This feels like curling up in a cozy tearoom full of swirling teacups, sisterly warmth, and soft magic. Stacy Sivinski builds a gentle yet impactful world where love, family, and magic intertwine and while it’s lighter on suspense than some, its charm and character depth shine through.

The Quigley sisters are back and reunited for another witchy adventure. Like sipping a hot cup of tea from their tea shop, this second novel in the series is a cozy return to good friends. Needing to help the ghost of a witch complete their unfinished business, Sicinski dives deeper into uncovering more of these loveable characters.

Perfect for the upcoming Halloween season, this book does not disappoint!

I think this book was even better than the first one in the series. The three sisters characters were developed more and new characters were introduced that added a lot to the story. These books are so cozy and comforting, they are perfect for enjoying with a hot cup of tea and a warm blanket. I would highly recommend.

Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

I was thrilled to find out the Quigley triplets were returning. I so enjoyed book one, and this one was no different. The relationship between the sisters may be different in ways, but also the same in all the ways that matter.

I really liked how we got so much more for each sister. It was like three stories circling the main plot, and was very well done.

If you enjoy sisterhood, witches, and historical fiction, this is definitely a book for you!

4.75/5 stars. My only real complaint is the overuse of the word texture. It was used over 30+ times.

The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski.

A continuation of Anne, Beatrix, and Violet's stories from The Crescent Moon Tearoom. If you haven't read book 1 of this series, I strongly recommend you read it before starting this one.

This story starts will all 3 Quigley sisters experiencing a personal crisis that draws them back home to the Crescent Moon Tearoom. For Anne, the threads of destiny are unravelling. It's a battle of wills between the Diviner and the handsome Necromancer standing in her way. Beatrix has lost her words, but perhaps with help from her friend Jennings she can find them again. And Violet's over confidence and impulsivity has led to a near tragedy with Emil. I love that there is romance (clean) present in these stories, but the relationship between the three sisters is the real focus.

Not only do we see the personality of the Crescent Moon Tearoom shine again, but we're also introduced to a couple of other anthropomorphic abodes with their own wonderful characteristics.

5/5 stars. Stacy Sivinski's writing has a phenomenal immersive texture to it that appeals to all 5 senses. It's a really unique style of writing, to me, and journeying through this book felt like being wrapped in a cozy blanket while resting next to a crackling fire with a good cup of tea that never grows cold. I will absolutely read any future books from this author, and this series will for sure be a re-read for me.

Thank you to NetGalley, Stacy Sivinski, and Atria Books for the opportunity to read the eARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.

I'm disappointed to say this one wasn't quite as engaging for me as the first in the series, The Crescent Moon Tearoom.

In the beginning the sisters are separated, with each pursuing their passions. However they all come back together again at the Crescent Moon Tearoom house as each finds they need the comfort and support of the others.

Anne is struggling with her new role on the Council of Witches, Beatrix has major writer's block, and Violet's carefree spirit has been damaged by a mistake.

The unraveling of Fates as Mr. Crowley's undone task looms large as it comes to light just how powerful he was. They have to find a way to finish his task without forcing him apart from his love.

I loved the magical aspects of the book and the sister relationships, but I kind of hated just how perfectly tied up in a bow (dang near simultaneously) each of their romantic relationships ended in this book. I know it's a cozy book but can we have some struggle? Ah well. Low stakes it is.

The Witching Moon Manor is the kind of story that wraps around you like a warm blanket on a crisp fall evening. Magical and cozy in all the best ways, it’s a perfect seasonal read filled with charm and a touch of whimsy. I absolutely loved the characters and the storyline. Also, the book cover is so cute!

Would I recommend this book to you? Yes

Expected Release Date: 10/07/2025

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the early access. All thoughts in this review are my own.

The Witching Moon Manor is the second novel by Stacy Sivinski and follows her debut, The Crescent Tearoom, which I had the pleasure of reviewing as an ARC as well. I was thrilled to have the opportunity to revisit this charming tearoom and magical sisters (triplets) with their unique, special gifts.

One a talented diviner, another an acrobatic marvel, the last an insightful author; the Quigley witch sisters each struggle with their diverging paths as fate and duty test them.

They must also come together to investigate what is causing the city’s magical disturbances. The future depends on finding an answer.

I enjoyed this book as much as the first and hope to see more of these characters in future stories. This is the perfect book for the warm vibes of fall when it is set to release on October 7, 2025.

This is the first sequel I"ve read that I enjoyed even more than the first in the series. Getting to spend time with the sisters again now that they have embraced their own paths was a lovely experience, and I look forward to what comes next

I loved The Crescent Moon Tearoom and devoured this sequel. The Quigley sisters reunite to solve a mystery and complete a task that threatens all while working through some issues of their own. The storytelling is masterful. Readers will feel drawn into the story and need a cup of tea to warm their souls. The characters are wonderfully multifaceted, and the introductions of the new characters was delightful. I eagerly read this on Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

The Witching Moon Manor

A perfect Fall escape, The Witching Moon Manor delivers spellbinding coziness and heartfelt magic. Sivinski’s warm, vivid prose brings Anne, Beatrix, and Violet—and their beautifully layered sisterhood—to life. With charming new romances, a mysterious unfinished Witch’s task, and the ever-enchanting Quigley house, this sequel shines. Be sure to start with The Crescent Moon Tearoom for the full Spellbound Sisters experience. These books are like wrapping yourself in a warm, magical hug.

This is the second book in The Spellbound Sisters series, and I have enjoyed them both. The 3 sisters own a tearoom that especially gives these stories very cozy vibes. Sometimes the coziness makes the stories feel like they’re moving a bit slowly, but I will say that The Witching Moon Manor grabbed and held my attention much better than The Crescent Moon Tearoom. These are sweet stories- I love the Quigley sisters and their enchanted places and friends, and I also admire the way the characters cherish each other. Thank you to NetGalley and Atria books for allowing me to read this ARC for review.

5 stars!! This is the perfect fall read. I love the sisters dynamic. It’s a fun, cozy and magical read.

Such a fun sequel to one of my favorite witchy books last year. I am so grateful to have been given the opportunity to read this book early. Thank you!

I was delighted to be reunited with Violet, Beatrix, and Anne. The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski was as charming and cozy as The Crescent Moon Tea Room and is the perfect book to curl up with on a rainy afternoon. While each sister experiences personal growth, they all remain true to their core selves and their family. Also, there's an enchanted house (!!!) and lots of swoony romance.

Thank you to the Publisher and NetGalley for the advance copy.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me a copy of this book to review.

This was a fun romance novel, and I enjoyed it a lot. I am looking forward to reading more by this author.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the E-arc.

I really enjoyed this second installment in The Spellbound Sisters series. The atmosphere and setting would make this book a wonderful winter read. The book takes place over a couple weeks in winter and has both the cozy and cold winter vibes in abundance. The magical house really adds an extra layer of magic and whimsy to the story.

I really loved seeing the Quigley sisters come together and support each other in this book. It was a nice change of pace from book one and really helped build them as individual characters and helped strengthen their relationships to each other.

I did find the book dragged a little bit in the middle and got repetitive for a while but by the end, it had me engaged again and I really loved how it ended.

This is a great book for fans of The Honey Witch, The Spellshop or The House Witch.

Thank you #netgalley for the review copy.

It had been awhile since I read book one in this series so I needed a refresher on where the prior had left off, it was kind of odd when I recalled how final the prior book felt and how the sisters had been so concerned about separating since this book takes place a year later and references other gatherings so my ladies are all verklempt about parting ways and are together less than a year later?! Okay then.

Putting that aside, the book was an enjoyable cozy fantasy read and while I will always want more sentient houses, without going into spoiler territory, let’s say I have wasn’t disappointed (even if I still want MORE) especially with the wish fulfillment sentient space that we are introduced to in this book. While I delight in the family home doing all the housekeeping it’s also been interesting to explore a teeny tiny bit what it thinks and dreams about in this book and I’m left with wanting more of this.

The family home is so much more interesting than these dudes although the necromancer is less boring even if the overall romance is zzzzzz and predictable AF. I’m notoriously not a fan of romances so take that as you will. Am I saying this snoozefest of couples is because none of them are gay? No, but honestly at least when it comes to fantasy cozy or otherwise, the gay coupling protagonists generally tend to be less dull and have so far contained less mountains of tropes and eye rolling dialogue.

You can read this book as a standalone since it really kind of feels like all the momentous decisions and big drama from book one become non-issues and perhaps it might even be a more rewarding experience if you haven’t read the first book before reading this one. Then after reading this one if you enjoyed the characters and want more you can go back and read book 1 already knowing the sisters are going to be back together all under one roof in short order. 🤷🏻‍♀️

While I don’t think it’s been announced, I bet there will be a third book, and I hope this one will delve more into the magic system of this world and the sentient buildings will get a lot more page time

The Witching Moon Manor is the perfect Fall read, and I definitely recommend reading The Crescent Moon Tearoom first, which is the first book in The Spellbound Sisters series. Sivinski's writing is so descriptive and it delivers the coziest of vibes in these books. If you're looking for books that you could curl up in, then these are the ones you're looking for!

Anne, Beatrix, and Violet are great characters, and I really love their sister relationship, and their individual personalities. There are some new romances happening in this book, and I loved seeing how each one of them unfolded. The unfinished Witch's task adds a great mystery element to the story and brings in some heartwarming feels. And I have to say that one of my most favorite characters in both books is the Quigley's house...it is the coziest of cozies!!

𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭:
* Teacup Readings
* Magic & the Afterlife
* Sibling Relationships
* Coming Home
* Feel Good, Cozy Vibes

𝐈𝐬 𝐈𝐭 𝐒𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐲?
🥶 (No)

If you love cozy, witchy stories with romance, supportive siblings, comforting vibes, and magic and mystery, then I highly recommend adding The Witching Moon Manor to your TBR.

I couldn't get enough of The Crescent Moon Tearoom when it came out last year. I loved the cozy, magical story of the Quigley sisters, and I ended up reading this book several times last fall. I was thrilled to discover that there was a sequel, and this book does not disappoint. The Witching Moon Manor has all of the cozy fantasy that I enjoyed in the first book while continuing the Quigley sister's journey. I loved seeing each of the sisters' stories continue as they worked together to find what was causing magical disturbances throughout the city. There was also a little more romance in this book that I adored. This book left me with happy tears, and I hope this is not the end of the Quigley sister's journey.

The Witching Moon Manor is out October 7th.

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to review The Witching Moon Manor. All thoughts and opinions are my own.