Let us talk about "A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons" by J. Penner.

I so loved diving back into J. Penner’s Adenashire Series! “A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons” brings you right back into the small town of Adenashire, and this time focusing on our lovely Doli Butterbuckle, a dwarf who just wants to get lost in romance books, spend time with her friends, and be who she is meant to be.

But Doli is in for a treat! Her great uncle has bestowed unto her a gift – an inheritance like no other. Although Doli tries to keep her past life and present life separate, the inheritance will pull her past front and center – making her come face to face with the reality of who she is and who she is meant to be. She’s been given a dragon egg – and not just any type of a dragon, but a rare and unique dragon that has no problem getting herself into chaos and trouble.

Plus – there is a new person in town that has caught her eye, and he is mysterious enough that she needs to know more about him. But will secrets and skepticism keep her from knowing more? Who is Sarson, and what does this gargoyle hide?
Lush with imagination, unexpected gifts, and all the baked goods, Doli is set to learn more about who she is deep down. She’s balancing her life, a new love, meddling parents, dragon-bonding, and a mystery!

If you love a good cozy fantasy read that warms your insides, makes you crave a custard tart with a hot cup of tea, I truly recommend picking up this book. It just warms you from the inside out.

Thank you to NetGalley, author J. Penner, and Poisoned Pen Press for the advanced copy for review.

✨ Found Family
✨ Magical Creatures
✨ World Building
✨ Small Town Vibes
✨ He Falls First
✨ Baked Goods
✨ Cozy Fantasy

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🫑
Series: Book 2 of 4

Thank you @poisonedpenpress, @jpennerauthor for sending the Advanced Reader's Copy of this book!

A charming, delightful, full of mischief and heartfelt adventure.

In A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons, the reader is whisked away to the quaint town of Adenashire, where life seems simple, magical, and endlessly charming. Doli Butterbuckle, a lovable dwarf with a knack for tea magic, is content in her small, close-knit world. She may never have lived up to her family's lofty expectations, but her life is full of warmth – until the arrival of an inherited dragon egg and a mysterious, charismatic gargoyle with a secret.

This delightful fantasy novel is not just a tale of dragons and magic, but one of self-discovery, love, and the strength that comes from embracing who we truly are. Doli's journey is a beautiful one, filled with heart and humour as she grapples with the weight of familial expectations, the responsibility of caring for an unpredictable fervour dragon, and the blossoming of a love that defies expectations.

Doli is the beating heart of this story. A sunshine dwarf who just wants to make everyone happy, she's incredibly relatable in her vulnerability. But as she faces the challenges of dragon-raising and the dark, sinister forces that threaten her peaceful life, we see her blossom into someone brave, wise, and fiercely true to herself. Her transformation is heartwarming – reminding readers that the most magical thing we can do is embrace who we are, flaws and all.

The town of Adenashire itself is a character in its own right. It paints a picture of a cosy, whimsical setting where dragons and gargoyles are as much a part of everyday life as books and tea. Doli's circle of friends, each with their own quirks and charm, adds depth to the story, offering light moments that balance the more intense moments.

The romance between Doli and the enigmatic gargoyle Sarson is slow-burning and utterly beautiful. It is a love story that doesn't feel rushed but rather builds with the gentle pace of the narrative, showing that the best relationships are those founded on mutual respect, understanding, and a bit of magic.

The pacing of the story is perfectly balanced, with a nice mix of action, humour, and emotional depth. The dragon subplot, with its mischievous antics, adds a delightful layer of whimsy to the plot, making the stakes feel high while keeping the tone light and fun.

At its core, A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons is a story about finding your own place in the world and learning that it's okay to break free from the expectations others have for you. Doli's journey is a testament to the power of community, friendship, and accepting yourself – even when it feels like the world wants you to be something you're not.

If you're in the mood for a cozy fantasy that feels like a warm hug, A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons by J. Penner is a delightful pick. I was happy to revisit the charming town of Adenashire, this sequel continues the series' signature blend of magic, friendship, and heartwarming moments.

This installment is all about Doli Butterbuckle, the ever-cheerful dwarf with her tea magic. Her journey takes an unexpected turn when she inherits a dragon egg, adding a whimsical twist to her story.
While it might not have the same momentum as the first book, AFoL&D offers a soothing read that's perfect for when you need a break from high-stakes adventures. It's a charming addition to the Adenashire series, it left me with a sense of contentment.

A Fellowship of Librarians and Dragons follows the adventures of magical creatures in the cozy and whimsy town of Adenashire. Doli is our heroine and she goes on a self-discovery journey to feel her feelings, set boundaries with loved ones and raise Evvy, the adorable pink dragon (this is a magical tale after all!). There’s also a library run by orcs, a handsome gargoyle love interest and many mentions of baking, including complete recipes at the end.

This story is firmly in the cozy fantasy genre. At times, the story felt very predictable, almost Hallmark-esque, but I think readers know this going into the series. It’s a feel good story where you know who the love interest is in first few pages. This is also the second book in the series so I’d recommend reading the first (I know, I know, that’s a hot take). I haven’t read the first and it took me awhile to figure out who all the characters were and their dynamics.

Overall, it’s a cute story and if readers previously enjoyed “Legends & Lattes” and “The Spellshop”, they might like this series as well.

Thank you NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for this ARC.

What a perfectly darling fantasy. Romantic elements, emotional dynamics with family, and a dragon whose need for a guardian couldn’t come at a more hectic time for poor Doli. J. Penner’s fantasy world is descriptive, cozy, and so heartwarming!

A Fellowship of Librarians and Dragons - J Penner

I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of this from Netgalley, and I am so glad I did! What a glorious series I’ve discovered. Cosy fantasy at its finest!

This book focused on Doli, the dwarf we met at the baking battle, and her journey in Adenshire, including a rather handsome gargoyle named Sarson! There was romance novels, dragons, difficult family members and tea aplenty. It was absolutely delightful. As an avid tea drinker, I adored all the descriptions of tea, and tea magic (I want tea magic now tbh).

I really enjoyed all the interaction between Doli and characters from the first book, like Jez, Theo and Arleta. As well as new characters like her parents and Evvy.

I’m very excited for the next book in the series, which is on KU, as I’m pretty sure it’s all about Jez the fennex, and I’m so excited to learn more about her! My chronically ill self resonates with her need for naps and general dislike of most people! Another ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ review from me.

A Fellowship of Librarians Dragons
I am completely in love with Doli she was such a fun character to learn more about and Evvy was perfect! This was such a cozy fantasy and I loved it. Especially, all the cozy recipes that I will now have to attempt to make because reading about them is not enough!!! Thank you NetGalley for the Deluxe Edition ARC

I enjoyed the first book in this series, and while I’m not sure this was quite as good, it was still very enjoyable. This book is the epitome of low stakes cozy fantasy. Nothing particularly high-impact happens, but reading it felt warm and fuzzy, it’s just a lovely world filled with magical things!

Oh my stars what a cute book. This book follows doli , taking care of a surprise inheritance from her uncle. Doli is a librarian dwarf who mostly hangs out with her friends instead of doing actual work. If anything slightly minor happens doli will burst out in tears.


Doli doesn’t get along with her parents since she didn’t follow the family business, so she ran away from home. They pay her a surprise visit and it gives doli so much anxiety. Ehhh rightfully so , they are a little intense!!!


I liked Sarson but I didn’t really feel a romantic connection between him and doli !!!




Thanks NetGalley and poisoned pen press for this e-arc in exchange for my honest review

I loved the themes of this book. I read the first in the series a while ago, also as an ARC and this series is just so wholesome in the found family and friendships. Can't wait to read the next one! <3

Such a cozy read, I love the characters and the plot line it had me hooked from the very first chapter will definitely look forward to more books by this author

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced digital review copy.

A Fellowship of Librarians and Dragons is the second book in the Adenashire series. I enjoyed this cozy fantasy. It isn't necessary to read the series in order. They are completely readable on their own.

Set in the charming village of Adenashire, A Fellowship of Librarians & Dragons bubbles over with found family, quirky magical creatures, and just the right dose of gentle chaos.

Doli Butterbuckle is refreshingly relatable—gentle, a little self-doubting, and learning to take up space in a world that doesn’t always make it easy. When she inherits a dragon egg and a secretive gargoyle strolls into town, her peaceful tea-sipping life is turned upside down. Cue magical mischief, heartfelt moments, and an utterly adorable baby dragon named Eevy who steals every scene.

I adore this series, and this latest instalment is another warm hug of a book from J. Penner. The plot is well-paced, the magical world of Adenashire is brimming with charm, and Doli’s emotional arc—especially her gentle journey toward self-worth—is a joy to watch unfold.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Cosy, whimsical, and full of heart.

Perfect for fans of Legends & Lattes and The House in the Cerulean Sea. I already can’t wait to return to Adenashire!

Thank you to NetGalley and J.Penner for allowing me to read this ARC.
A very cozy and cute fantasy, Doli is so relatable.
There is a lot of focus on baking, even including recipes at the end. Not a lot of book/library focus.
This being the second book maybe I should have read the first one before this one. Maybe the world and character building was there.
This book was not for me sorry

Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Press for this ARC

This book felt like a warm cup of tea on a rainy day: cozy, clever, and full of charm. As a fan of low-stakes fantasy, I really enjoyed the magical libraries, found family dynamics, and a quest that’s more about connection than chaos.

The pace is gentle, giving plenty of room for banter (my absolute favorite), bookish spells, and dragons who care a little too much about due dates. If you liked “The Spellshop” or “Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea”, this one will be right up your alley.

It’s the kind of story that leaves you smiling and sometimes, that’s exactly what you need! I can’t wait to try the recipes provided at the end!

I adore this book and series! The second book in the Adenashire series and it’s just as cozy as the first! This book follows Doli, a dwarf whom Arletta met at the Baking Battle in the first book. Doli’s uncle dies and leaves her an unexpected inheritance, a rare dragon egg. This book feels like getting together with old friends, catching up over a cup of delicious tea. The mischievous dragon and mysterious gargoyle are a great addition to the cast of lovable characters! Magical meets heartwarming in this cozy fantasy! Excuse me while I go bake, the jam-filled spiced cookie recipe in the back of the book!

Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for the advanced copy!

Cute but not as expected. Following A Fellowship of Bakers & Magic where the baking descriptions about flavor, texture, and the magic of it all coming together was A-tier, I expected more descriptions about the tea that Doli conjures up. I'm a huge loose-leaf tea snob and I guess I just expected that level of description because of the prior book...but alas, nothing descriptive at all. It's just a hand over her tea cup and she downs it like a shot.

Evvy (the dragon) was cute and equally troublesome. The tension with her parents was a little meh as well as the romance with the gargoyle. I'm not sure what I didn't like about the romance other than it wasn't as sweetly subtle as I loved about Arleta and Theo's relationship...I think Tea You At the Altar did it better.

Major thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read an ARC.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for this ARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This one hurt me a bit to be honest. After how much I enjoyed the first book I was really excited to be diving back into Adenashire, but this one fell flat for me.

Adenashire is so magical that it is the perfect setting for a cosy fantasy. As the first book focused on the baking competition, I was really hoping this one would expand on all the different magics and creatures living in this world. Sadly that was not the case. Instead Doli inherits a dragon egg and is tasked with raising a dragon, something she knows absolutely nothing about! While this premise could still deliver a wonderful cosy fantasy with all the mischievous things Evvy might get up to, literally nothing happens until the last 3 chapters and then it is rushing to the resolution. And while more creatures and magic is introduced there is no expansion on the world building, something that was already lacking in this series. With an entire book on Doli I was hoping for at least some insight as to why Doli has tea magic rather than the common dwarf magic, but again, no explanation is given. Doli's character has almost no depth and all her relationships were rather superficial resulting in the romance plot coming across as extremely forced.

Overall this story felt quite juvenile and didn't live up to its predecessor. Also, if you're going to mention the unicorns stampeding a dozen times, at least tell me why and what the actual impact is. Unfortunately I don't think I will be continuing this series any further.

The follow up to A Fellowship of Bakers & Magic is better than the first. Less wandering plot and more notable than before. The cozy vibes are still impeccable.
My only concern is that for a series is labelled as an LGBT series there is only one couple who aren’t even main characters

A sweet little sunshine dwarf who specializes in tea magic with her circle of friends 😭🥹🫶🏼 omg so cute. She’s fine with where she is at u til her parents come with a inherited dragon egg and a mysterious handsome gargoyle comes into her life 👀 cozy fantasy filled with new found love, friendship, and adventure. God I loved this.