Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The perfect enemies to lovers novel! I also really enjoyed the theme of class-differences and how easy it is to get swept up in critiquing those who “have more.” I love Chelsea Fagan’s writing and I will consume anything that she writes!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a romance but didn’t feel conventional. I enjoyed the discussion around class and wealth and the impact this not only has on yourself but also on the relationships around. The tangential plotlines really added to the main romance plot that it made it such an easy read.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the High Dive. Like Fagan’s first book, the setting is as much a character as anything else, which makes it an ideal summer or beach read. The two timelines were interesting, but it took almost too long to get to the meat of it all. The protagonist is relatable, plucky and deeply flawed without being a ditz, which is hard to find in the romance/women’s fiction genre. I’ve seen Fagan discuss her approach to writing sex scenes on her TikTok, but I think the one in this book kind of missed the mark. Maybe it was the logistics of the situation but if you’ve got just one truly steamy scene it shouldn’t be hard to follow. I’ve excited to read Fagan’s next book!

Was this review helpful?

I loved The High Dive! The banter, the slooow burn, the second-chance romance, the diversity and complexity of the characters—it all worked so well. I personally related to Alex the most, but also to Danial (there’s something about growing up poor—even when you’re no longer struggling, that feeling of being out of place lingers). I absolutely adored their love story (and Alex and Paul!).

I appreciated how the book used flashbacks for context without falling into a rigid back-and-forth structure. The pacing felt organic. This is a story about growth, self-reflection, friendship, deep love, identity, societal expectations, and class disparity.

Once I had time to dive in, I couldn’t put it down. I laughed out loud at several moments—the dialogue felt incredibly authentic, like I was right there with them. Even the characters I didn’t like were intentionally complex, and the entire friend group felt fully realized.

I’d love to see the story continue, but I also feel completely satisfied with how it ended.

I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Here's a nightmare scenario for you. You haven't seen or spoken to (who you once thought was) the love of your life in 10 years; you've since loathed them and everything they stand for. Now picture yourself stuck on a 10 day Mediterranean yacht trip... And they're on board. Not only that, but you're joined by several other pompous assholes you've known since college, the majority of whom don't even really like you all that much. How long until you sashay the plank and yeet yourself straight into the water, where your salty tears can mingle with the plentiful sea? ...yeah.

Alex Onassis is the Director of Social Media Strategy for the Worker's Horizon Party. Her function mostly entails making videos in which she vents about big corporations and their questionable ethics. She's mulling over her upcoming target, Horace Capital Partners (a private equity firm), and gets some final things in place before she leaves for a vacation in the Mediterranean. Well, if you can call "being forced to spend 10 days on a boat with a guy she hates because their mutual friend from college is getting married" a vacation. Danial Azad: former friend slash love of her life, and current Managing Director at Horace Capital Partners. Alex and Danial both come from a more humble upbringing, and Alex resents Danial for the choices he's made since she last saw him. 

TL;DR:
Grab a knife, because we've got tension to cut. 

All pretence of civility flies right out the window, much to the chagrin of their other yacht companions: the rest of the "Columbia Club" group of college friends. Sophie, couple Bee & Dev, and engaged couple Paul & Guy - every single one of them comes from money, and it shows. And now that Danial has gone up the corporate ladder, the only outlier in the friend group is Alex, and she feels incredibly uncomfortable for being expected to enjoy this kind of undeserved luxury - hypocritical when she does. And insecure, because Danial is here. 

The High Dive is a second chance - or rather, a missed chance - love story. Alex & Danial's constant bickering betrays their deeper unresolved feelings from years ago; flashback snippets woven throughout the present timeline reveal what exactly happened that one night, peeling back the onion layers one sneer at a time. The "before" scenes are deliciously angsty and give succinct insight into a younger (less cynical) Alex, and how everything with Danial affected her. Danial is a complex character as well: he doesn't come across as antagonistic; rather, Alex is the one who tends to be more volatile in temper. Danial is quick to defend himself - at times by cutting deep. 

Underneath it all, Chelsea Fagan shows - when you read between the lines - that they both obviously deal with a lot of hurt. And people you don't care about typically don't have the power to make you hurt that much. There is an effective intensity to their confrontational scenes, moving the plot forward in an evocative manner while pushing the characters toward change.  Their arguments are not just about unresolved feelings, but about socioeconomic status, morality, motivations behind choices made. It seems like a lot, but Fagan makes it make sense. I ended up seeing both sides, and I applaud that realistic approach to adult arguments and differences. Alex and Danial both have to work really hard to come together and the reward is so much higher compared to romances where one character messes up something in their budding relationship, and inevitably has to grovel. 

I can't not give a special mention to Paul - the sunshine character of the Columbia Group, the glue that holds together both the friend group as well as the book itself. The High Dive gets a lot right, but if it weren't for Alex's strong relationship with Paul, there would have been no logical reason for her to ever be on that boat. Had Fagan written him like the other Columbia Club characters, this book would have been an entirely different read. We don't care about the others in the group at all and I don't think we are expected to? Bee, Sophie, Dev and Guy don't feature heavily in the novel because they are supposed to be found lacking. They bring entitlement and generational wealth to the table, but other than that... I feel a disconnect there. 

But Paul? We need to protect Paul at all costs. In a sense, Alex has a few things to resolve with him, too, and I'm glad their friendship rides shotgun in The High Dive, with an emotionally impactful arc of its own. 

Thank you NetGalley for a copy of this eBook. My opinions on this book are honest and entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

3.75 ⭐️ Fabulous settings, well-drawn characters (tho some a bit insufferable at times ...), intriguing relationships. A. fun, escapist read.
The author's debut was such a wow!--enjoyed this latest but not as consistently captivating.
Still look forward to upcoming books!

With thanks to NetGalley, Orsay Press and Chelsea Fagan for this e-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This book was the perfect way to kick off summer! While I felt like the characters themselves could have used a bit more depth, I loved the discussion of social class and thought that was explored very well in this book. After reading A Perfect Vintage, I’ll pick up anything Fagan writes, and this was no exception!

Was this review helpful?

vibes are really good. our protagonist, Alex, is an interesting character, if a little grating at the beginning, and our LI is really fun and works well with her. 4 stars, tysm for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

I think this book just wasn’t for me. I didn’t find either character likable. I found their banter a bit exhausting. The book is well done for what it’s trying to convey but just not for me

Was this review helpful?

The premise of this book was really good, and I was excited to read it. It didn't really deliver for me unfortunately.

Alex sucked. She thought she was better than everyone else because she wasn't rich but in the same breath kept saying she was below them because she was poor. I'm begging for you to pick a struggle. Also, she was SO defensive and confrontational to literally everyone. Someone would try and show they care? Shes mad because she thinks they're pitying her for absolutely no reason.

Danial (I pronounced it "denial" every single time I read it, and I couldn't stop) I think had the potential to be good. If this had been dual pov and we could see how desperately he was yearning, this could've been a 5-star book.

They have this whole dramatic decade long yearn-fest and we don't even get the reunion??????? He finally gives her a letter saying how much he loves her then we skip to the next day where they wake up together?????? There was no emotional payoff.

Overall, this book was well written, the setting was fun, and the background characters (especially Paul <3) had distinct personalities. I just didn't like how the romance played out.

ARC from NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

First I’d like to than author Chelsea Fagan because I saw your book announcement almost two month ago and I needed to get my hands on your book one way or another. Secondly I’d like to thank NetGalley and Orsay Press for a copy of this eARC.

I’ll start this off by saying this isn’t typically my favorite kind of read to begin with, but having followed the author on social media for some time I knew I’d enjoy what she wrote. The fluidity of your words and how you weave together a realistic story full of life’s complexities is beautifully captured.

Was this review helpful?

This is a tight, fun beach / vacation read, with rounded characters, all-consuming vibes, and more than a dash of relatable real-life problems to ground it.

It simmers, crackles, lets you sink in but never get too comfortable (it keeps you wondering, hoping, cringing), until the end. There's an elegant balance of warmth, wit, and tension.

Was this review helpful?

I should preface this review by saying I don’t usually go for romances, so this book likely had an uphill battle to fight anyway. I went for it because I thought the idea of discussing class differences in the context of romance was intriguing. Unfortunately, I found the book a drag to get through. I can’t say that I’d recommend this even to romance readers because I imagine there have to be better romances out there.

My issues:
* An egregious amount of telling and not showing. The writing style felt almost YA in its insistence on spelling things out for readers.
* That being said, there was also a frustrating lack of background on major parts of the book. Alex is constantly complaining about her “friends.” They all seem to annoy her in little and big ways throughout the book, in both the present day and flashbacks. So why have they all maintained relationships and stayed friends for ten years post-college? It takes real effort to keep those relationships, and I cannot understand why Alex did so. I don’t believe that these people are friends.
* Also very little explanation on the enmity between Alex and Danial’s The reader spends the first 70% of the book not understanding WHY they hate each other. The reveal is ultimately anticlimactic. Their falling out is awkward and uncomfortable, but nothing that justifies a 10-year long beef.
* The book ultimately had very shallow and minimal discussions on class. Most of the conflict takes place in Alex’s head, which is not to say that it’s imagined, but that it’s Alex’s thoughts and observations. She notices or thinks to herself, “Wow, I’m so different from these ultra rich people.” But there’s very little direct class conflict between her and the rest of the group. There could’ve even been interesting conversations or relationships with the presumably less wealthy staff, but all we get is an awkward moment when Alex blurts out that she’s not as rich as her friends—and then she insists later that she talked to the staff all the time? Alex also displayed a myopic lack of introspection on her own privilege. While she might not have had yacht money, she attained an Ivy League education and seemed to have a stable, full-time job. There just wasn’t a lot said here besides: rich people have it pretty easy! More news at 10!
* The romance kind of came out of nowhere in my opinion. They went from hating each other to not. I didn’t find the relationship well-developed.

Was this review helpful?

I'm on a camping weekend with my husband and kids and I'm actively neglecting them because I'm mentally on a yacht in the Mediterranean. I love the conflict and the angst in this one and I totally identified with the FMC as a fellow broke liberal with lots of animosity toward the wealthy. I don't usually enjoy time hops but this was done well. The spice could have been increased a few notches, but the simmering want was there without too much graphic detail and I suppose that's on par with our high brow characters. I found the author on Tiktok watching her non-author content and I really love seeing that she contains multitudes.

Was this review helpful?

In The High Dive, Alexandra Onassis, a politically driven social media strategist, is forced to reunite with her old college classmate, Danial Azad, during a ten-day yacht trip ahead of their friends’ Mediterranean wedding. Once the only scholarship kids in an elite Columbia friend group, their dynamic shattered after one devastating night. Now on opposite sides of the economic and political spectrum, Alex and Danial must navigate lingering tension, buried feelings, and the stark realities of class and identity in this smart, emotionally layered novel. I loved it!

Was this review helpful?

The High Dive is a captivating and gorgeously written novel that draws you in with its sharp wit, vivid settings, and unforgettable characters. Chelsea Fagan paints a world of opulence and escapism aboard a luxurious yacht, where every glittering detail feels effortlessly real. But beneath the glossy surface, what truly makes this story shine is the friendship between Alex and Paul—complex, intimate, and beautifully developed.

Alex is a standout protagonist: intelligent, flawed, magnetic, and deeply relatable. Her inner life is richly drawn, making her emotional journey both compelling and authentic. The dialogue throughout is razor-sharp and emotionally charged, building a slow-burn romantic tension that is as satisfying as it is restrained. Every character feels fully alive, with layers of nuance that make even fleeting moments resonate.

Fagan has written a story that is as introspective as it is glamorous—one that lingers long after the final page. Highly recommended for fans of character-driven fiction with bite and heart.

Was this review helpful?

The High Dive exceeded my expectations so spectacularly. Beyond being beautifully written I really enjoyed the way the author incorporated so many real life elements into this romance.

I could really relate to the whole “difference of political opinions” as well as different social statuses and how they can inevitably complicate friendships and relationships. It made the whole book read like a “true life event”.

The romance was done so elegantly and clean. That being said it still had some of the most profound tension and chemistry I’ve read to date. Alex and Danial will have a special place in my heart forever.

Side Note: The book does take a minute to get into. It is slow paced. But I promise you it is so worth reading. The payoff is 👌👌👌.

Thank you Netgalley and Chelsea Fagan for the ARC copy. The thoughts and opinions above are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Such a page turner! This book ties up politics, wealth, and relationships in a beautiful sea-blue ribbon. Our MC Alex finally goes OOO from her political communications job at the Worker’s Horizon Party to celebrate her best friends' bachelor party and wedding. Reuniting with her college friends for a yacht trip around the Mediterranean means confronting extreme wealth and the crush she never truly got over.
I can see some readers not liking how much money is featured in this book, but for me it kept it grounded. It also helped me to better understand Alex's character and why she makes the decisions she does. I also really enjoyed the political aspects; how *can* you enjoy such a lush and expensive yacht trip that few can even dream of while working for workers rights and calling out the rich?
I found the romance a bit unrealistic but it didn't stop me from enjoying it.
The only regret I have is not lying out in the sun while enjoying this. Overall it's a fab summer read!

Was this review helpful?

An analytical and political hotspot of summer, love, and the repercussions of past mistakes and current ones. Fagan is an introspective writer with a sharp outlook on the complexities of the middle class and the wealthy and she doesn't hesitate to explore the complexities of both even if one of them often receives heavy criticism from her. Although the writing in this book is intellectual, sharp, and bold the storyline itself, in the romantic sense, is a bit unbelievable and random. I didn't feel strongly connected to the characters due to this writing style, though I know these characters will heavily appeal to the millenial demographic, especially those who work in corporate America.

Was this review helpful?

I had a great time reading this book. I was engaged with wanting to know where the story was going to go, if the main characters would work out their differences. I kept wanting to sneak in pages any chance I could and finished it in 3 days. (Would have been sooner had I not had work.

This felt like it should be first person but it’s written in third person. It felt like I was in Alex’s head, feeling her emotions, more than anyone else. We followed her around more than anyone else.

Alex has a lot of hang ups on not being rich. There was zero self-development around that. In the end she was still insecure about it. The incident that set this all up set 10 years prior was overblown. It didn’t seem nearly bad enough to warrant avoiding someone for 10 years.

Was this review helpful?