I appreciate the author's willingness to tackle such a big subject as AI, especially in the medium of a middle grade book. However, the age of the audience means there are important nuances about AI, such as it's horrific detriment to the planet, that get left out. I found the depiction of the kids sweet, but not at all true to life. The thing I loved the most was Malcolm and Mrs. Bettye's story -- it gave a story about the precarity of advancing technology a much needed organic anchor.

I love the representation of family and friendships throughout the story. From the start, Malcolm is determined to be adopted and find his forever family before his birthday. Malcolm’s list of dos and don’ts capture his sense of humor and desperation. The overall tone is lighthearted, but there are emotional moments as the main character rushes to leave the foster care system while juggling new kid status and a malfunctioning robot. Malcolm’s journey is well-written, and his happy ever after well-deserved.