Set in Yellowstone National Park in 1959, three sisters separated by distance and past hurts are reunited shortly before the devastating earthquake that hit Hebgen Lake. While the earth crumbles around them, the sisters face obstacles of destruction determined to be reunited and repair the “fault between them.”
The Fault Between Us by Stephanie Landsem is told from the point of view of the three sisters and Red, the oldest sister Claire’s husband. Each character has its own faults and secret struggles, but each experiences growth while learning to overcome both physical and emotional obstacles. The novel contains elements of faith and hope despite the tragedy and defection from the Hebgen Lake earthquake.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Tyndale House. All opinions are my own.

Wow, what an amazing story based on true events in 1959 near Yellowstone National Park!
A well-written story full of human drama as family bonds are stretched to breaking beforehand and strengthened after it all plays out. It kept me up reading late into the night to find out how things turned out for each of them. It had me holding my breath at moments, on the verge of tears sometimes, and cheering them on. It was very moving in parts, with plenty of emotional tension, especially between Claire and Red. I loved watching Bridget work through her own pent up emotions, overcoming her fears and becoming stronger when the situation demanded it. She was my favorite character.
The author does a good job handling the story with sensitivity and compassion about real people who were affected by the calamity. It brought back memories of time spent in this beautiful unique area. After experiencing a big earthquake as a child, it wasn't hard to imagine the fear this would bring for many years, especially for those who lost someone. It is a good memorial for those who lost their lives there.
Recommend for readers who enjoy stories based on real events with faith and hope. 5 stars!

I had no idea that was such a devastating earthquake in Yellowstone in 1959. Stephanie Landsem brings that bit of history to light. A well written tale of 3 sisters who have lost their way. They were great friends until they all grew up. They still love each other, but they all seem to annoy the other. As Claire, Bridget and Frannie find their way back to each other, the earthquake hits. What follows is a story of the strength of human kind.
Landsem always seems to find these little know historical facts and turns them into a fascinating tale that she then shares with us all. Do yourself a favor and put The Fault Between Us on your TBR pile and then enjoy.

Being a lover of puns, this book title caught my eye. I appreicated it even more as I read through this faith-based, historical work of fiction. I believe that Stephanie Landsem, the author, has done a good job, working at the multi-pronged areas of 'fault'.

Siblings Bridget, Claire and Frannie provide interesting fodder with the faults between them. Then the earthquake created a fault of another kind. Meanwhile, throw in Red and a marital relationship and you've got yet another 'faulty' recipe for perceived strife.

In my opinion, Landsem has developed the tension well, creating suspense and anxiety enough to disturb potential readers, keeping them clinging on for dear life and hoping for happy outcome. One aspect I really valued while reading this book was the backbone of prayer helping to bind the characters together and the acknowledgement that God hears and helps. I give a 'thumbs up' to this.

~ Eunice C., Reviewer/Blogger ~

June 2025

Disclaimer: This is my honest opinion based on the complimentary review copy sent by NetGalley and the publisher.

Many thanks to Netgalley and Tyndale House for an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest opinion. A historical fiction story about an earthquake I had never heard of in 1959 in Yellowstone National Park. The descriptions were vivid and it was easy to imagine living through the catastrophe. A story of three sisters and they're relationships with each other and their father and It brings to light the importance of truth in relationships. The characters were all relatable and they discovered their courage, perseverance and most of all the importance of hope. I really enjoyed this book.

A gorgeous cover, fascinating premise, and perfect title! This one drew me in right away. We follow three sisters who experience tragedy during the 1959 earthquake in Yellowstone. This is a story of mind-boggling and inspiring perseverance. The author does a wonderful job of immersing us in each scene and helping us get to know each character; this way we are fully invested in the story. The sisters (Claire, Bridget, and Frannie) are easy to tell apart as they are very distinct. The earthquake was a very traumatic event, which the author handled very well. The pacing works well and this manages to be both drama-filled and an emotional page turner. Highly recommended for fans of historical fiction.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance e-galley; all opinions in my review are 100% my own.

This is such a great read, it does make you think about what is really important!
A read that is fictional but based on 1959 Hebgen Lake earthquake! A beautiful part of our country, Yelowstone, full of wildlife and Old Faithful, but danger does lurk here, and this is a story of when a big disaster happens on an active volcano field.
We have three sisters, family, also abandonment, and dealing with the effects. This is also a beautiful love story, a husband and wife, and a father who really doesn't want his girls to grow up and make new lives.
There is loss here, even before the disaster, and we follow this family while wondering if any of them will survive? There is such devastation, almost unimaginable, and the author does a great job of describing what actually happening.
Such a great book to get lost in, the pages flew!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Tyndale House, and was not required to give a positive review.

The Fault Between Us was a BEAUTIFUL illustration of family ties and hope in the face of tragedy. I would easily rate this book five stars. It was a fascinating historical fiction read, telling a story I was unfamiliar with in a way that drew me in and had me empathizing with the characters. I thought she handled and dealt with the tragedy very well.

Claire was such an interesting character and her and Red's journey was so well-written. I connected with her in small ways, so I was probably the most invested in her storyline. I flew through this book waiting to see what would happen! Bridget was another wonderful character. I loved seeing her grow through her roadblocks. Frannie was just a delight. She had me cackling throughout the book, and I was agonizing over her life choices for her.

This was my second Stephanie Landsem book, (I also read and adored Codename Edelwiess) and I will return to her in the future!

I received a complimentary copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

The story told in The Fault Between Us by Stephanie Landsem was so gripping with raw emotion and tragedy. And yet, hope was in the midst of it all. Taken from the true events of the 1959 Hebgen Lake Earthquake near Yellowstone National Park and the true stories of people who endured this traumatic event, the book had me parked in my chair, turning pages as fast as I could. The book comes out in November. Give yourself an early Christmas present!!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.

This is a story about family relationships, surviving an earthquake, overcoming hardships, and learning to let go and trust God. The author did an excellent job of including the 1959 Hebgen Lake earthquake into the story, so I learned more about that time era.

This is a great book to add to your pile to read, especially those that enjoy historical fiction.

Story about three sisters who find themselves in Yellowstone during an earthquake and have to fight for their lives and the lives of their loved one. I liked the characters and the story. I hope the final version includes an author's note that explains whether the earthquake was a real historic event.

•𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰•

{𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝑭𝒂𝒖𝒍𝒕 𝑩𝒆𝒕𝒘𝒆𝒆𝒏 𝑼𝒔}

🏞️ Release Date: November 4, 2025 🏞️
.
.
.
I’ve really been enjoying the historical fiction I’ve been reading lately, and this particular story was most definitely a goldmine in literary form! It was exceptionally well-written and one of those stories that instantly pulls you into the plot. Anyone who enjoys a tale of perseverance through times of hardship, with strong family themes, will definitely enjoy this book!

The Fault Between Us followed the lives of three sisters abandoned by their mother at a young age, telling of their experiences during the devastating 1959 earthquake in Yellowstone National Park. The difficulties these young ladies faced were far from easy, but I am in awe of how well Landsem wrote their story of perseverance and overcoming all odds. This was a story ripe with emotions so palpable that I found myself feeling everything the characters were feeling—definitely a sign of a good book, in my opinion!

I found myself quickly bonding with all three of the sisters, though they were all quite different from one another. Claire, with her young daughter and quiet husband, lived a life full of hardships, but the way she remained strong through it all was such an inspiration to me! Bridget, the middle sister, full of big dreams and aspirations for her life of nursing, struggled to accept that Claire could live a life of contentment away from home and, in doing so, created a bit of a rift between the two sisters. Frannie, the very obvious baby of the family, wanted freedom more than anything else, which led to a lot of acting out and rebellion on her part. I really enjoyed reading about all of the adventures and mishaps that she got herself into!

The devastation from the earthquake was absolutely heartbreaking, but Landsem did a wonderful job at recounting the story! Though it was difficult to read at times because of the gut-wrenching tragedies, I still found myself deeply immersed in this tale because I simply HAD to know what happened to the characters!
.
.
.
I received a complimentary arc of this book from NetGalley and Tyndale House Publishers. All opinions listed are purely my own.

THE FAULT BETWEEN US by STEPHANIE LANDSEM is set at the Yellowstone National Park in 1959 at the time of the Helgen Lake earthquake and tells the story of the three Reilly sisters and their bravery as they fight to save each other and other victims of the disaster. In fact the flood is a turning point in their lives, changing their attitudes towards one another and life in general. There is much prayer and repentance in the face of the horrific situation they find themselves in. The Christian message is strong, based largely on Psalm 46 verses 2 to 4 and verse 8, about God’s might and His protection. It is a story of forgiveness, trust, hope, redemption, family dynamics and second chances.
In the descriptions we are made aware of the magnitude of God’s creation.
This is a beautifully written book with a powerful message, and one I highly recommend.
I was given a free copy of the book by NetGalley from Tyndale House Publishers. The opinions in this review are completely my own.

Rating it a three stars because it’s unfair for me to DNF the novel and rate it lower than midway. I couldn’t get into the writing. I honestly felt confused on where the story would lead to and I wasn’t invested even after several chapters. I’m incredibly disappointed because I wanted to enjoy the novel, but I completely understand that someone else could love this book so much!!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for allowing me a chance to read this but I unfortunately could not finish it.

This book kept me on my toes. So rich in relationship with the various characters. It helped me to remember to always rely on God and know he directs my path.

The book is a multi POV historical fiction following the lives of 3 sisters immediately before and during the Hebgen Lake Earthquake.

The story is told from each sisters perspective as well as Red, Claire's husband. It takes each character on their own journey with the three sisters being linked by blood, trauma and their connection to faith. Whilst the second half of the book is a high stakes depiction of the characters during the disaster, the first half provides crucial backstory and connection with the sisters which helps the readers feel invested in the outcome for all the sisters and of course baby Jenny.

The characters were likeable and believable and it was easy to route for them. They all had their faults, their traumas and their growth and themes of faith, familial love and the perseverance of people in the face of an unimaginable disaster truly make this a brilliant book. The sisterly bond is reminiscent of the Charmed sisters especially with the mother connection which I really loved.

I wish I could read it for the first time again to fall in love with the characters. Well done Stephanie!