descriptions of going from the biting cold winds to the warmth of a shop or a tearoom had me feeling like it was still late January and below zero.

The sisters have all explored their skills and what exactly that means for their future and careers. But when all three begin to feel a snag in the road of their responsibilities, they seek the comfort of one another once again. While I enjoy each sister going on their own journey, there is nothing like the Quigley siblings all back together again. The way the sisters are able to give advice and comfort to one another has me itching for that sort of sibling bond.

I adored the inclusion of Jennings and the mysterious necromancer in this book. The banter and sweetness they added to the book had me smiling from ear to ear every time they were on page.

This is the perfect book to read curled up in a chair, under a blanket, with a heartwarming cup of tea or hot chocolate; it's exactly what the house would want, I think.

5/5 stars

Three sisters, Anne who runs the tea room, Beatrice who is from the circus and Violet the writer. All three have issues and men in their lives, and all three are witches and are triplets. Enjoyed this one, although a few times I was a bit confused, but that was minor. Would highly recommend this one.

The Witching Moon Manor is the second book in the Spellbound Sisters series. However, this book can be read as a standalone. It is full of magic, cozy feels and perfect for Fall vibes! I really enjoyed the storyline, characters, friendships and romance in this book! It has a whimsical feel throughout the entire book. I found it to be engaging and felt joyful after reading it! I highly recommend this book to anyone that is looking for a cozy fantasy read! I rate this book a 4 out of 5 stars!

Thank you to NetGalley, author Stacy Sivinski and Atria Books publishing for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This book is expected to be released on October 7, 2025!

Loved this even more than the first book!!
A cozy and whimsical good time perfect to curl up on the sofa with some hot coco or tea to read!
Follow the Quigley sisters as they try to determine why the magic in their town is not as it usually is. We follow some new characters as well as characters from book one! Lovely to get to catch back up with them. My favorite part about this series is the sisterly bond! Definitely worth the read loved book me book two was even better and come on THIS COVER!!!

In this sequel to The Crescent Moon Tearoom, Sivinski serves up more cozy, atmospheric fantasy at its best. While I’m generally not a fan of sequels, I have to admit that I enjoyed this one even more than the first book. The stakes are still very low and the language still very flowery (occasionally a little over the top, to be honest), but it was great to see each of the sisters more firmly on their own journeys this time. The author clearly saw how much fans of the first book enjoyed the house as a character and has leaned into that a bit too hard in my opinion, but I loved the bookshop so I’ll ignore the sentient manor. While I enjoyed the awkward progression of romance for Bea, the very obvious enemies-to-lovers plot for Anne developed far too quickly and with an underdeveloped, underwhelming partner. All in all, The Witching Moon Manor is a great choice for fans of lush settings, charming characters, and the low-stakes coziness of a magical story to whisk you away.

This was so cute and pure and I had a fantasy time with this. It game me “A Witch’s guide to fake dating a demon” vibes that were just everything.

The Witching Moon Manor is charming, atmospheric, and full of heart—but also a little hard to follow at times. Stacy Sivinski really knows how to build a magical world that feels cozy and mysterious, and I genuinely enjoyed spending more time with the Quigley sisters. Each of their paths—Anne, Beatrix, and Violet —was interesting in its own right, and their reunion had that warm, nostalgic energy I love in sibling-centered stories.

That said, I found myself getting confused more than once. Some transitions felt abrupt, and there were moments where I wasn’t quite sure what the stakes were or how certain magical rules worked. The plot juggled a lot—necromancy, romance, looming danger—and while it was ambitious, it sometimes left me feeling like I missed a page (or five).

Still, the writing is lovely, the themes of identity and sisterhood really shine, and there’s a certain magic in the way Sivinski writes about healing and homecoming. I just wish I’d had a bit more clarity along the way.

If you liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom, you’ll probably enjoy this one too—just maybe bring a notebook.

I went into this hoping it would be like the first one and was not surprised! The characters as well as the plots flow beautifully and I really enjoyed learning more about the sisters. Definitely just a cozy fun read!

This was such a cozy story. I especially liked the scenes with the enchanted bookshop, and the sentient house was also a favorite character. This was a low stakes story, which made it easier to sink into the coziness and enjoy the comforts (and scents) along the way.