Cute concept, messy vibes…

Crazy Spooky Love had a lot going for it: ghosts, haunted houses, a ghost-sensitive family, and some chaotic romance energy. I was so into the premise, but the actual execution felt kind of scattered.

Melody is quirky and determined, and I liked that she wasn’t your typical romcom lead. But the humor sometimes felt like it was trying a little too hard to be wacky, and I didn’t always connect with her like I wanted to.

The romance was… fine. Fletcher had his moments, but the chemistry didn’t totally hit for me. Leo was pure drama. I didn’t feel super invested in either love interest, so the romance parts didn’t really sweep me away.

That said, the ghost mystery was fun! The Scarborough brothers were chaotic in the best way, and the whole haunted house setup was a vibe. I just wish the pacing had been tighter because some parts dragged, and others flew by.

If you’re looking for something light, seasonal, and a little spooky (but not scary), this could still be a fun read. Just maybe lower your expectations on the romance and character depth.

Thank you NetGalley and publishers for this ARC

“Crazy Spooky Love” is a light, quirky mystery with a dash of romance. The book should have been perfect for me, but unfortunately it didn’t completely work for me.

One of the main issues I had was the constant pop culture references. There were too many, and I found them annoying. I especially disliked the Harry Potter mentions. I wish authors would stop referencing the series, given how problematic JKR has been for years now.

The characters were a strange bunch, but they did have personality. They were fun in a way, though often a bit too over-the-top.

The mystery was somewhat interesting, and there were a couple of twists I liked. Still, I never really felt pulled into the story, it all felt a bit silly due to the characters.

I also wasn’t a huge fan of the romance. Leo came across as arrogant and rude, and I didn’t understand why Melody liked him, aside from being physically attracted to him. Fletcher, on the other hand, was more likable and seemed to treat her better.

The humor felt forced at times, and the book probably could’ve been shorter.

Overall, it was okay. Kind of fun in places, but not something I loved or would necessarily recommend.